Just got butchered in my first ever case interview 😭

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Well, dust yourself off and try again. I bombed a bunch of interviews recently.

like

Yeah, it is what it is. Lesson learned and time to move on.

like

What was the question

likefunny

If you don't think you're going to get the job why hide/protect it? 😋

Welcome to the club. Get em on the next one.

likeuplifting

Congrats!

funny

Did you learn anything about case interviewing? Take any lessons from it? Things you can do better next time?

like

Can't wait to see your follow up post: "Crushed my case interview and got the offer for double my current TC!"

likeupliftingfunny

That's ok. You'll learn from it, and do better next time.

like

Don’t talk about interviewing for those behavioral questions! Talk about a real life work situation - it holds more weight and is more legitimate

smart

Consider it practice for future and move on with more experience and savvy. :)

like

That’s the spirit, OP! :)

That’s not necessarily a bad thing at all FYI; it’s about how you handle the situation, answers, posture, critical thinking.

uplifting

Yup! The whole intention is to test your limits; consulting firms don’t like “know it all’s”. Just wait for results and let’s hope for the best :)

like

My first was truly terrible, second got me a job. Now you know how it’ll roll in real life, and you got this!!!

like

Related Posts

If you were honest in an interview... "Where do you see yourself in 10 years?"

like

Have an interview with GS this week for a Bank Compliance Associate role. Genuinely have no idea what these types of roles usually command (base + bonus). Any insight?

like

Just accepted an apps modernization PMO type role with D for $105k and got an email tonight asking to interview for PwC deal advisory associate role 😩. Bad timing. Would love to get M&A exp.

likehelpful

I’ve got a 3 hour long callback interview via zoom coming up sometime in the next couple of weeks. How do I keep from becoming fidgety and zoning out?! Seriously worried

like

Anyone interview with via? How is it

likehelpful

Flying into SFO to give an interview next Friday, Should I wear suit? As the company CEO never wears one.

like

Have an upcoming interview for a capabilities & insights analyst role at McKinsey - how does this role and track differ from the others at McK? Will I get to do some client interfacing?

like

I need advice on salary negotiation. During the interview process, I said I’m expecting a salary of 130k. They called me and said I’m the one and wanted me to agree on a number before putting it (cont

like

Bain 🐠, I have my first interview coming up. It’s for a consultant role in a specific Practice. What to expect in this interview? Also, how big your the EMEA presence? (Team size, projects, growth?)

like

Interviewing for Google - Sales Strategy and Ops Senior Associate role. If anyone has any tips, especially for the case interview and potential questions, it would be greatly appreciated!

like

MBB interview... what are the best resources for case prep?

likehelpful

Applying for some MPH and MS epidemiology/biostats programs at Harvard, Columbia and JHU and also thinking of the Duke Healthcare analytics. Is MPH valuable at all or am I wasting my time? I am trying to push more into trial design and clinical valuations + outcomes research.

like

Applying to T15 in R2. Currently have a 700 GMAT (43Q, 41V) after taking once. Even if I raise my quant to 47, which would be impressive for me, I’ll still be at a 700 (possibly 710). 3.6 undergrad GPA. Worth retaking? Or just focus on the rest of my applications?

like

Anyone know any good materials for REPE interviews?

like

Anyone know much about Sikich based in Chicago? Have an interview with them for a position in their business valuation and litigation advisory practice.

ClearView Healthcare Partners anyone willing to provide a referral? Applying for an entry level consultant position (PhD). Happy to chat about my credentials, resume etc.

like

I’m starting to wonder if the Biden admin assigned Kamala this “border excursion” to watch her fail. I liked her better before she gave interviews.

likehelpful

Anyone laid off from Deloitte been getting interviews? (Not for tech roles but more finance) im getting traction from head hunters but not much from firm website applications

like

I’m applying for an industry job and the company has no parental leave benefits whatsoever. Even FMLA is just unpaid 12 weeks and require 1 yr of service. HR rep literally said “my kid is 18, I don’t

Additional Posts

I have to vent... I’m all for male/female equity in our and any industry. But, the one thing that gets to me is the number of Moms I’ve worked with that get to work from home on Friday because of it.

likefunny

How do people in industry get promoted so fast? I have friends at fortune 500s who get promoted once a year or even less. Even my younger cousin just graduated last year, and at 8 months got promoted to “customer success manager” whereas in Big 4 I’ll be in my late 20s by manager

like

I’ve been laid off and, as I embark on my job search, I’d like to keep my marketing skills sharp. Any recommendations on must read books, or resources?

like

Anyone looking for referral in Chegg Inc . DM me. Thank you

like

My project is requiring a lot of time commitment during early hours and evening and it’s getting hard to pick up LO from day care. I wanted advise frm ppl who have hired help for pick/drop off.

Any Deloitte 🐠 looking for a project? Need a BA or C with very strong excel modeling and Tableau skills for an immediate opportunity. Would love to staff within the family.

likeuplifting

I’m in my 4th week of WFH. For everybody having a hard time being isolated, things get better per week ✨

likeupliftinghelpfulfunny

Has anyone ever tried negotiating for more vacation rather than a higher salary? I'm applying and interviewing for jobs right now. Some firms have unlimited PTO while others only give a few weeks. Personally, I'm much more interested in getting an additional week of vacation and would rather negotiate for that but usually only hear of people negotiating for salary. Has anyone had experience with this?

like

Anyone heard of Equitable Financial? They’re trying to pitch some life insurance investment vehicle for tax benefits. Sounds like BS but want to hear from other

likefunny

2018 i was laid off, took a salary and title cut, only got a 1% bonus from Accenture, final round and rejected by BCG, and today McKinsey Digital. Any words of hope? Thinking of leaving consulting.

likehelpfulfunny

I always hear stories about how it’s possible to hide in the big 4 and not be staffed...what’s the longest you’ve heard someone pull this off for? How did they do it? Asking for a friend..

like

I can't wait for the first zombie movie to go extra realistic and have a bunch of entry level hires at Big 4 firms complain that being eaten by a zombie is preferable to closing hair salons.

likefunny

what % of your post-tax base salary do you save? (excluding bonuses etc)

like

Has anyone recently gotten their H1B visa stamping done in Mumbai using Dropbox. If yes, what was the processing time and the overall experience? Any insight would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

like

When you work from home and set the alarm for 9AM and consider that "sleeping in"... I feel old.

like

Today, I showed a TED Talk about the Guatemalan genocide. We were discussing the role of forensic anthropologists. It made such an impact on my students. I teach in a super red state and district and often my students do not see the pain of our Central American neighbors and why they seek asylum here. I tied their plight to my mom’s post-WWII and asked them why she was welcomed by our current immigrants are not. It was so powerful. One of my LatinoX students told me thank you for today’s lesson.

likeuplifting

Have an interview for a role with EY's human capital consulting group tomorrow. Any opinions on the practice?

like

Was hired into a company at a level that was more junior than my skills (Was out of work due to pandemic for a year). I’ve been at the company 5 months. We’re going through a reorg and my new position will really be leveraging my years of experience more so than other role. Is it appropriate to discuss a raise/adding senior to title? Or should I do the job and then prove myself then talk about raise. I have more experience than the senior members of my team. New leadership than when I was hired

like

Has anyone had success with changing the lighting in your classroom? I'm thinking about replacing the use of overhead lighting with lamps.

like

Any consultants on the Tier 2 General visa who ended up working from outside UK? Accenture wouldn't approve the request to work remotely, so I did it for 60 days anyway but I'm worried if it would impact my ILR application.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.