The question is, is graduation from law school, not minimum competency? With this line of reasoning we are saying that law schools do not produce competent future lawyers, so should we instead switch to a system of taking the bar without the three years of a measure that frankly bar associations have deemed not an adequate measure? Dash this comment aside if it is fallible, but there is something here that has been overlooked. Competence is not regurgitation and memorization.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Doctors, nurses, teachers, CPAs, CFA, social workers all have to take exams after years of school, training, studying, etc to obtain their designations and/or licenses. No test or specific education curriculum is perfect, but awyers need to be tested and licensed and regulated just like any other profession.

The State, through passing the bar exam, grants lawyers the responsibility and ability of interpreting, determining, advising, and enforcing the law. That is not an insignificant responsibility. It's actually pretty big. The bar exam is the STATE'S way of having one standard for all lawyers in its state, regardless of where one was educated and measuring what the State considers minimum competence and training. Lawyers don't need to have any practical training as part of their requirements to graduate or sit for the bar. One could literally have never worked a day in their life, graduate, pass the bar and take on a criminal case and have someone's FREEDOM in their hands. Even MBA programs want to see at least two years of work experience.

Do I think law schools and the legal industry need to shift their priorities in terms of training and hiring? Yes. Do I think that we should require a least 2 years of work experience before law school in addition to required apprenticeship during law school? Yes. I think that would reduce a lot of the buyer's remorse and complaints from students and lawyers and increase the more practical thinking that comes with having work and life experience.

like

I don’t think other professions are necessarily great comparisons. The passage rate for med boards among the top 110 law schools is 96%. That’s a lot higher than the bar exam and more comparable to like, the MPRE.

like

I never thought I’d defend the bar exam, but I had to learn a lot of subjects that I didn’t take in law school like criminal procedure, family law, secured transactions (and however many odd NY specific subjects Barbri included). I never had to take them and would never have any knowledge of them without the bar requirement.

That said... 4 years later and I couldn’t tell you a thing I learned on those subjects just for the bar exam, so maybe it’s just a test to prove you can learn things efficiently?

like

It’s a money grab

like

Revisionist History podcast. Season 4, Eps. 1 and 2.

like

cruel? or a corrective to a testing methodology that foolishly screens for one type of talent of limited relevance at the expense of others?

we have a winner. it's a self perpetuating industry where all participants are committed to keeping things the way they are and won't face much resistance in normal times because people now take for granted that a) professional licensing b) standardized, time pressured testing c) professional degrees d) massive student debt are simply how things are supposed to be.

the people interested in maintaining the status quo have the most influence thereon. they may be outnumbered by people with an interest jn changing it - every consumer who may require legal services, every aspiring lawyer not yet in the system - but there's no American Not Yet Admitted To Bar Association, and few people advocating for clients' affordable access to legal services are willing to do so by introducing fair competition from non attorneys, people with less training (for tasks that don't at all benefit from having it), and other nonincumbents who would threaten their (our) legally-enshrined advantages.

Related Posts

What is MSI hike % range rolled out today for Wipro employees

like

Hanging v. not hanging diplomas in office?

like

A funny story to help get you through the holidays.

(See comments)

like

Im getting ready to set up my WFH area and need ideas! Let me see pictures of your WFH space!

Post Photo
like
like

Client sends an urgent request for 5 social ads, including imagery and copy, to be completed today. Creative team is busy. The request is out of scope. What are appropriate next steps?

like

Any jean recommendations for tall women? Looking for something super stretchy since I basically live in leggings.

like

If you had to choose only 3 TV shows to watch from now on, on a loop, which ones would you choose?

like

I can't believe I only just found out about this bowl👀

Post Photo
likeuplifting

What can you say about Armstrong’s New Zealand. Particularly Peugeot dealership?
Has anyone worked there?

like

What's the typical raise from A2 tax to S1?

like

Has anyone done a rope course in the area or Virginia? Recs?

like

Is there an agency softball league in Chicago that my company can get in?

like

How do you describe GSAP sponsorship in grad apps? They ask if your education is being funded by a company but I’m unsure how to describe that the Deloitte pays AFTER grad

like

Hello All,


Looking for a referral for SQL DBA position in Barclays Pune, Please do let me know if you can refer me

Anyone Available from any SQL DBA team

Thanks

Post Photo

Is it just me or does anyone else know or have an inclination that their employer committed fraud after receiving PPP loans during COVID pandemic?

like

Anyone successfully pivoted from audit to project management? Help pls

like

Going to Australia at the end of the year. Any tips, tricks or suggestions?

like

So we will be shut down for a while. What are some things you will send home or do for Preschoolers during the sit down?

like

Additional Posts in New York Big Law

What’s the NYC lit lateral market like right now? First year looking to move and not sure if I want to transfer thru my firm or switch.

like

5th year big law associate and have been at my firm for about 2 years after a district court clerkship. Trying to break into a white collar boutique that has ties to USAO. Any tips?

like

Already posted this in big law but anyone here work at DLA, Kirkland or Jones Day in NY corporate? Kirkland seems best on paper but I don’t want to work there lol

like

Giving notice next week to someone who went out of her way to recruit and hire me away from my old firm and has been really good to me. She worked for over a year to get me to come over. Now after only 6 months I’m going back to my old firm but in a different (better) group than I was in before. I am dreading the convo and feeling guilty but need to get over it. FWIW I’m 2012 and we are getting crushed with lack of senior people hence more guilt…. Just looking for a little encouragement :)

like

Considering a 2 year move from Sydney to New York - I’m a female lawyer working in banking & finance, just recently made a senior associate. Any advice on living conditions in NY and general work lifestyle? Thanks!!

likefunny

New York’s court system is postponing all “non-essential” services starting Monday.

like

Random question but recommendations for nice kosher restaurants or bars around midtown west? My new associate mentee eats kosher and I have no idea where to take him!

like

Book recommendations? Preferably fiction or otherwise non-law related.

like

Any insights on the bio patent prosecution group at WilmerHale NY office?

like

Top “lifestyle” litigation firms - what are they and what are the best ones in the nyc market?

like

Best tips for negotiating end of year bonus and/or raise?

like

For IP Litigation folks in life sciences/pharma - what are the likely exit options? The boutique patent lit firms don’t seem to have a lighter workload and it seems like most in house positions require tech transaction and patent persecution experience, which is not easy to get while in big law (since different groups). I am a junior associate and any advice is appreciated.

like

A recruiter emails your work email. You are not interested. Do you reply? Ignore? Reach out privately?

like

Any thoughts on the BOLE decision to limit the NY bar exam to in-state law school spring grads only? What % of the fakers are in state? And then spring grads? Seems like a lot of out of state, or second time around, or foreign, or other categories.

like

Is it hard for someone out of state to lateral into NYC? I saw that some firms require New York State bar, which I don’t have. I am wondering how serious they are about that requirement. I could waive in without taking the bar, but I am still not barred in NY. I am in litigation.

like

How is Milbank’s project finance team? Work / life balance? Hours? People you work with?

like

Mid-level M&A associate over here. Thinking I’d like to make the move out of big law but struggling with what my options are. Have no interest in going in-house and staying in a legal capacity - would want to transition into more of a business role. Wondering if anyone can share their experience making that kind of move.

like

What’s the magic number to retire in style in NYC?

like

Hope to learn more if you bought an apt in Manhattan, or if you decided against it (renting/moving to upstate/Long Island/Jersey). My husband and I are considering to have a baby soon and are thinking of buying and living in Manhattan for the next 10 years or so (looking at property under $2M). Please share what you considered as you were making the decision - I hate throwing away rent but also don’t want to trap ourselves in significant financial obligations. Thanks!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal