{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Is it petty to ask for feedback after not making it past a phone interview?", "post_id": "610842d9476701001c63e9dd", "reply_count": 1, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "5ae4a4f739e7cb001391ec8b", "bowl_name": "Consulting Exit Opportunities" }

Is it petty to ask for feedback after not making it past a phone interview?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

No, you can ask but very few will give reasonable answer.

like

Related Posts

several interview rounds. Positive (glowing) feedback all around. Im then told "they" just need to check w/the CEO...a short time later "sorry, we've decided to go in a different direction"...

like

Passed the DoorDash onsite for an S&O Manager role! The last round is an interview with a director. Anyone who’s gone through this previously? Anything I should know in terms of what to expect, how to best prepare, etc?

like

For the TPM final round, can you get system design questions for non SWE or analytics domains? I was told there could be 4-5 rounds, and 2 rounds with SWE/PM etc. My domain is supply chain, so trying to prep accordingly. Is it possible to have all interviews be with TPMs/PgMs?

like

Show of hands; who has been laid off because your agency lost a big client? Also, when you interviewed for your next job did you feel comfortable saying that? And do other agencies understand?

likehelpful

What’s your next move, if any? I had three interviews at the end of August (obtained outside of their normal recruiting process) with an AmLaw 100 firm for an associate job. The managing partner was up front with me that they are trying to gauge needs and that they need a month or two for something else to shake out. This was not a clear blowoff, in context. How/when do I show continued interest/remind them I exist politely/avoid hurting my odds? Assume I’m not delusional.

like

Hello everyone, I gave first round of interview on Saturday after clearing hackerrank test for JPMC. I got this mail yesterday, does this mean I'm selected for consecutive rounds or can it be anything (including negative). Please let me know if anyone had been in similar situation. Thanks

Post Photo
like

McKinsey & Company Is it considered negative if I present my framework for too long (~ 6 mins) in the case interview?

like

How many companies can you manage interviewing for at the same time without getting overwhelmed?

like

Does anyone have experience interviewing or working with Anaplan? I’d appreciate any insights! Having an interview for a Program manager role soon.

Hi All! I work for a US based boutique tech company in the healthcare admin space. I’m currently interviewing for a senior role with a startup that is based out of Canada that is breaking into the US. Does anyone have any advice on the difference between the two workforce’s or experience with a company entering a new country? Any and all advice / tips that can be used while interview prepping would be helpful.

like

Interviewed for a role at google and my phone interview went okay but not great. The recruiter wants to connect over a call - does google make the effort to call you in person to reject you?🙄

likehelpful

I am headed to Waddell and Reed tommorrow morning for an interview. Anyone have any advice or knowledge of there practices that can not be found on there website. Appreciate any information.

like

Thoughts on the DHP (digital health plan) practice within Deloitte? Going through interview stages now. Any other practice areas I should be open to instead within HC?

like

Just learned from a colleague that they were selected for GS-13 off the street without an interview. Is this common?

funnylike

I wanted to flag so others can know, I live in mcol and I just received an offer for 120k base and a 15k signing bonus. I have three years of experience. I asked for a signing bonus and a 110k salary. If you are a senior, you should definitely be applying and just see what comes up. Crazy the market for seniors right now

likehelpful

Hi Guys, I am a consultant for EY India and have been shortlisted for PWC India Senior Associate profile. Can anyone here help me understand what salary bracket should I negotiate in? I am currently at 12 Fixed. Also does being from EY make my chances of getting in better? Anyone who’s been through similar experience, please share your stories. Interview experiences and tips would be appreciated too. Thanks

like

Onsite interview: tech round, Case round & managing partner core consulting round. Which one has most influencing decision making effect?

like

How many days will Deloitte take to provide interview result?

First time potential lateral here. Is it par for the course to provide a list of matters during the interview process for conflicts? I am wondering if it would be acceptable to hold off on disclosing that information should an offer for a job arise.

like

Final interview at KPMG with a director or an MD for associate - transformation delivery. What should I expect?

like

Additional Posts

When did you start introducing solids? Paediatrician said today we should start at 5-5.5 months. This feels early and there is no medical reason.

Looking to sign up for a points card in the UK- does anyone have a recommendation? Anyone have the Virgin Atlantic Reward+ MasterCard?

Don’t MBA programs most want the people who don’t need/want to go to business school (Private equity associates already making tons, successful startup founders, etc)? Seems like they don’t really want anyone who actually needs business school for their career.

like

Hey Fb friends - need an advise. My current firm hasn’t stated my GC process yet and with current processing time it appears to be somewhere around 12-15 months time to get PERM approved. In addition my current firm needs leadership approval & they make me sign a reimbursement form in case I quit. On other hand, I have approved i40 from my ex-employer (Big4) who fired me last fall, I don’t know if they will hire me back. Since I am from India and the date of filing appears like going to be…cont.

like

First American Kpmg global services Epicor Danske IT All paying same CTC. Which one should I choose and why? Also likes needed for DM

like

In terms of total comp, who do you think makes more: an EP at an agency or a mid level producer at a FAANG company?

like

Cam anyone DM me Deloitte supplemental benefits doc? Planning to join in few weeks and onboarding team not responding

like

After talks with my regional marketing team (RMT), each of us feels that we deserve a raise and have been underpaid since we began. We are the most productive RMT, we drive global scaling with our work as examples, and train up our counterpart teams across the globe. All of this with half the team members of the other teams and within two years of our existence. Does anyone have guidance or advice on how to raise this type of issue, and how to seek a raise both individually and as a team?

like

Can you add parents visiting from India as dependents for our health insurance. Parents want to visit but not sure how to pay for healthcare if something COVID related happens (not sure I can trust India based insurers if something big happens).. any recommendations ? TIA

like

On the Bloomberg Article about Faster Promotion/Pay Raises: Who at MS is trying to get your boy a job?! 😂

like

Hi Ladies, This is a lengthy post, about a family matter. I am seeking some advice from the sisterhood. I am a married mother of a boy who is in Pre-K. I have been married for 8 years now. Contd..

like

Have you ever seen one of the nicest, most talented, hardest working people get fired for no good reason. Really breaks my heart about how heartless this industry can be ☹️

like

Worked really hard on some work only for it to be discarded/not get utilized. Super demotivated right now...how can I change my mindset to feel better?

like

Prob been asked but how do you best use Bonvoy points. Debating 60k/night in Iceland or saving up for 85k/night Ritz in Caymans (or something like that). Generally what level to spend the points?

like
like

Anyone at ATL Sky Club?

like

Taking some time off. Need some book recommendations. Some light interesting non-fiction. No self help or management books. Just interesting topics that won’t make me think about work.

like
likehelpful

Prestige or 30% better take home salary?

funnylike

Opinions on what happening with Facebook and their poor employee outlook? What will FAANG be if Facebook hits the fan? NAAG?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal