Need help/advice when comparing two offers:
P&G supply chain management:
Salary: 86K
Location: small town in PA

JPMC change management analyst:
Salary: 80K
Location: NYC

I’m struggling to decide because I live in NYC, so I’d just be living at home to save on costs. But for P&G, I’d be moving closer to my gf who’s going to DC area. Thoughts?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

P&G gives you high salary in a lower cost of living area, but depends on your motivation. Are you trying to get into the finance world?

The role at JP definitely sounds more interesting and what I want to do/learn, the role at P&G is more aligned with what I’m currently doing at Amazon. I guess looking for advice on what can provide me with the most growth and TC 10 years down the road.

I would go for P&G. It sounds like the better offer.

Related Posts

Can I please get some insight on starting salary for cyber security professionals at EY or Delloite ? What about Senior ? Looking to negotiate an offer

like

Hello I am up for 2 positions as Practice Manager II with HCAhealthcare. The position would be in either VA or NC. And salary ideas do that I make the right decision?

likehelpful

What is the salary range of a Tech Writer with 5.6 years of experience? Need help.

Thanks in advance.

What’s a good starting salary for a pharmacy supervisor in a hospital system’s corporate headquarters (overseeing the hospital system’s clinical and operational pharmacotherapy) when you have 5-6 years of experience, including manager and director experience?

Hello everyone

Any idea on how much joining bonus KPMG gives for consultant role?

like

Apart from salary what else do you negotiate in your sales account executive contract?

like

When talking with the HR recruiter about compensation before my first interview, she mentioned a base figure and OTE. The OTE meets my expectation but base doesn’t.

Can I negotiate a higher base while offsetting some OTE? Is that a thing?

I gave interview on 7 April got docs upload mail on I begin on 8 April and got it verified as well and now i can see "evaluation in progress" from 11 April on portal.... I haven't got any call from HR yet for salary discussion.... I'm worried whether I'm selected or not.. Pls help

like

4 years work experience after undergrad, no MBA. Can I get hired as a Consultant at BCG? Interviewed for Sr Associate about a year or so ago, made it to decision round then. My current comp is around what a Consultant would make so looking at that level.

like

Any chance of me starting off with a Salary of 90k in Public ? 5 years experience, 4 in GL type accounting and 1 in PA ( small firm ) . I do have my CPA . Looking for audit or advisory.

like

Asking salary for PwC Senior Associate in Identity and Access Management?
My background: Promoted to Senior Consultant at Deloitte last year. Total post grad school experience of 2 years and 10 months (all at Deloitte).

like

Hi Fishes, What is the policy of joining bonus in Accenture Accenture India For say if we join 1 month early? Does anyone has any idea. I wasnt offered any jb at offer discussion but now I got a mail from some person mentioning. Did it happened in a similar way for someone?

like

I am working in EY LLP as consultant 1 and joined in June 2021 I got an offer in Dubai protiviti should I wait to get bonus and then leave or should I leave and how much bonus can I expect .

like

Can anyone please weigh in on base salary and bonus structure for Strategy& director level role? Also is the path to partnership similar across S& and PwC? TIA!

like

Is there anyone that knows much about battle spares manager and knows what's a decent salary with this position?

like

Salary since college in Project Management 2016 Technical Support Specialist 37.5k 2018 Project Manager 46.5k
2019 Project Manager 57.5k 2020 Project Manager 60.5k
2021 Engagement Manager 120k (new job)
2021 Engagement Manager 132k
2022 Engagement Manager 160k (new job)
🥳🙌🏾

likeuplifting

First year as a Manager here (TAG) and my ye bonus is over $100k. Blown away. I keep hearing insane numbers about people who’ve been here even longer. Curious how others did?!

likefunnyupliftinghelpful

FREELANCE DAY RATE QUESTION: What’s everyone at, these days (equivalent title and market would help for context):

Please help evaluate my Facebook (Meta) offer. This is for IC4 TPM MCOL/Remote.
Base 140k
Performance bonus 15%
Equity 165k for 4 years
No sign on.

I have competing offers from Amazon (Seattle), Apple (Cupertino) and Microsoft (Redmond)

Thanks.

like

Sr. Product Manager/BA role salary in NYC?

like

More Posts

Hi everyone,

I am looking for a job change and enquiring if you have, or are likely to have, any job opportunities in your company.Please refer me for the position of Software testing engineer.
Skillset : Selenium, Cypress,java,jmeter,soapui
Experience:5 years
It would be my sincere pleasure to hear from you soon.

Thanks and Regards,
Satarupa Panda
Email id:satrupapanda1@gmail.com

like

Hii Fishes, I am java fullstack with 9 yoe, currently based out of thane Mumbai have offers from HERE Technologies mumbai goregaon , HSBC India India pune, Citi pune. All are giving almost same CTC with almost same role. Which organisation should i join . Also I have question if pune will suit me or not. Citi is having poor wlb as per Glassdoor and some linkdin feedback. How is hsbc bonus , job security, wlb. Thanks

like

Hello guys,

Hello,

I am working into service management, having my working expertise in Change, Problem and vendor management.
Prefered location - Pune
Current ctc - 7LPA
Total work experience - 10+years

If someone can please refer or suggest how much is the market standard pay for the above skills

Regards

like

Currently a “corp dev manager” at a consumer goods company. However, I haven’t worked on any acquisitions, more raising debt and equity. I want to exit but not sure what other opportunities are out there for me especially since consumer has been hit relatively hard. Anyone have suggestions? Currently at ~140K TC

like

Hello. Would like to know what all is tested in pre employment health checkup.

like

First year teacher here so I don’t know much.. but what are some good educational free websites for the summer? We are off but the students still have their chromebooks. I teach 1st so they are going into 2nd.

like

Does ThoughtWorks also have the internal client round even after the job offer? What is the bench policy over there?

Role - Scala developer

like

Anyone willing to take refer me for a role at salesforce? I’d love to discuss the opportunity and how I’m a good fit!

like

Hi fishes,
Recently I applied at EY gds for associate analyst post. The status in career website shows we would like to move u to the next step of the recruitment process but I haven't received any call or mail. Any idea how much time does it take or what should I doEY

Post Photo
like

Are you folks able to keep up with reading books (any genre)? If yes, how long on average does it take you to complete one?

likehelpful

Has anyone done brow lamination? Thoughts? Looking for a nyc place to do it or may get a kit to do myself

like

Hi Everyone,

I need one suggestion,

I have 2 offers one with
Virtusa - 16.75 fixed + 1.25 variable+ 1 bonus
Cognizant - 16 fixed + 50 variable

YOE - 4

Based on job security & Yearly Hikes which one should I Join?

One more thing do virtusa have a probation period?

like

WellsFargo or Deloitte USI? Exp 7 yrs, offered CTC 16 at deloitte and Wells 19.5?

like

Checking out the Met Ball last night!

Post Photo
like

Hey all - have a JD with prior HC experience, but strongly considering an online MHA or MBA in HC mgmt to gain more business knowledge and position myself for growth/opportunities. Any thoughts?

like

🐠 fam - I posted on here a while ago about my classmate and I working on an IRL Social App called Venty. I’m glad to announce that we officially had our beta launch today. Venty is a new social app that makes it easy to find people nearby to enjoy social activities. No swiping needed! You create activities you want to do and users nearby send you requests to join. Venty is designed for real connections and purpose-driven dates. Please download and review our app on the App and google app stores.

like

Hey fish! Planning an upscale dinner & subsequent social outing in DC for a group of 10 coworkers, mixed ages/seniority levels. Any restaurant recs with a nice ambiance? Thinking multiple courses, cocktails to start, etc.

Also looking for a bar with fun activities for after dinner - like bowling, arcade, karaoke, etc? Other ideas? TIA!

Anyone here an Associate Principal at Iqvia’s consulting group? Curious to hear your take on the culture and trajectory

like

Anyone join a no name startup in product or strategy and move to bigger companies? Would love to chat!

like

Fish Fam - Any suggestion on the distribution? Age 30 - Can take above average risk if returns are better.

Post Photo
like

Additional Posts in Salary Negotiations

Hi all, my current title is Motion Graphics Designer. I just finished my probation (6 months which is very uncommon). I proactively asked my manager for a review because I negotiated to have "title review" included in my contract when I got hired as they didn't want to offer Senior Motion Designer. The department head (my manager's boss) is happy with the work I delivered. How should I prepare for this title review and pay raise negotiation? Currently getting paid 88k. I am expecting 95-100k

I just realized I'm over paid for my role. By a lot. What do I do? Can I negotiate a lower pay?

funnylike

Girl Scouts has brought me to my last interview stage for Community Engagement Manger. What should I ask for? I have over 5 years of experience and I am also a military veteran and served 7 years.

like

I’ve been a freelance copywriter for 11+ years. I have a client who prefers all their writer to charge per word. I typically charge $55-60/hour. Would $0.50 per word be a realistic rate.

like

A week ago, I started with a fairly new position within a company designed for fresh grads. I graduated with an MBA early this year. Today I found out that this company just opened up a new initiative for MBAs, and is offering a 6 fig salary. What is the best way to convey to the management that my skills and education would be an ideal match for their new position?

like

How much more comp should I ask for for a 1099 role?

like

Working on a salary negotiation with a company. Their initial offer came in at $120k. Based on my research and the fact that I exceed all their posted min/preferred quals, I am looking for closer to $127k. I've drafted up my counter and looking for some input on it - posting in comments:

likehelpful

Anyone idea what the compensation looks like at Glovo HQ in Barcelona is for senior product roles?

like

Any tips for negotiating salary at Amazon, guys?

I’m expecting an offer within the next few days and would appreciate some piece of advice!

like

I just received an offer to work as a Program Coordinator; however, I want to negotiate my pay as I will be receiving my MBA next month. Any tips?

like

I'm on a work visa in the US. Employer naturally has a higher leverage over me and my peers make 10-15% more money than I do despite having relatively lower performance ratings. Any tips on how to negotiate?

like

Anyone a Cerner learning facilitator and can share their salary?

funny

Any recommendations when negotiating pay within the same company for a level up with more responsibilities? The current salary is below market value and I want to negotiate for about 9K-15K more as I have 5+ years experience with valuable industry knowledge.

like

If moving into a new company but similar role. How much salary hike should I be asking for in the first negotiation?

like

Was asked for my salary expectations because they want to move me to the next round. The role is a principal PM for a global real estate firm. Any insight? They want total comp so I was thinking in the total comp area of 190-210. Is that too high?

like

Maybe some perspective might be of use to me. I’m transitioning out of the service and I’ve positioned myself decently to be competitive in the market. I’ve got two offers from great companies. Biotech and Healthcare, both on the Human Capital Team as an Employee Relations Consultant. I have a graduate degree pursuing a Doctorate, LSSBB, ScrumMaster, SPHR, and PMI-ACP certified. I know this is personal and dependent, but what should I be considering as a commensurate salary?

like

What is the salary for a Transition
Specialist Representative at
Paycom - What is it
like working for Paycom, pros/cons,
etc.

like

So I recently got a promotion and they’re trying to start me 11¢ under what they claim the “minimum” on the job posting. I tried to send it back and they said it was their “best and final offer”. If I continue to fight it could they retract the job offer? More background in the comments

Anyone willing to share how much a junior associate at Goldman makes per year? Need it for reference for starting negotiations on an offer.

like

I work as a finance assistant at a car dealership. Next month is when I’ll get a raise…but I’m sure they’ll only give me a small one. Any advice? I’m making $16/hourly, and really need a good raise to, well, live in this crazy economy.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.