I’m sure this has been discussed several times but Taking into account the network opportunities, cost of living, family life, and overall quality of the team, what are the best cities to work in for the major consulting firms? Or is there any sort of measure for which cities rank highest in terms of employee preference?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I want to be brutally honest with you. Your question is so absurdly broad and vague that no one can give a reasonable answer to this. There are so many variables at play here.

First this is going to vary by firm and team. Second, how are you weighing all these factors / what are your preferences? For some people, network oops are more important than COL and what you find interesting others might not.

If I was forced to answer, I would say NYC and SF are known as the T1 (aka most competitive / prestigious cities). These cities will have (generally speaking not always the case) the best networking opps and highest quality team members with the trade off of HCOL. If you want better COL you gotta make sacrifices when it comes to networking etc and go to a smaller city.

Just to illustrate how weird all of this is. In the consulting world, LA is considered a T2/T3 city, but it’s T1 for most other industries and the only other official T1 city in the US besides NYC in the traditional sense (city >10M people).

Thank you for your brutal honesty! This was essentially a preamble to building out a tool that would create the different factors that go into making a decision.

Personally, I’m at the stage of my life where I’m considering whether it’s worth it to slug it out at one of the top consulting firms for 2 years to build the network/credibility OR use my existing network/startup success to go independent as a consultant right from the start of my post-MBA career.

I’m 30+ with 3 kids under 5 so If I feel like I have to go to a firm first I’d rather go somewhere where COL isn’t high, life is easier for the family etc while I slug it out for 2 years.

But that’s just my personal situation. I still think a tool that puts all these factors into account could be extremely helpful for those trying to make a decision.

like

Related Posts

like

Wash your hands

Post Photo
likefunnyhelpful

Typical salary ranges for CCOs at network agencies at the major cities like NY/SF/LA/CHI?

like

All AMs on my account are supposed to get planning training, our CS VP was replaced with a VP of Planning but they kept the CS SVP. They said this is part of an “industry trend”. Has anyone else experienced this? I’ve been on the CS side for a while and don’t know the first thing about planning… feeling a bit unnerving about the switch but also open to it if it will benefit my career. Thoughts?

like

Need advice. Any tips on how to keep libido active ? Have an amazing BF who wants to hump all weekend. (Also desi & travels for work) & Am dead tired, just wanna sleep. Not sure how gets that energy

like

Hi, this isn’t directly related to career pivot. But I have a question. I have been aggressively trying to pivot to consultancy. A recession is anticipated in the coming future. As a new hired employee, do I fear the axe of lay off falling on me first?

like

Hi!! Would love to connect with folks from Takeda who are open to providing a referral or connecting me with HR/recruiter? Applied for something this week I’d love to be considered for!

like

Anyone working at Abbie willing to provide reference? Desperately need one

like

What happens if someone on a work visa gets laid off? How long do they have to find a new position?

like

Anyone wanna meet up for drinks 🍹 tonight??

like

Have begun noticing that my corporate flirting skills are quite subpar. Nobody is 100% honest with what they say and I have been way too honest 😀😭 Shocked and disappointed.

Men who are fit and have ripped bodies, does that help with getting the ladies ?

And K-3 pull out teachers willing to share their schedule with me. Looking to redo mine in December and want to see how others do it!

like

I had my power round Friday for Implementation wing, haven’t heard back anything yet. Does that mean a NO?Not sure if it’s too early to reach out to the recruiter.

like

Would it be career suicide to take a sabbatical to get an MBA at an ivy?

likefunny

Hello Fishes,
Do you think it will be of any benefit from career standpoint to pursue Post Graduate Diploma in Management(PGDM) from Grade A (IMT/NMMIS etc.) college in India through Distance learning. I’m having 11 years of experience and currently working as an Individual Contributor.

like

Want to use Google’s code for Hertz in UK. Any chance that they will ask for a proof? What kind of proof would that be?

like

What are the best websites to search for PM jobs? I have been with my company for the past 23 years (Engineer then PM for the past 5 years) and not sure how the employers will interpret this. Any advice is welcomed!

like

Anyone with a Ranger or Marine service background care to share their experiences? What does the process look like for those already in industry? FYI - 25 years old

like

Bank / lender recommendations for rental property purchase? Tried sofi but got 4% yikes

like

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

Do HSW re-calculate your gpa or just take what you tell them? Or do they just ask for some third party institute such as WES? International undergraduate here

like

Enrolled in Stern for a few weeks.
The number of the alumni and current students that go to top consulting firms FT& summer intern are countless even for a small class size.
Stern is way more than a finance school. Given its location, do you want to spend your 2 years in a rural area or heart of Manhattan? Location is almost everything for business school. (I have a friend in Cornell that frequently travels about 5 hours to NYC for events.)

like

How easy/hard is it to get a deferral? What kinds of reasons do colleges usually accept?

like

Sloan results out yet?

like

Finished my last interview. Happy to be done, now we wait….

like

Anyone do the Tuck interview yet? What was it like?

like

To those who completed TTP and did well on the real test (>=48) what was your accuracy like on Data Sufficiency & Problem Solving questions ?

like

Did you all put performance ratings on resume?

Is anyone’s Columbia decision late?

like

Taking the GMAT this afternoon. Thought, luck, or prayers are appreciated whichever you prefer

like

I wrote paid ETS practice test and got ~10 points less than what I scored in the both PowerPrep tests. I’m writing my actual exam tomorrow. Am I doomed? 😢

like

What’s a solid ‘story’ to apply for an MBA? I short, mine is that I ultimately want to help people in my (developing) country by starting a microfinance bank.

likefunny

Hello NYC 🐠 - Looking to sell GMAT prep materials. Just scored 750 and these books were instrumental.

Post Photo
like

Yale dings are coming out 🥲

likeuplifting

A year ago, I was depressed struggling and frustrated. I couldn’t beat the gmat and spent every waking hour trying to beat the tests and only hovered around 620. I was praying I’d be able to get into T20 schools like Emory, McCombs, and UNC. 1 year later I’ve beaten the test and received interviews at Michigan and NYU while waiting to hear from CBS, Tuck, Kellogg and Wharton. I’m in a place I never thought I’d be. It’s been a tough year. But I’m proud im close to the end. Keep trying everyone.

likeuplifting

Those who took the GRE - how long did you study? Self-study or take a class?

like

Have done a few mock TBDs with Wharton prospects. They went well but I feel impostor syndrome kicking in. Everyone else seemed so polished, articulate, and compelling... feeling nervous af

like

Anyone have any advice that worked for them for this Harvard essay?

like

Anyone reapplying next year and would like to chat and brainstorm strategies? Either in person in NYC or virtually

like

Ughh got waitlisted by both Wharton and MIT, what are the chances of getting off? Any tips? Thank you!!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal