{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Is it unusual if you are a M3 who has been rated 5/5 this year and for the past two years but was not considered for a promotion to SM?", "post_id": "5934591cacd1590011022932", "reply_count": 10, "vote_count": 4, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting", "feed_type": "crowd" }

Is it unusual if you are a M3 who has been rated 5/5 this year and for the past two years but was not considered for a promotion to SM?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Agree most take 4 yrs at mgr. some but very few do it in less.


Not unusual. I was in similar situation for a few years. Aside from doing great work you have to perform "at the next level" for at least a year in order to get promoted. Depending on project size you may not have a chance to do this.


No, not unusual in PI anyway. Typical track is 4 years at M


OP - what practice ? In PI there are a lot of very experienced Managers. There are only a limited slots for new SM. In scenarios like you mentioned, it's better for the firm to promote higher performing, but more experienced managers (M4/M5), than to promote high performing, but less experienced managers (M3 and Below). These is a lot of lateral hiring at the M level, and it is possible that many of them were SM material when they were hired.

I'm in this exact situation have consistently been a top performing manager, currently an M3 and the messaging has been you've had a fantastic year, but there are a lot of M4/M5s and it's going to be really tough to "jump" ahead of the line, which is bullshit because I am performing at the SM level and there are a bunch of relatively worthless SMs in my practice. In PI if you're curious. So unless there's some huge raise (which I'm doubting) not sure that I plan to wait until next year.

How long is path to partner at EY? 5 years at manager is insane.

Yes, I'm in PI as well. So @Manager 2, are you thinking industry or another consulting firm?

I've only done consulting in my career so likely consulting, but if something interesting came along in industry I'd think about it.

@Deloitte 1: for better or worse, I think EY is less up or out than Deloitte. That provides a bit more job security, but can also slow down career growth because it's acceptable to be at a rank for longer duration.

Related Posts

I hear people are getting another raise at Moss Adams. Is this true? How much is everyone getting?


Forget the catered lunches and tacky care packages, what's something your supervisor could do that would actually make you feel valued? Outside of a raise, I can't afford to give my whole team a raise.


I’m working at a very niche, boutique consulting firm. I’m happy, but was always open to exploring my horizons, especially because the compensation was fairly low. With COVID-19, workflow has been non stop, but significant shortages in cashflow (despite growing clients) has resulted in no foreseeable raise, and opting between 401k and bonuses. I’m more proactively jobhunting now, but have only one interview at a larger firm and 0 boutiques. Any recs on who is hiring? I’m desperate.


Currently working at a boutique consulting firm but currently considering an offer to either:

- Get hired as an FTE (work is pretty chill, job security is good, and I would receive a small raise)
- Go back to Accenture (work would be more stressful, job security is medium-low (out model if you do not progress) but would receive a bigger raise). Also traveling again may suck.

Any advice would be appreciated.


My company promised me a promotion that was ultimately postponed indefinitely due to COVID. Rather than stay, I am now seeking new opportunities! Would love to hear about any companies currently hiring (anyone going through a hiring frenzy?) Referrals and advice/tips are more than welcomed! 😊 Thanks to all for reading :))


What are comps on a percentage increase basis working out this year across firms. Comment with your firm, group, level and %raise this year and include if your were promoted. I’ll start.


I’ve seen some of my colleagues update their LinkedIn profile with their promotion. Is it too early for that?


I'm up for promotion at work. My workplace does not have competitive wages and I'm worried they're going to saddle me with much more responsibility for not enough pay. I'm not quite sure how to broach the subject of the wage and I could use some advice.


I’m currently an SAE at an agency in DC making $75k. 2.5 YOE but it’s my first agency job.

Is this a good salary for the role and my YOE? What salary should I be pushing for next year, whether it’s a raise or at a new firm? I’m new to agency life so any input is appreciated!


For those in Advisory and not pursuing their CPA, what are the other credentials you can use for promotion to senior?


I need sponsors for my promotion. I have this really big mental block when it comes to networking. Especially with everything being virtual. The thought of 1:1 video chatting someone I don’t know personally to see “how can we mutually benefit each other professionally” is just so dis genuine to me … it gives me a lot of anxiety. How do I get over this mindset?


When getting promoted, is it common for agencies to propose a new salary/raise or do employees give a figure first? If the former, how much room for negotiation is there (if any) + what's the (cont'd)

Additional Posts

Best DC neighborhoods to live in? Looking for an apartment to rent, not a house to buy. Budget is $3000 for a 1 bedroom apartment for 2 people.


Hope someone knows.
Which agencies in NY work with gaming or esports?

I ordered my first pair of beta brand stretch yoga dress pants and am in LOVE! However they’re basically sold out of everything in my size until April or May... wondering if anyone has tried (cont)

Looking into private schools. My kid will be a 5th grader next year & I’d like him to go somewhere coed he can stay through 12th. Anyone recs?


Oh tomorrow is Friday? Okay, here is everything I need you to do. These 3 things are emergencies, can you have them done ASAP. And everything else by Monday. Oh, have a great weekend!


Just finished a bag of Doritos and noticed it says Doritos is “for the bold” on the back. Feels good to know I can be bold in my underwear watching TV eating carbs with zero nutritional value (...)

Post Photo

Anyone ever put their two weeks in around Christmas right before busy season? Any regrets?


Would love to buy a ski condo out West to rent out during the year (have ~$100k for down payment). Any suggestions? Is it a bad idea in this RE environment?


I hear people are getting another raise at Moss Adams. Is this true? How much is everyone getting?


As a project manager, if the client keeps adding scope, and I’m pushing back to protect my team due to resource & time constrain, is it good? Or should I kiss client’s ass?


Looking for an exit to an early/late stage startup in NYC. How do I go about this?


For anyone who received a coronavirus check, would you mind sharing the merchant name on the transaction that showed up in your bank account? I want to know what to look for.


CPA vs CISSP? I’d like to get into cyber but come from the accounting background. Currently doing IT Audit.


What are the odds of finding another accounting role that is 100% remote indefinitely with comparable pay?


Starting as an experienced hire at the associate position at BCG (US) in a month. Looking for advice and tips, especially from BCG 🐠 and experienced hire 🐠 re: staffing, building network, PD, etc


Need to covince my family to let me live by myself. Any tips?


Over the next couple days, my colleague Jess (who heads all our customer experience work) and I will be popping in and out to take questions on the topic of becoming a homeowner. Hope we’re helpful!


Would love to hear some Cannes stories!


When you first joined your job, what were told to do and not to do?


New to Manhattan. Been here a few weeks now and the WFH is finally getting to me. Would love to make new friends. 27M


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the Fishbowl app

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or