Partner just graduated college and is insisting on saving her income instead of contributing it to 401k as stocks are too “risky”. I know it’s not my money but this sounds like a recipe for deep regret in the future. Thoughts?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

A powerful tool I use is making an extremely simple excel model with each year until retirement representing a column and then two rows, same annual contribution rate but one row compounding at 8% vs one compounding at 1%. Obviously completely over simplified but shows the power of compounding investments over a long time at average returns

like

The book I Will Teach You to Be Rich has similar charts that outline everything really clearly. I recommend you have your partner read the book to gain some financial literacy. Personally I always just “knew” that contributing to a 401k was something I was “supposed to do” but the book has helped me so much and is really easy to understand.

like

1. Show her a historical chart of the S&P 500 that displays all the peaks and valleys for the last ~20 years. Then zoom out and show her how ultimately, it went up over time. Show her a chart displaying the returns YoY.

2. Show her what the standard rate for HYSA’s are/were pre-COVID (2%).

3. Show her this website:
https://www.calculator.net/investment-calculator.html

4. First show her what her return would be in 20 years if she contributed $XX at the HYSA rate of 2% for the next 20 years.

5. Then show her what it would look like if she contributed $XX at a modest S&P 500 rate of 6% for the next 20 years, so she can see what she’ll be missing out on if she doesn’t invest her money.

I did this to explain to my girlfriend why getting into the market is important.

like

Is her rationale that stocks at their current valuations are risky or stocks in general regardless of valuations are risky? If the former tell her to overweight other assets and non-US markets. If the latter, she needs a financial literacy course.

likesmart

Might be a good Segway into talking about life goals. Not in an aggressive way to show you are right and your partner needs to save, but in a collaborative non judgmental way. Sit down and write down your life goals, does not need to be a soul search, talking broad strokes. Maybe her goal is to quit work in a year and travel the world who knows maybe you share that goal. Cool let’s talk about how we can save for our future and do that. Maybe she wants to travel and you want to retire early, is there a compromise? Maybe you have totally different goals, not an end to the relationship but worth a hard convo

like

Segue not Segway lol

like

My SO was like that as well. I told her look - at least get your matched contributions. You're literally leaving money on the table.

I asked her to try it for one year and see the results. It was good (obviously any single year in the last 10 years would be good)... she upped her contributions after.

like

I found this article pretty interesting, specifically this quote
"
So, what do women need that’s different? Advisors say—and studies support this—that when it comes to big money moves, and investing in particular, women tend to consider their decisions in the context of their overall lives, as opposed to looking at investment returns or other key numbers at face value."
So rather than show her sp500 returns or whatever data point ;talk about the growth of money in relation to your retirement and what you hope to eventually accomplish for you both.
Hope that helps

helpful

Everyone else has provided good sources but you need to explain that investing in broad stock index funds is actually quite low risk over the medium to long term, and it's also the only way to make sure that you're beating inflation by a decent margin--otherwise your money is barely keeping its value (if you invest in bonds) or it's actually losing value every year (if you keep it in savings accounts).

like

Try making your partner realize the power of financial engines. Like how daily returns can easily have more impact on your wealth building than whether you actually got up to go to work that day.

Assuming she doesn't have a specific thesis of waiting due to current market valuations (which is at least plausible), try to convince her over the next few weeks/months. If that doesn't work, get a new partner or align on the idea that you will be on charge of finances if you stay together. Sounds harsh, but if their views on or knowledge of money aren't well enough aligned with yours, it indicates future problems; money arguments are a leading cause of divorce.

A few things for her to consider:

Putting in just enough to get the match is a 100% return! You put in $1000, employer puts in $1000 and once you're fully vested, that's $2000 for you! Even if you leave when you're just 25% vested, that's still a 25% return! And you always keep market value of whatever money you put in.

You can start with pre-tax to get used to the idea. It is less of a decrease on your take-home pay because of the reduction in taxable income (you can give some estimates of take-home pay)

There is no way to save up for retirement with just cash unless you make a solid salary and live well below your means. For example, you'd have to save an average of ~$25k per year to retire on just $50k (work for 44 years, retire for 22)

Because of inflation, your money loses value if it's not invested or put to use in a way to get at least a small return. HYSAs don't have interest high enough to negate inflation.

Buy them the Simple Path to Wealth and let them figure it out on their own.

Teach her about inflation.

Related Posts

General optimum age and mileage for buying a used car?

like

My investing strategy is just to DCA into an S&P 500 index fund and keep buying and holding. If I understand correctly, the sole disadvantage this has compared to a tax sheltered retirement account is that the quarterly dividends will be taxed? But even so, they’ll be taxed at a lower qualified dividend rate since I’m automatically reinvesting those dividends.

like

PENN down 20% on earnings miss and Portnoy allegations…what to do?

like

Hi guys.
Do you think investing in gold is a good choice?
Seeing their prices are going up, there will be good value in future for these

like

Hi everyone, how much % do you allocate shares for early employees

like

Is this a good deal or not. $93,600/year” “BENEFITS “ medical, dental, vision(30%60%90% after CYD) 80hrs vacation time after 1year of employment, it cannot be carried over year to year, nor will it be paid for it upon termination same for sick time which will be granted after 90 days of employment. Max 240 hours. Paid for the 6 holidays but if happen to work holidays will get paid 8 hrs for another day off during the same pay period. No 401k

like

Looking to add 2 members to our team in CT. Asset management based team. Full benefits, pension, and enough leads to make your mind numb!

like

Hi Fishes

Joined My new company this Jan. My previous income was not eligible for tax slabs. Now while adding the income from Apr 21-Mar 2022 it's become 5.9 LPA. I don't have any investments and in my new company I declared the same. The only tax exemption I have is PF contribution and professional tax. I have only 25K PF contribution and 2.5K professional tax. So while calculating the tax I am getting 15K as tax payable. How can I avoid this 15k. Kindly pour your suggestions. TIA.

Post Photo
like

What are you doing for a retirement plan as an independent consultant? Solo 401K, SEP IRA, etc.? Any recommendations on where to open an account?

like

How are the areas around white rock lake to buy an investment property? Any suggestions appreciated!

like

Question for other people with student loans. When the deferment period ends are you planning on making a lump payment or are you going to wait to see what (if any) student loan forgiveness comes through before you pay?

like

A friend of mine works with TCS as an Analyst, his base location is Bengaluru but he is been working from his hometown in Lucknow since the first COVID lockdown. Now he is being asked by his team to work from Ahmedabad, where his direct supervisor (manager) is working from. In this case, according to TCS talent policies, what is the procedure and the benefits that he can avail, as part of project initiated relocation? Also, how long it takes to get base location changed through HR in TCS?

funny

Guys, how's the career and salary growth at a senior level (Sr.manager) at Tata Consultancy? Also what are the distinguishable benefits at TCS?

I am currently evaluating offer

like

Want to trade in my 2014 X3 for a Porsche Macan S, lease or purchase? What’s the maintanence costs of Macan looks like?

like

Is anyone else pissed that our hard earned money wasn’t lost today, it was STOLEN by CORRUPT GREEDY HEDGE FUNDS

Anyways, not giving them the satisfaction. Gonna keep holding. Actually just bought the dips today for AMC BB NOK. Will keep holding for years if I have to because stocks eventually go UP📈📈📈 and ain’t no paper handed simp.

That is all
Obligatory🚀🚀🚀

like

Hi all, had a situation I need some help with. PE fund owned interest in a bank that was a CFC that has 965 PTEP. Recently sold off part of it's interest and the bank is no longer considered a CFC. Under the new PFIC regs, I believe it qualifies as a PFIC. How would distributions be treated seeing as it would still qualify as a specified foreign corp?

like

First time buying home in the US. Do lenders typically allow you to repay the loan earlier than the loan term? without any additional fees/charges.

likehelpful

I am getting a 3% interest rate on a jumbo loan with 20% down on a $850,000 single family home. The ball park in July was 2.65 - 2.75
Checking if folks are noticing a spike in interest rates or if I need to look for another lender.

like

Does anyone have an idea on the best emerging markets to invest in before the recession hits? Is gold, or any other commodity going to be the safe haven as well? Thanks everyone

like

Thoughts on investing in DISney ? Better to go in as a stock or via ETF exposure?

like

More Posts

Anyone planning on attending the virtual HOD meeting Friday about the name change?

like

Hi Folks - agency vs in-house - pros and cons - go!

like

Hello Fishes, I'm new to fishbowl and need your help and support
I'm serving NP which will end in 15 Days.
Need referral , if anyone can help, in Amazon, capita
YOE:- 5 years

like

Hi all NICE interactive solutions is hiring for various positions. Anyone interested DM me.

Post Photo
like

“The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads” ~ Facebook data founder.

Is it wrong that we idolize FAANG? Should the govt intervene in business and privacy?

like

Hi,
What is the fixed pay range for Grade 27 in Optum?

like

MM PE vs MF PE - which would you (do you) prefer and why?

like

If WFH stays after vaccine(maybe split 50/50 with office and WFH) do you think that will have some major impacts on our economy?  our economy is based off of people spending money not saving. I think of all the lunch, coffee, happy hour, dry cleaning etc spending we used to do.

like

GME and AMC are not doing well today 😂

like

Greetings from ATL

like

How can I get resignation acceptance mail stating my lwd from HR? I got acknowledgement mail though but I need resignation acceptance mail to show to the new company

like
like

Got the second moderna shot yesterday around 5pm est. All day, my body is in such pain, I am crying as I can’t get comfortable, and i have a fever. Took Tylenol but only helps moderately. Feels like the flu with the body pains. Grateful to get it but this feels awful rn. 37 female 🐠

like

Need your to unlock DM
Pls like my post

like

Hey all, this could be excessive but I actually find the fitness side of things pretty easy, whereas the nutrition side is much more difficult to maintain long term. How would you all feel about nutrition check ins tracked with something like myfitnesspal? I generally tracks cals and protein, but find that if I stick to these I get absolutely ripped

like

Creating a 529 for myself before having kids…Should I setup a 529 for myself?

I don’t currently have kids but probably will in the future (31M, single now). Alternatively, I may go back to school at some point, or I’d be happy to disperse/gift the $$ to my nieces and nephews too… what’s my upside/downside?

like

How to handle your own procrastination? Any tips/advice?

Is anyone willing to look over my resume to let me know if I’m qualified enough to be a consultant at Deloitte? TIA

like

How is everyone getting Fall/ Spring/ summer internships? Are you all applying on the company website/ LinkedIn page. Networking to recruiters? Through college career center. I've been applying and not getting anything? Any tips or advice?

like

Additional Posts in Personal Investment Chatter

Is it financially irresponsible to buy a home that requires you to divert what you’re currently saving / investing monthly to pay the mortgage?

like

Are Vanguard target funds good options to invest my 401k money in?

like

Parents- do you have UTMA/UGMA accounts for your children? Pros/cons over 529?

like

Best robo advisors and why?

If I make $120k base and have 50k for down payment, what should the house price be?

likehelpful

If WFH stays after vaccine(maybe split 50/50 with office and WFH) do you think that will have some major impacts on our economy?  our economy is based off of people spending money not saving. I think of all the lunch, coffee, happy hour, dry cleaning etc spending we used to do.

like

GME and AMC are not doing well today 😂

like

Creating a 529 for myself before having kids…Should I setup a 529 for myself?

I don’t currently have kids but probably will in the future (31M, single now). Alternatively, I may go back to school at some point, or I’d be happy to disperse/gift the $$ to my nieces and nephews too… what’s my upside/downside?

like

ZM - back to 🚀🚀🚀🚀

like

My investing strategy is just to DCA into an S&P 500 index fund and keep buying and holding. If I understand correctly, the sole disadvantage this has compared to a tax sheltered retirement account is that the quarterly dividends will be taxed? But even so, they’ll be taxed at a lower qualified dividend rate since I’m automatically reinvesting those dividends.

like

Question for other people with student loans. When the deferment period ends are you planning on making a lump payment or are you going to wait to see what (if any) student loan forgiveness comes through before you pay?

like

What is a good alternative to a HYS and/or a CD for short term 6-12 month horizon? Low risk similar to HYS/CD, atleast from a principal conservation view.

like

Thoughts on investing in DISney ? Better to go in as a stock or via ETF exposure?

like

As a US resident, (how) can you buy stocks on international exchanges (like Hong Kong, Bombay)?

like

Recommendations for how to allocate 401k with Fidelity. Just switched jobs and have to move from Merrill Lynch to Fidelity

like

Tendies? 😊 🤚💎🤚

like

Someone talk me out of buying the C8 Corvette 😭 I make >$200k and am early twenties FWIW

like

I’m 26 and have ~40k sitting in my savings account. Annual income 140k. Maxing out 401k. No debt. Planning to invest 25k but don’t know where to start. Should I get a wealth manager? What is the best way to approach this?

like

Does anyone put money into CDs anymore?

like

Thoughts on Jumia stock?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal