{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "My SO just told me she’s expecting a $30k engagement ring and says that’s a normal price… Is that actually normal or am I crazy to think that’s absurdly expensive? Context: we’re 26 combined income ~220k", "post_id": "60cbebe2988c340021d190eb", "reply_count": 584, "vote_count": 71, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting" }

My SO just told me she’s expecting a $30k engagement ring and says that’s a normal price… Is that actually normal or am I crazy to think that’s absurdly expensive? Context: we’re 26 combined income ~220k

likefunnyhelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

The number is irrelevant as it depends on your social circles, your financial profile, and your philosophy on spending. What’s more important is if this is typical behavior from your fiancée: telling you she is expecting something, especially in terms of how fancy or expensive something should be. Do you guys live a more extravagant lifestyle? Does your wife buy luxury handbags and designer labels and have expensive jewelry already? Do you guys go to frequently go out to fancy dinners or take extravagant vacations? If this is typical behavior from your future wife, by her justifying something because she feels it’s normalized, then I think you don’t have much choice but to spend the money to keep her happy. Have you guys had a convo about finances yet? About budgeting and expectations over the years? $30k for that combined income seems like you’re stretching it quite a bit (assuming you make 1/2 of that). The scarier question to me is how much does she expect your wedding to cost?

likesmart

If she's asking for a 30k ring I would assume she already lives a fairly extravagant life, and this isn't the first time she's expected luxury things from OP. Nothing wrong with nice things, but the expectation of them is something I couldn't personally deal with.

like

So, I thought a little about this. Can you honestly picture this woman staying with you if you lost your job tomorrow? These days, very few people stay with the same company (or even in the same career field) for the duration of their career. Is she planning to work once you have kids? If not, will she be able to accept that major financial sacrifices will need to take place if you become a one income family, even if only for awhile? I personally would recommend having some serious conversations about finances and lifestyle expectations. Most importantly, will you be comfortable working like a dog and missing out on import milestones in your children's lives (assuming you want them) just to maintain lifestyle expectations/ keep up with the Jones'? Will there ever be "enough" money for this woman to be happy? As a woman myself, I feel that marriage is about love and family, not $$$. My husband and I have been through our share of ups and downs in our careers, and we have had many times where we have really had to tighten the purse strap for the good of our family and our futures. Most importantly, we have each others' backs, which is why our marriage works. Would she have your back if there were a serious financial setback in your future (illness, medical bills, job loss, family needs, etc.)? Will she be happy if you can't buy her everything her friends have? Personally, if you really believe that this woman is the one for you and will have your back through all of life's ups and downs, I would suggest starting with a more modest ring budget (ideally one that you don't have to finance) and upgrading it on a milestone anniversary later.

like

"" lifestyle expectations"" I'm thinking exorbitant

like
Recent IconRecent

A lot of people are going to say it’s absurd and it is very very expensive. Still about half of what my ex was expecting - she ended up with no ring at all

likefunnysmartuplifting

Now this is the type of ending that makes me happy

like

That’s not normal man, my comp is $200 and I spent $7k last year for a real nice ring. To this day, I catch her admiring the ring (even if she doesn’t think I’m looking) and the smile it puts on her face is priceless. If she is putting a n absurdly high minimum on what would make her smile, that’s kinda a red flag. Then if you spend 30k, she’ll always think you did the bare minimum, so realistically you’d be looking closer to 40k. Also, someone who randomly throws out a massive number like that has clearly never researched diamonds. There is no reason in this world to get a D/FL diamond, and that’s pretty much what you’re looking at in that range.

likesmarthelpful

Yeah I think I spend like 8k years ago. This seems crazy to me but I guess it depends on who your comparison is to.

like

Wow. I have no words. I’m definitely not in this social circle and would never want to be. I have a lab created ring and it suits me just fine. My husband had no need for a fancy engagement watch. Think of all the wiser choices you could make with that money. I clearly do not get this mindset. 🤷‍♀️

likesmarthelpful

Amen! Just…wth? If you’d leave your SO over the price tag of the *ring*?! You probably aren’t meant for each other (or, like, maybe *anyone*…at least not yet…

like

Dude, run.

likeupliftingfunnysmart

You know how 1/2 marriages end in divorce? These are the early behaviours of the unsuccessful half.

like

However much she wants you to spend on an engagement ring, she should spend on an engagement watch.

likesmartfunny

SC1 can't tell if you're joking or not. No, the engagement ring is most often combined with a wedding band (which typically complements and is simpler) to the engagement ring. They get fused together.

like

Damn this thread is making me hella self conscious about my 2k my wife has

likefunnysmart

My ring was $5k. Love it and wouldn’t change it for anything. We’ve been married almost 13 years with two kids.

like

My husband spent $26K on my engagement ring and another $3K on my wedding band. He wasn’t making all that much at the time and used most of his savings - it felt good to know he was willing to spend that much for me. I know his peers spent around that ballpark too +/- $5K. Also - men compare more than woman do… it’s almost a flex talking about how much they spent… they talk about this at work/church/just any social gathering. Also women compare too, some of my girlfriends are still not happy about their ring (ranging from $1K - $3K)

funnylike

"Wasn't making all that much at the time, spent most of his savings" but then later on you say "a ring shouldn't be more than 5% of your net worth". Make up your mind!

like

God I should stay single forever

likefunny

WTF you all need to chill out on the taking care of my wife mindset. I make more than my bf, I broke my ring finger last year so if he spends more than 1k on my ring I would find it silly. Maybe you should consider it’s your mindset that’s driving you to find incompatible women

like

Tangential question. I honestly feel guilty letting my man pay for an expensive dinner, I could not in good faith tell him I expect a ring of that cost. This is a normal thing?

likefunny

Anything for the gram and the status these days I guess. Normal in some circles and preposterous in most.

like

You guys are either really rich or really poor

likefunnyhelpful

D2, they’re really rich if they can spend all that money and not notice, or really poor if they spent all that money and have nothing left. 🙃

likefunny

There used to be a rule that an engagement ring should be X months’ salary. I don’t remember what the number was. Also think that formula may have generated from DeBeers…

likesmartfunny

When I was an Associate, the topic of 3 months’ salary came up. So the first question was, “gross or net?” The ultimate solution the guys came up with was to hedge our position and pre-buy a ring for future use at our suppressed salaries to hedge against promotion-adjusted ring inflation.

likefunny

I spent 5k and got a lab created diamond. They look no different then a real diamond and are much cheaper

likefunny

I’m looking to buy a ring in the next 3-6 months. Can anyone elaborate on where they got their lab created diamond from or if there are any stores I should specifically look at? For reference I’m in Houston

She will leave you if you get her anything under 20k…. I expect my significant other to spend 30k on mine and that reasonable among our friend group…

funnylike

Let her leave him lol you’re both are gold diggers

like

In my view, If your SO is “expecting”, the ring to hit a particular price point, you should think hard about this. People like that often also “expect” the wedding to be of a certain size, at a certain destination, with a certain theme, etc. Chances are, she’s planned all this her entire life. The only missing piece was the name of the groom. Later she’ll probably expect a certain house, in a certain part of town, driving certain cars, with the kids attending certain preschools. The only true expectation should be that you both love, respect, support, communicate with each other, and make big decisions together. The rest is materialistic BS, which 50% of the time end up being inventoried by divorce lawyers down the road. FWIW, I’ve been happily married for 32 years.

likehelpful

I remember the guy I was buying the ring from saying “if she doesn’t like it, you can return it”, and I replied “this is the one she’s getting and she’d better like it”. What exactly did she do to “earn” a ring that expensive? Is this a transaction? It it important for her to show off with other people’s money? Does she buy you a 30k watch to compensate? I’m sorry but I just can get my head around this… Red flag. Run.

likesmartfunny

I agree with you D2 about the fact you can talk about it, but I don’t get the disposition of expecting a gift of that size. In my book, marriage is a joint venture based on equality and the fact you believe the both of you are stronger together than apart and I find that very difficult to align with a 30k gift to kick things off.

like

It starts with the ring. Then the Range Rover. Then the annual Fuji vacation. Then the Manhattan condo. But then again If she is making good money and you are making good money then it’s doable.

likefunny

Lol I’m having trouble envisioning a woman who demands a min $30k ring summit mt. Fuji every year 😂

likefunny

I bought my wife a $16K ring from Tiffany several years ago when I was making about $110K and felt even that was a stretch. I pushed myself and saved hard. I can’t imagine spending double on a ring. The 2-3x monthly salary norm for the engagement ring should be based on YOUR income, not your combined income. I mean, unless you’re making $210k and she’s making $10K. Long story short her expectation is unreasonable.

likesmartfunny

Also convenient that the number "expected" to spend on a ring was created by...the diamond industry themselves...ridiculous.

Our engagement ring was a thousand dollars. That was what my husband could afford at that time and not put it on his credit card or spend money he didn’t necessarily have. 8 years later, my husband makes north of a million. I still wear our cheap ring and wouldn’t change it for the world. It shows me I have a sensible man who understands finances and can take care of the family regardless of where our fortunes may (or may not be). Different people value different things. Trust your partner and see if their values align with yours

likeupliftingsmart

I really love that you value your original ring (and original husband) so much. :) I bought my hot but usually sensible wife a 20th anniversary ring. It was what she wanted. I wanted to get he something much more fancy and expensive. Nope. It cost <$2.5k though she knew that I’d spend more and knows we are blessed to have the money to afford much more. She likes the design and would have been upset. Spent the extra instead on feeding some starving children and helping trafficked women. Invested some as well. Win! I spent more on her original set but nowhere near $30K. Today that set (including quite good quality 1ct engagement solitaire) would probably go for 15k depending where sold. Didn’t spend nearly that much at the time either.

like

Huge red flag. If she's right for you and you're right for her and you both know it, she's accept a ring-pop. I spent 4.5k on a ring when I was making 80k salary and even that felt like a stretch at that point in my life, but I did it because I wanted to, not because she had any expectation for what type of ring she'd end up with. If that's the clue you're getting, run and don't look back. It'll only get worse.

likehelpful

I don’t think the norm really matters. If you want to spend more on a ring then spend more, if you want to spend less then spend less. If you think $30k is unreasonable then have a conversation with her about what you think is within your limits. Grow up and talk to your partner instead of posting about your problems online.

likesmart

Spot on D3

Related Posts

What is a good salary for and IT manager with 10 years of experience in the US?

like

What should I request for Mother's Day? And why is it always Mom's job to come up with gift ideas, even gifts for herself? Wish my husband and 12 y.o. would put some thought into it & surprise me instead of asking me to pick my gift every year.

like

11 hrs on a workday can expense dinner but 4 hrs on a weekend or holiday can expense lunch. Am I supposed to be working 7 hrs every workday or 1-2 hrs every weekend 🤔

like

The more I look at this COVID executive order the more it looks like a scam. Similar to the cool toy or trip a parent promises that never happens. Also like your toxic ex who likes to deflect blame. •Money is coming from FEMA. Hello Hurricane season?!? •Months to set up. •Feds are only paying 75% and wanting States to handle more.

likehelpful

Why is partner comp so opaque? I can’t think of any other job where they expect you to go for promotion with such little understanding of what you’re actually going for, how long you have to stay etc.

like

Snapchat salary Sales Strategy & Operations associate and manager?

like

How is the work culture, work life balance & compensation at Cargill Bangalore office. Asking for Business Analyst profile with 7 yrs experience.

like

Can you negotiate salary for full time associate offers in big 4 right now? Does it look insensitive?

like

I just got offered to switch teams at my company, which would mean moving to an AE (one level jump). We haven’t discussed salary yet - what are AEs making on here/how much experience do you have? TY!

like

How is the maternity leave and culture at Google?

like

I have an opportunity to go in-house at a huge beauty/fashion brand. I’ve only been in advertising for 3 yrs but am getting sick of it already. Haven’t gotten my promised raise and the current agency is a mess with layoffs/raise freezes plus the horrific hours and not making work I love. Am I too soon to leave advertising? Do I give it another shot? Or is it smart to go in-house because the industry is suffering? This new job offers a title bump, the salary I want, and better hours but also...

like

Does the Workday company hire change managers? What’s the salary?

like

Expecting a baby this summer. Should I still be looking for other job opportunities? EY has a very generous paternity leave if you’ve been with the firm for 1+ years, but not sure if I would have the same opportunity to take 2-3 months leave if I switch jobs. Can I potentially work parental leave into negotiations?

like

On vacation and there's an active deal going on where I have to check the emails to see if my input is needed. Do you bill for this? I got 100 emails and checking this is very time consuming.

like

UK SC at EY. Offer coming from Deloitte but they want me to move across the country and I have 3k left of my grad loan to pay off... anyone know if I will be able to get relocation bonus to help out?

like

Average age and salary??

like

VENT: I took a month off between jobs to finally get a break for the first time in 20 years. In that month I have had one single day off. All the other days have been doing house projects, managing our rentals, or taking care of sick kids. I even went on a vacation with my husband for a week where he had a depression breakdown so I was stuck taking care of his emotional well-being the entire time. I’m FRIGGIN EXHAUSTED. I’m so tired of taking care of everyone else. Rant over.

like

👀 Still looking for an apartment swap in NYC. I have a clean apartment in Mexico City. The dates are October 27th to November 3rd, Day of the Dead holiday weekend. With LOTS happening. Located in the best area of Mexico City with a ton of restaurants, cafes, and parks. High speed internet with standing desk, large TV, external monitor, and more. Message me your email or phone number and we can text to exchange pictures and more information.

like

Offer Evaluation for Director of BizDev/Strategy role - Got 270K base, 30% bonus, 90k annual equity refresher and 180K sign on bonus. MCOL location. Is this a good offer? Have 14+ yrs of experience, 10 yrs post MBA across strategy consulting, private equity ops roles.

likeupliftinghelpful

FTM of a 10 mo. At what age do you start having baby sitters for date nights and such. No family or friends can help. I am paranoid that my baby will just cry out of strangeness the whole time.

Additional Posts

Need referral for Angular developer position with 6.3 years of experience. Kindly help.

like

Does Healthcare companies like Anthem, Humana or United Health pay more than 160+ in their Technology group? Experienced on Docker, Kubernetes and Cloud Native world and Google Cloud certified..

like

KPMG M&A Strategy folks - what type cases should one expect to see in the interviews. Asking for a friend. Thank you ! KPMG My guess is maybe a market sizing case? Anything else?

like

Spinoff question... I know FMLA technically only covers you if you've worked for 12 months at your employer but has anyone actually had their employer say "sorry you we only here for 10 months so you can take your two weeks of accrued vacation, after that we'll expect you back." ? Since FMLA is unpaid anyway, I would imagine most employers would at least let you have unpaid time off.

like

What’s the highest quality CBD brand? Asking for my father who is having neurological issues and I read that CBD can help. Thank you.

like

Jumping from tier 2 to tier1, position remains the same. Will they hold tier 2 against me for comp negotiations?

like

Which health insurance is better for you and your spouse? Cigna or Aetna?

like

Looking for opinions on joining PwC Workday team: work/life balance? When you’ll go back to traveling? How much do you travel on a weekly/monthly basis w/ no COVID? Recently interviewed & would like to get a better idea of the position/team.

like

BCG/ Platinion 🐠: Suggestions on how to prepare for case study interview?

like

Interview question why EY

like

Anyone here at Lyft? Wanted to talk about a role there but have questions about hiring despite the recent layoffs. TIA

like

For my 401k I have a section that shows Roth contributions and earnings. I have a different section that is labeled “nontaxable balances” and just shows Roth contributions. The Roth contributions number is smaller than the Roth contributions and earnings (which is expected since my contributions have grown). But why aren’t my Roth contributions AND earnings showing in the nontaxable balances section?

like

What are some common exit opps for an Technology Analyst/TDP at Accenture? LinkedIn shows that CDP folks have good exit opps but not sure about TDP

like

Had anyone at PwC had babies 14 months apart? Any limits on parental leave with the births so close together?

like

While attending Catholic school in the first grade I was really naughty and sneaked in the empty classroom during recess with a friend. We raided the treasure chest full of goodies (candy, stickers, snacks) and stuffed them in our backbacks. When it was time for class, our teacher noticed the missing treasures and made us all sit in silence until one of us cracked. Someone ratted on my friend, I was in the clear, and my friend never told on me. I still feel bad about it. : (

likefunnyuplifting

What an upgrade! Thank you Bonvoy for maintaining my status despite not travelling for a year and a half!

Post Photo
likeupliftinghelpful

McKinsey & Company What’s the deal with the alumni interview first round? Recruiter told me I’d have just a case with an alum for the first round and three sets of interviews for a final round. How concerned should I be for the alum interview?

like

My case team is all American except me (Canadian), Partner wants to collocate in New York and told us to book travel plans and hotel. Any more seasoned Canadian consultants can help answer if I need a work visa?

like

My firm has been pushing us to go back to the office since June, and every single day now they are sending pro-office propaganda. You can convince me there are benefits to being in the office, but good grief, let us work from home once or twice a week! Otherwise I’m out.

like

Both my husband and I have been remote since April 2020. We’re both very independent and do things alone here and there but I feel like working from home for so long has caused a bit of co-dependency. Recently, I’ve gone into the office a few times and I’ve noticed that I have a lot of anxiety about everything when I’m in the office - from work, the commute, my husband, how he’s doing, what he’s doing, etc. Has any one else dealt with this?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal