Is it appropriate for a team during a round table interview ask where else you’re interviewing?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’d say something vague like “shops similar to this one, a few in-house opportunities.” If you feel compelled you could say something like “I’m only looking at places whose needs align closely with my experience, which is why I’m sitting here today...” and then pivot into a spiel about what you can offer.

It’s honestly none of their business and this seems to me like a type of salary fishing. If they know X agency pays mediocre and you’re interviewing with that agency, then they know their offer will be competitive even if it’s not great.

like

Thank you, agreed

like

Just because you get asked frequently, doesn’t mean it’s appropriate. Sounds like none of their business.

like

Yes, I get asked this frequently.

like

Yeah I’m hesitant but give them insight that I’m active so they know they’re not the only “suitor.” I wondered if sharing where could be used against me, or if there’s any hr policy/legality around it.

like

“You guys are literally the first agency I’ve interviewed at during my search”

like

It's not inappropriate but you definitely can choose howto answer, obviously. It's not asked about salary. It's asked to gauge competition and where you are in the hiring process elsewhere so the team knows how quickly they need to move if they like you etc. All of that said, you're free to answer with as much or as little detail as you choose. Candidates tell us all sorts of appropriate and hilariously inappropriate things - you'd be surprised the stuff various people share sometimes. I agree with the advice above where you can share that you're actively looking and pivot back to what you like about them and their opportunity and how that fits with what you bring as value.

i think it's ok for an outside recruiter to ask so they don't present you where you have already been. but no, i think during a round table interview that is not appropriate.

Related Posts

I had given technical interview for Barclays two week back. Status of my application shows as Interview Process. Overall it’s was good first round. I am yet to get update from HR. How long does it take for next process in Barclays. Any leads?
Barclays

like

Happy Wednesday everyone. I'm so excited, I have a recruiter call scheduled with @Meta for Administrative Partner position. I've been in my current employer role for 19 years and I'm nervous as heck. I haven't had to do an interview in so long. Can someone please tell me what to expect with the recruiter call? I'm assuming it will be mostly about the role, my skills and background? Do they ask salary expectations? I have no idea what to say for the salary question. Feedback appreciated. Thanks

likeuplifting

Tata Consultancy Infosys Cognizant Wipro I have completed all the technical and HR rounds and salary discussion, documents submission also done. But all of sudden got mail from hr saying that my profile is kept on hold. Any possibility that I will receive offer letter or it will be in hold forever? Meantime can I attend interview for other positions in hcl?

like

Hi Sharks,

How many total rounds does
EPAM Systems have?
I am looking for Frontend Developer role and have 2 yoe. Please let me know if anybody have any idea.

Thanks in advance.

like

Hi,

I am done with the multiple rounds of technical interviews in PWC AC and HR confirmed that the feedback is positive and they are working on next process.
Its been one week I haven't received any communication on that. When I called HR, she told that background check team will reach out to me over email or call in some days.

Can anyone suggest if I should hope for the offer letter in this case from PWC AC or not.
Also, what salary I should negotiate for Senior Associate.

like

I'm venturing out and starting to interview for different companies. Is it okay to lookup the interviewees on LinkedIn beforehand? I know most get notified so I wasn't sure if people sometimes think it's weird?! I'm probably overthinking this but I haven't interviewed in almost 10 years! Thank you for any insight!

How do you guys beat the AI that is screening job applications? I found that if I apply somewhere I get rejected. Whenever a headhunter introduces me to a hiring manager they love my experience and I most of the times get an offer.

like

Going to have my first clinical interview for urgent care ... what should I expect ??

like

I am a Java backend developer. Capgemini shortlisted my profile and conducted 1st round of interview. I cleared my 1st round of interview. He is okay and finally simply said i am looking for angular & react js guy. He simply said i will forward your resume to other team. HR sent me mail regarding documents. I sent it. After 3 days, HR contacted me and scheduled 2nd round. He simply saying that we are looking for react & angular js and said same thing. Finally HR saying you are not selected. 🙏🙏

like

Anyone have tips for the 5 interviews with team members/leaders for a user researcher position at twilio?? Have them this week and want to crush it!

like

Hey everyone,

I wanted to know the market value with 1 year of Unity 3D experience. I'm planning to switch and I'm not sure as to what would be the ideal package that I should be asking for during the interview. Please do reply and help.

Thanks in advance.

I’m interviewing for BCG and had a principal reach out to me for a zoom chat. Is this normal for principals to reach out or is this a positive sign?

: I have given interview for tech lead position / oracle programmer role & Infosys , i have 10 years of experience , job location is in AustinTx /Sunnyvale CA , what is the minimum $ I should ask ? I do not know the salary structure of the company yet ? Please advise if you have worked with infosys ? Any other advice on benefits etc ?

like

Where did I go wrong 😞🤨? Got a Masters in Bio engineering with thesis and working 10 hours a day making 150k. Saw several interviews of influencers making 20-25K for posting a picture... feeling lost

likefunny

Does anyone know the timeline between the assessor interview and the confirmation interview? Had my assessor yesterday and wondering when I might hear if I'm continuing foward.

Have you even felt completely grilled in an interview? I feel as if one of the interviewers didn’t want to see me succeed in the process.

like

Any tips on interviewing for an internal job/ promotion? I feel like it can be trickier.

like

What are the key things to look for when interviewing at a series C startup?

like

Hi, I’m looking for a production co in London who has great directors who can direct talking head interviews on location. Any suggestions?

like

More Posts

What kind of role is CFO Advisory? I'm context to US GAAP. Please suggest. A captive center is offering this role.

like

How many of you fishes have yet to step foot in an Accenture office? Thoughts on going back?

like

First/Second Year Managers in PA, could you please share your salary, group and city? Interviewing in a couple of cities and not sure what is deemed competitive

like

Darcy is engaged?!

like

Is I join Accenture this month, can I expect any hike in December cycle? Accenture

Anyone from Deloitte who works on GCP/AWS ML/AI? Would really love to chat and get to know more. Analyst rolling off in the upcoming months.

like

How is greenway health? Any idea?

like

Arnold NY, how is it? What are the accounts?

TIA

like

Gosh I hate Jim Cramer’s voice.

like

Hello! Please help me choose a career with good pay for someone with the following strengths and weaknesses:

Strength:
1- Good at computation
2- Good analytically
3- Good at arts
4- Good at singing

Weakness:
1- Hate to read books
2- Issues with focusing on something for a long time
3- Shy, not expressive in public

like

MBB manager in conversations for head of strategic operations role at large corp. Interesting but not life changing, TC of ~350-400k. My biggest concern was clarity around potential progression / career path. In 2nd interview with COO of the company (~3Bn rev & ~7k FTE) they mentioned the aim is to transition me into their role or to COO of their largest BU in 2-3 years when they become CEO. This sounded far fetched to me / unlikely or like false / unrealistic promise? Any thoughts/advice?

like

Hello All! New to this specific bowl. I was going to make a Christian bowl and alas there was one with 414 members!! Such a beautiful surprise! I pray for all of you at work, so that we may be a positive impact to those in our workplace. I hope to learn from all of you on how you lead your spiritual journey with such a rough road lifestyle (pre-covid🙄).

I want to engage in convos, what do you do at work to bring other to know Jesus? I personally educate people on finances with FPU as cont.

like

Do you have any tips/advise for someone who was laid off recently and early in their career?

like

How are SAP Projects in LTI ? Support or implementation?

like

Happy Friday watch fam!

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Another failed cycle. I barely had to pee on the stick for it to give me a raging negative, like ‘did you really think it would be positive, you shameful creature of hope?’ Clinic is shutdown.

likefunny

Per diem dinner allowance for Orlando at KPMG seems low at $33. That city has become much more expensive especially since it’s essentially a resort town. What do other firms allow?

like

Hi ,I am look log some good courses to learn cloud and devops but I am not able to find any with good industry level projects. Can someone please suggest any good courses to learn cloud and devops.also please share your experiences of learning at ed companies like simplilearn or edureka

like

3 YOE, Manchester based, 44.5k is this within normal range?

like

Additional Posts in Ask A Recruiter - Advertising

Hey Recruiters! I need some advice / insight-
I have been in media planning and strategy for 2 years now (straight out of college) but am looking to make a career change. I've always been interested in Talent Acquisition but don't know where to even begin making that jump. I would love to stay in the Advertising industry but want to try out the Talent Acquisition area. Does anyone have any tips on how to get started making that jump?

like

Are the recruiters that contact me hot by design?

likefunny

Agency recruiters, how would you rate today’s market for creatives? Is it more of a freelancers’ market or is it tight for everyone at the moment?

like

I'm days away from starting the freelance position that a recruiter found for me, then another opportunity just fell in my lap last minute with better pay and a better agency. Whats the best way to...

I got an email from an agency recruiter who wanted to set up time with me “sooner rather than later,” asking for my availability over the next 3 days, which I provided. She then ghosted.

like

How accurate are the salary ranges for job listings on Glassdoor?

From agency to client side as a executive/senior executive, is asking 15 to 20% pay increment reasonable? I have relevant industry experience as well.

How much should a social media manager or copywriter make with 2 years of experience? Trying to figure out what’s reasonable to ask.

like

Do online application go into a deep dark hole, or do they actually get looked at?

likefunny

Recruiters: When checking references, if a reference is honest that a no-fault lay-off is why you left the last agency, is that a deal breaker?

like

Any BBDO SF recruiters here, open to an informational chat? Does the outfit there have a big presence?

Super bummed I missed a recent Ask a Recruiter Happy Hour on this subject (was drowning in work at the time), would any recruiter be willing to glance at my portfolio and give me some feedback?
Thanks so much in advance!

like

Is $60k base plus commission too low of an income for a senior healthcare recruiter position ?

likehelpful

Recruiters, what are good questions to ask at the end of an interview, in particular to the hiring manager?

like

My AD coworker (not currently my partner) just got hired at a new agency and wants to bring me along as his writer. I'd love to join. He told the recruiter at that agency about me and sent my book. I also have another former coworker (creative) who put in a good word for me.

Should I reach out to the recruiter, too? Or is that overkill after two recos? I don't want to be bothersome. But I do want to show interest..

This all happened on Friday, if that matters. Thanks!

likehelpful

What's the best job board to find PR/Comms talent? Deciding between Mediabistro, ZipRecruiter, PRSA. Appreciate any and all recommendations!

like

How do you work with a creative head hunter/ recruiter?

like

What’s the current range for a senior creative recruiter in NYC? Does in-house vs agency affect the number? Or past experience as a creative?

like

Please give me some advice on how to negotiate a salary. How to ask for more money if they come low? What else beside salary can I negotiate? Anything else I should know.

like

What are the most important qualities to look for when you’re considering who to share as a reference? Obviously that they like you / would recommend you, but other than that? Seniority? Others?

helpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal