{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Is an over-reliance on portfolio school grads hurting diversity efforts? Portfolio schools are expensive, majority require private loans. This is how you get nothing but wealthy white people.", "post_id": "582fad2c059b25001060af0f", "reply_count": 11, "vote_count": 18, "bowl_id": "5565cfca8b2b9a03009acf57", "bowl_name": "Advertising", "feed_type": "crowd" }
null

Is an over-reliance on portfolio school grads hurting diversity efforts? Portfolio schools are expensive, majority require private loans. This is how you get nothing but wealthy white people.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I've found some of the best young creatives aren't from portfolio school. In fact, they don't have a traditional portfolio to begin with. So hopefully that mindset is changing.

like

That is definitely part of it. When I was in portfolio school, I'd say 75% of the students were completely bankrolled by their parents - from tuition to gas money. And that's AFTER having already attended a 4-year institution. So you had not only racial homogeny, you also had socioeconomic sameness. Which doesn't really make for a lot of diverse thinking. Also, from what I've seen, most agencies don't even entertain the idea of visiting or recruiting from Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCU). The talent in those schools is a precious resource that oft goes untapped by larger institutions. There's really just a general lack of interest from the industry. No one really prioritizes diversity. No one really understands it's benefits.

like

I don't care where you went to school. Can you do the job? Are you not an asshole? Cool. Let's work together.

like

I didn't go to a traditional portfolio school and I worked my ass off to get my book where it was before I got an internship. The other CW in my intern group went to VCU so I was super intimidated.... until he started taking frequent naps on the office patio.

like

I went to portfolio school in NYC and we were a pretty diverse bunch. Guys & gals. Sweden. Canada. India. Americans from all walks of life.

like

@Arnold agree completely. Not recruiting at HBCUs is a major oversight. One only needs to see what mostly young black people did with vine to learn that.

like

I definitely think so.

Went to portfolio school and while there were definitely some people being bankrolled, nowhere near the majority were. Lots of people taking out big loans or using a chunk of savings from working previously. It was also pretty diverse.

@Strategist 1 I would imagine everyone's experiences differ. So yes, in my experience, the majority of students were bankrolled. If your experience was different, I'd be interested to hear about without you devaluing my experience. Being that we don't know one another, you can't really speak to the validity of my experience, can you? P.s. I'm one of those people who took out big loans and used savings...and I worked the entire time I was in school to supplement what loans wouldn't cover. So, I had a pretty good knowledge of who was going through similar things while in school.

Also, it was mostly white. Saying that as a monitory, too. But again, our experiences were different.

@Arnold not trying to devalue your experiences at all! Just sharing mine.

Additional Posts

Has anyone ever shot in an airport? If so where and how was the experience? What options are there?

like

Are index funds a good investment?

like

I'm looking for Job in HR Shared Services , I have 8+ years of experience in Compensation management, Appraisals, Salary planning activities, Annual Bonus activity etc

like

How often do you go over budget?

like

Currently working at 19LPA as a Salesforce developer with 5+ yrs of exp. Can anyone pls suggest the compensation can expect considering the current market trend? Hold an offer of 26 from Nagarro. Also wanted to know about the Salesforce practice at Nagarro if anyone is aware of.

like

Coach and project leaders supportive of promotion. Milestone year shows TBD. Skill: Cloud Integrations, total yoe- about to complete 10 and years at same level - 2.5, flags raised for all the snapshots
Chances of making it to next level?

like

Does anyone do intermittent fasting? How long do you go for and how has it helped you (weight loss, more energy, etc)?

Starting at a job on Monday doing defense work (I've only done plaintiff side prior to this) and I'm unfamiliar with billing. Heard plenty of horror stories, though. Any advice or something...

Hey ladies, styling question here. How on earth do you manage to style the back of your hair? I have curly hair and always had a friend straighten the back in school / college. Whenever I do it myself, I always end up leaving a curly section in back and it looks so much worse than if I did nothing at all 😩 any tips?

like

When you're an associate with a major crush on a single MD. What to do...

like

MIT Sloan with significant fellowship $$ vs. Booth with no $$... Spending hours after hours trying to figure this out... 🐠🐟 I would love to hear your thoughts- especially if you've attended either!

like

What are the best investing books that you've read?

like

New financial advisor here 👋🏼 I go to the gym every morning at 5:30 and get into the office by 8. A fellow advisor suggested I start coming in earlier... as in earlier than everyone else...

like

How many of you paid money for a consulting interview prep program, and did it help you get your job?

like

Wonder which party is behind these… 🤔

Post Photo
likehelpfulfunny

Can u get EY vision plan to pay for contact lens you buy in India?

Need dinner ideas for a picky toddler. We started him with BLW but COVID made us give him almost same food everyday and now he doesn’t want to eat anything other than rice or couscous and I am out of ideas. We are vegetarians.

like

How is M&A IT at PWC? Recruiting firms reached out about opportunities in the “Deals group” (not sure if that’s what’s actually called”.

likehelpful

Any tips for staffs who struggle to pass the CPA exams? A staff has tried four years but can’t pass Audit and FAR. Another staff has outstanding performance but just can’t pass any section.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal