The Google guy should not have been fired. Yays? Nays?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Should not.

like

Just because you say the truth doesn't mean a company can't/shouldn't fire you over it.

like

If you sign a contract to work for them, it's probably explicitly stated that you represent them. So if you go against their values publicly as a google employee instead of as an individual, then you broke the contract no? Not sure of specifics of the situation though. Also if was at will employment then def fire

like

My "^" was @IBA1, not @BMO

like

@JPM1 agree 100%. But just because you wrote something that hurt someone's feelings, it doesn't make you wrong. I'm not saying I agree with 100% of what he wrote, but the cupcake society is in full effect at google (have friends who work there who said the stuff from the memo directed specifically to google is spot on).

like

IBA1 and Assoc1- did either of you read the full 10page memo and his corresponding footnotes? Did either of you try to read the document objectively and with a conscious effort to set aside your biases? His memo did not state that all women are neurotic, prone to anxiety, or cooperative. In fact among many qualifiers he used, he wrote "women on average". He also wrote that: he values diversity and inclusion ; he does not deny sexism exists; and that he may be biased and only sees evidence that supports his views but that he is "very happy " to discuss any points further. His tone throughout the memo was respectful. Furthermore, he has a PHD in system biology so naturally he is inclined to view this issue through a biological lens. He used a common psych survey model standard ( right or wrong) the Big Five personality traits, otherwise known as the MFF model. It is not a pseudoscience model. Whether his biology perspective and MMF lens are accurate tools to use in this issue or whether his points have merit are highly debatable and should be intellectually challenged. I'm not saying I agree or disagree with his points.

To answer OPs questions, the answer is undecided. This memo was intended for internal use. It was submitted (rightly or wrongly) on a open internal forum Google created to invite free exchange of ideas. Since Google created the forum, did leadership outline beforehand what constitutes acceptable and non acceptable discussion points? What role did Google play in fostering an environment where an employee felt safe to offer a perspective for discussion?

The better response by googles HR would have been to put the employee on a leave of absence until they can investigate the memo and its impact further. Now they have a PR, HR, and possible legal mess.

The CEOs statement and action also sends the wrong message to his employees and the public. Employee may grow hesitant to voice their opinions and their hidden biases will continue unchallenged. If employees are afraid to respectfully offer points for consideration or share a perspective that may challenge a norm, it may over the long term have negative effects on the co culture, talent management, organic innovation, and risk management.

like

It was correct to fire him. He's entitled to his opinion, but he's a moron if he thinks sending a companywide dossier full of opinions contrary to the company's official stance won't come with consequences.

like

No woman would want to work with him after that. Also not great reputation-wise for Google.

like

^ not an answer to his question, and thank you captain obvious on your second point. I know women, plural, who consider themselves progressives and do not disagree with what he wrote.

like

Freedom of speech is not the same as freedom from consequences

like

^thank you. Also, saying women are prone to being more "neurotic" is bordering on workplace harassment. He broke his employment contract, so they terminated him. It's not complicated. If I wrote an article about how black people are inferior and we shouldn't try to hire more of them, and poorly cited a bunch of pseudoscience about how they are all poorly educated and commit a disproportionate number of crimes, I would fully expect to get fired for that too.

like

@GS1 I guess it wasn't clear to you... I agree with Google's decision. Funny you mention "cupcake society" but the engineer talks about being scared to bring forth his conservative views. Why is it up to Google to coddle his political leanings but not maintain diversity programs to help the disadvantaged, which the engineer is against? His saying things like "women are more prone to anxiety" or are "more cooperative... " Is he saying out of the womb, females exhibit these traits more than males? These are not controllable characteristics?

like

Nay

like

From a business perspective, it makes sense what they did. From a personal perspective I bet there's many more people within Google who share his views, he just put it out there and that's not good for business.

like

Haven't read it and don't have an opinion. I just made a point that snowflaking isn't a one directional thing.

Also, if I state that I value diversity but only hire white male ivy league grads because no one else is biologically qualified to do the job (on average), am I cool with HR?

like

I may be crazy but I'm pretty sure he said women are more prone to anxiety and being cooperative. Using "on average" as a catch all qualifier to justify his assertions as objective and/or unbiased is, in my opinion, very lazy.

And who cares how respectful his tone was? Why are people using this as some counterpoint to criticism as if it's amazing that someone could write in a respectful matter?

Google might have had a PR, HR, and legal mess if they didn't fire him either, it goes both ways.

like

Free speech even if it doesn't agree with everyone's view

like

^ you mean Google's choice to fire him?

like

Related Posts

Constantly worried I’m going to get fired because I don’t know where I stand at my mid sized law firm (second year associate).

like

I was just laid off from a fintech startup after 4.5 months as their first ever IP attorney. Anyone have any leads on other IP roles. I’m soft IP/marketing focused but also have patent experience.

like

Hi! This is post is for a friend who was recently laid off due to budget constraints at their company. They’re actively looking for new roles in Business Analytics, Finance or a combination of both. Any referral would be extremely appreciated.

like

Most staff/sr assoc would make 80% of salary for the next 4 months if fired & yet firms are considering pay cuts.

Like at this point just fire me idk what kool aid some of you are drinking

like

How is Lowe's India in terms of Tech Stack, Job Security and WLB.
My joining is next month, should I consider joining it as an SE, considering the current scenario of layoffs and recession in IT market.

like

Horrible anxiety about considering a new job....
I was one of the big firm stealth layoffs in covid and joined a boutique firm in Sept. They came sort of close to matching my salary but I moved to SoCal and have an opportunity to jump back in to big law and get $100k raise. The people at the small firm are so nice, but hours are nuts and if I’m going to work this much, I might as well get paid more, right? Is it too soon? How do you tell them when the managing partner took you under his wing?

like

A friend of mine from a top tier consulting firm was counseled out. Do you consider it ethical that his career counselor is intentially spreading the information to his colleagues and to other consultants from other companies in the project? What can he do about it? Specially that he considers the potential layoff is purely based on the current situation (chargeability was low) and not on his performance (they said that his contribution to BD during his bench time was low)?

like

After 10 years of working as a FTE PM/producer I’ve now been laid off (thanks Covid) and am looking to start freelancing for the first time. What advice do you have for a new freelance PM/producer?
Also, what kind of insurance do you take out as a freelancer?

like

Hi Everyone

I see recently due to market demand there are raining jobs even for less than 10 yoe getting above 25 lpa is it safe for the job security in terms of long term serving the company ,am afraid of getting laid off in future whats your thought or advuce on this?

Anyone else using their layoff as an excuse to finally pursue a new career?

like

Anyone got or knows someone who got laid off during a leave of absence?

like

Anyone know any biotechs/Pharma (ideally oncology-focused) that are looking for a VP (or even SD for the right TC) of BD/CorpDev and allowing for remote/travel models (if not Boston-based) or at least a Boston-based hybrid model? I know someone with good biotech/Pharma BD&L experience that is looking for a new role given the current biotech layoff scene. Feel free to share any company names with open roles or DM, if preferred.

Hi Fishes!!!
How is Coforge(previously known as NIIT Technologies) is for the Scrum master role on the basis of :
1. Work life balance.
2. Work nature.
3. No. Of teams handled by one Scrum Master.
4. Being Agile forum.
5. No. of reports and meetings for the agile forums not just teams.
6. Layoffs.

Please help me by answering as many pointers as you can.

Location is Noida.

Thank you.

like

Anybody else also having the layoffs anxiety already ? Any update/rumours about GL ?

like

EY fish - when you are laid off, is it immediate the day you're told or do you get a little warning?

like

Should people be fired for lack of people skills?

like

The partner in charge of my office had a nearly hour long conversation Tuesday with our new hire, behind closed doors. I didn’t hear yelling, but the bits I heard weren’t good. Will he be fired?

like

Hi everyone, my sister was fired from her job because her exemption from the vaccine got rejected. She has Director of Nursing experience as well as experience with case management and utilization review. Anyone know of any startups or tech companies that are remote and wouldn’t require a vaccination that are hiring for experienced nurses? Really appreciate the help! Any leads are welcome!

like

There have been surprising news with layoffs lately. Has anyone here been affected by the layoffs at Twitter or META?

like

How much severance should you expect after getting booted after 1 year. I got 3 months salary

like

More Posts

Is it smart to get multiple credit cards as a traveling consultant?

like

Hey everyone. I found out we are expecting our first child and I’m really nervous. I got into consulting one year ago and I’m up for promotion this year. With timing of our performance conversations I would have to inform I’m pregnant before outcomes - then shortly after the promotion effective date I would go on a leave for due date. I’ve worked really hard and I’m worried our wonderful news will throw chances with this :(- also if I don’t get promoted pretty sure it’s up or out. Any advice?

like

Discussion post: I feel almost all consulting firms are the same. Mbb, big 4 etc. if you are paid enough there is probably less wlb. If there is good wlb there is not much money. Can you single out a company that you can confidently say pays very well and also has good wlb and also has good opportunities etc.?

like

Good morning, I’m looking for an Entry Level Scrum Master position. Please send referrals

like

Recommendations for best suits in Dubai? Good quality but not 10k either.

like

Any tips or advice for Google Strategy & Operations interviews? I have my role related knowledge interview next week. Thanks a lot!

like

Books to learn more about how to drive sales in consulting? Any recommendations?

likehelpful

How do you all role out your ERG

like

My manager got hired with 0 actual sales experience, comes from operations and marketing. It’s impossible to take any of his advice seriously, he ends team meetings and messages with “always be closing”. Like tf you know about closing, go back to making your PowerPoints.

likefunny

Anyone from LS hedge funds? What is work / life like? Pros and cons? Thinking of transitioning from Consulting

like

Some more jobs where I can refer

Post Photo
like

Anyone know any biotechs/Pharma (ideally oncology-focused) that are looking for a VP (or even SD for the right TC) of BD/CorpDev and allowing for remote/travel models (if not Boston-based) or at least a Boston-based hybrid model? I know someone with good biotech/Pharma BD&L experience that is looking for a new role given the current biotech layoff scene. Feel free to share any company names with open roles or DM, if preferred.

Welcome! Hopefully this is a good space for professionals working in the mental health sector to make connections and feel connected. This is a safe space, so feel free to talk about difficult situations and bounce ideas off others. Dude to the nature of this profession, there may be uncomfortable topics discussed in this forum.

like
like

Is anyone joining Deloitte India in October? Have you received any update regarding Background verification from Deloitte apart from submission of form?
Deloitte India Deloitte

like

What do you think is the best site to make your book on as a copywriter?

Is $22.10/hr for Technical Support Specialist decent? Been with the company going on two years and have supported that particular department quite a few times. Currently sitting as an IT Tech and support general help desk and between tier 1 and 2 tickets. This will also be my highest paying job yet lol. Thanks in advance for any guidance!

like

Any one knows which company ctc is this?

Post Photo
like

Which certifications are considered high value right now?

like

Additional Posts in Finance

What can I do during downtime throughout my day to prepare me for investment banking? I have a while until I am eligible to move internally but I want to be prepared when the time comes

like

Does anyone here work in residential mortgage trading capital markets desk at one of the big banks in Toronto and would be open to chatting?

like

Any insight on CAIA? Difficulty and whether it impacts salary?

like

What are the best ways to increase my assets and decrease my liabilities? Specifically for the age range: 21–30, paying down my student debt, need to pick my next investment targets

like

FRM is has narrow focus, demands depth, quick to complete

like

What's your morning schedule like? Mine 1) wake up 2) curse and cry looking at myself in the br mirror 3) dress nicely to make myself feel better and 4) coffee up and head to office.

likefunny

First time posting on here… what do you like best about this app/what’s the best way to use this app to get its benefits? 🤔

like

I got a new job a month ago in FP&A and my work ethic and motivation has drastically decreased. Has anyone experienced this? How do I go back to the same work ethic from back when I was in IB?

like

Best advice in 6 words or less:

like
like

Leaving this summer to PE, bonus pays in June. When should I give notice? Don’t want to burn bridges but don’t want to risk a slashed bonus (or none at all)

like

IB Analyst, want to move banks. Searching via my contacts but want to expand my network with cold outreach. Should I reach out to MD's or VP/Directors?

like

fellow monkeys - how do you stay up during shitty team meetings where all you can think about is GTFOing?

like

NYC bowl: Which bar/club do you go out on a Friday night?

like

What’s the cleanest way to show monthly, quarterly, and annual projections? Would you do it on one tab or 2/3?

like

Which firm hires the dumbest people?

like

Good day to be buying bonds... any of my fellow yield grubbers out in effect today?

like

At what age did you become 100% financially independent? I.e. not a single thing paid for by parents including things like staying under their insurance

Do you buy the fundamentals for a MBS sell-off?

like

Working at a private equity firm as an associate/analyst is similar to that of investment banking.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal