Pros and cons of paying off mortgage of rental property earlier? We have $149K on it and ~370K on primary residence. We have no other debt, and HHI is $300K. If we have another kid, we’ll estimate needing to purchase a bigger home for ~$850K. We have the liquidity now to pay off the mortgage of rental property but am afraid we’ll need that liquidity for down payment in a year. We have a buffer, but not enough to do both in 1-2 years. Thoughts?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Yo. Ya’ll are so wise with this shit. Thank you.

likefunny

The pure mathematical answer is that you only pay it off if you don’t think you can earn greater than 4.25% elsewhere

The practical answer, as B1 mentioned, is that it is largely dependent on your risk tolerance.

Personally, I wouldn’t pay it off. The flexibility is invaluable to me, I can make more money in the market, and it sounds like you don’t have cash flow issues

like

If you need the liquidity, keep the investment in something more liquid. Paying off the mortgage early only makes sense if you can’t find a safe place to get a higher return than your current mortgage interest rate.

like

Debt is often good. Frees up money for other things. Don’t pay it off unless you think you can’t otherwise get a 4.25% return on your money.

Perfect example from myself, wife and I have over $100k left in federal students loans at little under 4% interest. We also have $500k+ in equities in our brokerage account. Not only is inflation helping devalue our student loan debt, but the money we could use to pay off the student loans is earning way way more than 4% in our brokerage account.

like

Great points. Adding to it are the tax advantages. You deduct mortgage interest, student loan payments, etc. The tax shield is the keystone to debt financing

like

I’ve been wondering the same thing and in a somewhat similar situation.

Another option is to use your capital for a down payment on another rental property? Probably just depends on your risk tolerance.

Also depends on mortgage interest rate. 3% is not bad debt.

like

Maybe try the personal investment chatter bowl. Lots of helpful resppnses there for these typenof questions.

like

Paying 4.25% interest rate on rental property, fwiw

Echoing other posters, refi even if you don’t do cash out and pay the minimum to increase cash flow for other investments.

With inflation as it is, I wouldn't pay early, even at 4.25%.

With the housing market the way it is, you’ll net a gain when you sell the rental property anyway. Key is to sell it before you buy another place, that way you have liquidity for a down payment if needed.

Just sold my old house last year and used half the net to put 20% down on our forever home. Kept the rest for DIY and Reno projects that we just finished over the last 4 months. Now the remaining cash is going into the market.

1. Refinance if you intend to keep rental property long term. If youre planning on cashing in on the hot market, dont bother. Not sure what rates are if you refinance so id say do it if it saves you a substantial amount like 400 plus a month.

2. Pay more towards the principal amount every month. (An extra $1500 a month perhaps?)

3. Lump sum payment of maybe 30% of the remaining balance as opposed to completely paying it off.

4. You can always take out equity from this property to use as a down payment for next home. Although im not too familiar with this strategy but i know real estate investors do this all the time.

Refinance, pull out the cash to purchase another rental property. Interest rates are extremely low

Definitely refi if you can. Another piece of info not discussed is how much are you netting from rental income? Is it enough to service the debt and how consistently is it coming in? If the tenant is able to service the debt, this gives you further flexibility and reduces your need to pay off the rental property’s mortgage yourself

Related Posts

My sister wants me to pay for my father's hospitalization and related costs

My parents planned a trip to the US and never told me. My sister helped then plan. In the US, my father fell sick and had to be hospitalized. They did have travel insurance but there were still a lot of out of pocket expenses and other expenses related to rescheduling tickets, etc.

My sister contacted me once she got the bills and told me "as their son" I should be paying for everything.

funnylike

When people say you should be saving at least 20% of your annual income, does that include 401k, Roth IRA & other investments (Ex. RSUs)? Or does the 20% savings need to be additional to these?

likehelpful

What does it even mean when an employer offers 3% match on 401k?? They contribute 3% of what I contribute or what I earn overall? And monthly or annually? Thanks, basic brain here.

likefunnyhelpful

So, a possible Blue Wave in November with some promises to reverse the 2018 tax cuts and maybe introduce at-death realization of capital gains - should mean a hectic November-January, right?

(Then again, I've been wrong before. Last time it was "So, a global pandemic that preys on the elderly, many of whom have a bunch of unused gift and GST exemption lying around since 2018 - probably a busy time for estate planning?" Was underwhelmed. )

Good time to buy TLT now? Long duration treasury

like

What’s the average return on investment for real estate? Is it better to invest in real estate than stocks?

like

Hi Fishes,

I want to set up a small business in Rajasthan (remote area) for my father, I don’t want him to leave home and stay with family.

Can you please give some ideas on what can be setup for consistent long term profit and also setup cost is not that high.
Thanks in advance.

Moving to San Jose from East Coast. Any recommendations on movers? I don't have too much stuff, most of it is for my kid.
My new unit in San Jose doesn't allow for Pod type services so it has to be movers

like

Hello fishes,
Let me share my story, I have work experience of more than 7 years. Mostly I worked in remote sites as a planning engineer and project manager. Unfortunately, my father passed away in covid second wave. Then i realised spending life with family is equally important. I left my job and am looking for a job near or in Delhi. My last employer was godrej & Boyce , designation Asst manager and by background is civil engineering. Please suggest is there any relevant openings available.

like

Anyone else struggling to get work done while working from home with children under 1 (or children in general)? Spouse and I are both working from home and both struggling with getting our work done while taking care of baby.

like

How do you get out of a credit card debt trap?

like

If I did a wash sale and repurchased shares within a few days and then sell 30+ days later for a loss, will I still be able to harvest the tax loss? Or does IRS disallow or require me to claim that the following yr?

like

Ideally how much your net worth need to be in order to retire comfortably as a couple? Not looking to have an extravagant lifestyle but do want to travel regularly.

like

What is your agency’s paternity/maternity leave policy? I’d love to start a roundup of agencies and holding companies offerings.

like

Hi does anyone know if we are entitled to bank holidays on top of parental leave?

Hi,
I wish to share my story:I was working with ICICI Bank Ltd as chief manager since last six years. Last year my father expired during lockdown. While he was sick and after his death I took leave for three weeks. After I joined back I was informed about transfer from Mumbai to Gidderbaha branch and was asked to report there. I requested for change in location but in vain, organisation did not even arranged for place to stay for single woman. I resigned now after few months with no job in hand

likehelpful

Ok so I make 130k a year and instead of taking the prorated deduction on my Roth IRA, I'm planning to open a traditional IRA and then rollover the money ASAP to Roth. I'm planning to use my post-tax payments to fund the IRA.

One, is that the right thing to do?

Two, should I anticipate any tax issues during filing? I've read about tax liability when doing the conversation, would that apply to me here?

People who do this every year, tips are greatly appreciated!

like

Hey guys wanted to hear your thoughts on PE co-investing, is it a good path to direct investing? I read that the skill sets are similar but I see very little info on how hard that move is. I usually see posts linking co-investing to FoF but co-investing doesn’t seem like FoF (unless I’m wrong). Open to hearing your guys’ thoughts on it

like

Is this a good time to send money to India or wait I feel with covid on rise in India .. rupee will become weaker. Any thoughts?

like

Hello fishes, I am filing my tax return using hrblock premium. I have made contributions to nondeductible ira and then converted to roth ira (backdoor). the form 8606 asks these questions, but the questionnaire doesnt ask about whether I have converted. does anyone have experience with form 8606? which tax return software does this properly?

like

More Posts

How do you find an immigration lawyer, and how expensive are they? I’m currently in greencard recruitment phase and have lots of questions to which Deloitte isn’t providing sufficient answers

It's great to have this bowl. I am astonished at the replies to conservative posts in the general bowls are. I don't mind sharing and having discussions, but not fun when the others are attacking and not communicating!

likehelpful

Is it possible to change Cisco mail id as per our interest?

like

Hello Everyone,

I am looking out for opportunity in retail industry as an Area Or Regional manager, if any reference or lead in any Brand or organization would appreciate your help...

like

Hypo: You’re at a BL firm averaging about 2000 hours a year. Not bad environment. Google offers you a great in house gig. But, you have to switch your iPhone for an Android. Do you do it???

funnylike

Live to work or work to live?

What are your favorite excel macros to make you more efficient at work?

like

Anyone have Tonal or know someone who does? What are your thoughts?

like

Kpmg donated 500k, am I the only one who takes this commitment to be small and just an act of damage control? I mean we bring in 20+ billion annually.

like

Hi everyone,
I recently joined a small company as a tech lead in Pune.

I am not enjoying the work here. I have good experience in Linux application development in C. Also as a hobby project completed small projects on opencv/image processing on python.

I have a good hold in system design using python and C.

Looking for suggestions should I starting looking for another opportunity or should I wait for atleast completing 1 year to justify my change.

Looking for honest suggestions

like

The COVID age brought a new wave of innovation in academic writing. What's your favorite change from the past 3 years?

like

What’s a ‘Creative Manager’, is it above ACD?

like

How is the job security for Fujitsu Consulting India band fj12. How is the overall job security?

like

Anyone have suggested resources for finding open in-house roles looking to be filled? Other than general LinkedIn postings, I’m only familiar with Go In-House.

like

Who’s the best person to win against Modi in 2024?

like

How much is IBM IMS hierarchical database suitable for EDW implementation for a mid-size insurance company? The company is insisting on using IMS, thoughts!!

like

Is there any Muslim organizations at Deloitte?

like

I’ve been frustrated at work. I’ve been having several days were I come in and have nothing to do nor will anyone give me anything additional that I can help out on.

like

Hi Fishes what do think of opportunities in Coimbatore? Is it growing and does it have any scope in the future?

like

Anyone having doj 20 june in dusi ?? Are they providing accommodation?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

If I’m a new analyst from undergrad on the bench, am I at risk of getting laid off?

like

Has anyone ever been in a position where you had to witness cheating? Significant others friend wants to bring a +1 that isn't their wife and I am really against being put in this position.

like

Anyone else here ever get some uncomfortable bloating on long flights? What is it and how can I prevent it?

What are your 401k plan’s administrative fees per year? Mine ~$45 annually which are billed to the account quarterly.

like

Folks who have gone from Big 4 Operations to MBB strategy - what are some of the differences in culture, work life balance, skills needed, etc.

like

Anyone have any recommendations for good ergonomic chairs <800?

like

What are the top consulting firms for transformation implementations? McKinsey, BCG, LEK, Accenture, Deloitte?

like

Scranton/Wilkes-Barre PA? Is there anything worth eating or drinking there?

Would taking up more work decrease your odds of being laid off in a recession (assuming performance, and all else stay the same)? Assuming your current workload is 100%. This is for industry

like

Speaking to a senior exec tomorrow at a firm I’m super interested in. She’s my friend’s friend. Best way to ask what roles are available for me? She has mentioned no roles under her are available but oversees other teams

like

Planning on moving to Canada from Chicago to mix up my scenery - however this would result in a 2 hour time difference between me and my team. Does anyone have success stories (or tips) about cross-time zone teams, or is it a better call to just find a new job/new office?

like

Haven’t interviewed since covid hit. What’s the process for most companies now? Is it all virtual? Or a few rounds virtual and a few in person?

like

Everyone's talking about the meet up. Who's down for End of Month Get Together in Houston? Let's plan for Saturday, 2/27 dinner/drinks. Or Sunday, 2/28 brunch!

like