The training company I’m working with, suggests the usage of an e collar to correct (not hurt or harm) my pup. Anyone use one before? Have heard of dogs being scared of being wrong so they’re little anxious with them

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

My former trainer occasionally uses one as well. We never did- wasn’t necessary for our pup. Agree with VP1s post.

like

If you'd like a positive reinforcement trainer, mine is wonderful and she's currently only doing virtual sessions.

All of my dog's bad behavior is fear based, so an e collar would absolutely not work for her

like

I do not use one.

The trainer I work with does recommend them for some of her larger and more unwieldy dogs [she was working with a friend and her pit puppy and used one]. Not for every dog and should be used situationally.

Our guy listens when we click it at a 5 out of 100. Today we only clicked it maybe 5 times (when he grabbed shoes, wasnt listening to go to his place, jumping on a neighbor). He seems just scared of it which obviously isn’t good!

like

We used one with a trainer on our dog. We used it on ourself first at the level he suggested to get comfortable that it wouldn’t hurt.

Our trainer associated the buzzing of the collar with our dogs name. He explained it to us it’s like someone calling your name and tapping you on the shoulder at the same time to get your attention. We didn’t use it as negative reinforcement only as name calling/attention getting.

like

It’s fine as long as you put the collar on correctly (the prongs need to go under his or her ear, not middle of the neck). Also; use the correct setting. Each e collar is a little different (so 35/100 might be equivalent to a 5 on another). I tested it on myself to make sure it was ok - should just feel like a little static shock, nothing crazy. Remember to say “no” simultaneously when you use it so the dog associates the corrective behavior. Now I can say “no” without using the collar.

Have one for our German Shepherd. It was life changing. Our puppy is stubborn - knew the commands but would not listen. Very early so he shock him. Usually enough to send the beep and he knows we mean business.

Yes, I use a Mini Educator and it's awesome. It has 100 settings and it gives more of an uncomfortable buzz than a painful shock. It's not cruel at all. It's really good because it allows you to give your dog more freedom.

Something to think about that our trainer shared with us is when you use any aversive training - e-collar, shock collar, physical reprimand - is that you’re telling your dog to not do something but you aren’t giving them any information about what they SHOULD be doing - so, our dog reacts when people come in the door, rather than just try to get her to stop barking / jumping, we’ve trained her to go to her crate - so now, she doesn’t bark / jump because she knows that when someone comes to the door, the thing she is supposed to do is go to her crate. All that to say, regardless of what you do, make sure that your dog knows what they should be doing in situations where they aren’t doing what you think they should be.

And if your dog isn’t “listening” probably the treats you’re using aren’t high enough value

Related Posts

likeuplifting

Hi there,
Anyone here into technical Consultancy. I am looking for a suggestion/advise as where does this leads to after years (5-7) of experience. What’s the career ladder onwards?

like

Looking from a transition from B2B to B2C in Product management. Total tech experience : 11 years, Total PM experience : 5+ years

like

Hi, I’m about to graduate from my MBA and want to move back to India. Looking for possible openings at MBB/Kearney. Anyone willing to share or recommend?

like

Anyone working at CIBC that would be able to provide me with a referral?
I appreciate it in advance!

like

It’s looking like my job is gonna start asking us to return to the office. We have an open office plan and before we wfh FT I would save all my work for my telework days bc I can’t get shit done in the office. I’m having major anxiety about them making this decision. I know I’m not alone that people don’t want to return to the office. My ADHD and the open office just makes working from the office a nightmare and I’m feeling really nervous and kind of resentful.

like

I am a match maker on the side. How many people would sign up to get this service ? It will be free for the first 50 people I officially get matched. I have been doing it for free for years now.

like

Got a speeding ticket in Minnesota, should I argue? Is traffic school an option here? I have a clean record. TIA

funny

I am so sick and fed up with some of the older clients at my job. I know it's my responsibility to take care of them, but they're just so sexist sometimes.

like

Week 3 and Cinderella still doesn’t trust grownups but she’s on good terms with Ollie and the kids. I’m finding out quickly there’s no way of bribing animals into liking you, at least not cats.

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Do you know what today is, today is the day I am now allowed back to office as our vaccination requirement was dropped? I still can’t go to our office in NYC and possibly some other jurisdictions and we do need to follow client rules to visit them.
Have any of other Big 4 made changes?

like

What are your tips on convincing a fellow employee not to switch agencies? I really don't want to compete with them

like

What is the secret to creating good slides...?

like

Fishes.
Can you please mention all points to take care in HR discussion?
I am a .Net Developer with 8.5 YOE. I have observed that clearing two technical rounds is still half the battle fought.
Scenario: If the company budget is 20lpa and I am asking 20LPA.
I would love to have points to take care while in an HR round.

How are firms treating their employees during this time? Do you feel as if morale is low (excluding the fact we aren’t face to face with people daily)

like

If you refer to financial statement numbers in a possessive tone such as “my numbers” - you need to be fitted for a straight jacket.

likefunny

Joining McKinsey soon and got the email about social media checks. Do I need to give them my account links or can I just pretend I don't have it?

I keep FB on private anyway so my accounts can't be found unless you're a friend of a friend, and my IG is private too

likefunny

Who here can’t sleep even on the off chances they can sleep?

like

Quick question on Personal Capital — I just downloaded and set up the app. It looks like only 3 months of my Chase credit card transaction history will import to the expenses. Is this right? I can’t see a way to get any more data than that, which is fine, but just wanted to make sure this is normal. Thanks!

like

Additional Posts in Who loves dogs?

You guys know what her breed is ??..we got her from a shelter and we know she is some kind of Shepard (60 LBS)

Post Photo
like

Single people in consulting (travel-involved), do you have a dog? How do you manage?

like

Generally he knows he's not allowed on furniture. With this new couch, he's apparently decided the rules don't apply. Every day when I realize I haven't seen him for a while, I go in to the living room and find him like this.

Post Photo
likefunny

After work vibes brought to you by Piper

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunny

Handsome or handsome? ❤️😇❤️

Post Photo
like

Does anyone have a frenchie?! 😍🥺

like

Has anyone ever requested to stay local because they have a dog? Ex. if you live by yourself otherwise

like

This boy is one today!!!!

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunny

I heard there’s a dog at the daycare named FIFO instead of Fido. Can’t wait to meet him. Whose CPA mens did this?? 🤣

funnylike

Our Chief Morale Pawficer

Post Photo
like

Hahahah I laughed too hard at this

Post Photo
likefunnyhelpful

Hanging out on a great spring day

Post Photo
like
like

Sometimes I sleep wif my tongue out

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunny

Did you know that there’s an adapted hierarchy of needs for your furbaby?

Post Photo
like

Walked the dog today in an intersection with heavy traffic and she decided to have (excitement poop) diarrhea in front of ~20 strangers. I couldnt clean up everything and left a smear. The embarassment is still fresh in my head. 😂🤦‍♂️. Thank god we are will wearing masks.

likefunny

Is there a difference between these two harnesses? Someone at the park said the one on the bigger golden was harmful.

Post Photo
like

He was very ready to go home today ♥️

Post Photo
like

Fave group - over and out...

like

My silly girl...in front of a pillow that says it all...

Post Photo
likeuplifting

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal