Is it ok to deny sharing your compensation details or payslip with future recruiter citing ethical reasons?

For a fact that's not legal, but still a common practice in India. Has anyone denied sharing their details? How was your experience?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I've never denied sharing because it usually has been helpful for me in terms of negotiating salary

I suppose it depends on whether you're trying to get a huge hike or not. You're definitely not required to do so, but as A1 mentioned, it could potentially help with your negotiations.

I like using it to negotiate so I don't deny it. I'd be interested to hear how it went for anyone who has.

You can deny it if you think it won't help in negotiation, but I would expect a fair bit of pushback. Why do you want to deny the request?

Yea.. in short you will be judged by your payslip.. whether you want to share it or not is completely personal.

I have never found the need to do so, why would you want to deny sharing these details?

You can read through comments to know my reason of doing so

Some companies ask for proof to procced, so you have to show them. In case you put a point that you had been offered a higher package somewhere else, then they strictly ask for that offer letter

Related Posts

Is HDFC bank account mandatory for pwc ac Bangalore as salary account? Currently I have icici as my salary account.

like

Hi! Anyone from Tesla or know of Tesla salary structure for Entry level Product Manager? Thanks!

like

What is in-hand salary after tax deduction for 16 lpa fixed?

What’s a good exit from IB in transaction banking? Is it normally similar comp ?

like

Does anybody work for case text? If so I would love to talk about how you're liking the role and your compensation specifically as an attorney.

like

Has anyone been able to leverage high Cpa scores to get a higher salary in an interview or anything like that. I passed all exams on first try with high scores and was wondering if I can use that to get a higher salary or better position or something

funnyhelpfullike

What does comp look like at a PE FoF? Specifically interested in manager research roles and secondaries/co-investment investment teams

like

Would you leave external audit for internal audit even if there is no base increased, just sign on bonus? Been having an awful year round busy season and I’m just done. I have heard from multiple sources that WLB is better.

like

Does anyone have experience interviewing with Playstation for a non-developer, non software engineer role? I’m in the final stages of a Product Management aligned role and I am trying to best prepare myself. The recruiter has been really great, informative, and supportive so far.

like

Any mama works in management consulting? What’s your travel looking like? And comp? And work life balance in general? Care to chat?

Having an interview with a VP of Data Science tomorrow. Not sure what the interview is going to be about. Does anyone have tips for a 30 minute interview with VPs and what kinds of questions might be fielded?

like

There is this big bank where I'd love to work at, and after several interviews for various positions they end up promoting someone from within, even thou I understand it and think it’s good they promote their people, it left me feeling like I'm just being used to comply with the process.

Hi, I am interviewing for a role at @Scotiabank and I need some insight into the salary ranges for a Manager in AML Risk.

likehelpful

Hi,
Can anyone here help me with Crisill case study for structured finance?
#urgent

Hello, I am hiring a General Manager - preferable with a local passport and education - for anm digital advertising agency to start up subsidiary in SG to cater for the local SEA market.
What should I expect this person would require to receive in salary and benefits?

like

Anyone who’s been in the communications side of Western Digital: how long does it typically take to get promoted with a raise? My minimum salary is a good 10k above their cap, so I’m wondering how long it would take to get to my ideal pay Western Digital

like

How do we get the market data of salary . I am looking for investment banking field. Any websites? Pls help

like

Anyone at Coforge, Coforge ltd How's the overall WLB in company. I've an offer of 36 fix + 2 Var pay + 1 lac of joining bonus.

I've an offer of 42 fix and 2 joining bonus from @creative synergies group.

My skill set is Azure Data Engineer.
Does anyone know which company is better and which one should I join.

like

McKinsey & Company Hi Sharks,

What is the salary offered for 9yoe in Manufacturing and Supply Chain ,Operations practice for solution delivery consultant at Mckinsey India. McKinsey & Company

like

Hey guys How much salary should I ask For Associate Infrastructure L1 in Publicis Sapient I have 1 year of experience

like

More Posts

Hi folks, I have been selected for contract & commercial analyst role. I hold 6 years of experience. Would you please suggest how much salary I can expect, the interview went great.

Suggestions on learning Arabic? I'm a non native speaker but have always wanted learn the language and also be able to read/write.

like

When you become a manager and your workload gets significantly lighter so you spend your time downloading apps like Fishbowl #winning?

like

Hey guys,
I have joined GBS practice in Strategy and Business Design under SAMA in DI. I have joined as a management consultant. Can you brief me about this role and growth/learning potential? Is there travel involved? Can I get offers from good firms after 2-3 yoe in DI under this role?

like

Can anyone give any insight on pros vs. cons on cyber security vs. Data analytics? I’m looking into making a change but not sure which degree is more fundamental. Looking to stay in Healthcare

Holding 2 offers. 1 from Accenture and One from Hexaware. Hexaware paying 2lakhs more than Accenture. Which one I Can choose. Accenture taken me for Cloud. Hexaware taken me for Devops. Friends pls suggest. Confused lot

like

Hiring related question (practical and no need to be political correct): would you consider hiring a 34 years old woman, who is a fresh international graduate with a master degree in accounting and no prior working experience, for a staff position in audit/tax?

like

How fast can one get promoted from SR1 to SR2 at EY (FAAS)?

like

I am currently working in top MNC with 14 yrs experience in home care S&T, Design and Deploy roles. Have expertise in product development in Fabric solution powders, liquids and capsule formats across known brands. I have demonstrated consistent track of landing Innovation/Renovations/Clean future and saving programs.

Approaching you if any opportunity you have in your company where i can be fit, request you to please recommend.
@fmcg @consumer goods

like

Can you polish small scratches out of sapphire crystal? Perplexingly have the smallest scratch on the case and can’t remember knocking it at all.

like

Hi ladies, I’m currently in the agency world, but I’m looking to switch to an in-house Marketing Manager position. Any tips, advice or leads (virtual or Texas)?
Thanks!

like

Can someone provide me the list of good product based companies which I can apply to as Backend Developer or AI/ML engineer?
Currently working in Relianxe Jio.
I have experience of 2.5 yrs in backend and 4 months experience in AI/ML . Would like to switch my job and learn more.

Tech : Nodejs, mongodb , Redis, MySQL, ElasticSearch.
Currently learning python .
Have personal projects in Deep Learning and Computer Vision.

like

Has any has anyone decided to leave the pharmacy profession, and go into another field? If so, what did you choose? I’m currently contemplating leaving and I don’t know where to begin.

like

How does one find solid alpha groups?

like

If there is a worsening recession in 2023 will the market actually fall more or will it just stay flat?

like

Need role and salary insights about Technology Business Development Devops Sector Lead roles in Morgan Stanley, Quebec, Canada.

P.S : I have 8.5+ YoE in consulting and operations/Devops roles.

like

Hello D folks, joining soon, any tips and tricks that I need to be aware off from this group learning experience ? Any folks care to share?

uplifting

Where would you rather work and why: Grey or Saatchis London?

like

Additional Posts in Tech India

Can you suggest some good laptop models for a fresh graduate developer?
Budget max 70k

Thank you.

like
like

Do you think your company cares about your physical and mental health?

likehelpful

Hello fishes,

I need a shared accomodation in Indirapuram, Ghaziabad. If anyone is interested. Please let me know.

Thanks.

like

Just an offtopic discussion, I recently discovered my OnePlus mobile got automatically factory reset without my consent and I lost all the data that I have saved for years including contacts and important documents
,has anybody faced similar situation ever? It's really painful to go through something like this 😨

like

How is Hughes Systique Corporation I have an offer in pipeline from them for automation testing profile - python I have another offer in hand from Nagarro for automation testing - Java (flexible)

I am concerned that nagarro may not have automation testing projects
Is my concern baseless? What about personal growth from longterm perspective with respect to Java and python for automation?
Salary is almost same

like

As a salaried individual it is unfair the amount of tax we pay!

like

I lost a cousin recently and I am really depressed. Is it ok to quit my job and take some time off to mourn?

like

How many fishes here who have got more than 500% hike while switching?

like

Hi fishes!!! One of my mate has selected in IBM and she is confused to negotiate with salary.
Yoe: 3.4
Cctc: 4lpa
How much she can expect and also pls share your reviews on IBM wlb and job security

like

Has Anyone Recently Got Interviews in Delta Airlines for Senior Test Automation Engineer ?

If so could you please help me with Technical Round questions and on which are they were more focused on ? Is it Java or selenium or Rest Assured ?

#DeltaAirlines

like

People saying that yearly hike in Genpact is very low. May I know what percentage it is in average? @genpact

like

Hi Admin please approve, 4.3 java

UST global - 15L, Senior Dev
Capgemini - 17.6L (1.5 v), Sr.consultant

Please suggest which one is good, based on job security and recession in future.

like

How to deal with colleagues in office who try to book unnecessary zoom meetings and ask to join zoom call whitout no solid meeting agenda?
Joining and attending zoom meetings make me feel less productive and I can’t concentrate on my work 😓

like

Hi Guys,

Need you suggestion.
I had selected pay later while filing income tax return and finished the e verification as well today.
How can i pay income tax now and avoid any late fee/penalty by 31st July?

like

Happy New Year fishes 😊
I am SAP Ariba consultant
6.10 total, 5.8 relevant exp
CCTC 15.6 fix (17 total)

I'm interested to do one year online PGD in supply chain.
Any comments whether this is a good idea ? Or shall I focus more on Ariba module learning ?
This year I will be surely promoted to CL9 - lead. Can someone give me any career advice like something can benefit me through which I can learn more and can beg more package too ?
Thanks in advance.

Kindly recommend some self help books!

like

Which Oracle IDC project is working on Java full stack?

like

How much salary can we ask for 5 years exp with current ctc of 18.2 lpa.
Technstack:java +microservices

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal