I’m sure this won’t come across well but I have to say it… my husband and I make good money (about $600k combined) and are grateful for it but these Biden tax increases are going to kill us. The truly rich don’t get hit hard meanwhile it sucks to be an upper middle class family. No matter how much I make somehow my take home seems to keep going down.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I think the broader point is that well compensated professionals (let’s say HHI between 500k-2m) are paying a much higher effective rate than the true capitalist class like your hedgies and high earners off w2. I have no problem paying more but I would like to think that those with the means should pay more in general. This entire debate really hits w2 earners hard. I also assume big4 k1 types as well.

likesmart

There’s not a problem with capital formation in this country. So no reason to subsidize it. There is a problem with ensuring adequate retirement savings in this country. So there’s plenty of reason to provide tax advantaged investment accounts through which I own nearly all of my equity investments and thus capital gains taxes are irrelevant to me.

Furthermore, you wouldn’t be “penalized for responsible behavior” — making the capital gains rates equal to other income just removes a subsidy. Working hard at a job is just as responsible a behavior as investing in equities.

I’m glad to see all the benevolent partners posting here. Taxes suck. They suck for everyone. And they disincent success. But you guys go right ahead and think we’re “doing our fair share”. I assure you, there are far more people (not to mention our clients) getting away with no tax bills, while we are paying more.

likesmart

EY2, do you have any highly compensated partners or friends in France? It happens.

Recent IconRecent

You’re right. It doesn’t come across well. You’re not “upper middle class” if you’re above the 99th percentile in household income.

But agree that the IRS budget needs to be massively increased to chase tax cheats among the megarich

like

OP that is a delusional interpretation of upper class by any measure. Do you also think lower class is < $200k and the poverty line is < $100k?

likefunny

I am reading the details now (on WSJ). Ouch.

That said, I don’t think anyone on this thread/bowl is “upper middle” class.

Just taking it like a champ here.

like

Whoops! I got that backwards… Marginal rate increase is greater than total rate increase

I already caught it in the shorts with the SALT BS.

likesmart

I have a real problem with dramatic & sudden
changes to tax structures after I committed a serious amount of capital based on the structure being something else. Income tax changes are one thing, but real estate is something else.

like

OP, let's be clear, we are rich.

likefunny

My wife and I make $600K+ combined and would probably call ourselves rich by common standards. Read an interesting article recently on whether “rich” should be defined by income in the top 1% or assets in the top 1%. The taxation policies seem to be socking the income earner class harder than the asset accumulator class. I consider myself
socially liberal and fiscally conservative. I’d like to see SALT deduction reinstated in full. It is wrong to tax income that has gone towards paying other taxes.

The issue I have with the DEMs is they think throwing money at a problem is the solution (e.g., education, child care, healthcare, unemployment,infrastructure) and they never bother solving anything. And ofcourse, raise taxes to waste more money. The other bunch of REPs thinks cutting taxes, running up deficits, denying societal problems is the way to go. We need bold ideas like the moonshot to spur innovation and light up the imagination of next generation to solve hard challenges ahead. We cannot raise or cut taxes enough to bring about the next round of prosperity.

likesmart

Companies and super rich will always find ways to avoid taxes .. hire lobbyists and tax consultants. The real targets of the “tax the rich” rhetoric are income earners like us. Look at what’s missing from legislation .. wealth tax, financial transaction tax, carried interest loophole, 1031 exchange or closing corporate tax loopholes like stock option expensing, minimum corporate tax. Between the progressive taxation of higher income and regressive taxation of consumption, the current tax policies are heavily skewed to benefit the ultra wealthy class who should be paying more. I did the math on our total tax burden (federal, FICA, state income, sales, property) is somewhere between 33% and 40% of what we earn. I think it ought to be more like 30% to be considered fair and equitable.

I have no problem paying high taxes. I benefit from government services more than low income earners because the subsidize a lot of the infrastructure that makes it possible for my wife and I to have the income we do. My only problem is that they keep going after salaried employees instead of closing the bullshit loopholes that the ultra wealthy use, like carried interest. My basic principle is that the more you make the higher the tax on your marginal dollar should be. That’s true until you get to the ultra wealthy at which point there’s a huge drop off and they pay a lower rate than many middle income families.

like

Stop shaming her. OP has courage for speaking up and is correct, the new tax proposals are aimed too low.

like

Pointing out a fallacy over the definition of rich is not shaming. Claiming that 2.9% of the difference between $535K and $600K is going to kill her is also hyperbole.

like

Wait, what does “kill us” mean quantitatively?

Wife and I make about $550K. I just plugged the numbers I found online into my tax planner spreadsheet and got an increase of $460. That feels pretty ‘meh’ to me.

What’s driving the increased tax burden you’re worried about? How much is it?

like

The latest proposal starts at $535K.

I don’t much care about most of my income getting taxed by another 2.6%. It’s a meaningful sum, but I’ll be plenty fine without it.

My bigger objection isn’t with how much of my money the government takes. It’s that they do such a garbage job of spending it wisely. And the Biden administration is no more interested in being serious stewards of my money than the Trump administration was (or the various administrations that came before them).

like

Yes - most of my income will be subject to an added 2.6%.

The majority of my household income resides in the space between $450K and my total household income.

I bet Jeff Bezos calls himself extra upper middle class

likefunny

Can the “the taxes are unbelievable” people help me understand that POV? It seems we are living in the golden era of taxes for people making over 200k; let’s alone 400k. Perhaps I’m missing something…

likesmart

Pwc3, in the 1800s the mean time between recessions was under 5 years, very few went to school, apprenticeship was only a small step beyond servitude for 10 years, medical was done only for the rich or through charity, starvation was a major cause of death.

The government was funded heavily by tariffs which are simply hidden taxes on consumers.

I'd hate to have been alive then, or in the current equivalent.

helpful

Crazy how many people here are happy to just fork over more money to the government. Boiling frog syndrome?

like

The quality of the political analysis here is not good.

The Trump administration was very antipharma. HHS was run by a guy who was fired by pharma and he was widely known to be vindictive about it. They had proposed various forms of price control themselves using broad “pilot” authority within CMS.

Meanwhile, price negotiation already exists in much of the government business. Medicare Part D drugs have price negotiation and discounting is substantial - just run through private entities. And Medicaid has access to the best prices that pharma negotiates with anyone.

The problem is that when people say the government should “negotiate,” what they really mean is that government should “dictate.” That’s clearly the intent behind the actual legislation sitting in the house.

Believe what you want about drug prices. I’ll just note that the social return on investment in pharma R&D is massive. Had the kinds of price controls envisioned in house bill HR3 been passed into law 10 years ago, we wouldn’t have had mRNA vaccines today. That one innovation is worth trillions of dollars annually to society. It seems like a strange time to be complaining about us not getting a good enough deal on pharma stuff.

like

You mean the 2.6 pp increase on income above 450k?

I agree, this doesn’t come off well at all. And no, you are not upper middle class by any measure.

like

Really? It’s going to kill you?

likefunny

I’m more worried about this reduction in the death tax amount, yikes!

likehelpful

OP, I feel the same way you do. Top 4.99% of earners (professionals and small/mid-size businesses) will take brunt of the blow, while the 0.1% will find loopholes and minimize impact (BIL works in private banking, they already have options for ultra rich).

like

$600K is nowhere near the middle class, not even the hairy upper edge. Come on.

like

Friends of mine are considering divorce because marriage penalty is REAL.

likefunny

And yes, MD5, married filing separately is a penalty. But it was designed that way as that filing status is intended for people who are married but not really cooperating financially (e.g. legally separated) and therefore aren’t acting like a single family unit. Therefore they’re taxed as separate units. The filing status can be used for other reasons than it was created for if you want, but then you get the penalty that comes with it.

Related Posts

like

Health stuff (beyond anxiety and depression) getting me down. Want to take med leave (dr has said yes), but am afraid of internal politics and YE. Need courage to go through with it

like

Hi

I'm looking for job in Insurance domain P&C with 6 year of experience can anyone help me?

like

Is Life Insurance a scam?

Why or why not?

like

Have a Chase Sapphire currently. Looking to get the Reserve or the Platinum Amex. Thoughts?

like

Anyone recently join Guidehouse as an experienced hire Manager? I have an interview coming up and am curious what kind of salary/benefits package i should expect. TIA!

Question: what are the chances to get re-hired after a year if you leave your job for 1 year to move to a different country to take care of your spouse who is having mental health problems? My husband works abroad and with the travel ban he is unable to come to UK. He needs me over there but my company doesn’t have an office in his country with roles open. And I’m not fluent in the local language.

like

For those of you that work from home, is there any salary or benefits that would convince you to return to the office full time? My job is trying it and receiving a ton of pushback regardless of what they offer people. My coworker is seriously considering leaving the company rather than start commuting again which seems crazy, but I really don't want to go back in either.

like

What do strategy positions within health systems do? e.g. director of strategy...I work in HC strategy now and am curious how similar the roles/responsibilities are.

like

Is a JD a good move? I am currently a claims analyst for a top brokerage firm in NY. However I also want to attend law school as I think it will grow my career. Is this the right move? I plan to go into labor law (I.e. littler and Jackson Lewis) or an attorney for an insurance firm as a backup plan.

Hi all,
I have been a practicing DPT (doctor of physical therapy) for 9 years and am a certified orthopedic specialist. I have worked in multiple environments including hospital based outpatient sports ortho and acute care. I am about to finish up my MBA with a focus on healthcare administration, and am worried that my current place of work may not have a place for me to grow into. I'm hoping that some of you may have suggestions of roles or positions to pursue? Thank you!

like

How do you evaluate the financial health/viability of a startup you’re interviewing with? Are there specific questions you ask and/or external research you do? A company I’m interviewing with offers equity, and they say they anticipate going IPO or being bought out by a larger company in the industry. I know any company will put its best foot forward during interviews, so I’m trying to figure out to accurately evaluate those statements.

like

Looking for suggestions on courses to take. I’ve been managing various types of healthcare related (clinical system implementations, strategy/planning etc) projects for 15 years and my background is business info systems and then added my PMP ages ago along with change management. Now I feel like I need something healthcare specific to take me to the next level in my career. Thoughts?

like

Has anyone taken a leave of absence for mental health/suicide/depression? I’m getting there but I’m also the primary earner in my house.

like

Hello and happy Thanksgiving! What are the pros and cons of living in San Diego vs San Francisco? I’m from NY and looking to move to one of those locations. I’m hoping to get more info on rent, dating, entertainment, taxes, and job stability.

like

I am a Payment Posting Coordinator. I am thinking about leaving Healthcare all together. I feel like I have reached my maximum earning potential. I have worked as a Front Desk Rep and in Insurance Verification. I'm at a stand still. I'm currently earning $21 an hour. Has anyone had any experience as a Loan Officer? I'm leaning in that direction.

likehelpful

Realtors who work in big cities: have you ever considered working with listings in the Midwest? Or do you prefer the challenge of a ruthless market but that can bring greater benefits?

like

It looks like Y&R healthcare is looking to expand... what’s it like? The accounts, culture, management, etc.

like

What's your day start time? Let us know if you're in house / agency / HCP or Patient healthcare / onsite freelance / etc

like

At what number do you feel like you’re making enough whether to satisfy your desires or just not feel guilty about spending money.I’ve been blessed to have my income raised a total of 85% throughout 9 years but shortly after each raise I still feel like it’s not enough to live by and that I’m always behind. I live in a high cost area and make triple of what my friends make yet it still doesn’t feel enough. Cont’d

like

More Posts

I hate taxes

likesmartfunny

You know what sucks?

Hey designers! I’m currently in the process of getting a new wfh set up and was curious to see how everyone’s current setups look 😊

like

Walmart hr collected all the documents from me but she hasn't come up with an offer from the last one month...., Will Walmart give me an offer or not??
@walmart

like

I’ve been working on joining the 225 club for a little over a year. 50ish guy weighing 205 here. Got to 215 today doing 1rm, but my trainer didn’t want me to attempt it (215 was definitely a struggle). Will try again next month. Any tips on how to train for a bit of improvement?

likeuplifting

Hi everyone! Heading to Barbados in March for the cricket. Any good recommendations for things to see, do, eat etc?

like

So I finished my 3rd interview with a company and the TA specialist said they loved me but can’t meet me at my bottom line salary, however, I said I can negotiate and she said she’s going to speak with the decision makers and see if they’re okay with that. What does this mean? This is for a marketing specialist role. I’m asking for $70K bottom line

like

Hi All

I am working as SAP FICO consultant at Infosys. I have 4+ years of work experience. Worked on CFIN migration, S/4 , ECC support projects. Can anyone please help me to get referred in CG.

like

What's the yearly appraisal percentage range in Capgemini engineering?

like

Hi Deloitte Fish, how are Job Architecture consulting projects like? Any insights?

like

Anyone know corporate banking associate/ senior associate salaries in Dallas? Would greatly appreciate any insight.

like

I (M) am on a budget and need an outfit for 3 summer weddings with very different vibes. Possible to have one base outfit (with variations) for all weddings?

Wedding 1 - very formal. Venue is a museum in a big city, and I’ll be meeting majority of significant other’s family.

Wedding 2 - beach wedding.

Wedding 3 - venue in a small town and reception is an outdoor BBQ.

like

For those that manage interns- How do you do it without losing your mind? I keep telling these interns the same critiques over and over and every new project has they show me has same fundamental design issues. H E L P 😩

like

Hi All,

I am having 6.5 years exp and currently working for Capgemini with 9LPA fixed.
I have below offers Im considering and further negotiation is not possible because of budget constraints.

DBS is my current client company and offered 20 LPA as I resigned.

DBS : 20LPA Fixed + 5LPA variable (Associate)
Wipro: 21 Fixed + 10% variable( Team lead, B3)
Virtusa: 21 Fixed + 10% variable( Senior consultant, Tier 2)

Please help me pick one. Im confused. Suggestions are appreciated. Thanks.

Just applied to Apple with a Gmail email address, think they won’t mind? Lol

funnylikehelpful
like

Hello all, need your valuable feedback.

How is work life balance in
Citi, Chennai.
GIDA team, Metrics & Reporting Analyst team ?

and What CTC can be expected for my experience level?

YOE: 5.7
Skills: Business Intelligence
CCTC: 9.5
Expected CTC: 18 (yet to receive)
Grade: C10

Citi

like

Trying to save up for a down payment on an investment property. Would it make sense to remove my 401K contribution for about 6 months to gain an extra $4K or is that stupid? I’m 23 and have no experience, just wanted opinions

like

“Boston leaped over San Fransisco to land in second place on the list of most expensive US rental markets” (source: Bloomberg)
This is insane, Boston is definitely not worth the rent we’re paying right now🙄 Are we headed towards a rental bubble here?

like

Hi All,

I am putting in an offer on anew house and the sellers are requesting a rent back contingency for 45 days post closing. Can I do an addendum for my offer but also have a new rent back agreement drafted for after closing to better protect myself?

like

Additional Posts in Partners Only

Tax question - if partners have to file in all 50 states, does establishing your primary residence in a tax free state like Florida or Texas provide any state tax advantage?

like

Has anyone been invited to sit on a board of directors for small to mid-size companies? If yes, what process do you go through to get approval from your current employer?

like

Thoughts on introducing an RSU-type retention construct for non-partner staff at management consulting firms?

likehelpful

We are at a level where by making 5% returns on our net-worth we can sustain our current lifestyle.

What should this mean from a lifestyle perspective? Keep it the same (but then why work), step/up a notch (but once you increase you cant go back), or make one off splurges as excess cash accumulates? How do others things about it?

like

Any insights on Slalom? Compensation, work culture, pros and cons? Why (or why not) join them?

like

Folks - who do you use for your financial planning and wealth management advisory? Yourself or a form? Anyone you recommend?

like

Anyone looking to bring on a manager who can build out a cybersecurity offering (not the technical aspect, but the human-centered awareness and learning component). Im friendly too

likeuplifting

Is there a general expectation that a Partner has an MBA?

I doubt it's required at most firms but I'm a pretty senior staff and when I speak with Partners, they seem to speak with an MBA level of business knowledge which extends past their technical skillset.

I realize that's what makes them good Partners but it makes me wonder if I realistically need to get an MBA to keep growing and hit Partner.

funnylike

I’ve been asked to serve as chair for a non-profit. I don’t have time and this is a dysfunctional board (many board members with a tie to the mission of the organization but w/o relevant experience). However, there aren’t many options and I feel obligated. I’m considering it, *if* I can put some guardrails in place to minimize the dysfunction and stay out of the weeds. That’s a huge if. Any advice?

I forget newbies can’t be entirely left to their own devices at times... Too old for this

likehelpful

How do you lead and inspire others when you’re depressed or lacking inspiration?

Do we get dividends over vested RSUs?

like

All -
I am interviewing for a Strategy leadership role at a SaaS company. A bit rusty on interviews so crowdsourcing from senior folks here, what are best practices or good examples of certain behavioral questions.

1. What is your weakness? I can talk at length about strengths but unclear what weakness to state so as to not mess up my chances.

2. Where do you see yourself in 5 years? This question is tough because there aren't very many levels above me so cannot say in an EVP role.

helpfullike

How much cash do you keep in bank accounts? I have 50% in RE, 25% in market through retirement and education accounts and 25% in cash. Always think it’s too much cash but have never been able to gather courage to put more than 25% in market which I already have through 401K and 529. Any ideas on what to do with money just sitting in the bank earning no interest with 9% inflation eroding the value every single day

like

What is median earnings (or range) for US PwC Advisory equity partner -year 5- in the Transformation Practice?

In serious discussions for putting together business case.

Any insights on how the reorg is going? or on the integration process for direct admit partners?

like

Even to this day, I feel like I have crippling anxiety and imposter syndrome when speaking. It’s easier in project read outs and dedicated client meetings, but much worse when I’m going in cold or without a set agenda. Has anyone worked with / used a coach, tools, etc. to help with this? Recommendations?

like

How are Managed Services viewed in your firm? Traditionally Big4 have shied away.

like

Partners, those of you that have successfully switched employment to another consulting firm as a partner, how did you navigate your non-competes?

helpful

I have an underlying disdain for any incompetence and I generally write people off if they don’t show improvement. I lose patience (never react but I wouldn’t staff on projects). Any tips to improve?

Anyone have any experience with Atheneum or Coleman Research Group. Both reaching out aggressively about consultations on same / similar topic. Emailing aggressively by the hour to seek scheduling.

No real question here that I have, just wondering if these are known / reputed firms you have any experience with?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal