Should I have been a quant? Was a USAMO level math competitor as a kid, but fell out of that world after being sick of it all.

After two years of aligning logos and models at an IB, I’m in an enviable place — but still earning less than some of my former peers who’re at Citadel and Jane Street, with worse hours. I like the work I do now, but it’s kind of frustrating that I’m never really using the skills I was once world class at.

Is the grass actually greener?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Do you mean you earn less than peers at citadel who are doing quant? Or fundamental?

I’m someone who set out to be a quant but ended up switching to fundamental investing this year. Worked as a risk quant (only required stats/programming) before deciding to apply to MFE to up my math background; then decided that 1) the bar is higher for quant than fundamental investors; and 2) quant models didn’t do very well in tail events like COVID.

I switched to real assets PE and am now in later stages with one of the top HFs for a L/S equity role. So my anecdote is that you could skip formal fundamental work experience and still get an investment seat if you can craft a pitch. Can’t skip MS PhD if you want a quant seat. And the upside is unlimited at both, so why spend time and $ on higher ed? I also think direct market exposure is more useful than academia.

like

I am not saying the bar is low. Getting into Citadel/millenium/P72 is hard. But they are more open to those with investment ideas even without the “right background.” I never did ER/banking but I can build models and generate ideas. I was also self taught in machine learning and can build those models but always got the feedback that quant funds strongly preferred MS/PhD candidates who know 3 programming languages. Higher ed could be right for others, but I don’t want to spend another 5 years being drowned in theories. At the end of the day, investors outperform on creativity and business acumen. You can hire others to build/implement technical models but you need ideas on what the models do.

like

Trading and algorithmic strats are very different, which are you looking at?

Yes, it is greener. WLB isn’t great (55 hrs/wk on average), but blows banking out of the water, and I have my weekends to myself. I considered banking in college but definitely made the right decision in hindsight. If you were USAMO level, you should have no problem getting interviews/offers from those trading shops (provided that you review concepts since you’ll probably be rusty). Happy to refer you if you pm me.

Related Posts

I'm a Sr. Project Manager and for the next step in my career track, which do you think is better to go for: a Program Manager or a Director of Project Management? I'm based in Atlanta. All thoughts are welcomed.

like

Hi Fishes,

I joined Accenture in Nov,2021 in CL 12.2
I received compensation revision in Sep (sub level change to CL 12.1)
Will I be eligible for annual hike in Nov cycle..? If I'm not, then in 2023 when will I get annual hike.? Sep or Nov 2023...?

Thanks..!

like

Seems like EY would have an exodus of employees post-split. We will get randomly assigned to assureCo vs newCo by leadership and expecting many people going to assureCo will try to flee to other B4 especially for senior and lower level.

likefunny

Just got an offer from Accenture Strategy.. Manager level, $175K base, 10% bonus, and a $20K sign-on bonus. is this a fair offer and has anyone had success negotiating a higher base and/or sign-on bonus?

like

Is LTI chennai culture good?
How much hike we could expect?
Will I get variable pay (bonus) fully 100% as mentioned in offer letter?

Hello fishes,
I am a Salesforce Developer with 8 months of experience. I also have PD1 certification and have a good knowledge in Apex, Aura, LWC, SOQL and Configuration and Customisation too. I want to switch after a few months. Are there any opportunities for this much experience? I am good at my work and can learn more about new stuff. Please suggest how should I prepare for switch.

like

Any good parenting book recommendations for a kid entering 1st grade? Read lots of the positive discipline series and found it helpful through the toddler stage but now looking for some practical parenting advise for grade school. Thanks!

like
like

Has anyone been able to get into MBB straight from FDD? I imagine it would take a lot of preparation and networking but I’m trying to find out if this is a possible move without an MBA

like

Favorite science show to watch as kid?

like

PFB breakup and help me to calculate in hand salary
SAP Tata Consultancy

Post Photo
like

Confused!
So I am working as a UI UX designer since Jan22. I started with a really good project (everything from the scratch) with research, knowing the user etc. The project went really well. It was my first project that I handled individually. I got another project it also went well. Then I was told to work directly with a client, it's been 2 months already we work late hours and also on weekend (asked by the client). It feels like my personal life is gone. Do you think I should change job?

like

Hello I am currently working in PDM model and might soon shift to USDC model, can someone share any insights if you have any of pros and cons for the shift ... I am currently project delivery manager so might translate to solution architect in USDC

like

Since Deloitte handed out retention bonuses, are they giving huge sign on bonuses for experienced hires or is base comp just higher than the past year?

funnyhelpful

Hi Partners,
Seeking your input - I'm a Senior Assoc. aiming for fast track promotion to Manager 🎯

What values/qualities/traits do you look for? in need of direction.
#anyadvisewouldbegreat👏

like

Hi All,
Can anybody clarify what is non promotion eligible (non PE) SO ? Can they really stop your promotion just because you are tagged in a non PE SO ?

like

Best way to becoming an executive at a portfolio company for a PE fund? What is the most successful path from consulting? I.e go to fund ops as an associate then work your way up or stay at MBB till partner then try to hop over, etc.

like
like
like

I am currently working in advertising with experience on fintech & CPG. I would like to work in tech marketing, specifically Google’s APMM program.
I’ve been studying some PM/PMM books/podcasts/videos, attending Google events, and want to keep learning more to try to prepare myself as much as I can.
What resources helped you get into product marketing/Google?
Has anyone here moved from advertising to tech?
Would love to hear from a marketer about their experience getting into Google.
Thank you

like

More Posts

Exit opportunities for litigation associates?

like

How do y'all stay motivated when you're not passionate about your job? It's getting hard for me to do more than the bare minimum these days and it's impacting my overall disposition and demeanor

likehelpful

I recently got excepted in NYU for both their MBA and MS in Quantitative Management (think business analytics). They're both from The Stern school of business so I'm wondering does it matter which one I got to in terms of advancing at a Big Four or financial institution?

like

Hi everyone. I have been living at home saving money and I was wondering should I use my money saved by the time I leave my parents should have close to 200k saved. Should I use that to buy a house since I like stability. I am 24 if that helps.

likehelpful

Can I pay a State Farm auto loan with Plastiq to meet Minimum Spend on AmEx? Worried I won’t hit the 5k on regular spend.

like

Technology consulting at EY India vs similar profile at Bain Capability Network at similar pay, which one to choose?

Main focus on growth towards learning and pay, future opportunities. Currently 2 YOE IT Services

like

I have a offer from abinbev and fractal analytics. Package is similar . Which one to choose ?looking for good quality work and work life balance. 4 years of experience in data science

like

What's your favorite date night spot in Vancouver? Bonus points for views/ambiance.

like

Reached the friday danger point where i could stop working but only if i make monday a 12 hour day

likefunny

Hi all,
I want to know what kind of portal tech mahindra HR are using. They are giving an excuse like the portal is down that is why your offer letter is not getting released. Can someone please help.
I did all the verification from digiverifier and so many documents I have shared with them


@Tech Mahindra

like

Does anyone know the new pay for FDD in pwc? Today RLs are supposed to know right? Do they have the info already?

like

Vacancies in EPAM Systems

DM if interested.

Post Photo
like

Has anyone joined the Grand Seiko GS9 Club? I have to say, I am very impressed but this new endeavor. It is not gimmicky as I initially suspected. Joining allows you to directly purchase even their limited edition timepieces that would’ve only been available at boutiques. Grand Seiko is really positioning themselves in the market. Very curious to see what is to come and whether prices will begin to reflect that.

like

Hi Everyone, Could someone please suggest the best institute for DevOps Online Training course?

Isael all euro airports a nightmare right now or is it certain ones? Is there. Way to figure out which ones to avoid when planning a trip?

like

Does anyone work at Charlie health and know what the salary is for the Continuing care coordinator role

like

Have you been party to a great training sessions on PLG - product led growth? If so what made it great for you, your team, your leaders etc.

like

Good luck to all the fish running the Brooklyn Half tomorrow. 🐠🏃 👍🍀

like

Can you post pictures of your favorite plant babies? I’ll go first..

Post Photo
like

so turns out BLR office peeps are spreading covid to fellow coworkers… leadership plz send help

Additional Posts in Finance

PE Fish -- Do any of you NOT have a background in IB? If so, what was your background and how'd you break in?

like

How difficult is it to transition from Associate to VP at your firm?

like

Anyone working at PNC that would give me a reference?

like

How much work, if any, do you take home with you?

Which HF offers the best training and mentorship opportunities?

like

What is something that you’re grateful for?

like

I know questions about internal mentors have been asked before, but has anyone ever gotten a life coach? Did it help or was it more of a money making scheme?

like

Thoughts about dating someone from your floor

like

What are some nice color schemes you've used on a model?

like

I have an MS Amex Platinum-if I close my brokerage account, will Amex automatically close my Amex?

like

Trying to upgrade my ties. Suggestions? Should I go vintage hermes/ferragamo or new lower tier brands (tywritt, thomas pink, etc)?

like

What is the longest amount of time you’ve had between a verbal offer and the written? I’m going on 3 weeks since HR called me, and I know with COVID we should expect some delays, but this seems abnormally long? BB bank for context that said they needed the role filled ASAP.

like

Excel formatting pet peeves?

like

Currently working as a senior financial analyst at an industrial gas company in the Houston area. What is a reasonable salary for that position? Trying to make sure for negotiations.

like

Has anyone successfully learned a new language in adulthood? If so, how did you do it? Physical classes? Online classes? Personal tutoring?

like

The S&P 500 went 94 days without closing up or down 1%, but in the last 17 days, it has done this 10 times.

like

For those with deal experience across FIG, TMT, Healthcare or Consumer.... what sector have you found yourself enjoying most?

like

Hi I’m currently working as a bond indexing product analyst but I have a desire to transition into being a private credit product specialist….I’m hesitant to do Investor Relations in PE/PC because from what I read it was a heavy sales role i.e. fundraising. Does anyone have insight on this or any advice on how I can plan to transition. I would also love any information on what the job entitles

Do you think your average BB/EB for sure more of a grind than the average MM? That seems to be a prevailing opinion but I feel like it’s group specific

like

What’s a more lucrative career path? Financial analyst or Wealth management? Goal is to get filthy rich and become a CFO

funnylike

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal