Partners: Are consultants who become partners usually high performing rockstars, or at least above average? How often do you see average consultant (lets say someone who never gets promoted ahead of schedule, year end eval always in the middle) make it to the partner admission?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Not a partner but the smart ones usually leave, the bad ones get counseled out, so the average ones that grind it out become partner.


All the of the very best people I have known in my consulting career left for an MBB upgrade, to very lucrative finance/startup/big tech jobs(including me, I now work in venture)-,or to an industry job because they realized they valued their life more than their work. Of course it depends on how you define some of these three groups, because I think in reality there is like top 5-10% (who leave) next 25% (who become partners), then sort of everyone else. If you are in MBB I imagine you would not see this pattern.


I had two mentors in my career (I am now a retired partner) tell me that making partner required that you ‘have it all’. Solid technical skill (pick yours), great people management t skills, strong sales and sales acumen, and the ability to think and act like an owner of the firm. One mentor said I needed to become more benevolent. Remember, when you are up for partner, your future partners who are voting on you are asking themselves “do I see this person as my partner, my equal.


Partnership is rarely about true consulting content / delivery capabilities but rather ability to build business by selling work and managing clients and coaching teams.


P2 is spot on. The bar keeps getting higher.

Additionally, how fast someone got to senior manager/director isn’t necessarily a leading indicator of how well they will perform as a senior manager with the prospect of becoming a managing director or partner. So getting promoted ahead of schedule and past ratings (middle of the pack or great) up until this point is only what got you there. When the SM/Director clock starts, all that matters is how you perform and your SM track record/business case/book of work at that level and most do not make it, it is the way our partnerships are designed to operate.


To add on to this: a lot of people that rocket up the ranks to say manger and maybe even SM don’t make it. I’ve seen plenty of smart, great people get hung up at those levels because they don’t have all those extra skills that being a partner requires. Or they were great IC’s but what made them great IC’s prevented them to being a great leader of people. I would think that the people that make partner are pretty well rounded, liked by the other partners and seen as an equal, and some luck.


Partnership is about grit and sacrifice during the dog years - especially as a SM/Director. Everyone knows the prize is rewarding but the only differentiator is - are you willing to tolerate BS on your way.


Resilient characters make it to partner - got to have a thick skin to get to partner


In B4 Consulting - high performing; more so now than before, and the bar only continues to rise. I have not seen an average person they way you describe it make it in years. Doesn’t mean you have to hit it out of the ballpark every year, but you have to be consistent and the latter years mean much more than the earlier years.

That said, I would say three things:
1. There are some Partners now whom I believe were average according to current expectations when they made it years ago. Thus the bar continues to rise comment - expectations changed.
2. Being a high performing SM doesn’t always translate into being a high performing Partner. Not everyone is effective, and we do separate partners for lack of performance.
3. Our business continue to grow aggressively YoY. If you believe we can do that with subpar average partners, then we must be awfully lucky.


Quite the opposite actually in B4. The standards were higher when I was there than what it takes now. The salary levels have also been impacted as well. Partners in Canada at least are staring at much lower end now than what was the norm few years ago.


I was never promoted before peers but made partner 20 something years ago. Every stage of my career has been 'on-expected-time' or 'late' - and that includes post-partner-promotions. There are some absolutes around cracking the case, managing the team, delivering value to clients, building the firm at each stage and some are quicker to demonstrate those skills; and some are slower.

But, keep in mind, 'slow' is often 6-18 months behind the 'rockstars'.

What I can say is that it took me a slight bit more time than others did but I have had an incredible career and now have a colossal book of business and run an incredible practice.

If your performance evaluation system has teeth then 'middle of the pack' is pretty damn good!


If middle of the pack performers regularly become partners I’ve never seen it. There have to be some standout years in their tenure.


You can be a high performing delivery/execution person and yet never make Partner.
1. Can you make your own niche/market and add net new business?
2. Do you have friends in high places who will hand over (advocate for you is the pc term) coveted accounts to you when they retire or move out?
3. Are you coming into B4 in an area where there is a huge white space that they want to capture immediately and you have the skills?
——> these are a few ways to Partnership


Related Posts

Hi i got offers from TCS - 21LPA (associate consultant) and CTS - 22LPA (Manager). which company would be suitable for career growth and work life balance?

Recommendations for GP/family doc between downtown and Addison, near 75 or Tollway? Details inside.


Anyone know of a toastmasters or something along those lines in Philly?


Hello Everyone. Looking for a role in supply chain firm in Ontario. I have 5 years of experience in supply chain particularly as buyer, spend analyst and order management.
Any leads will be appreciated.


Interested to hear some thoughts on
private debt in terms of
compensation, work life balance, and
career optionality. Any comparison
against PE would be helpful as well - if
you considered both at one point, why
one over the other?


Can you be friends with your attorneys? Wondering if anyone has any insight or experiences.


My confession is that I am roughly 7.2 inches and it’s hard to date considering sex hurts for many of the females I’m with. Anyone else encountering a similar issue? Any advice?


What's enticing about becoming a partner these days? Doesn't seem worth the years of a lower salary to maybe get there.


You will be eligible to participate in the GDS Variable Pay Bonus (VPB) Program, with a VPB percentage target of 10% at your rank.

What its means? My rank is 44


What’s the best way to network with bankers? Is cold emailing okay or does it annoy people? Thanks for any advice.


Hi Guys,

I have 4.6 years experience in TCS.
Got two offers from capgemini and Cognizant with 130% & 150% hike.

Which one should i have to join.

Kindly suggest.

Anyone at Ogletree Deakins, Jackson Lewis, Littler, or Fisher Phillips who can share the latest on their remote work policies?


Did OFSS has increased notice period from 30 days to 60 days??


Native English-speaking writer thinking about moving to Germany. I’m a B2 German speaker, but should probably stick to writing in English. Is there a maket for my type?


Oracle hiring for Front End Developers

Post Photo

Hello Fishes,

My np is 90 days and am actively looking for change.But i rarely get any calls due to 90 days np.I have been searching jobs for last months, Would it be wise to resign and come in notice period without any offers? Maybe then I would get some calls?

Can Suggestion what to do in this situation??

What if our company paid us a nice bonus now if we are >100% utilized, then had a clause that we would have to pay it back if we left within 1 - 3 years. Something like this may resolve the retention issue.


Hello folks,
I have 3.3 years of experience in automation testing. In my current company work culture is very toxic and I'm looking for new opportunity from last 15 days but I'm not getting any call because of 3 months notice period.

Can you please help me out to tackle this 90 days no thing. I'm not brave enough to resign without offer


MILFHS (Man I Legitimately F*cking Hate Social)


What is the current interest rate you are all getting for an investment loan?

Additional Posts in Partner One

Hey All, I am looking for book recommendations for my dad who just retired as a partner after 33 years at his firm. Any ideas you can provide would be greatly appreciated.


Partners will you promote an Analyst after one year? If his/her performance has been good but the general practice on the team is to wait for two years.

At what point in your careers did you know you wanted to gun for PPMD? Any point wherein you doubted yourself?


Can anyone share actual data on partner life expectancy? I’ve heard myths (eg average partner dies 5 years post retirement), but haven’t seen data and would love to know. Thanks!


How many Partners here made it at their first company?

Did you have to leave to move up? Is it easier to make Partner at your 2nd or 3rd firm than your 1st?


This Bowl is missing profile pic. Might I suggest this one.

Post Photo

Hi partners - what would your advise be to a newly promoted senior manager? What are the things that have helped you get to the next level? Thanks much!


I started my career in the military and am 5-7 years behind my peers. Is there an age at which I should rule out making it to partner and instead plan for MD or an exit to a C-suite role?

Genuine qs to partners here. Between B4/ACN, is there any firm in particular where making consulting partner/principal could be easier? I know the cliche answer is NO but looking for opinions/experiences that may say otherwise.


Partners, what are your biggest insecurities and paranoia on a day-to-day basis?


Partners - I m a new director in a firm and I m slowly reaching out to other directors and partners from different groups to sell work together. My approach is to develop relationships with....


Partners - when you see someone on your project that has been with the firm a long time and is basically a career consultant how do you view that?


How rare and/or respected is it for an Analyst at big4 to voice their discontent about their placement? Is it seen poorly if done professionally and with humble intent? Will it get anything done?

Last day most clients are doing deals - hope all the execs and partners out there finish well (unless your competing with my bid)


Anyone left Accenture in September? Did you get your cash bonus? Was it lower as you had already quit before decisions were made?

What kind of music do you like? Asking because I've now seen/listened to three different partners' playlists and they all contained both Dave Matthews and Eminem


What can I do when a partner on my engagement doesn’t listen to me and makes bad judgment calls, gets us into bad situations despite of how I advised him against, he pulls rank and makes executive dec


Am close to making Partner at my firm (T2 Strategy shop) but worries because I see many peers stagnate at my level for 4-6 years (I’m in Yr 2) and COVID crashes the pipeline (con’t)....


McKinsey & Company Bain & Company Planning to transition into consulting. Any PMD's willing to chat for fitment or guidance.
In current role had built a profitable consulting practice for b2b saas product. Worked with F500 clients on multi million dollar engagements. YOE : 12+

McKinsey & Company, Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company


Seeking advice on a client/internal politics situation


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone


Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or