Need some advice!

I'm a recent PhD grad (30 yo) in STEM, and just got some offers from different companies. Particularly, two of them are interesting to me.

1) from a Energy Market Company in Pennsylvania as an Operations Research Scientist, 95k + 15% bonus + very good benefits and generous PTO. It's a very chill job (9-5) with good people but limited opportunity to growth.
2) from a consulting company in NYC as a data science consultant, 130k + 10k signing bonus.

Which one you choose? why?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

130 in nyc as a phd consultant is too little IMO. Go finance to DOUBLE that figure in nyc

like

Really? They’re lowballing me you mean? I haven’t accepted the offer yet and have room to negotiate.

95 in Pennsylvania is better than 130 in NY

Also 9-5 does not equal chill job. That’s still 40 hours a week. A chill job is at max 30 hours a week, usually 20

like

Your pay is utopia for me

Depends on if you want chill or non-chill 😊. I have no chill so I’d go #2

like

Consultancy will provide you better exposure and help you build out your career path. See if there is negotiation on wfm or travel as 130k doesn't last long in NYC. If long term benefits from working in the industry is there then stick to your initial choice.

like

Yes, I’m staying in NJ and commute to NYC if needed.

like

Yeah 130 is looooooow right now for data science PhD

like

Thanks. The position is data science consultant already. I don’t have work experience but have academic experience in data science and operations research

Related Posts

Hi Tata Consultancy's

I have a sudden query, how can I send the salary receipt to my personal mail from tcs laptop, am not able to login gmail in tcs laptop so how can I send those documents??

Can I send those documents from tcs mail id to personal mail id ??

like

Hi Fishes,

I have been offered 37.5 lacs ( fixed ) plus 20% variable for the associate director level . My current fixed CTC is 29 Lacs .

Can you please let me know if this a good offer or I can get more?

Please also let me know what is the salary range for associate directors?

like

Hi everyone! I have my first round of interviews at Dapper Labs this week for a Content Marketer role. They mentioned in the email that they would want to talk about compensation during the call. Does anyone have an idea of what the band is for this role/department?

like

When talking about salary, do you usually say your base or TC?

I have many options to consider but two options below are what I’m thinking of right now.

I want to see your thoughts on which one I should pick.

Job A: Project Engineer. 135K/yr base. 10% signing bonus.

Job B: Senior Project Manager. Contract. $60/hr standard. $90/hr overtime.

Additional Information added / pinned in the comments.

Pretty new here! Great news ..JOB offer …however the company is lowballing salary ..I informed recruiter Amount was not acceptable …sent off the salary requirement letter …. Nail biting ..Why waste my time again …she didn’t know the budget… so we proceeded forward, her reply ..advised me to talk w hiring team but in final interview there was no opportunity to speak abt salary w hiring team ….Have to say I enjoy the posts & it’s a decent networking site!!

How long NielsenIQ takes to release final offer letter after sharing salary breakup ?

likeuplifting

Anyone work at GE or GE healthcare?

like

Recent grads - what was your major and what kind of work are you doing now? Also what was your starting salary?

like

Hi all..I got offer from JP Morgan Bangalore and UBS Pune with same CTC. Can someone help me which should I join ?

hi
what is the component called other allowances and reimbursement 1 and 2 ? for what purpose its used ?

like

Does anyone know the salary bands for PwC Advisory M1 in Top Tier city (NYC/SF) ?

like
like

Asking for market comparison on a regional sales director role in SaaS.

Public company, 8-10 direct reports and a $25M+ territory.

Was curious what is considered market and above market. Base is currently $150k with a $175k variable at $325k. Would love y’alls help.

Working at Deloitte soon! I read the benefits but I’m still a student and don’t really understand what benefits are good and just mediocre. Is the benefits and rewards at Deloitte ACTUALLY good? Any tips to maximize on the benefits? Advice for a new grad hire plz 😭

like

Anyone work at UPS (corporate side)?Thoughts on culture, compensation, stability/progression? United Parcel Service Inc UPS

like
like

For those of you that are targeting tech at Kellogg/Booth, are you looking to end up in the west coast? I’m most interested in tech, but bummed out that more folks from those schools don’t land in tech companies in Chicago or NYC

like

Hi Sharks, Please let me know the in hand salary if I take 80C 1,50,000 and NPS 50,000 as exemption. IBM EY Infosys

Post Photo
like
like

More Posts

What kind of pay does a finance lawyer for the city of Chicago make?

like

Hi Fishes,

Can someone please tell me the in hand salary of the below offer . I am just confused by the PF thing.

Post Photo
like
like

Hi Fishes,

Can anyone tell what is the variable component percentage for D1/Senior Manager band in Capgemini? And also do Capgemini provide variable pay quarterly Or yearly once?
Please guide.

like

Managers & above who made the switch from commercial to federal: How have you tailored solutions for federal clients since they are not impacted by standard metrics such as revenue, pnl, competition?

like

Hi all,

I'm looking for someone to refer me for a Business Analyst(Functional) role.

Experience : 35 months
Education: MBA(IIM-R)
serving notice period

Thanks in advance
Like if you please!

like

Hi fishes,
Anyone knows about teleperformance. Got an opportunity as Senior Data scientist.

like

Hi,
What is the fixed pay range for Grade 27 in Optum?

like

I've been waiting tables for the past 20 years. It's a decent job that has gotten me through some difficult times, but I am getting old and tired. What career path would be most advisable for me at age 40?

like

How does one most effectively make the transition into management from an Individual Contributor?

I've been an individual contributor for 4 years in Tech, have 8 years of experience total. I'm finding it difficult to make the management transition despite having management experience, performing beyond expectations, and having a genuine passion for enablement and development.

I'd appreciate any success stories or pointers you can offer in regards to this transition.

like

I still get really nervous before doing telehealth video calls! I'm never this way face to face.

like

How would you give your manager a negative review?
Manager's boss reached out to obtain review about my manager. I have nothing good to say about him, would you be honest? If yes, how would you go about it knowing that both he and his manager can read this review and know where it's coming from?

like

The old administrator at my department won't allow me to write on what I want, even though I thought that was implicit when I joined. Can I push her to allow me to take control of my research?

like

Hey fellow professionals, how do y’all feel about cover letters? Are they truly necessary or should I only do them when required?

like

What is the salary for an entry level audit associate in NYC?

like

I am an experienced hire. My case might just take you by surprise. I joined EY GDS 10 months back at 40% hike (leaving PwC) and now Deloitte (DIJV) is offering me 2 level up designation at Manager level with another 40% hike. This has effectively doubled my salary in the last one year bt still I am confused to switch or not considering the amazing bonuses GDS payed off today. Please suggest.

Hi, how much can I ask ectc at Rakuten
Yoe 4.3
My cctc 6.3 lpa
Holding of 13lpa

like

Salary range & bonus target for Senior Associate in Tech Advisory at KPMG in NYC?

like

Hi Folks , ey hire for technical domain and then assign non technical projects. Does it happens with everyone or some people ?

And is there any way to shorten the 3 months notice period in ey ?

like

I have recently given interview at Microsoft.
HR provided the feedback as I am not rejected bit not fit for the role so they have put me in talent plus pool. What should I expect next and does this mean that I may get the offer ?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Best consulting companies in the social sector?

like

For implementation of a project , Is delivery important or leadership ? If only one had to be chosen rather which will you give more weightage

like

All these layoffs reminding me that loyalty is dead

like

How long does it typically take for Altman Solon to make a decision after the final round interviews?

like

I find myself struggling the explain things with the same eloquence as my colleagues. How can I improve my consulting speak? Any recommended books?

like

KPMG 🐠 , how long to hear back after final round partner interview?

like

After getting kicked out of McK late last year, this gives me schadenfreude 🤣

Post Photo
likefunny

Books to learn more about how to drive sales in consulting? Any recommendations?

likehelpful
like

Do any strategy arms of Big 4 or MBB do pre-MBA internships?

like

Working at Deloitte soon! I read the benefits but I’m still a student and don’t really understand what benefits are good and just mediocre. Is the benefits and rewards at Deloitte ACTUALLY good? Any tips to maximize on the benefits? Advice for a new grad hire plz 😭

like

I think I made a faux pas during a discussion with a recruiter when asked what my salary expectations were. I KNOW not to give my number first but I was so caught off guard by the question since it was our initial discussion that I just blurted out a range. I’m afraid that I’ve now locked myself into a range with little room to negotiate if extended an offer. Any advice for how to proceed?

like

Best ergonomic chairs for neck and back pain that aren't $1000+?

likehelpful

Some construction work going on in the room next to me at 11pm central time here at the Westin! How many points is this worth?

like

My younger brother has the opportunity to do Software Engineering at FAANG and consulting at MBB as a fresh grad. I told him to do SWE, but I’m afraid I’m giving him biased advise cause I’m jaded in this industry. If you were me, what would you advise him?

likehelpful

My colleague just told me they never filed their state tax for a state they travelled to for 2-3 months last year. They didn’t know they had to, they self filed their taxes. What should they do to

likehelpful

What is the salary breakdown for the different levels of corporate functions? How does this compare with client-facing equivalent?

like

Planning to relocate to Dallas, work location is Coppell. Looking at Flower Mound and Frisco as the potential options? Definitely need good schools. I’m open to commute during non-peak hours. How’s the drive from Frisco to Coppell during peak hours and in general?

like

Are there any books or classes about convincing people that have irrational arguments? Trying to figure out how to frame conversations that lead to my conclusions that aren't based in logic and fact.

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal