Should I invest in the roth or traditional 401k option? 23 making 75k as a consultant

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

It depends on if you want to pay tax now or later. If you think your bracket is higher now than when you withdraw in retirement do traditional, if not Roth. Most people have no way of knowing so a split between the 2 may make sense

like

Agree. I think Roth is a no brainer if you are in a low bracket. After that it is a guess and a split may be best. I just see so many people saying it is stupid to do traditional without actually thinking about how withdrawals might look

like

If you search within this bowl you’ll see suggestions for your income level are to establish an emergency fund first (~3-6 months of expenses), max your 401k employer match, then max your Roth. After that, you can max HSA, rest of 401k or put the rest in a Brokerage account depending on your preference.

like

Roth is an adjective—there is a Roth 401k vs traditional 401k, and a Roth IRA vs traditional IRA. The question is to go with Roth 401k or traditional 401k. What I heard is Roth 401k for when you’re in a low tax bracket (early career etc) then traditional 401k when you’re at the peak of your earning

Recent IconRecent

Roth. Your tax bracket will only increase as you age and move higher in your career

like

That is why I suggest a split

People always say “Roth because your income will increase over time”.

This is too simplistic a way to look at it. You’re likely going to start drawing down from your 401k when your regular income is actually $0 (because you’ll be retired) - so you won’t be in a higher tax bracket when you start withdrawing like people assume. You’ll probably actually be in a lower bracket.

If you have $0 of W2 income (which you will if you’re retired) you can draw down more than you think from a pretax 401k while paying $0 in taxes.

like

SC2, I assume you mean from traditional. Only traditional has RMDs. Converting from traditional to Roth makes sense often, but it all shows up as income that year and can impact your total income and all the things that go with that.

This bowl has a lot of responses. I’ll also note that if you’re planning to go to grad school, the Traditional may be better (so you can convert to Roth when you’re in a lower tax bracket during school).

like

I do a little of both - my 401k is all traditional, and IRA all Roth

like

Roth & taxes probably can’t drop in future as our debt keeps accumulating somebody has to pay it down.

like

This. I’m not leaving my money to chance. Historically speaking, we have lower tax rates

like

Both

like

Do all roth. As your salary rises over the years with promotions and job hops, you will become ineligible for roth contributions by maybe age 28 (assuming you stay in consulting and get promos or a new job every 2 yrs). Make those post-tax contributions now, and you still have decades for pre-tax contributions. But if you start with pre tax, you might not have the opportunity again in a handful of years.

I think op is talking about 401k. There is no income limit for Roth 401k.

like

Also consider if you’re in a state with high income tax. If you plan to live their forever, even in retirement, then either could work for you. If you plan to move to a state later on with lower or no income tax, then go with a traditional 401k.

Roth

Roth

For my 401k I split. But favoring roth more. Maybe like 80% roth & 20% trad. I don't want to worry about taxes down the line even tho it could cost more, but less stressful for me. If I need more $ now, then I'll change it up to favor trad which I've done.

Roth

Why Roth? Traditional may be better. Or a split

Roth.. returns are not taxed. Returns are taxed on withdrawal in traditional. At this stage in your life, that compounding growth will be significant

Traditional - it could lower your tax bracket and the taxes you need to pay

Roth would allow you to roll into a Roth IRA later without tax consequences, which is the only categorization that doesn’t have RMDs (MRDs).

As long as you are willing to pay the taxes on the conversion, which can get complicated if you don’t do it all at once. I.e., what to convert, when to convert. Sounds like an idea for an app....

I am 23 and have both a 401k to take advantage of employer match and a Roth IRA

Related Posts

Is it normal for a company not to provide paid maternity leave? They said it’d be paid by the state under FMLA for 3 months. Is the FMLA benefit payment taxable?

like

I am currently stuck between two job positions, one with Merrill making $85k base and big corp benefits and another for an RIA for $65k and no benefits like healthcare and 401k. I really like the RIA position better but other comparable positions in the area range from $45-$60k so it doesn’t seem like strong numbers to negotiate. Should I chose ML for the salary/benefits security— Anyone have insights? Worried of being a new higher compensated employee with a potential recession on the horizon..

like

I'm an in-house counsel at a national company. Our GC is leaving. I’m the only other in-house attorney, and I’ve only been here for 4 months. I like the job. Previously, I was a 6th-year associate.
The CEO asked me to stay and implied a larger role, but doesn't have a clear picture of what that looks like. Asked for my help in redefining. Even unsure as to timing or whether we'll hire another GC. Questions for Fishbowl: (1) benefits or pitfalls? (2) questions or requests you'd have for CEO?

like

Does anyone have and pay for both Chase Sapphire Reserve and Amex Plat. Would you recommend having both?

like

Thoughts on joining Epsilon as a Strategic Consultant? What’s it like working there? What’s it like working with the inter-agency teams, whether they’re within Publicis or external to Publicis? Benefits of being a Strategic Consultant at Epsilon? Downsides?

like

Should I leave a firm that promised to pay maternity leave and then took back their word? Mid sized plaintiff firm in Atlanta.

like

Hi there! I’m looking for a role as a technical project manager. Preferably at a bank but I’m willing to look into healthcare as well. Please let me know if your company is hiring and you can provide a referral :)

like

@zs fish, any cool perks you found out after joining that weren’t included explicitly in the offer letter? Ie gym reimbursement, swag, lunches?

like

I am a new hire at Deloitte...do I need to sign up for American Express rewards..what do you guys normally redeem your rewards for in order to get the maximum value for your points?

like
likefunny

What does everyone think about the whole Mark Cuban cost-plus drugs situation? Is this the way to devalue the monopoly of healthcare insurance companies and PBMs? I personally love the cost transparency, and I can see why patients would too.

like

Hi Fishes,
What are the benefits of joining pwc? Do you have wfh allowance and embloyee well being for phone reimbursement like Deloitte?
If yes, is this level specific?

like

Can I pay a State Farm auto loan with Plastiq to meet Minimum Spend on AmEx? Worried I won’t hit the 5k on regular spend.

like

Anyone have insight/experience in HIG, specifically relating to healthcare tech consulting? What type of work do you do? How’s salary for senior assoc level? Potential bonus vs actual? Any help is appreciated.

like

Recently I was pulled aside by my colleague who told me he was part of an operation that included “special benefits”. He asked if I wanted in. Should I be worried?

like

Recent graduate with Bachelors of Health Science in Workplace Health and Wellness. Currently working in a Healthcare job but as a client service coordinator. Really would like to get a job in my field. If anyone has suggestions/recommendations please share. Within GTA would be great if not, remote anywhere works.

My recruiter told me I️ would be hired as an FTE after 3 months now they keep extending me month by month & the instability of not having health benefits makes me feel extremely anxious. I️ initially wasn’t interested in contract jobs but thought it would be a good opportunity for my career. Im thinking of sticking around but also debating looking for a new opportunity w/ more stability/clarity. Any advice? Open to anything, preferably a proposal/project coordinator role if anyone is hiring

like

Bain & Company Hi Looking for opportunity in healthcare/pharmaceutical consulting. Kindly share if any opportunities are available. Thanks!

EY-Parthenon Deloitte Accenture Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company

Hi all. I am licensed in life, accident and health and am looking for new opportunities. I’ve been working in employee benefits in a small brokerage firm on a book of business of over 400 clients, I’m the only account manager. We’ve had 100% employer retention since I’ve been here. I am a high performer, but not sure I’m valued much at all . I want to reach the top and become partner in my career ; this is why I went to work for a small firm. My boss favors others when I do the most work!!

like

Looking for exit opportunities in Bangalore . have close to 5 years of management consulting experience serving the US pharma and healthcare sectors.Any leads are highly appreciated.

like

More Posts

The sleepiest little dog with stinky corn chip feet.

Post Photo
like

Engagement rings? Looking for cushion cut. Would be willing to just get the diamond and have the band made after.

Alvarez & Marsal How does Alvarez & Marsal compare with MBB, Kearney, Roland Berger, etc. in India?

This group needs more members !!!

like

I am too indecisive for streaming services like Netflix. I don't like picking what to watch, which is why I like having cable. I need the randomness of what's on the cable channels.

like

Hi Recruiters,
Let’s talk cover letters.
What do you think makes a good one? Length? Content? What should definitely be in there and definitely be left out?
What’s the biggest mistake you see people make?
Who is actually reading them? You? The department heads?
Bonus points if you can give insight into the way this works with the Creative Department. (I’m a Copywriter.)

Thanks in advance!

like

Let’s get a list together. What firms are mandating a vaccine?

like

I have a side gig consulting business specializing in data analytics, PowerBI, API integrations, data warehouses, and Amazon PPC. My team and I have worked with multiple top Amazon companies to do this. Anyone know someone who needs this ?! Let’s chat !

like

Any chill part time jobs?

likefunny

I was recently accepted to an Ivy League pre-med program, which has made me enormously excited. Despite this, I am now growing increasingly uncertain and afraid due to the weight of the decision. I would finish residency at 35 years of age, having passed on over $1m in earnings and in $300k of debt (although later earning $350-600k+). It scares me to think of having to provide for a family in such a situation.
Does anyone in their 30s wish they became a doctor? I need some elder advice please

like

Hello Folks,
I am working as a test lead at present. Need suggestions on what all certifications and courses should I do for Project management?

like

Any developer from the Paytm promotion team? Paytm

like

What are everyone's thoughts on executive MBA vs. traditional MBA? I'm currently pursuing a traditional MBA but sometimes I wonder what could've been 😅

like

I Have an upcoming second round interview for a major social tech company to be a talent sourcer. In this interview there will be more in-depth metrics questions as well as behavior questions. Any advice or insight . I really want to make this move from finance to tech. I will be meeting with team lead.

like

Hey folks! I am an intern at Cognizant it’s been a while I am just and intern! I have given my interview for a full time employment also! No response from there side! Can someone please refer me? (Location - Hyderabad) Thank you in Advance!! Have a great day!!!!

If my H1-B location amendment RFE gets rejected, can i still work from home or have they changed any rule that the whole H1-B would get cancelled?

Looking for a flat in wagholi area, any leads would help. Thank you.

Hi Guys,

Im a SAP BODS Technical Manager/Lead. 14 YoE. Looking for better opportunity. Can someone refer me for BODS Manager/Lead Role ?

like

Hello Everyone, I got an offer from Mindtree kolkata. Offer 24 lac fixed. YOE 10 years. Tech stack Azure Data Engineer. How is project availability and job security? Also, as LTI and Mindtree have been merged will I get an offer from LTIMindtree? Mindtree @LTIMindtree

like

Hi fishes. I have an offer from BofA for senior analyst (Data Science). The interviewer said I'll be working on marketing analytics. Can any existing data science fishes in BofA tell me what to expect in in terms of learning and working on ML? 3Yoe Data Scientist.

like

Additional Posts in Personal Investment Chatter

Where do you go for stock market news?

like

Best high interest online savings account ?

like

What is the best 401k strategy? I have both traditional and Roth, would you contribute to traditional only up to the employer match and the rest in Roth? Looking to max out my contributions but not certain the best way to allocate between the two...

Also - after maxing out your 401k, would you recommend to move to a Roth IRA and contribute the max prior to other investment accounts?

26, 90k base if that would impact your advice. Thank you!!

like

Thoughts on downside of index funds? Passive investing just created a forced index buying investing environment where stock price keeps going up despite no fundamental improvement in a company.

like

Advice needed! Investing gurus, I need some guidance on my current situation. Last Nov I pulled most of my non-retirement accounts out of the stock market. Since then I've mostly just been saving cash due to being conservative about the economy and wanting potential flexibility to buy property. At this point though I have a solid $90k liquid and it's making me nervous that it's just sitting there. What should I do??

like

Just maxed out the investment in 401K. I am getting an extra $700 on a biweekly basis. Any suggestions where I can invest the money outside of IRA?

like

What’s a good rule of thumb for backdoor Roth IRA conversions, when incomes are too high? Once a year, twice a year, anytime, etc.?

like

For those concerned about inflation, what are your thoughts on converting and storing USDs into CHF , Swiss francs? What possible issues would I deal with?

like

When you do your taxes, do you file with a CPA or do it yourself by using TurboTax, H&R block, or any other tax filing systems? I just know it’s cheaper to use a software, but can a CPA give you a better tax return?

like

Maxed out 401k and HSA. What are other tax deductible options (and how much) can i enroll into and do i need to find them on HQ? Salary of 100k in MA if that matters! TIA

like

A healthy pull back is actually better for long-run, liquidated some of my positions yesterday and wait. What do you think?

like

Moved from KPMG to EY. Had a Roth 401k with Merrill. I need to move my Roth to an IRA. What and where to? Need unbiased advise. Have roughly about 100k in roth 401k. Should I switch to F/V/S?

like

Thoughts on investing in oil?

like

Application for monitoring spending?

like

Anyone here do drop shipping as a side hustle? I used to do it in high school, but I had trouble funding my supplies due to the slow turnover of paypal proceeds as a small seller and not having a credit card. Well now I have a credit and I am thinking about getting back into it.

like

Received some cash ($10k) from family and trying to move it into the bank. I understand anything $10k and over is reported to IRS, but banks can also report suspicious deposits too. Should i just make a handful of smaller deposits over a month or two? Wondering if anyone has done something similar?

like

Need to sell some stock to buy an investment property. How should I think about which stocks to sell to minimize taxes?

Should I sell stocks that result in least amount of capital gains (short term)? Should I sell the first load that qualified for long term capital gains? Should I be selling my oldest shares that would have the most capital gains?

Thanks

likehelpful

Saw a post earlier on life insurance and am wondering what everyone’s thought on term vs whole vs blend. Just wanted to hear people’s thoughts and decision making

like

What is the easiest way to gift someone stock?? I don’t have their SSN or anything so I was thinking I would purchase it and then transfer to them after their birthday.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal