Is it a bad idea to redesign a potential employer’s packaging design just to show case how you would work with them? If you’re interviewing as a packaging designer? Or are there any other alternatives?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Could you just speak to how you'd like to improve the product? That way they can get a sense of how you think and bring things to life, and you're not doing spec work/they can't just take your design and pass on you.

helpful

I personally don’t mind doing free work if it’s going to open the door to a conversation I want to have. If I went this route, I wouldn’t let them use the work though, it’s just to show the skills. I’ve heard of some sketchy companies just taking your work but I don’t believe it’s the norm.
A real redesign project though, has to be in response to a problem. Either stated by the customer, new regulations, competition, etc. For me to see value in your redesign, I would like to see that you deeply understand the product, the brand, the customer, etc. So a successful redesign would include research and documentation around your design decisions. Otherwise, it just shows me that you do pretty things, but I don’t know if you actually solve business problems. Now that sounds like a big investment just to interview, so I’d probably find an alternate way of getting their attention. Personally, I’d write about the problems I see with their current packaging, do some light research and not redesign anything. Just show them that I understand the challenge, which IMO is the hardest part.

smart

This is great advice, thank you!

I tend to agree with Consultant 1. While I have known people who had their work on "assignments" used by the company/manager where they were applying, I think this is rare. As long as what they are asking me to do only takes me a few hours, I will do it. I had one company give me one of their dashboards and I completely redesigned it, resolving multiple usability and information architecture issues, and they offered me a job.

If you are worried, one alternative is to redesign the packaging (etc) from a different, well known company. This shows your skills without actually "giving away" something of value to your potential employer.

Related Posts

What are some really good questions to ask at the end of an interview? Have you found asking specific questions has always led to a second interview?

like

Omg got HBS interview invite!!

like

For a 6 year experienced person how many rounds of interview?

like

I’m getting a new boss and I get to interview them. What kind of questions should I prioritize?

like

I recently interviewed with Natwest and I got confirmation that they wanted to offer a role. Salary negotiations were started. However, now I got an email from the hiring manager that hiring for my role has been paused due to the ongoing cost of living crisis. He expects to resume the hiring for the role in Q1 '23 and would resume the process then. So is it the end? Honestly, I don't expect him to come back. But what do you think?

like

Interviewing at Strategy& for manager level (Deal Value Creation) - heard there will be M&A focused cases. Anyone ever been through this process and have any advice on prep?

Do any of you stay with your current job bc of the flexibility you’ve earned over the years? I’ve been at the same company for ten years and am SO READY to make a change but I’m scared to give up the flexibility.

For example, my 3 and 1 year olds were home with me all week because daycare had to shut down. I did as much as I could, joined calls and met all deadlines but I also stepped away a lot during the day to pay attention to the kiddos. I’m scared if I go somewhere new this wouldnt be ok.

like

I’m interviewing for BCG and had a principal reach out to me for a zoom chat. Is this normal for principals to reach out or is this a positive sign?

Honestly, I’ve never been more disappointed to be an HR professional than in the last couple years. As someone who has heard and experienced the unprofessionalism during the candidate experience, I literally am questioning daily why I went into this line of work. But I tried to stay and impact the change I want to see. I just am really frustrated by an unprofessional HR Director I encountered during an interview.

like

Hi TCSers,
What does this means ?
I got a call from HR after 3 technical interview and said she can only match my CTC but she will give my candidature to other account but Didn't recieved any call .
What should I expect ?

Post Photo
like
like

What is the best way to get interview calls from middle East consulting firm offices? Currently in BCG- India Consulting team, looking for opportunity in ME. Any help with referrals will be awesome.

like

Interviewing for a Senior Analyst role in data science & analytics in Detroit. Any idea what salary I should be asking for? Don’t want to sell myself short, but having trouble finding market value. Thanks.

like

m a current student with professional exp and prior degree in FashionMerc…I did the career change during the pandemic I have 1 yr of exp and close to completing AA in networks admin… currently working on a pilot program w ALOt of down time … I’ve been thinking about leaving because am not learning as much as I would like too… am getting more exposure to systems and cloud computing through my classes should I aggressively be applying else where or stick it out until they can promote me?

like

How long does it usually take to hear back after an interview? Had first round interviews with 3 VPs last Wednesday and I still have not heard back from recruiter even after sending follow up email last Thursday

like

Bombed a case interview. Didn’t expect one for a tech company, but should’ve been prepared. Definitely not the best day

like

I was recently invited to interview for a PM role in trust and safety for a tech company. My experience is in supply chain and I have no pm experience. Should I move forward with the interview?

like

I am a PIO at a state agency and I’ve been thinking about applying to the FEMA reservist. Does anyone have experience with doing this while also being employed for a state agency? Is that a normal route to take or is there another way to gain more experience with disaster/crisis communications?

Any insight appreciated!

like

Tips for VC interviews?

like

Hi everyone! I'm applying for a Legal Assistant at a local Law Office and was wondering if I can get some feedback on my resume! Anything helps, thank you (Pictures are below)

like

More Posts

What is your best classroom management trick?

like
like

Drake or Singletary for .5PPR?

I would love to learn more about Comms strategic planning on a global scale. Can someone provide me any recommendations or advice that can assist?

like

Anyone know how working for the IRS would compare to Big 4?

Restaurants, bars in Cleveland? Thanks! Staying at the Ritz if that helps.

like

Please tell me the in hand salary. I calculated on the online platforms it is showing 1.4 per month. Not sure with this break up, need confirmation for the same. Please help.

Post Photo
like

We have Netflix in FAANG, yet don’t see much discussion about the company. What’s up with it?

like

If you weren't an engineer, what would you be?

like

I’ve recently lost 25lbs (5’4” now at 130lbs) by eating cleaner, working out, cutting out snacking/most alcohol, and portion control. I’m now plateauing. Any recs on how to keep pushing? Ideally I’d lose another 5-10lbs so nothing too crazy but just not sure what additional changes to make

likeuplifting

MBB interviewers too.

Post Photo
funnylike

My BGV is showing as completed on ionboard hcl but I haven’t given my form 16, bank statements etc… does that mean BGV is not done properly…

like

Hi guys, I've been off this app for a couple of months and I am SHOCKED with how many people joined this bowl! Thanks to everyone who has joined - can't wait to connect with you all 😊

like

Any suggestions on how to study For the OCI exams besides the learning paths on Oracle Learning site?

like

I got offer from EY GDS, but in the offer letter, in subject line, it says 'Appointment in the position of '. Also in the subsequent line, it says, 'we are pleased to confirm your appointment for the above said position'. I'm wondering if this is appointment letter and signing this would mean that I am bound to join them without considering other offers. Please help me know if EY GDS sends offer letters to everyone in this format. EY

like

I want a job in setubal .I am good at cleaner so

like

Is AD discount possible on a dj36 (fluted bezel & jubilee band)? If so, what’s general the range? Thanks guys!

like

What does it take time be financially independent?

like

I'm so amused that Elon actually bought Twitter. How do you think it will affect the platform?

likefunny

Hi Fishes
Tomorrow is my techno managerial round in
Natwest group . Can any one help me what kind of questions are asked in techno managerial round.
Thanks in advance.Natwest group RBS

Additional Posts in Designers

I accepted an offer recently and just got the email about tech equipment. It seems like a generic email: Laptop: Mac or PC, Monitor: Y or N, Mouse: Y or N, etc.
The thing is, I’m pretty picky about equipment and don’t want just any random monitor, mouse, etc. sent to me because it’ll impact my ability to do my job well. Is it rude to include links to the specific items I’d prefer? How do I phrase it so I don’t sound like an ass? I know I may not get everything, but don’t think it hurts to ask

like

When I joined the company I was to inherit a very small team of 2 to grow. In the past I have managed and built teams of 3-300.
While I still hold the responsibility of managing these two, as well as recruiting with HR, my manager has never transferred my reports to me. It seems highly unusual and confusing to the reports. What should I do?

like

Hey everyone! Any chance ya’ll could spare some likes? I’m loving this community but I’m not able to DM yet. Thanks! <3

like

Does it bother anybody else to see “Your designs are pixel perfect” in job descriptions? Nobody’s going to be perfect all the time. Stop expecting that of people.

like

Not sure if anyone else is going through this, but I'm feeling a little burned out. I don't know what it is, but I'm thinking it's time to do something new creatively.

like

Been in-house four years and managed to skip agency thus far. Considering next steps and really I’m happiest doing the work (hands-on print and visual design, brand work, etc.). Just moved. WWYD next?

Hi guys, I am updating my ux design portfolio. Any good project ideas that I can work on ? Please recommend.

like

What if you're an ad creative/ designer that isn't in it for the awards?

like

Anyone transition from Adobe Xd to Figma? Was the transition hard or are they similar in usability and function?

like

Any non-profit looking for a full time UX/UI/Product designers? 😬 would love a referral!

like

As a designer which company would you choose, Turner Duckworth or VMLY&R (Design Team) 👀

like

I currently lead a team of UX consultants working at an enterprise client. Recently, the consulting company got another enterprise client asking for a single UX resource and I am seriously considering it to diversify my experience. My concern is because this is a one UX resource request, leaving my current leadership position to become an Agile team feeding, UI-producing consultant. What are the questions you ask the client before you switch to another billable project to mitigate such risks?

like

So I've heard from a bunch of people that working as a Product Designer at a FAANG company isn't as glamourous as people make it out to be.

Is there any truth to this? Or is it just bitter people who didn't get hired?

I've heard the work life balance is tough, and that people usually leave after less than 1.5 years because the churn is crazy.

Is it worth going for FAANG companies or nah?

like

Hello everyone,

1. How do you self asses your performance as a designer and send it to your manager?
Do you make an excel format or make a presentation showing progress of projects visually?

2. I have been into design since 8+ years and my compensation is 80k CAD. Annually
With no benefits.
How much should I ask for?

3. My achievements were:
2 scholarships in design
Learning UX design - designing 2 websites in the past year.
Managing instagram posting and designing.

like

Is it bad or good to specialize in designing Native mobile apps?

I've been in the UI/UX field for 3+ years and have only had the chance to work on Native apps. (No web design)

I love app design!!

like

During negotiations, what other perks/benefits besides salary do you like to bring up to arrange?

like

Hi fellow creatives! I’m looking for any and all kinds of creative people to participate in a research study!

www.creativitystudy.com

I’m a creativity researcher working on my dissertation on the psychology & neuroscience of creativity. I’m interested in understanding how different types of creative careers, side hustles, and artistic outlets relate to our emotions, mental health, & well-being. Ultimately to help build awareness, resources, & improve the lives of creative people.

Please visit www.creativitystudy.com for more info!

Post Photo
like

I recently took a job that didn’t provide a pay bump but provided what most people would consider “a name” on the possible path to my dream job. It’s only been a month but I’m realizing that this position may not be providing me with the creativity I need to get me to my dream job as well as the pay. Would it look bad to recruiters for me to start searching again? Any advice on what to do?

like