{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Monday fun: rank big 4 overall subjectively, no reason needed. Here comes mine: Any Big 3>EY.", "post_id": "5f84d9cabbb7f800215b8878", "reply_count": 43, "vote_count": 20, "bowl_id": "564a5cdb94887803001dd07c", "bowl_name": "Accounting", "feed_type": "crowd" }
null

Monday fun: rank big 4 overall subjectively, no reason needed. Here comes mine: Any Big 3>EY.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

12+ years here across 3 firms. Honestly, it’s all the same guys....just spelled differently. Pros and cons here and there, but same work, same people that are attracted to the work and job, same type of people leading these firms, same personalities and issues you will encounter. I heard a joke from a recruiter once that encouraged undergrads pick their form of choice based on their favorite color. (Blue, red, yellow, or green!)

likesmartfunny

I really hate yellow so guess I am never working for EY

funny
Recent IconRecent

I’d put GT above EY at this point

likefunny

I’d go one further, I’d put KPMG ahead of EY at this point.

funny

I feel like EY really took a hit reputation wise with their employees, campus hires and potential external hires. Not worth $36M

Deloitte, PwC, KPMG, EY

like

Does everyone really know about it though? I talked to others at my firm and they hadn't heard.

like

1. A whole different career 2. Government 3. Industry 4. B4

likesmart

On the basis of recruiting experience: EY, PwC, KPMG, D

likefunny

How can you pass up EY with unlimited pto? It’s a no brained tbh

like

Deloitte > PwC >> EY >>>>> KPMG

like

Lol I love that you did this. Kudos chief! I stand corrected.

like

Doesn’t matter bc NOBODY OUTSIDE OF PUBLIC GIVES A FUCK. speaking from experience. Nobody in industry cares.

likehelpful

Pwc, D, EY, K

like

PwC, Deloitte, EY, KPMG

likesmart

tupac > biggie > nas > andre3000

funnylikeuplifting

DT, KPMG, PWC, EY.

like

Nope. Never worked for KPMG or PWC. Have friends at both. Those who are at PWC complain way more than the KPMGers.

And the associate is at a Biglaw firm; I'd rather work with DT and KPMG on my deals.

OP said it was subjective. IDC whether PWC is shinier than the big K

like

DT, KPMG, PwC, EY

DT, KPMG, PwC and EY. I have been at three of the Big4s for perspective.

Oh please don’t put DT in first place...we are the first to implement that genius performance review system where you don’t ever see the truth and lower staff get screwed over it so much

Once you see how the sausage gets made you see it’s probably all the same. I’ve gotten complete crap provisions from Deloitte and PwC and I’m sure EY has sent out some pretty bad ones too.

Related Posts

Hello! Has someone worked w/ a career counselor they’ve really liked? Looking to think about transitioning out but could use support to think thru the many factors to consider. For context I am ~30 with almost 10 YOE, MBA grad, current Big 4 manager

like

6 years of experience with couple of years of Big 4 experience and making 92K in NY; Taking into consideration the current inflation and Great Resignation - how much should I negotiate as an AVP/Sr Analyst for a bank like Citi?

Time taken to become a partner in any of Big 4's?

As per my knowledge in EY it is 15 to 20 YOE

Which of the Big 4 has the best Restructuring practice? PWC

like

Considering moving to Chicago and applying for Big 4 financial due diligence. What is the senior associate 1 salary like?

like

I am a Senior Manager at KPMG, about to be offered a Senior Manager role at Deloitte. Consultant with 9 years of Big 4 experience.

How much should I negotiate for base salary?

like

Interviewing with a small (50 people) boutique firm in a management position. They are in an industry I have 10 years of experience plus I have 5 years management consulting experience in B4 firm. Assuming the pay and potential bonus are reasonable what kind of challenges would I be in for? I already understand this would be a risk to join and help them grow but if I were successful I think it could be very rewarding.

like

What does Alvarez & Marsal pay at the manager level if you’ve been a manager for 2-3 and you’re coming from the big 4? Do they bring you in at the SM level or is it a lateral move? What are bonuses and pay structure like?

like

2 career options : big 4 CF vs boutique Financial restructuring. Which one should I go for ? End goal : IBD Advisory

likehelpful

What is SM role salary band with Big 4 Value Service Creation/M&A offering in Canada? What is a sign on bonus?

like

How's a US CMA vs CIMA? Big 4 M in a finance transformation role who's become somewhat of a generalist who knows GBS and operating model design. Looking at this decision to study as an accelerator to exit consulting and having a safety net to do so. Preferred roles are in finance business partnering, program management or key account Mgmt (won't need a finance degree for the last two, I assume, but will help to drive conversations nevertheless).

like

I like my job but feel that my loyalty hasn’t paid in $$. It sounds like making a move might make sense right now. I current sit in ITS, ASC 740 and C Corp specialty groups at my firm. Any thoughts for where a move might make sense for maximizing my skill set? I’ve applied at some fortune 50 companies and gotten offers, but none of them seemed appealing (I’d be stuck picking a specialty). That’s the feeling I get at B4 too. Thoughts appreciated.

like

Looking to make a switch and was curious what people think about Vynamic. Specifically:
1.) How is the WLB?
2.) Is pay comparable to B4?

like

How does base compensation vary across the accounting advisory roles in big 4? PWC CMAAS, EY FAAS, KPMG AAS, DT advisory. Specifically for senior managers.

like

For B4 equity partner/principals- how do put a value on pension in terms of annual replacement cost and years invested? In conversations with a public firm and need to put a line in the sand for offer

like

What’s the purpose of huge tax compliance practices at the big 4? The fees are small. Is there some other business purpose or am I missing something?

like

In your mind which Big 4 has the best image if any? I say Deloitte.

like

Would you rather be a partner at MBB/b4 or take a cxo level role with unicorn startup like snowflake or stripe? And why? (there is no 3rd option). Age / location / industry / culture / wlb etc is not relevant!!

like

How different is the manager level from senior 3 in big 4 tax? Does the job get any less stressful or more enjoyable?

like

Last day in PA! Leaving B4 Advisory for a strategy & finance role at a tech company. Couldn’t deal with the PA life anymore but I appreciate all FB’s advice along the way.

likeuplifting

Additional Posts in Accounting

This is awesome and being on virtual till January 15th at least this is a nice Avenue just to keep the encouragement and positive vibes for all

like

Accurate depiction of me in the office ☝🏿

like
like

Good morning, Teachers! How is everyone doing the day after Thanksgiving? My day will be filled with: leftovers!

like

Hi, I have a last round interview at @Accenture UK which is called an Executive fit interview. Could someone let me know what to expect? Thanks

like
like

Hello everyone,
I have recently moved to Long Beach, CA and I am currently looking for a Recruiting Coordinator or Technical Recruiter role close by. I am also open to hybrid or remote jobs.
5 years of HR and Admin experience, masters in business and management and currently reading towards my SPHR. Also looking for someone well experienced in the field to serve as a career mentor.
Any advice, criticism or suggestions will be appreciated.
Thank you.

like

What is virtual onboarding at oracle, can recent joiners shed some light?

like

So cp+b people, what changes are happening?

Hey Fishbowlers! Need advice: my boss had asked me a few weeks ago to look at a new job description for a recently created role, Technical Writer. Fast forward, now the job is being posted and he would like me to apply. I’ve recently discovered an interest in UX Design and taking courses to learn more. Would taking a technical writer position be way too off base? I’m a Business Analyst with 4 years experience and want a career change but still figuring out my career goals.

like

Hi all, had a question about visa documents needed for H1B stamping in India. One of the documents needed is “visa fee payment receipt”. Even though this isn’t in the official requirements list, it’s recommended on almost every immigration website I’m going through.

I made my payment using NEFT and didn’t receive any receipt. How can I get a receipt? Will a screenshot of my bank statement suffice?

like

How much does the average person receive in a lawsuit where their identity/security has been compromised?

like

Alright, what are some other ways to stay in this country in the event the H-1B doesn’t get approved? Please don’t say get married.

like

Deloitte People: Is there a search function within EMS to search for workpaper names like in AS2? I'm working in EMS 3.7 as well

Recruiter from Amazon had reached out to me in the past and I went on a phone interview casually without prepping much at that time. Of course it didn’t get much further afterwards. Fast forward now, there is a position I am interested in but I was told that I have to wait 6 months. Does this mean I can’t even get considered by other teams and pretty much done for Amazon for next 6 months?

like
like

Every mistake I make, no matter how small, feels like the end of the world. I feel like even though I’m just ending my 1st year at the firm everyone knows I’m dumb. Any suggestions on how to handle these feelings?

like

Why can’t these clowns in our office agree on a stimulus package. Why does it always have to be a political game... damn clowns

likefunny

Any suggestion on brands or mmg for compression stockings when traveling? Anyone use compression leggings? I would like to prevent swelling while traveling.

Additional Posts (overall)

Would you volunteer to get on a four hour call during on one day of your four day vacation?

like

Can someone explain reversing entries .. say you incur an expense of 10k and haven’t received an invoice in January. So you’d DR 10K exp, CR 10K accrued exp. then beG February the reversal occurs so now you have have the entry DR. Accrued 10k, CR exp 10k. Then the invoice comes mid-feb and you DR exp for 10k, CR AP 10k….. so the expense was appropriately captured in Jan and nets to zero in February but now you have a credit of 10k in accrueds sitting January books and a debit of 10k for …

likehelpful

I constantly just feel like I have no idea what i’m doing, constantly having to redo assignments/projects because i’m doing everything wrong. Anyone else agree

like

Does trump know specifics about anything ?

like

I live in NY, but work in CT. I noticed my paycheck has CT withholding, but no NY withholding. I spoke to HR and they said this is normal and they can’t change it. They said they’ll allocate certain CT taxes to pay for NY at year end, but I find that unusual. Anyone else have a similar situation?

like

B4 folks, what's your firm's meal allowance?

like

New first-year seniors: What's your motivation now?

like

Is your goal partner if so what keeps you motivated?

like

If I leave big 4 to go for an industry job and do not like my new job, how hard is it to get back into big 4 (either same firm or a different firm)?

like

Can you get the Certified Fraud Examiner certification if you work in corporate tax?

like

How often do you take breaks during the day? And for how long?

like

Why does EY have 2 recruiters in the hiring process ? Like I had one recruiter reach out to me and the she handed it over to another person for interviews, and now once the decisions are closer, she seems to be back in the game. I don’t get it lol

like

Currently an A2 and offered a 50% raise to join RSM as S1. Am slightly concerned on the adjustment from big 4 to mid tier, but everyone I’ve met at RSM has been great and welcoming. Likely will be staffed on industries I enjoy. Any other factors to consider in why to not accept the offer? Don’t want to make a mistake just because of the pay increase.

like

So EY is doing prettyyyyyyy bad this year!

like

Forensic accounting has always been an extreme interest of mine. Does anyone here work in forensics that can give some information on it? (Do you like it? Worth getting CFE? What type of work? Etc.)

like

Does BDO have a strong presence in Forensics in NYC?

like

I’m a 1st ur associate and I started with 2 other 1st years. I’m sure we are all on the same level in terms of quality of work but they both got RTR and I didn’t. Should I be upset?

likefunny

When you really have to pee by you sacrifice and let the people with connections off the flight first...

like

advisory folks of ey what should a senior 3 versus manager be making in the northeast?

like

Slave Labor Day? 😂

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

New to Fishbowl?

image with Fishbowl logo and arms reaching out for a handshake

Already have an account? Log in

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Messaging rates may apply

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal