Left Bain for an offer at a small tech company, and it took the new employer a month of pushing my start date, poor communication, and “internal discussion” to pull the offer because they think my US work visa is too risky for them, despite immigration lawyers backing me saying there’s virtually no risk. I’m now out of a job and on my visa grace period due to their incompetence (bullet dodged).

Any advice on potential actions besides jumping back into recruiting? Feeling quite disrespected 😫

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Sigh. Always make sure your visa transfer is confirmed before putting in the papers at your existing job.

Re: next steps, not much you can do. You could try to sue, but that’s going to need a lot of your money and time, but the reward could be worth it. Would consult a lawyer.

like

Speak to a lawyer to see if there are serious grounds to sue. If so, call back the employer and explain that you will sue if that's where it gets to but that you want to keep it amicable and you're still very much wanting to work there if they are willing to make it work. Not the best of starts but you need the visa more than settlement money.
Otherwise if Bain will take you back that's also a good option before jumping into recruiting (maybe after a while...). Would try to connect with your highest relationship there and have them support you through the transition.

likeuplifting

Another option I haven’t seen mentioned is to find a lawyer to write a strongly written letter and look for some sort of cash “settlement”. Decent chance the company would just cough up some money to have you go away and helps offset your lost income while continuing your job search.

I definitely wouldn’t want to work there at this point though, even if they agreed to bring you on... sounds like a shitty employer. Would be nice to drag some money out of them though.

likesmart
Recent IconRecent

Life lessons. A job isn’t real until you have a signed, non-contingent offer letter.

like

You can still sue, talk to a lawyer. You quit to join them and they reneged for no real reason

like

That’s horrible and unacceptable. Would definitely look into what rights you have and if you have grounds for action.

If you’re on good terms with Bain, would also pass along the intel to whoever so they can blacklist the company for future alum exits.

You’ll definitely find a new job and get back on your feet!!!

like

Do people normally leave their jobs before the new job is actually final? A visa seems like something that you would absolutely want to wait to clear before you quit...

likefunnysmart

Is it a TN or an OPT?

like

Switch to McKinsey if you are good no one is going to care about this BS . Be honest and upfront

likehelpful

You should have no issues going back to Bain or any other competitor firm. It’s just difficult that your 60 day period is during the holidays and a pandemic. I’d say, get back in touch with your old team if you left on good terms

like

Focus on landing the next job first. Try to sue them/shame them after that.

like

Happy to refer. We are ramping up experienced hiring, at least in my office (NYC)

like

What practice

like

Don’t have any advice, but thinking of you, OP!

uplifting

Do you have the option to go back to Bain?

like

Could be promissory estoppel, but employment is at will in most of the US so I don’t think you have any grounds to stand on. It’s not uncommon to have offers withdrawn, sadly.

like

Well a bainie never lets another bainie fail so you should be good yo

uplifting

Dm me for EY referral. Would love to help

like

Sorry to hear this OP. This must be very difficult for you. Can you log into the Bain Alumni job board and check out any new opps there?

DM me , maybe we can find a job for you :)

DM for EY referrals

Or a EYP referral

Please make that company public so that we all know which ones to stay away from

Never resign before H1B transfer is approved. You don't have many options, try the Global Immigration bowl for some advice. Your only true option is to get back into recruitment or you'll have to move to B2 visa after your 60 days grace expires.

Happy to refer you at PwC and help out by connecting with the recruiter/hiring manager directly if you are interested.

Related Posts

Looking for recommendations to generally upskill my Strategy work (or learn from scratch) — be it courses, classes, books, podcasts, people to follow.

For context, I’m a freelance Social Media Manager/Strategist and I came into Ad world via Startups. Throwing myself into learning on the job with more Strategy gigs - but I still don’t feel like I quite know the lingo or best practices or theories.

like

What are exit opps if you make it to Principal in PE but don't get promoted to partner at your fund?

Move to another fund or?

Would love a view for both Ops side and Investment side of the house. Thanks!

like

Is a product associate (ie. 210 job code) a dead end job? Trying to decide between a product associate role at JPM or a FDD role at a medium sized consulting firm.

AWS Cloud Practitioner advice about the program and details for skills training for the next step. How to be career ready?

Is there a minimum work experience for experienced hires for MBB? It so, how long will that be? Is 6 months enough?@

like

Anyone have good ideas of some exit ops if I have worked 3 years tax then 2 years audit?

like

If I'm looking to have the CFP completed 12-18 mths from start date, what would be a solid prep course/program you guys would recommend? Any pref to online classes vs. in-person classes?

like

Directors/MDs that are not on the partner track, help me understand how that works? Why and when did you decide to go that route vs leave vs try to make partner? Pros/cons? What’s the salary like?

like

Any recommended study material for CIPP and/or CIPM (still debating the two)?

I started my career in the military and am 5-7 years behind my peers. Is there an age at which I should rule out making it to partner and instead plan for MD or an exit to a C-suite role?

Hi folks,

Need an advice from you guys. I joined TCS Kolkata as a BPS employee in 2014 and currently I'm in a Finance project working as a Senior Analyst. I have always wanted to be a developer so recently I acquired the knowledge of HTML, CSS, Javascript and Angular. So can I apply for the same in other companies? Or they only want freshers in this segment? As my overall experience is 7+ years but will I be treated as a fresher if I apply for the same?

like

Any suggestions for books to help determine your next career move? Considering leaving consulting for other opportunities (biz ops, product management, non-profit, etc.), but unsure when the right time is and what to pursue next

like

I'm offered a role of Specialist ( Package implementation) with 7 YOE @LTI. Is this equivalent to a role of team lead??

like

I am currently in Retail Project Management (coming up on 2 years) right now and am looking to make a shift into real estate finance. My degree is in finance, and I am really looking to pair that degree with my passion for real estate investment. Any suggestions on how to make the transition? I am just concerned on how to sell my current experience to a finance-specific role. Any thoughts and comments are greatly appreciated!

like

Feel like I missed the boat years back to get into Director of Product role. Back in the day there was only Senior in between a Director role, now there’s Lead and Group levels, so much hierarchy now.

like

In Wipro portal is showing my career stream : project management

What is the meaning

like

So I want to know everyone's opinion on the CFA exam and whether it helps in a career in investment management. I'm 24 and in two minds about it. Advice?

like

Hi Fishes, I have H1 visa but my travel

like

I’m looking to get out of direct patient care, and would love to find a job where I can work from home (even if that’s something in the future.) I would like some advice with switching careers into healthcare data, healthcare informatics, etc. I’m currently a nuclear medicine technologist with 2 years experience, and a BS.

like

How is CIB at jpmorgan chase

like

More Posts

I have an experience of more than 2 years in financial operations, audit and compliance, reports management and data analysis. Is there any opportunity in EY GDS as per my skills?

like

Can anyone speak to the work/life balance and workload for Tech Recruiters at Amazon?

like

What's your hands-down favorite restaurant in the city? Just moved to the area and I'm excited to try them all out. (Bonus points for sharing what makes it special!)

like

Is MBB Chicago a popular/competitive office choice that is comparable to SF/NYC/Boston?

uplifting

Completing my onboarding at Accenture. How long after your start date did you receive your laptop in the mail?

like
like

What do you think about the Octo 38mm? Still undervalued imo. Got this half a year ago and appreciate it. However don’t wear it that often… in the end it is kinda „special“.

Post Photo
like

Please dm for freelancing/training/guidance in SAP CPI DS

like

Drunk account director here. AMA.

likeuplifting

Anyone at Coforge, Coforge ltd How's the overall WLB in company. I've an offer of 36 fix + 2 Var pay + 1 lac of joining bonus.

I've an offer of 42 fix and 2 joining bonus from @creative synergies group.

My skill set is Azure Data Engineer.
Does anyone know which company is better and which one should I join.

like

Want to get everyone's thoughts on a trend I'm seeing lately. Not yet at my own company but with people close to me.

I'm sure we've all seen the uptick in companies asking their employees to come in to the office more often.

Given the economic environment, does anyone feel that companies are doing the Musk thing: mandatory office attendence to cloak a need for a workforce reduction? Like coaching people out so you don't have to fire them and be the bad guy essentially.

like

Best dosa spot in Charlotte, NC?

like

I have working as a Data Scientist in one of the leading analytics firm, I wanted to move to Google as Data Scientist, for which I'm taking a year of prep, someone plz guide me the way to prepare, upskill and crack their interviews.

like
likeuplifting

Should we do another ASL thread 🤨

like

What’s an acceptable range for an Account Executive VS Senior Account Executive? In Singapore... Not sure if I’m underpaid....

like

What number of hours per week is legal? Trying to understand what people think about companies having a 45-hour minimum to bill on timesheets per week?

like

Any thoughts on Winston and Sidley openings in Miami?

like

Received offer. Thought about it for a week. Ready to accept. Recruiter reached out on 4th day to see if I had questions. Responded that yes would like to talk. Radio silence for 2 days. What now?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

I’m really thinking about the pros/cons of compensation structure and career growth as part of my search. How do 🐠 who’ve gone on to FAANG think about the potential for growth in role/promo (since not everyone will be Sundar) and the potential for growth in equity value? How have you thought about trade offs and opportunity costs?

like

If I took a part time MBA program, can I still campus recruit for a summer role at MBB, Big 4, FAANG, etc?

like

It took me 10 years but I am so glad I left consulting to go into industry. Wish I would have done it sooner. Hope this post helps someone who is struggling to make a decision about leaving consulting. ❤️

likeupliftinghelpful

Typical salary for Director at FTI Consulting? Corp Finance & Restructuring. Considering move from EY

like

Anybody hiring for healthcare strategy, product marketing, or product development roles? I gotta get out of here. This cant be life.

like

Any folks who have left consulting to stand up / lead Corp Strategy at a Fortune 200 willing to chat? Considering leaving consulting for a VP role and want to understand downsides.

like

When in the interview process is it acceptable to ask about compensation / bring up your comp expectations?

When looking for a new job is salary your main driver in your decision process? What other factors do you take into consideration?

like

Should I have any caution about taking a newly created position vs one that is being backfilled?

like

Worth taking an offer for ~160k in sales strategy for a boring HR tech company? At ~120k now I’m tech consulting.

Sales strategy is interesting but the mission of HR Tech is meh.

Thoughts?

like

Am I an idiot to pass on a role that would be a 60% pay bump (100K —> 160K)?

Very happy where I am, and new role would be a step back in terms of growth opportunity and worse WLB.

like

Recruiter reached out to me regarding a position with a series B tech start up… valuation over $1B , is it possible to negotiate equity in the compensation and if so, how much could I expect for a Strategy & Operations Manager ?

like

What kind of work does Deloitte’s Advanced Analytics Enablement group within Cognitive and Analytics do? Is it worth joining?

like

How long did it take KPMG to extend an offer after on-site?

I have been seeing a lot of McKinsey Implementation job postings on L.I. for supply chain and/or procurement consultant roles. I know they require 3+ yoe in posting, at 2 yoe right now and wondering if McKinsey does in fact have a potentially aggressively growing Workday team or if these postings are for generalists etc. any idea of salary ranges for roles more so in implementation at McK for Chicagoland area?

like

After 100+ applications I’ve gotten to a final round!!!! Any help to the following questions would be appreciated! It’s been a couple of years since my last real final round.

Does anyone know what are “scenario types of questions”? Recruiter didn’t give a lot of details.

What kind of questions do you ask during a final round (multiple 30-min) interview? I’ve asked a lot of my go tos during the first couple of rounds and am trying to prepare!

Any general tips?

like

Thoughts on Customer Success as an exit option post Strategy Consulting? Seeing loads of Customer Success roles.

What are the future pathways from this role?

like

Does anyone know of any contract roles in the New Jersey or nyc area?

Any insight on the Retail Strategy group at Accenture?

Anyone here exit into luxury goods (i.e. LVMH, Hermès...etc) Love the history and the brand implications/strategy differences of being a luxury brand, but feel like it is difficult to build a career there. Any advice would be appreciated!!!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal