My direct report is not meeting expectations after nearly a year on the job, & repeated feedback from myself & others. I’m meeting w/HR to implement a performance improvement plan. Experiences/tips?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

It sucks and it is hard but treat this task with empathy and your authentic self will come through. If it's framed all around helping the person be successful and what they need to do for their daily responsibilities, then it's not about the person. It becomes a little easier - but it's never easy. A year is a long time to let this go on and I hope it doesn't reflect poorly on you or impact the team too negatively. Good luck!

like

You'll have to go through hoops to fire him. Do the easier agency route and move him to a different team/account.

funny

We recently let someone go who wasn’t meeting expectations. The rest of the team appreciated it because it showed how highly we value the bar for creative excellence — we weren’t going to let someone else drag their work down.

Not everyone is a fit for every role. If they aren’t meeting expectations, chances are they are feeling it as well.

I’m glad you gave them so many opportunities to get better. But at a certain point you need to put the rest of the team first and hope they find something that’s a better fit.

like

PIP is a cover your (& companies) ass document, it’s the justification for terminating.
If it’s been a year and you’ve been providing feedback and working with them on their performance, what do you think the outcome of a 30/60/90 day PIP will be? What do you want the long-term outcome to be?

Even if they ‘pull through’ and meet expectations, it required that type of ‘motivation’ for them to take action, how sustainable is that newfound performance?

Give them 2 weeks severance, get quality short-term freelance as a FTE can be identified and move on, it’s less of a burden on the remainder of the team picking up their slack. If it’s widely known the person is underperforming, there are broader team dynamics that should be considered as well.

like

What level? If they are good in the fundamentals and just wrong for pharma or the types of tasks on your team you can try to find them another spot. If they are missing the basics, you waited too long, should have fired them 6 months ago.

Side note, from experience last year I took someone onto my team that was entering a PIP on pharma media role. That person is killing it now and makes publicis a better agency. We sometimes put people in the wrong place

like

After a year, it’s unlikely they’ll step up now

like

Honestly OP I worked there and the place was f@%ckd. Are you sure it’s not the leadership or the ridiculous time frames for getting things done?

Related Posts

What are some of the best consulting firms for digital strategy roles? Looking for a change and was wondering which of the T1/T2 firms have digital practices in Canada. I have applied to ATK and McK. BCG is working to establish their presence in Canada but their team is focused on establishing top down. Bain doesn’t have digital focus. Can anyone shed some light on other T2 firms?

like

Hello All,

I got selected in WIPRO and today I got to know they are offering me SAP Successfactor Learning-Lead position.

I am a SAP ABAP on HANA consultant and my interview was also based on my area of expertise only not on Success factor.

Does any one here know about this position in WIPRO. If yes kindly share.

I think they will be giving me Band B3 (correct if my understanding is wrong). My HR round is tomorrow. What is the expected CTC for this band.

YOE - 6.7 yrs

like

Hi Fishes,

I just want to know if
Wipro has its office in Gurgaon location?Wipro

like

👋Hi, Anyone recently got Doj postponed Addendum letter from wipro? Why they are doing this? Can we realy on updated DOJ? Please pour your inputs

like

Hello everyone,

I hope you all are having a good day,

This is to inform that I have been selected in Amdocs as software developer for pune, my current ctc is 13.4 with total 6 years of IT experience in my home city.

In HR call asked for 20 LPA, should have gone

for bigger number than this or this ctc is ok.

Also does Amdoc offer wfh?, as HR says till december only wfh is there, after that office will begin.

Please guide with your experiences🙏

like

Does bosch give internet allowance during wfh?

like

New product idea: Hydrocolloid face mask! Not patches or stickers, but a full face mask made of hydrocolloid! Anyone in?? 😂

likesmartfunny

Any suggestions for good running shoes?

likehelpful

This allergy season has been brutal! Most of my patients aren't sure if it's COVID or just bad allergies!

like

What is advance monthly performance bonus in hcl ?
Is this variable component only ?
In offer letter it is mentioned that it will be" restricted for first year of employment " what does it mean

like

Moving to Chicago from Boston at the end of the month! Signed a lease in River North at WPE. Any tips for getting acclimated, dos and don’ts? This is my first move and although I’m excited, I’m a little nervous to be in a brand new city. For context 29 F.

like

Opinions on Propeller? Should I care that they were bought by omnicom this year?

like

Can someone please inform recruiters who post on LinkedIn that it's now called Adobe Creative Cloud. Which covers Photoshop, Illustrator, and all the others. 7 out of 10 is really harshing my mellow.

Post Photo
likefunny

Are there any supervisor or manager positions within claims available or becoming available that anyone knows about? It can be private passenger or commercial claims… Ten + years of experience and looking for that opportunity….

like

I'm up for a promotion from Senior Account Director to VP Group Account Director. I have 6-7 solid years of director experience and I'm based in NYC. 12+ years digital experience overall. For any experienced Group Account Directors out there, would you mind sharing your salaries? I'm aiming to be at a base of $200-205k which is a 15-20% bump from where I am now. Is that reasonable?

likeuplifting
like

How difficult to switch from growth investing to mid market buyout as a VP?

like

Anyone into the s/4 hana project yet ? Hearing couple of big names getting into as of now.

like

Hey, could someone help me with how to check notice period on official ey site?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Bean, get it??

Post Photo
likefunny

Hey veteran 🐠, what have new coworkers fresh outta school done to earn your respect? specifically in strategy?

like

Grey - what's the deal behind the new 4 day work week?

....are you hiring?

like

Am I “in” advertising or is an ad agency just the place where I work? My last several jobs, including my current one, have been at ad agencies but I don’t create ads. I design brand identities, design systems, style guides, digital campaigns, and digital products (UX/UI).

like

160over90 NY? They have a Jr. AD opening and I don’t know much about them but I just applied. Also if anyone currently works there and likes it wants to help me out Dm me :)

like

Is there generally a penalty if you give your resignation while you’re out on short term disability or FMLA? My employee handbook doesn’t say anything and HR won’t give me any info. I don’t want to get an unexpected letter telling me I owe back healthcare or salary costs because I quit before my leave claim was officially over.

like

Have you ever been laid off? How'd it go down? How'd you handle it?

I think I should be safe in an economic downturn, but a junior and worrier about money so I want to prep as best as I can.

like

I don't need my laptop to work. I'd say 70% of my time is not using the computer to do production, but the creative process, thought and planning that happens before that. Pen & Paper = cool new tech.

like

PMs/Producers who have done both full time and freelance work - what do you prefer/why? Thinking about giving freelance a try, but am intimidated by the prospect of leaving a salary/benefits behind.

like

Many creative awards submissions and judging are happening right now, should it continue amid the current situation? Does carrying on with it with thoughts and prayers make us look good as an industry? If you’re one of the judges are you going to look the other way for the sake of bragging rights and “glory”?

likehelpfulsmart

Big layoffs at 72 NY? Anyone know anything?

like

WFH still unclear and layoffs last week, but sure, send an email about executive level promotions. An A/S person who lost every acct they had in the 8y I’ve been there.

likeupliftingsmart

Books on human psychology that have affected you. I'll start: influence, sales Bible, on killing.

like

Seeing the “3% pledge for pay equity” popping up next to agency names here. Interesting that our Global CEO is a woman and don’t see us on that list. We also have the worst parental leave. 🤔

likesmart

Be honest, how many have used the bathroom camera off during meetings. Number 1 or 2 counts

like

Anyone know someone at Trailer Park?

like

CDs - I recently got laid off and would like to work on a personal project during my job hunt. I’d like it to be something I can add to my book. Anyone have any advice on what direction I should take?

like

How do companies really benchmark? My company says they benchmark salaries each year, but when I ask the numerous networks I've built over my 5+ industry experience, the numbers are vastly different!

like

Probably won’t get anywhere with this But a really good friend of mine is a recruiter in L.A got laid off and have a hard time finding a gig because of ageism.
If you have job leads please tell me.

likefunny

Holding Co HR people please answer: Why do you blackball people who were fired from an agency in your network from working at other agencies? What if it was a just a bad fit?

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal