My manager told me to inform them if I was thinking of quitting the firm. Is this a trap?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

My company told me that as well, I waited until I had the offer in hand. They asked me what it would take to stay, and I gave them my terms. They said congratulations and see you later.

likefunnyhelpful

Sorry but this is very funny. That company didn’t deserve you clearly.

likefunny

Only inform them once you have an offer that you plan to accept, then provide the customary two weeks' notice. That's perfectly acceptable and reasonable.

What's not reasonable is for your manager to expect you to share your plans with them before they are finalized. HARD NO. They might turn around and fire you first, and then where would you be?

likesmart

Seems like bait. If they are only interested in offering additional compensation if you are planning on leaving that seems like a pretty good reason to leave.

like

I’ve said to let me know if you’re unhappy with your job and it was not a trap. I want to know if people are unhappy and why so that I can do something about it. If we’ve fallen behind market, your work has gotten stale, or you’re not clicking with your boss, I might be able to help. But only if I know about it.

Now sometimes shitty bosses say that too. And then it’s a trap. So know which case you’re in…

likehelpful

It is but isn't. I've had this happen to me and they ended up letting me go after I gave my answer. So beware.

likesmarthelpful

Yeah true. My friend got a similar sort of "warning" but it was more like "We love you and please let us know if you are ever thinking of leaving." Have never heard of an employer saying it as a kind of trap...but people can be shady for sure.

Not entirely. Firms are offering pretty sizable retention bonuses, but out of cation I wouldn’t bring it up until you have an offer in hand elsewhere in case they’re going to can you ahead of time.

like

Never do that.

like

Tell them nothing till the background check on your new written offer has come back and you have a joining date scheduled.

like

I think I still wouldn’t say anything until I actually had another offer in hand. They might have good intentions, but I always try to air on the side of caution.

likehelpful

OP the other thing with this is if they give you a substantial raise or something like that to stay. HR is going to paint a target on your back. You should just figure out if you really want to leave or not. I find a lot of companies if you go away on good terms you can come back usually with better money and a better position.

likehelpful

Retention is a big challenge for many companies right now so I understand your manager wanting to get ahead of it. Their request might not be sinister right now. But do NOT respond to it.
Every company and every manager has a list, even if it's only in people's heads and not actually documented. That is the list of people who they would cut if they had to downsize and still conduct business. If you actually tell your manager you are a flight risk, you WILL be added to that list.

like

I also ask this and it’s not a trap - my job is to develop my team even if that means it develops them into a new role in or out of my company. I do my best to retain top talent until that point though, so if someone is actively looking for a lateral move just to leave - I try to remedy the situation if I (and my budget) can.

like

I usually discuss what my career goals are and what I am looking to grown into with my managers but I would never disclose if I am looking to leave before I have an offer. By the time I have invested my time ans effort in looking and finding another employer, usually means I have made my decision to leave because my managers failed to give me the growth that I was looking for after many conversations. My leaving the company has a lot to do with the company not realizing that they needed to invest in my growth while they had the chance. This is where I find some companies and managers fail.

like

You might want to see this as an opportunity to get more information. Maybe the manager is about to leave and wants to take you with him. Maybe a layoff is coming. It's a poor thing for a manager to say, so there is probably something behind it.
Your response depends on your style and relationship with the manager, but I would say something like "I have no such plans. I like it here. Why, what's up?"

like

It all depends on your perception and experience of the integrity of the manager and the firm.

like

Yes. I had a manager at a previous job try to tell me she needed 6-8 months notice if I was looking elsewhere. You’re under no obligation to do such a thing unless it’s in your contract, and doing so might lead to them trying to get rid of you early.

I don't think an employee would think about switching unless they're undervalued and/or underpaid. No manager can take that thought back even if they know you're planning to leave. If they increase your comp, it's a new cycle.

Related Posts

Is it presumptuous to invite a new coworker to join our company’s LGBT+ employee group? He mentioned in a call that he recently got engaged to his bf. I want him to know he has a resource if he needs it but I haven’t interacted with him before and not sure if it’s the first thing I should bring up.

like

I've always considered my current job temporary, I needed something and all I could get after graduating into the pandemic hiring stalemate was at a small company in my home town doing a job that isn't quite my specialty. My lease is up here in the fall and I want to leave the area. When is the best time to tell my bosses I'm planning on leaving? I don't want to snub them with too short of notice and I don't want to give them too much notice and make for an awkward work environment. Any advice?

like

Hi Nadia thank you for doing this workshop my question is: how do you deal with raging systemic bias and not get victimised by your line manager who is also a group head ?

like

Hello!


Do we have any international members in here? I’m looking for some company recommendations that I can purchase holidays gift for team members in the UK to have it delivered! I am in the US and I think I can use PayPal to pay for it! Types of gifts are helpful too! 🤗

like

I got promoted, but so did the other guy. We’re on a small team and all I can do is compare myself to him and obsess over what that conversation must have looked like. Who was closer? Who was better? Etc.

I know it’s dumb. We both got what we wanted and he’s AWESOME! It’s totally fair, but has anyone else struggled with this? Just checking.

like

For all beard carrying folks here, do you feel like shaving before an important meeting/event/interview? I am going to join one of the big 4 advisory practice in a few weeks. Is carrying a well maintained bear okay in consulting?

like

My CDs, while brilliant, suck at organization (i.e. rarely respond to emails and if they do, only half-answer, don’t care about proofing, lose files). I’m sick of defending them to account. Tips?

I have a client who has gotten in the habit of only calling my cell phone, without notice, rather than my office phone, always expects me to be available at a moment’s notice and often wants same or next day turnaround. To some extent I may be responsible in trying so hard to please, and he’s a top client but not my only of course. Any tips for bringing this relationship back down to earth without upsetting the apple cart? I’m tired of my days constantly being flipped upside down.

like

I keep working under a Senior CW, who keeps on telling me and my partner that our projects don’t need concepts and that the client is just looking for an execution but even when asking Account...

like

Struggling with my mental health. Doctors signed me off sick. How much detail should I go into with the partners I work with? Have really good working relationship with them and don't want my mental health to hinder my progression.

like

SA just joined the team for the last 2 weeks on the project. This is his first project and keeps making silly mistakes. Guessing this is not a big deal and verbal feedback is enough - thoughts?

like

3rd week on the job, a guy 2 levels below me came into my office and started the conversation with "let me lend you a piece of advice...". As expected, it was not useful advice, he was just a douche.

like

I recently moved from research to banking within the firm. I feel that my new manager has a preconceived notion about me; I mistakenly glanced on her chat window and saw that she was bitching about me

like

Whelp, just added another SM to the list of people whose projects I won't work on.

Lifes too short and the job market is too hot to deal with people in management positions who never learned how to manage and use aggressive shaming to try and deflect from their poor direction and lack of leadership.

likeuplifting

Who do you reach out to first when quitting? I’m not really close with my manager or partner. My senior is my guess but it’s going to be so awkward

like

When to tell the boss, team and hr that I am pregnant. I am 9weeks 6days along.

like

Does anyone have recommendations for a small punching bag i can set up next to my work desk so I can put the picture of my co-worker's face and beat the s**t out of it?

likefunny

How to deal with a client that requires something urgent to be done every single day? Just lateralled to a new firm and there’s a fire drill every day with this client and it’s exhausting and stressful.

like

I love working at the bookstore and I'm proud to work with such a large group of people from different backgrounds. I'm really happy we're all here. But it probably isn't the best idea to get someone to reshelve books when they haven't been taught how to categorize them properly. It's like I spend most of the day following one of my coworkers around and discreetly fixing what he works on. He's a great guy, very personable, but wow is it frustrating.

like

How do you tackle ignorant managers and favoritism in the team ?

like

More Posts

Any Army Reservists here know of cool/chill Reserve gigs (TPU or IMA) for a 25A/O3 type? Trying to get away from the staff/command BS. Thanks in advance!

like

MDs - do you insist that nurses / staff / patients refer to your title as Dr. so and so; or do you allow people to address you by your first name?

like

Any MDs here? If so, do you work private practice or are you part of a system? Do you like it?

likehelpful

Hi, has anyone seen anyone with covid 3 times. My mother has had covid once in April2021, December 2021 and now today. I work in outpatient and I have never seen any patients catching it three times. Any stories ?

like

What are some of your favorite resources to learn about OCM and build upon your existing knowledge?

like

Could someone start an agency called Gen X to service all Gen X focused clients, but NOT pharma. You would be swamped with so much experienced talent. Please and thank you.

likeuplifting

What’s the best advice you’ve ever gotten for dealing with the politics of making the work?

like

1 year old systems engineer (AWS) looking for an opportunity as a DevOps engineer. Any referrals guys?

like

Off Topic: Anybody has referral code for Porter App?

like

Been noticing a lot of agencies doing VP, Strategy Director // Director,Strategy Director// SVP, Strategy Director...what gives ? Why the Director at the end of the title?

likehelpful

Who hires freelancers at Klick?

like

Hi community,
Any idea if Alvarez Marsal is currently hiring consultants? If so, would anyone here be able to refer my resume?

What’s a typical salary for a producer in the midwest with 2 years of experience?

like

Hi Folks,
Can anyone help with the procedure of submitting internet claim bills occurred for a month. I got approval from my manager but do not know the procedure to submit.

Has anyone done any data engineering bootcamps they would recommend ? I’m in nyc if that helps

like

Has anyone ever heard of Protiviti? What is it’s reputation like in the marketplace? Trying to decide if it’s worth leaving a big four for.

When someone reads my paper and says "wow, you really did your homework," it doesn't make me feel good at all—it makes me feel like a failure for not being able to write something original on my own!

like

🙌 this is what we’re talking about right here.

Post Photo
like

Getting ready to study for the CAMS exam. Do I need anything extra besides just studying the study guide and practice exam over and over. I’ve read online about people using AML assassin; is it worth it?

like

Additional Posts in Tech

I’m a Program Manager working for the Government. I’m looking to transition into Tech. Any tips/recommendations/or referrals?

like

Is it too late to make a job switch?

I feel like we're already in the recession now. Just heard that Shopify axed a bunch of people and even folks at smaller startups are getting let go.

My parents are retired and I'm the only one in my family with an income, I am genuinely fearful for the future.

like

Some Business Intelligence/Analyst roles are very data heavy. I wonder why these roles do not have the term “data” in them, and wonder if it’s to keep the salary lower than it should be. I have colleagues doing intense data science tasks as BI Analysts, and can’t help but feel indignant on their behalf because when hearing their job title, one would underestimate their technical ability.

likesmart

Why doesn't everyone post TC? Seems disrespectful tbh

TC: 135k

like

Hey guys, need some career advise. I recently joined Adobe nearly 3 months ago. And I now have an opportunity to work at LinkedIn for a much better package, a better city and possible visa sponsorship. They also it is a senior role then I’m working at now. However, I’m feeling extremely guilty even considering it as I’m just finishing off with my training and it feels so wrong. But LinkedIn is my one of my dream organisations to work at. Any suggestions on what I can do?
Adobe LinkedIn

like

Hello,
I am looking for associate product management roles (based in India or remote). Please DM me if your org has openings/referrals available!

like

Any content designers that transitioned from a copywriter role? Advice on interview process, salary, necessary skills?

like

Are Amazon phone screen interviews with the hiring manager heavy with Leadership Principle questions? Or is that mainly saved for the panel loop?