Is it better to work through an agency recruiter or an independent recruiter? Or does it not really matter?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Agency recruiter 100000000%. Independent recruiter takes a cut of your paycheck. People go to independent recruiters (often) because they have trouble going right to the agency.

like

Agency recruiter. Nothing wrong with independent recruiters but they’re really just matchmakers, they have no pull. An agency recruiter can go to bat for you internally during the process, and actually have some say in the decision to hire.

like

To clarify, external recruiters don't take a cut from your paycheck. A ridiculous way to put it. Their fee is part of the recruiting budget for the agency if they can't or won't do their own recruiting or their internal recruiters are swamped

like

AD1: You’re only partially right. If you go through an external recruiter for freelance, your hourly rate won’t be as high (typically) because the recruiter fee needs to be offset. For full time, I’ve definitely seen offers undercut because a fee was involved. While there’s typically a budget set aside for outside recruiting costs, most agencies will keep that fee in mind during offer/salary negotiations

helpful

Agency recruiter for sure, for the reasons already mentioned.

Yes i know how it works but also this is where offer negotiations skills come in. And I definitely was only referring to recruiting for full-time positions. I don't even call staffing agencies that keep a lot of the freelance hourly rate for themselves recruiting

More Posts

Had a great first day with a guy, he initiated the second date before the night ended. We’ve spoken daily, but it seems like neither of us can keep the conversation going?? I asked if we were still on for our second date as I was looking fwd to it; he’s not sure because of the weather (outdoor activity). Then he filled me on what he was doing as he was enjoying his day out with his parents. Any practical advice? I haven’t been on a date in years so it feels like I’m messing it up 😭

likesmart

I left my company without any offer in hand. What could go wrong when I apply in other companies after a span of 6 months?

like

What's the deal with analyst and sr analyst roles? My company says it's the great resignation, but I'm really struggling hiring this level.

What gives?

For those considering this role, what makes it appealing or not appealing?

like

Hello!
Are you looking for someone to refer to your company's creative department?

I'm looking for new connections and/or referrals in the entertainment industry.
As a concept artist that would love working on Video Games / Animation / Movies.

Please reach out and see if I'd be a good fit!

Post Photo
like

Anyone else’s fishbowl app not working when you click notifications?

like

I miss baseball.

likefunny

Any advice for women going into a male-dominated field? People always have something to say, and they try to make it sound challenging, so I’m wondering what I can do to have a better experience.

like

I'm a SWE from Italy. Love my country but salary and taxes here are outrageous. Got 2yrs experience in fullstack and data science, 2masters, a peer reviewed paper and outperform all my peers for 24k€ a year.
I'm thinkin about landing a remote SWE job (leetcoding and building a portfolio this summer).
Have you got some advice? Is it possible to work for US remotely without visa? What other countries pay well? Is it possible to land a 100k$+ with this kind of experience and working from Italy?

like

For those in LA area, any RE recommendations? Also, any indication from your clinics will start new cycles (or any clinics in LA already reopened)?

like

Google associate product counsel (L6) or product counsel (L7)? Was asked by recruiter to provide comp expectations. I have a sense of the base, so really wondering about initial stock grant. 5-7 YOE.

like

Crowe peeps: Is your annual level training in Chicago every year? Associates, Seniors, Managers, etc etc

like

I flew home from a client today and my delta flight’s brakes locked up shortly after landing, causing us to sit on the plane for over an hour before they deplaned us. Anyone have similar experience...

like

Anyone interested in Joining KPMG in
M&A Tax practice?
I can refer you for
Assistant Managers, Manager, Associate director post

Criteria:- CA and 2-7 yoe

like

Does your agency share creative briefs with clients? Some do and some don’t. I’m confused.

like

I have zero knowledge in French. I have a CRS score of 467 (Scored CLB 10 in English, masters, age:32). But given current draws are happening at 500+, losing hope by the day.

I need at least 25 more points to make sure I'm safe for ITA. If I start preparing for TEF now, what are my chances of getting CLB 5 in next 3 or 4 months?

Creating in-house vs side hustle:

After years working in a particular vertical, I’ve developed a framework that allows me to quickly research, size, prioritize and produce inputs for organic growth. It’s different from anything I’ve directly on/done while working at any company, and I’m tempted to build an MVP with a freelancer but scared of my employer finding out, expecting me to building it in-house (taking ownership) /file any type of (legal) complaint against me. Recs/thoughts?

like

Best way to approach recruiting for ge/vc if not coming from the most prestigious background? 2.5 YOE (1.5 B4, 1 at CPG unicorn)

like

Hi Any hiring manager here from product company looking for a business analyst?pls DM me , serving NP

like
like

Just wanted some thoughts on how people got used to the mon-Thursday traveling projects. I just recently got married, and new to the consulting world and find it a struggle to just be gone.

like

Additional Posts in Ask A Recruiter - Advertising

A recruiter from a really good agency added me on LinkedIn but didn’t message me or anything, what could be their reason for adding me if we don’t know eachother?

When recruiters “aren’t allowed to name the agency” for whatever reason, don’t you guys realize that at some point down the line we’re going to find out? And if it’s a shit place we would never...

like

What’s recruiters go place/site/app when they’re looking for candidates?

like

What’s a normal salary range for a junior recruiter to make in New York if they’re just starting out?

What are the pros and cons of reaching back out to the same third-party recruiter who got me my current full-time job, and asking them to help me get a new one? My main concern is: Would they be likely to tell my current employer? Any reason for them to do that?

like

Probably a subjective one but, best day and time of day to email you?

Any advice on cold emailing agency recruiters?

like

What are the most important qualities to look for when you’re considering who to share as a reference? Obviously that they like you / would recommend you, but other than that? Seniority? Others?

helpful

Any tips on getting a recruiter’s attention in an In-Mail message? Looking to make a career transition and am having a tough time getting responses from recruiters after I reach out. Thank you!

like

Recruiters: how many emails from outsiders do you get per day?

like

Def got ghosted for asking v high salary. Did well on interviews. Is it too weird/desperate to send another follow up email after more than a month, explain how I accidentally asked for that much $lol

likefunny

Hi! I’m currently a Sr. Recruiter at an Agency, looking for a better opportunity in NJ. I have a B.S. in HR Management, 3.5 total years in Recruiting/HR. I have experience recruiting for various industries, and across board for different levels (entry, supervisor, manager, director, cfo). I’m seeking hybrid or on-site positions at this time - any leads or reach outs are appreciated!

like

Any recruiters / talent / HR folks help people rewrite resumes and LinkedIns on the side? If so can you please PM me I am looking for someone thank you!

like

Hi! I would really appreciate your help and professional POV.
I recently received a job offer at a new company (!!) but I'm only 6 weeks away from being fully vested at my current company (which has a policy where you need to make it to three years or you don't get to keep any of the company's contributions).
Is it worthwhile telling this to the HR team so I could get a delayed start date at the new company? Or is that a no no?
The companies are a part of two different holding companies btw.

like

How do recruiters typically react/respond when candidates for a full-time position get rejected and ask for feedback?

like

What are the best recruiters in Chicago for social media roles?

Does anyone here have good sourcing resources for a Payroll & Benefits Specialist for full-time work?

like

My turn to bitch
Found out last week that a very large agency hired one of the candidates I sent to them within the 6 months in my contract. They never got back to me about the candidate...more

like

Has anyone else experienced a recruiter that ignores your emails, and places friends or people whose parents are high up in the industry even if they have less awards, pitch wins etc?

like

Do any of you need me?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal