{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Is Commonwealth good as advertised??\nIt just seems to good to be true. ( all the top ratings in JD Power etc)\nEdward Jones also has excellent J.D. Power scores but we definitely have issues.........", "post_id": "5d43b8782243bd001c11a743", "reply_count": 14, "vote_count": 0, "bowl_id": "5ac7151f848b740013523fd1", "bowl_name": "Leap to Independence (True Hybrid)" }

Is Commonwealth good as advertised?? It just seems to good to be true. ( all the top ratings in JD Power etc) Edward Jones also has excellent J.D. Power scores but we definitely have issues.........

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

25 bps platform charge was the most glaring but they were on my top 3 when I made my move.

United Planners allows Schwab, TDA, and Fidelity with no platform fee. Check them out if you’re still looking.

I was considering Commonwealth Avenue in point, from what I read and my interactions with them, they are a good independent shop. However, I’ve always had my own skepticism about any company that is privately owned, because previously working at Edward Jones, I knew they can change the rules as they went along.

Can’t a public one do that too?!


Thanks for feedback RJ. Any company can change things tho. Think about the wire houses. They change Comp plans every few years. Pros and cons either way. I visited RJ, very solid firm, has good name etc. from a service standpoint and technology, CW seems much stronger. The trade off is RJ is a good name with a solid reputation. How long since you jumped, and did they harass you ?

Is EJ as good as advertised? There is always something that could be better, is better, would be better, but that is only a snapshot in time. If you want the control and feel you can handle the compliance, technology, etc, then RIA is the way to go. Keep in mind that one reason that things change at the BD’s is because policies force compliance changes, technology changes force companies to change. That won’t change as an RIA, but you have more control, a higher payout and freedom and flexibility. EJ is a fine company, Commonwealth is a fine company, RJ is a fine company. Moving from one home to the next is a lot of work and expense, but it does allow a purge of all the things you don’t need. Moving firms can be similar, but my guess is you will lose some clients you thought would never leave you as well Each firm will make changes, send out directives, and ebb and flow in the BD space.

What’s your point riskalyze?

Thanks !! Great feedback

Where are you located?

Commonwealth is good at getting a $250K producer to the $750K mark. After that, you’re paying for a bunch of bells and whistles you don’t need anymore. IMHO

What is the next move after that ?

Additional Posts

Ex- Deloitte 🐠s, when did you got your pension amount after leaving? I have close to 10k vested which I thought would be paid automatically after I leave. But Nothing so far. It has been close to 2 months now.


Good gay bars in San Francisco? Alt traveling with the bf


Hypthesis: consulting only exists because client businesses are unable / unwilling to pay significantly variant salaries for people who are wildly better / worse than their peers in equivalent roles.


God. There is one other black person on the project (which is a miracle in itself), however the partners and directors only seem to have capacity to remember one guys name. My name is now Michael.


Has anyone heard back from Milk about their in-house PR position? Trying to figure out if they haven’t started scheduling interviews or if I’m being ghosted.


What roles do associates with 2 yoe at MBB exit to when they join FAANG?


Maybe one of you blockchain experts should create a universal currency for travel miles and points so I don't have to be tied down to one brand and we (consultants) can feel rich and loaded, for once!


Applied to multiple positions (different roles) at PwC consulting on which I perfectly match and I received quick rejection emails (within few days /hours which I appreciate not like EY who takes months or Deloitte who completely ghosts you). All the other big 4 got back to me positively with interviews. It's not my resume, my cover letter or how I match to the roles. I don't understand what is happening.. I really would like to get at least a screening call from PwC ( I really like the company)


Just got some interesting feedback that I’m not really sure what to do with. It was that I need to be less awkward”, but they gave me no concrete points about what makes me awkward! I have a bit of a stutter, maybe that’s it’s but I can’t control that! Really unhelpful and a bit hurtful!


If FAANG PM roles are the new “prestige”, what graduate programs guarantee employment into FAANG at the same rate M7 lines you up for roles at MBB? Coding bootcamps don’t seem to be answer....neither does “Master in X”🧐


Anyone know what a CD at Amazon is making in total comp?


When is the appraisal cycle takes place apart from annual performance bonus in pwc india ?


Anyone got PMI ACP certification? Who do you list as project contact? Manager for each project or is it your direct manager or HR manager or general HR contact? Any Audit exp you can share?


What will be the take home salary for fixed 10L in Accenture?


I’m looking into an M role at Accenture Strategy in their Supply Chain space. Can anyone speak to that practice and expected salary band? Any and all insights appreciated. Thanks.


Anyone in NYC have GMAT books they want to give away? Applying this coming year.


Catching up on GOT. Work from home perks 👍🏼


How are you experiencing Coronavirus? Are you working from home? What's your professional life like now?


Random question: does anyone here work at PwC in Philadelphia? Looking to make contact, ideally with someone in a leadership position but willing to start anywhere, for a high profile charity thing.


Using work laptop zoom to do a job interview. Yay or nay?


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or