I've seen some negative comments about dividend investing. I think its a pretty good way as passive income. I am 23 and contribute to my Roth 401k but I've also had my own portfolio since I was 18. I've mainly been focused on dividend stocks and I'm now at $250 a year from dividends. How can this hurt in the long run?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Dividends are inefficient from a tax perspective and those funds almost always underperform the market in the long run.

The only real "benefit" I've seen is that psychologically, it feels like you're getting paid. But what's the point of getting a $250 dividend on a fund that grew 5% (and had taxable dividends) when the market itself grew 10% (just an example)?

like

KPMG: Traditionally dividends ARE profits. It’s rare for a company to pay dividends while making a loss, at least over the medium term.
If the company can’t reinvest profits at a higher return than the cost of equity then it should absolutely pay dividends.
Just because a company doesn’t have highly profitable reinvestment options doesn’t make it a bad company. Investing in low returning projects would be far worse.

Holding a stock means you are part owner of a business, they aren’t some abstract financial product.

Why do you need passive income pre-retirement? While dividends held over a quarter LT taxable (yes, even if you reinvest), why pay that tax now?

like

Microsoft is a value/growth stock still, with a hefty dividend. I’d rather have that in an index where it doesn’t get passed through. I’d personally avoid individual stocks, though.

like

You missed out on the greatest dividend buy in decades when XOM was yielding 10%

like

Are you treating dividends as different from capital appreciation?

like

Stock picking is even more dangerous than dividend investing.

smart

I buy SCHD and HDV to get growth and dividends . It is a small part of my portfolio.

like

Dividends are taxable

Disagree that dividend funds underperform. Dividend investing is a good way to target investments in profitable but slow growth companies and value stocks. These are companies that are highly successful but have limited reinvestment opportunities. Overall their returns historically have beat the market. However they do limit diversification and need to be done carefully. However, investing in an index and targeting value stocks as a percentage of portfolio is probably more diversified than dividend investing. In the very long run, almost all stock returns are basically from dividends.

Exactly my thinking. Most dividend stocks are some of the biggest companies in the world that have constant returns and still continue to grow

Why do we all vti if it pays dividends? Or does it stay in the fund?

Reinvest.

like

Related Posts

Recommendations for how to allocate 401k with Fidelity. Just switched jobs and have to move from Merrill Lynch to Fidelity

like

How is EY’s HealthCare Insurance sector growing? Who are your major Payer & Provider clients?

In 2018, I founded a boutique ODD advising firm with a primary client base in healthcare and biopharma. I am now transitioning from FT consulting through my firm and exploring new opportunities.

I have over 25 years’ experience in healthcare and oncology clinical research. While I’ve worked in a variety of business entities, my preference is start-up. If there are any HCLS/health tech start-ups looking for a leader that can hit the ground running, I’d love to chat.

like

If anyone is interested in learning more about personal finance please let me know. My friend and I are teaching a class tomorrow night where we discuss all aspects of personal finance.

We’ll cover 401k, IRA, Roth, debt, ETFs, savings, budgeting, etc.

Class is $25 and we offer a 100% money back guarantee if you don’t learn anything from our class.

If this interests you please PM me and I’ll send you the details.

like

I am a Business Transformation consultant, having worked for Asset & Wealth Managers, Investment Bank, Boutique, Government Pension Fund, Family Office as part of my current role with a small consulting firm.

I am looking out for a new role in Singapore. Any leads or references would be helpful.

like

Can interns get benefits like RSUs?

like

Anyone know of companies that don’t require 1 year of work before taking paid maternity leave?

like

Living in VHCOL city, single M mid 30s, is 50k a year expense ‘too much’?

likefunny

What's the longest anyone has fasted? Let's say I wanted to fast for 48 hours, are there any health benefits to doing that 1x a week?

like

Just started my first job out of college. What percent of my income should I put towards retirement? I’m planning to max out my Roth (as I’ll reach the income limit in a few years) then put some in my 401k. My company does not match anything but automatically puts 5% in a profit sharing retirement fund.

How much savings does a 40 year old realistically need to retire?
For sake of discussion, let’s assume house is paid off, need to purchase decent healthcare, you have a healthy 401k, and are single with no kids.

I’ll guess that you need at least $500,000?

like

What percent of salary is your RRSP match or pension? Please feel free to comment even if it's zero so we have a full picture

like

Does anyone have any insight on what is entailed during an “expertise chat” at McK in Healthcare Services & Technology? I spoke to a recruiter and made it through to the next step. The next step is the expertise chat before moving on to the official first round interview. Any insight appreciated.

like

How much of an increase in benefits in would you be willing to accept to move to industry? Good role but not the dream.

like

How much should I negotiate for the salary ?
Role offered - BI Lead
YOE - 5 years, Current CTC - 13.5
What should be the ask as Fixed CTC ?
Do we have variable pay and others benefits on top of fixed ?

Does Capgemini provide reimbursement for technical certifications? What is the process to be followed?

like

A pensive Saturday thought.

How do you calculate the emergency fund allocation in your portfolio?

I mean, I have equity and MFs, where I invest about 50% of my monthly salary.

Just confused about how to plan for emergencies.

Should that be in debt funds and what could be a safe amount for a 29 year old guy looking to get married soon.

like

Hi, I wanted all your opinion I have got
offer from ADP & Thoughtworks almost
both are paying equal. Which company is
better from learning perspective, Job
security wise & benefits ? My skill set is
Automation Testing - Selenium Java.
Please let me know your inputs. Thanks in
Advance

I am an RN with 10 + years bedside experience. I work part-time as a school nurse at a private school. I am wondering how much nurses make per diem working as a school nurse. I live in Florida.

like

Incoming EY SM. Can anyone tell me who EY’s pension provider is please? thank you!

More Posts

How is everyone going to stay fit over the holiday weekend? I'm going to the beach with my family, and there will be lots of drinking. Need help and encouragement fam!

Any good advice for going into the negotiation meeting with an agency? How does your process look like? Kind of new to this world :)

like

What is the annual hike for associate 2 level in PwC AC with 4+ years of experience.What is the salary range for the same ?.

like

DM me if you need referrals for following positions at Virtusa:

Cypress+Automation (4-7 years)
.Net+CRM Developer (6-8 years)
SDET Engineer - Python/Java & Rest API (4-6 years)
QA Lead - API Automation (9-15 years)
Big Data Developer - Spark with Scla (5-7 years)
Wintel Admin (12+ years)
Java Microservices (4-8 years)
Java Developer (4-10 years)
Java with AWS developer (5+ years)
Business Analyst - Capital Marketing/FX Products (5+ years)
Salesforce Health Cloud (3+ years)
Synon Dev (4-10 YOE)

like

People entering ITPP Office first time

Post Photo
funnylikehelpfulsmart

Can one self buyout remaining Notice period at Mastercard India? What is the procedure?

like

What is the Green card filing process in @ThermoFisher ? @ThermoFisher

like

How I feel explaining a really complicated workpaper to my boss who doesn’t know vlookups, sumifs, or how to filter by color.

Post Photo
likefunny

What are your firms/companies doing when general offices are permitted to open up next Monday? Are they opening? And if so, what measures are they implementing? Or are they continue to allow WFH?

How many Deloitte Workday consultants got laid off? In the Consulting bowl there appear to be a few, which surprised me. Workday tends to be strong. I even see Deloitte is hiring right now.

like

Interested in pursuing a PhD in Econ (don’t have research experience or the math classes yet) what can I do to strengthen my app? Should I apply for a masters before phd? Graduated from a T20 undergrad with a finance major and good gpa, been working at D as an analyst for a year now

like

That game on google homepage definitely killed my afternoon productivity smh

likefunny

How is Williamsburg to live as a first time New Yorker?

like

Hey guys, I just recently graduated with my bachelors degree and am working full time as a software engineer. I want to continue my education and in a few years apply to one of the bigger tech companies. Not necessarily a FAANG, but I would like to be prepared enough that I could take a job at a FAANG company at a mid senior level. What would you guys suggest doing to further my education? Are there classes or certifications that would be helpful? I hear a lot of people talking leet code?

like

Are udacity nano degree/certificate useful or beneficial in any way

like

If I have to take the red line then walk out of the station to take the blue line, do I get charged twice?

like

Has anyone been successful at creating “boundaries” in the workplace both with duties and relationships with bosses and not been gaslighted to believe they just aren’t being a team player ( or in other words highly agreeable)? I’ve seen it happen around me and I’m waiting for the day it directly effects me. I would love to learn from your experiences and success stories…

like

Thinking of buying this one. What do you guys think about it ?

Post Photo
like

Any thoughts on Be Grizlee?

like

Hello, does anybody have an recommendations for hospitality experts in Texas? Defending a hot coffee case.

like

Additional Posts in FIRE Financial Independence Retire Early

Are there any books on financial independence y’all would recommend?

What’s a good, practical tax book to read for someone who knows nothing about taxes? I feel like I should familiarize myself with them but don’t know where to start/find the topic very overwhelming and dense even as a finance attorney. Welcome to other beginning finance book suggestions too! (Already read Kiyosaki and Ramsey)

like

Just got my first promotion of my career and with it about a $15k salary increase. I want to put most, if not all to retirement. I already max my Roth IRA, 401k and HSA. Are there any other specific accounts or things I should be doing with this money or should I just put it all into a brokerage?

like

Never used Vanguard before and kinda confused on the site. What are the go-to funds people put their money into that are lowest fee and just generally track the us market? Or just the most popular? Thanks for any advice!

like

How do I invest in index funds? I have $10k. I want to set it and forget it and check on it once a year. You can recommend a website, person/team, app, or whatever you use. 👍🏻

Or, give me another thing to do with the $10k.

like

I have about $70K total in undergrad/law debt. I accepted a job in big law starting in fall of 2022. I’d like to be debt free as soon as possible but given that student loan interest is frozen and has the potential to continue to be for the foreseeable future, any recommendations on where I put my money in the mean time? I’m thinking I’ll make the minimum payments upon graduation and let my money grow elsewhere until loan interest starts up again then make lump sum payments. Thoughts?

like

Hi everyone, I am looking for ideas on how to pivot out of accounting. A remote job ideally. If you were previously in accounting and switched roles, I would love to hear about it as well.

My background is:

3 years Financial Audit - manage small team, manage engagements, client facing

2 years Industry Accounting - manage small team, improve monthly processes, month end close, reconciliations, generate financial reports, generate budget and forecasts

like

Have a friend that just signed up for a 529 plan in Utah (we live in Texas) - is that really the best one or are there better plans out there offered by other states? Texas is no state tax so I don’t really care about the tax breaks unless it’s a federal one which I don’t think exists...

like

Has anyone ever worked part time with turbo tax or something similar? Buying a house and would like to find a way to bring in some extra cash. TIA!

like

Stupid question but I gotta ask. I’ve got like 30k sitting in a checking account, I feel like I should push it into VTI and forget about it, but for some reason I feel like a downturn is on the horizon and I don’t want to lose a chunk of it. Already have plenty in emergency fund, no debt. Already bought my 10k of iBonds.

like

How much should you ideally have in checking and savings?

like