My District decided to initiate a “no zero policy” starting now. I was informed by administration that when a student does not turn in their work, I still have to give the student a fifty percent even though that student didn’t earn it. I teach sixth graders and I am not sure how I feel about this. Any words of advice?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

This policy just seems like another way to decrease the likelihood that students experience failure and makes recording keeping look like things are going better than they are.

If I have a student who does 0 work, then that student's grade should be a 0%. A 50% is still failing, but makes it look like the student did something instead of nothing and requires less work from the student to be raised to passing. How are students going to learn anything about being responsible or being held accountable for their actions and choices if policies like this become the norm.

likehelpful

In my school, we do not have the choice of using absences as a determining factor. It is in our handbook, but NEVER enforced. The argument is that the child cannot help what the parents allow.

Not a fan. Life skills are just as important as learning standards in the classroom. When was the last time you simply chose to NOT do your job but expected half pay. Not a fan. Choices have consequences. Think who you’re saving. Any kid can recover from “one” zero. This policy will save the kids who just decide to not show up, take 10 zeros and then decide to try. They earn a passing grade, but how much have they learned? What the point?

likesmartupliftinghelpful

What if you hired someone to clean your yard for 20 dollars. He doesn't show do you still pay him 10? What are we really teaching these kids?

likesmart
Recent IconRecent

The same kids that were going to fail in your class if you didn't have the no zero policy are still going to fail. It gives kids a chance that care about their grades but get behind for many reasons. I have students that are running the household during the day while their parents are working, making sure their younger brothers and sisters get breakfast and attending their classes all the while their trying to attend their own classes. To top it off, they are dealing with covid issues as well. Our middle school students are being forced to grow up fast and unfortunately school for many of our students is low on the priority list.

like

Why do we have grades? The purpose of grades is to accurately assess and report student progress toward mastery of curriculum standards and goals. If grades are used for other purposes they are misused. Grades do not exist to give students an average, determine promotion, rank students, make students feel good about themselves, or to provide students more opportunity to make a higher grade. If you report that a student earned 50% that should mean that he has achieved half of the CSO. If that is not the case then you are dissembling, or, in other words, lying.
Abraham Lincoln reportedly asked, "How many legs does a dog have if you call its tail a leg? Four; just calling it a leg doesn't make it so."
If your system requires you to dissemble, to be inaccurate, then you need a better system. I recommend that schools teach for mastery. Two grades: A=achieved CSO, and I=incomplete (has not yet achieved CSO). When the student has demonstrated mastery of the CSO he gets an A; until then, keep trying. If you can only tie your shoes 70% of the way, you can't tie your shoes. If you can only get 70% on a division test, you can't divide well enough to rely on your answers. (And I know that doesn't mean never making a mistake; I occasionally have to retie my shoes.) Teach for mastery. You will accurately access and report student progress, and you won't feel as if you need to dissemble.

likehelpful

Texas, I think about grades (percentages, at least) a measure of Demonstrated Proficiency —- that is, grades answer the question, “What percent of this assignment’s content, standards and objectives did this student DEMONSTRATE proficiency in?”

I used to think about percentages as a metric of “student proficiency/mastery” or “this is the percent of what they know”... but it started getting pretty wonky. We all know many kids who COULD learn the skill or do the work ... but they just don’t for whatever reason (sometimes by choice, sometimes circumstance). So in that sense, yes, giving a 0% for something not handed in felt weird and frustrating and even a bit disingenuous. A kind of a lie... just because we KNOW if they actually TRIED... or did the work... they could get a 40%, 50%, 70%, 90%, 100%... depends on the kid. But, that’s a measure of “potential” - and then I’m acting as a mind-reader. But giving a 50% also felt like an arbitrary lie — much lower than some would get, but higher than what others would get.

So... instead of focusing on what grades to give, I shifted perspective — how I defined them. I shifted context. Now I interact with grades as the measure of what the students have DEMONSTRATED proficiency in ... so actually, it becomes cleaner for me: if they don’t turn it in, they’ve demonstrated 0% of what I needed to see. If they turned in something and demonstrated half the standards of what I needed, they’d get a 50%.

It’s been helpful when establishing this view of grades as part of a growth mindset with students and parents. When students view grades as what percent they DEMONSTRATED they know or what they can do (as opposed to “getting” grades we “give” them), it gives them ownership and opportunities for action. If they want a bette grade, they know they have to DEMONSTRATE their proficiency.

To that end, it’s also important that we, as teachers, vary assignments and assessments to measure the many facets of learning and success. Especially in a virtual setting in a pandemic — we can’t just teach and assess and give grades as usual. Nor can we give grades arbitrarily. Effort matters. Resilience matters. Communication matters. Independence matters. Responsibility matters. Following directions matters. Attention to detail matters. Perseverance matters. For me, personally, those are objectives that are build into assignments and reflected by grades.

I think it’s important that all assignments (and grades...) that are given purposefully and thoughtfully are viewed by all as what they are — opportunities for students to DEMONSTRATE proficiency with ALL the standards that matter most, and to give them clear paths to growth.

like

our district has had that in place for some time. An "F" is an "F." However, in these current times, if a student does not turn in an assignment by the deadline, I flag it as missing, marking it as a zero. If nothing is turned, it's a zero in the grade book. If there is some effort made that fails all expectations, regardless of the range between 0-50, it's permanently marked as "50." Go with this and see how your administrator handles it. If still no, you've offered an alternate solution.

like

Very close to what I do.

I really disagree with this policy. What are we telling our children? When they get to the real world is their boss going to pay them for not doing their work? When did we start letting our students be lazy and not accountable for their actions?

like

The letter grade system does not work. The grading should be similar to AP testing in high schools, from 1-5. You need a 3 to get college credit for AP tests but a 2 is technically passing and 1 is a failure. We started letting kids be lazy when our politicians encouraged half of our workforce to be lazy. During this pandemic, nurses, doctors, grocery store workers and truck drivers all worked while teachers and office staff stayed home.

like

I'm trying optional exercises this cycle. Low risk, they do it they can earn a good grade and lower the risk of a missing or low grade assignment. They don't do them, I'm exempting it and their formative grade is based on much fewer grades.
Notes, reviews, quizzes and exams are mandatory, don't do them get a zero.
So far kids are responding well.
Of course the students that are doing the optional work are scoring better on exams. It also helps that I assign optional exam correction grades too.
*I teach older kids upper division Math

likehelpful

If anyone cares, after 5 weeks of this experiment.
75% of my routine exercises as optional (formally known as daily work, practice quizzes and HW), turn in rate is up about 50% as compared to cycle 2, and the mandatory exercises are now sitting at 90% completion (notes, reviews and quizzes)
I need to dig down on this, but early results are pretty convincing.
Grades are higher across the board.

like

I’ve been doing this on my own accord for 3 years but I use 49% just because of these oddness of the number. it allows students, parents, case managers, and me to immediately know the assignment is missing. If you are completely against this initiative, then do everything possible to get students to understand the purpose behind every assignment and be resilient with your expectations that every assignment must be attempted with effort in your class. Grades don’t matter very much, especially in 6th grade.

likesmart

Readers, Writers, Researchers. I taught 9th grade for the last five years. This year I teach 7th.

I mean they are still failing if their average is 50-55%. I have some students who have done NOTHING and their average is 55%.

likesmart

It's still an F and if this is the policy in high school, it is the letter grade that will be recorded that matters - not the percentage.

It is also disproportionate to all the other grades. Why should the F be worth 60% of the grade while the rest of the grades are each worth 10% (or if you have a different scale, it's even worse).

Why should a student who had a 95% average on 9 equally weighted grades end up with an 86% because they failed to complete 1 assignment. Are we grading their ability to turn in work or their knowledge of the subject matter? I want my grades to reflect what my students know of the subject. If they don't turn in an assignment, there needs to be a penalty, but not one that impacts them so significantly. Using that same scenario - 10 equally weighted grades, 9 of them 95%, if the last grade is a 50%, they end up with a 91%, a lower A that still reflects their knowledge of the subject.

likefunny

In our district we shifted our mindset that homework falls on the parents. The students should not be punished with detention or a failing grade because their family does not support education. Now at some point when they're older, it becomes the students responsibility but we cannot change the attitudes of their families and how they do not support their education.

likeupliftinghelpful

There are county libraries in most towns that offer free internet. Our school district offers T-Mobile HotSpots for parents who can't qualify for regular cable internet. The T-Mobile devices are very slow and have a theoretical 20GB limit, but it's better than nothing. After the 20GB the device still works but their data speeds slow to a crawl until the next billing cycle. It's free for these parents and we're paying for it in our taxes. But it's better than nothing. So kids have very few good excuses to continually not turn in their work.

So, is the lowest grade a student can receive also a 50%?

like

That’s correct Ohio Elem 1. Doesn’t matter if they did the assignment and didn’t do well or if they did not do the assignment at all, the student gets a 50. I don’t think we say “earned” anymore.

like

The district understands the learning environment of our students. Not all students come from safe homes with supportive parents or environments conducive for learning. Some may only access education in the classroom while being a caretaker of other siblings in the home. We don't know what goes on at home. If parents do not take the initiative to get on their child about doing their work nor is it a priority, can we expect our students to actually care as well? Behaviors are learned. As educators, we know some parents have their child log on for attendance and then unplug from school after that. The district needs to do what it needs to, or realistically, retention and high school graduation rates will become an unprecedented historical anomaly.

like

We have that in my district as well and at first I thought it was total BS. Why should I give a kid a grade for doing nothing? But I started to see the advantages after a few weeks. The chronic failures were noticing that they were still failing but that they were close to passing. Several students who normally turn little to nothing in starting turning in some work. I’m not going to say it works miracles but after the policy being in place for four years now, I would say I do see the benefit of it.

likehelpful

My school tried this a few years ago. Needless to say, we don’t do it anymore. I didn’t mind giving them 50% if I had seen them at least attempting the assignment, but if they never did any of it at all, they did 0% of the work and I felt that was the grade they deserved.

like

Well YOU can feel how you want but if it’s the new policy in your school you have to do it. You have been told. BY your administration that this is the way things will be. You don’t get to pick and choose which policies to follow. If you really can’t do it, start looking for another job, but good luck, as this is becoming the norm. The idea behind it of course is that a zero has 59 % points of weight, as any other grade would have at max, 10? And that it unfairly pulls down a grade. In our district this doesn’t apply to tests or quizzes.

likehelpful

Since 50 is now a zero, I’d grade all future assignments on a 50-point scale rather than a 100-point scale.

Make sure the students are EARNING those points. Adjust their grades accordingly.

likehelpful

Oh good. Just ignore the intent and defy the directive. Professional. And teachers, at least in Michigan, are on a four-point scale. No zeros. Go figure.

like

Well I’d start by asking if I don’t do my work can I still get 50% of my pay? 😂

likefunny

Okay, but I really am kidding. 🤣😂

like

Better yet, I can now do 50% of the work and get 100% of the pay. Not quite. I’m glad we’re really preparing these kids for real life. Don’t forget the participation trophies!!

like

As long as parents are aware that a 50 really means a zero...and that then a 75 is now really what a 50 would be.. and so an 80 is really "barely passing"

likehelpful

Today most districts are afraid of lawsuits by parents. They will always sided with parents.

likeuplifting

Food for thought: I think everyone needs to remember that we are working and perpetuating a system of grading that never worked. If you have 20 assignment in a quarter and more the 5 students flunks 10, I think you need to look in the mirror and ask yourself did you teach to the best of your ability. Did you target the visual, audio, kinesthetic learners. Or do you expect your students to sit down, shut up, listen to you, and know all the answers, after a lecture, because they are taking notes. Hmmmm.... Think back to high school, were you the perfect student, I wasn't, I was scared, anxious, happy, angry all before 1st period. My point is some of us struggle thru high school, and when we barely graduate we find ourselves and our niche in life, and some of us even become teachers, because we believe we can do a better job then what we were subjected to.

like

Exactly California middle school 23 and I was that student I was that poor student but you know what I studied my ass off and for the whole time I was in elementary school I was in the three group and I studied my ass off and got into high school and thought well now I have a new chance now maybe I can get a new start studying my ass off still in the three group yes and that’s why I became a teacher but they didn’t give me a 50 I got that 68 all by myself. But you know it taught me that life isn’t fair then I need to work harder than Ever because working hard as survival and I worked hard I kept working hard and got all A’s in college and now I have a six-year degree HELLO. Would I have worked so hard and I’ve been given a 50 so that I could coast???? I don’t think so🥴

I have been grading this way for 15 years. A 50% floor is more fair than a zero. If a student decides to turn it around they're working up from 50% which makes passing grade attainable. I once had a student named Thomas, he decided to get his act together and did well. He averaged 90% or better on his assignments but he was only able to get his grade to a 34%. Had I implemented the 50% floor, he'd attained a 84%, what do you think that would have done for his self-efficacy, I can only imagine. Fair is not always equal.

likehelpful

Related Posts

Anyone have three kids and working in big law? I just found out I’m pregnant with no. 3 and it’s been a lot trying to juggle morning sickness, but based on my experience, I know this is only the tip of the iceberg of what’s to come. My husband and I are elated, but the anxiety of being a mom of 3 kids and working in big law is preventing me from truly enjoying this news. It would be good to know what it’s really like having 3 kids so that I can evaluate how long I really have left in big law.

like

Hello Fishes,

I have got my L2 Dependent Visa stamped for the US through the Wife's organization and she has booked the tickets for the both of us in the next weekend. I am currently unallocated in TCS and seeking projects in the same US location as my Wife. Can I travel to the US just like that and then continue my search within TCS from there or do I need any approvals to even fly in the first place?

I am worried because of the time crunch and will be glad to hear some points on this.

like

Check out my Instagram live Question and Answer about Piano, Flute and Violin lessons Sun June 6 at 7:30 my instagram page is helenes_notes! Last weekend I did a Facebook live on the same subject in case you cant make it in a couple of weeks you can check out my Helene's Notes Facebook page! If your interested in lessons feel free to call me at 516-474-6181

SOS I’m a first year teacher. I’m at a VERY challenging school district & a different culture than I’ve ever been around before. I cant get through a full day’s lesson! I spend more time disciplining!

like

Looking to sign up for a points card in the UK- does anyone have a recommendation? Anyone have the Virgin Atlantic Reward+ MasterCard?

I learned that someone we just hired, in the same team, 1 level lower, came in making 20k more than me. This role is based in SF, and I'm in the midwest.

I have my master's, two years with the company, and was recently promoted last quarter.

I feel some way about this, and I'm wondering if I should bring this up with my manager? I'm grateful for the raise they gave me and the promotion last quarter, but I don't understand how someone at a lower level can be making more? I'm I being greedy?

like

Need help, I have relevant experience and good reputation among team. I want promotion in this cycle to manager level but the thing is the seniors I have, managers and senior managers are with PwC SDC for long time, so they are not ready to promote me with 4.5 years of experience. Can you please guide me on how can make it work?

like

Guys I am struggling with something. I went through a very tough year last year, and finally have a job I like. I am in NY and have to now summon up the strength to face covid. I

like

Any moms who really badly wanted a girl but ended up with a boy(s)? How do you feel now? Do you still want a girl? Would you try again? Does it matter really, or was it just in your head?

Had a difficult relationship with my mom growing up, so always wanted that closeness with my future daughter. FTM having a boy and a little disappointed, but feeling guilty for that too. Difficult pregnancy so likely won't have another. But I want a girl. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Please no woke left gender drama responses. Thanks.

like

I hit my one year at my company on the 15th of November. I had lunch with my boss on the 10th and he mentioned a raise but not how much or when it would be effective.

Flash forward to now, we’ve had 2 paychecks since then and I haven’t received anything. He said last week he would let me know this week, but I’m getting frustrated.

He’s raising my billing rate effective Jan. 1, and I’m worried I won’t get my raise until then. Anyone have something similar happen?

like

How do you best support your students who do not speak English? I have four ELL’s in my 6th grade ELA class and they don’t receive push-in or pull-out Bilingual support during my class. Do you pull them for small group to provide instruction separately or do you just try to use google translate to translate your lessons and the work? Any best practices? I’d love some help.

like

I am a partner in Canada and have been offered a role in USA with a bigger buss unit but a level down in the org chart. I can live anywhere in USA and part time in Canada. My boyfriend can move to USA with me but my daughter is in west coast who is 20. Since Covid I have spent more time with her. I have worked a lot with American partners but not clients. Thoughts on how I would be received as a leader being a Canadian woman in USA. About 2000 people in BU.

likesmart

Currently a C at Deloitte (3.5 years since graduated UG) in my promotion year to SC. Being reached out to for project manager role at slalom. Would this be a good step up? Or stay put?

like

what do you talk about in your 1:1s?

I got lucky and now have leadership that seems to care about my career growth, but I'm 1. a little overwhelmed taking over a new role from someone who went on parental leave earlier than expected and 2. not used to thinking outside my day to day job, happy to keep my head down and just produce good work.

most of what I bring up in these meetings are logistical or prioritization concerns but I feel like my manager is expecting a lot more from me.

like

I am moving classrooms, and my new classroom has a bathroom. I’m looking for literature that discusses bathroom etiquette and any other suggestions you might have for using a bathroom in a class.

like

I heard that travel used to be a thing pre-COVID. Any idea if travel is coming back?

If you are already in a super big market like Bay Area or NYC, do we even travel since all the deals are probably happening in home office?

like

I posted here some months back about my ectopic pregnancies but today, I'm posting to tell you all to hang in there and God will do it for you. (Please don't insult me of you don't believe in God because I strongly do).
In a nut shell, we had baby #1 without trying. Started trying for #2 and over 2 years, I had 4 miscarriages and 2 ectopics. In July, my doc informed me that the only way forward was through IVF. I was tired and confused. I PRAYED! and continued trying. (The rest in the comments.)

likeuplifting

Am I missing something with this corona virus? I saw a statistic the other day that for anyone between the ages of 10 - 60, the death rate is ~0.2%...so what is the big deal? I assume just media hype?

like

GroupM CEO announces the promotion of 4 men in an email this morning. But nothing about the dissolving of mPlatform, which we all find out via press...

like

I was told by management they see me in a more supervisory role at my first year review and during meetings. My second year review comes and there’s no talk about a promotion - instead it says “we can’t wait to see her excel“ and my raise and increase were the same as the prior year. I know I deserved more of an increase this year. I mentioned to my manager about the promotion and was told she will bring it up in a meeting. Three months later and I haven’t heard anything. Any advice?

like

More Posts

I’m Kim E. I work in public school grant funded preschool for 4 year olds in Michigan, and I also own a private preschool program for 3 and 4 year olds. This is my 18th year teaching.

like

What’s the best structure for a Creative Brief? I’m trying to train my account team + our main client into sticking to a one pager (right now it’s all over the place)

We’re hiring at Havas. Looking for Administrative Assistants in New York, San Diego, Los Angeles and Chicago. Let me know if you’re interested in learning more!

likehelpful

Is watch a good investment vehicle in terms of resale value?

like

Any freelance creative teams in the Tampa area?

like

Anyone know any good salons I can get a women’s haircut under $100 in Manhattan?

like
like

7 likes and I’ll quit my job today 🤪

likefunny

Never know how to answer when people ask what time I "usually" get off ...

like

Happy Valentine’s Day teachers!

Post Photo
likefunny

I am new to Deloitte. My background is in agile transformation and product management within provider settings. I have found tech projects, but none within healthcare. Any advice for finding these?

likehelpful

I know Big 4 handles the mega deals, but which firms are the ones that handle the most mega deals? Is there a big 4 firm that handles mainly MM deals more so than the others?

like

How do you all feel about faculty team building activities?

Post Photo
likefunnyhelpful

Dear All,

Trust you are doing well.

I am looking for a job change 16 years of experience in Finance and accounting.

Domain expertise Accounts Payable, Reporting, Month end close, Balance Sheet reporting, Internal audits, controls, automation, driving project, client management ,team management,process improvement,efforts reduction, maintenance process accuray.

Let me know if there are any openings based on my experience

Regards,
Mohammed Amjad Ali

like

For my day job... I'll start doing product shots. I'm old does anyone else remember collecting labels off cans?

like

Hey all! What are your thanksgiving plans? (Traveling, shopping, eating?)

like

Thoughts on $AXS for the rest of the year? Thinking about converting it to SOL LUNA and QNT.

like

Any thoughts on Iron Condors on DOCU?

like

What was the first thing you did after you got EAD ?

Is there any branch of the service that you can join without having to get vaccinated against Covid-19?

like

Additional Posts in Teachers

How any of you teach or have taught in a low SES school with very low test scores? Any tried and true teaching points that have made a difference?

Every year the 5th graders I teach span a huge spectrum, from newcomer ESL students to above proficient native English students. Trying to find ways to improve outcomes.

like

Why are textbooks so expensive?

like

Do you think schools should offer credit recovery classes? I know that high school students need credits to graduate, but they're not learning anything from those programs.

like

I’m new to my building and I’m such an introvert...am I alienating myself if I actually just want to eat lunch in my room and keep working? I want to make friends, but need time to myself to breathe!

like

I'm shocked by the number of parents who don't understand the basics of technology/internet. I don't mind helping them, but it is time-consuming one on one. I wish the school would have training for them.

likehelpful

Good evening everyone,

I have to rant and seek advice. It’s my 5th year teaching overall. I’m a 1st year at a new district it’s been really nice except for just some very small inconveniences: no classroom budget, too many meetings during planning time, printers are so bad that I had to bring mine from home, my district gives teachers chromebooks for laptops. I’m a a point where if I was invited to come back next year I’d say tell them no, am I crazy, is it just me? Please help

like

I took last Friday and Monday off for Lunar New Year. Last Friday was an optional teacher workday and we had regular school Monday. O had out it into the system back in September and gotten... 1/+

likehelpful

I am on FMLA before Christmas break and admin knows, but grades were due and my sub couldn't do it. However, the grading system which is new messed up my grades up but I am not allowed to do anything during my fmla school related. Praying I dont get in trouble when I get back in January. Was I in the right not to stress about it until I get back?

like

I teach in a private school, and I am very unhappy (first year in a private school) I have an opportunity to go back to public school. Any advice on leaving?is it a possibility?

like

Anyone over 70 still teaching? If so, why and how is it going?

likehelpful

Print and Ship?

Does anyone know of an online service where I can upload documents that are then printed and shipped by the company to my students? FedEx Kinko's is astronomically expensive.

like

One of my fathers disciplines his son when he cries because he says that boys don't cry. What should I do?

like

So how did your students deal with the attack on the Capitol? How did they feel about it?

like

All schools in the state of Kansas have been closed for the remainder of the 2019/2020 school year!!!

like

Should I be doing read alouds with older students?

likehelpful

Any unique fundraiser ideas for clubs and activities?

like

One of my classes is very talkative. What can I do to quiet them down whenever I need to get through a lecture?

like

Having a positive mindset is hard right now. Trying to fake positivity for others is hard. Not feeling like a failure after everything you do is hard. This year is just hard.

like

Really need to go back to spelling! Anyone ever teach spelling words through Greek and Latin words? Or have any other suggestions? My district “gives up” on spelling around grade 3

like

Working with a friend on the best way to get into teaching. Is subbing a good way to “get my foot in the door?”

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal