{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Please help in offer evaluation from Pay, wlb, job stability, visa/immigration.\nLocation:Bay area\n1. Product manager at Walmart $220k TC(Base 170)\n2. Project manager at Linkedin $200k TC(Base 150)", "post_id": "6166053dd576b3002f76626f", "reply_count": 27, "vote_count": 5, "bowl_id": "58f0df008ad7250010f8c590", "bowl_name": "Compensation", "feed_type": "bowl" }
null

Please help in offer evaluation from Pay, wlb, job stability, visa/immigration.
Location:Bay area
1. Product manager at Walmart $220k TC(Base 170)
2. Project manager at Linkedin $200k TC(Base 150)

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I’d go Walmart. Product Mgmt > Project Mgmt all day.

likeuplifting

Walmart! Product management is a different career track than project management.

like

I'd choose LinkedIn. Gets your foot in the door as a PM for major tech player. I assume you can later transfer to Microsoft easily / get other offers at Bay Area tech firms.

likehelpful

Walmart is a great brand and Walmart Global Tech is innovative. How is Linkedin a great brand? MAANG + Microsoft for big tech! Also, tons of people go from Walmart to Big tech!

likehelpful

Walmart

like

Can someone share the differences for a newbie like me?

like

That’s not my understanding of a Program Manager. Program manager based off my experience and learnings typically oversee a handful of smaller projects aligned with an overall program. And may have a couple project managers supporting.

like

Go do Product Management at Walmart and then come and be a Product Manager at LinkedIn later.

It is NOT easy to transfer. In order to be a Product Manager at LinkedIn, you need Exec sponsorship for the APM program, and you’ll then need to interview for 4-6 slots amongst 70-100 applicants, and if after all that you get the job, you come in at the Associate Product Manager level, and then go through regular promo timeline.

like

That’s not an easy jump, two different type of companies. LinkedIn is a tech first company which has a public facing product, Walmart on the other hand might have some public facing tech products, but not at the same scale.

like

Second the product management choice

like

Product Manager position will have a better upward mobility than a project manager or rather project manager role will be a longer route.

like

Thanks all for your responses. The linkedin offer mentions role as 'Business Program manager', not sure if this would be similar to a product management industry role or project management role.

Linkedin Role - i know few people who worked at Walmart and they didn't have lot of positives to talk about the IT unit.

What’s your role at EY?

Take LinkedIn. Business PM can set you up for greater things. Enough with the product mgr hype. Take product only if you want to do it. Not for the firm.

LinkedIn is a better brand than Walmart for PM roles .

Walmart opportunity is better. Don’t listen to people saying LinkedIn for brand. People in consulting have been too enamored by brand names.

Related Posts

My company is a women and minority own management consultancy/ SaaS products company based out of the SF Bay Area and we are hiring talented technical recruiters (100% REMOTE!) !! Mid size company. Please reach out to me directly if you are interested :)

like

Hello! Any one in here who can give me a referral for a position at McKinsey and BCG? Thanks in advance!!

Hello fishes,

This is my first and I need 11 likes to DM for a job referral. Would you be kind enough to help me ?

like

Hello everyone,
I have recently moved to Long Beach, CA and I am currently looking for a Recruiting Coordinator or Technical Recruiter role close by. I am also open to hybrid or remote jobs.
5 years of HR and Admin experience, masters in business and management and currently reading towards my SPHR. Also looking for someone well experienced in the field to serve as a career mentor.
Any advice, criticism or suggestions will be appreciated.
Thank you.

like

Does any work for the M&A deal analytics team at Deloitte? Looking for a referral. Thanks!
Deloitte PwC EY KPMG

likehelpful

What happens if I join a new firm upon H1B transfer receipt and get denied? Do I still have the 60 day grace period to find a new job that’s willing to file a new transfer application?

Any openings for SAP ABAP ,YOE -2 ??

like

Hi Fishes- Just to let the people know if they are getting paid enough for their role in the data field. Share your role, yoe, ctc, company name(if comfortable ) and number of switches. Request Only Data analysts,data engineers or data scientists to comment.

like

Can you use automated ReValidation for going to Canada or Mexico under 30 days and coming back with expired visa/i94 but new H1 approval?

My project manager can’t manage projects

like
like

Looking to relocate to the south-east U.S. to be nearer family. Anyone know of any good agencies/clients hiring senior roles at the moment or will be soon? Ideally one that's going hybrid at least. Fully remote also good, but would like to be in the SE so going to the office would be at least an option. And yes, I've looked at LinkedIn, Indeed, Google etc.

like

I am on OPT Stem currently in my last year. What are my next options for visa if my company doesn’t want to sponsor me for the H1B?

Founders: What are you looking for when hiring lawyers?

like

Can anyone pls tell me, i recently got an offer from IHS markit which is now S&P global, They mentioned in the offer position offered for Markit India Services Pvt Ltd and office location is Noida 62. Tech stack .net developer with angular Yoe- 5Years Is this is the salary structure they are following, did anyone got the same salary structure?? Or different one or different format ?? How's this join over EY GDS Tax TTT line ?? IHS Markit S&P Global

Post Photo
like

Does Amex provide accommodation to new joiners?

I saw an SDR manager position open up near me. My career goals are to get into management and keep moving up. I got promoted quickly at my company and have coaching experience but that isn’t on my resume. How do show on paper that I want to be a manager and that I want to develop SDRs to get where they want to be?

like

Best skills to have if you want to specialize in product marketing? Finding it hard to get actual hands-on project experience so wondering if any skills/cert training could make up for it

like

May I know when AMEx is going to call its employees to the office.
WFH till date?

like

Additional Posts in Compensation

Feeling some major imposter syndrome as I job hunt and compare myself to other people my same age. I feel like most of my friends/colleagues that started out in the industry at the same time as me...

like

Hi Can anyone refer me in IBM. I have the job id.

Thanks in advance.

If I have an h1b approval that hasn't been used yet from one company, can it be transferred to another company? (If I want to switch jobs)

like

Hiring Sr AD at independent shop in LA. DM me for details.

like

Would you wear your engagement ring to get your nails done? I dont want it to get dirty/damaged Lol

like

What salary range can be expected in Barclays for BA4

Current CTC 19.1 LPA
Holding offer of 27 ( 24 fix + 3 vp)
Tech stack :- Abinitio
YOE : 8 years

like

Hello Tigers

I have an ongoing discussion with
Tiger Analytics, have cleared R1 and have been told that there will be next round. Can you pls let me know abt R2 ? If it's more of Technical or Techno Managerial..?
What are the stages involved.

Tech: Azure
Exp: 12 yrs

#thanks
Tiger Analytics

like

I switched from audit to analytics consulting, but feel like all I do is make dashboards all day and am looking to return to accounting.

My base now is 120k with 3yoe in audit and 1 in analytics, how much of a pay cut would I be looking at to go to FDD?

likefunny

How much fixed pay hike does IQVIA offer from current ? My fixed is 10.26lpa

like

Are the default promotion in Cognizant from PA to A soon after 1 year of being PA stopped now? Or is it still happening?

I am a PA who joined as a PAT 2 years ago.

like

I have a offer of Cisco SBG( security business group) with 2.5 yoe as data engineer any one have idea what this group do there and future prospects after joining it ?

like

! The international Girls Academy is launching a Global Education Week from April 11-19, they have some really amazing projects for teachers and students. And it’s free! Email:theinternationalgirlsacademy@gmail.com for more info!

like

Account ladies, what do you wear to interview?

ranking of top FDD firms?

like

Anyone working at starcom, how generous are they with holidays/summer days off, PTO, benefits , 401k matching etc

like
like

Hi fishes,

I am selected in
Infosys as devops engineer last week i got call from HR after discussion he said he will release offer letter within 7 days after approval but he has not till now, can someone confirm how much time it may take?

like

Was laid off from a startup about a month ago. It happened over a phone call with HR.

Still haven’t received any paperwork or anything regarding termination. Is this common or do I need to reach out? I still have my company-issued laptop as well.

like

Has anyones dm feature got blocked? If so How did you got it back?

likefunny

Additional Posts (overall)

Started a new job, my base salary went from $80k to $100k. Federal income tax jumped from $243 to $577. Is this normal?

funnylike

New OTS manager in high cost state, no MBA. What to expect? Can I ask for more in the compensation call if the number comes lower than expected?

like

SA salary in KPMG lighthouse woth masters?

like

Anyone know what a global program director at IBM makes? (And how distinct is that from a global leader?). What are the titles beyond that? Thanks!

(And yes, I looked on Indeed and Glassdoor - no idea how accurate those are.)

like

What TC should I expect for a Technical Program Manager III role in Amazon Robotics ?
Not sure on level

like

Would a consultant at Deloitte make more or slalom? Coming from Accenture

like

Range for SC Deloitte Advisory with 3 years experience? Coming from a boutique.

like

Is 125 base. 20k equity. 5k signing bonus. Good comp for nyc and 3 yoe? Got this offer from a tech ish shop and don’t know if it’s in line

like

Does having an MBA bump you into a higher cohort regardless of vertical? More specifically is there an MBA cohort for pwc cybersecurity? If so what's the difference look like at the SA/M levels.

like

What’s the expected base package to be expected from a Big 4 in Australia for a manager in consulting?

like

My start date was pushed from June - September last year. Looking to jump to a new firm now. Think there’s any chance my current firm will honor the original June date and not make me pay back the signing bonus?

like

Was contacted for a Managing Director role in commercial real estate and was asked for compensation expectations. Very few data points I could find on the typical sources Glassdoor Etc. Any idea comp ranges at this level / industry? TYIA

like

How does SM compensation range in Canada amongst the big 4 in Consulting? I would imagine $125-$200K annual plus bonus. Is that right and what’s the median like

like

$110,000 For a 3rd year manager 11 year experience -Deloitte Canada. Is this norm?

like

What are salary expectations for someone coming into a big 4 firm with prior experience (3 years) and coming in as a Consultant?

like

Anyone know comp for Decision analytics at ZS, associate level 1.5 years of exp?

like

Speaking with a recruiter that reached out from PWC Workforce Transformation USA.

Salary for SA and M in this group?

3 YOE in consulting with an MBA not top 10 but top 25

like

What pay would you expect for a compliance mgr position in a HCOL? (Large company). When I asked about salary budget they said it was "flexible".

like

What the average compensation for manager & senior manager (consulting) roles in Texas at Deloitte ? >10 years experience

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

New to Fishbowl?

image with Fishbowl logo and arms reaching out for a handshake

Already have an account? Log in

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Messaging rates may apply

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal