Thoughs on private vs public high schools in America? If you have the means, is it stupid to send your kids to a public high school? (Asked by a non-American)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Depends a bit on the district, but I’ll never send my kids to private school. Growing up in a protected bubble creates more harm than good imo. Want my kids to have exposure to a diverse student body.

likehelpfulfunny

If you mean that I want them to grow up to think like me in terms of valuing a diversity of opinion and spending time with others who aren’t exactly like them, yep. You’re right. I don’t in any way think that white people are bad, but I also know that hearing about the Greensboro sit-in from someone who was there is an entirely different experience than reading a textbook written by a white person and sanitized through the textbook approval process. I don’t think that is exactly shocking.

I went to both private and public school. Public schools tend to have more diversity in thought and background. If you want to prepare your kid for the real world, don’t put them in a hyper homogenized bubble.

Oh and K1 is right about the drugs. My private school had a massive black market in pharmaceuticals for the “smart” kids, and cocaine/party drugs for the wealthy “cool” kids. Most came to school medicated on something.

When I went to public school, the most kids were doing was weed and beers on the weekends.

like
Recent IconRecent

It’s varies a LOT by geography. In some places, public schools might actually be better than private schools.

like

The Raleigh area here in NC has a very complicated public school structure - lots of charter schools (which are public), magnet schools, and “normal” public schools. The “best” school in the area is a charter school, followed by two “normal” public schools, then a magnet school. All public but very different.

ALL of those and many ranked lower than them are better than any of the private schools here. Several very expensive private schools and the big Catholic high school do not offer half the quality of the education of the magnet school my kids go to. They don’t offer the breadth of AP classes (if any), options like an IB program, the number of language class choices (or the ability to get to very advanced levels in those classes), any types of academies (my son is part of the Medical Bioscience Academy within his larger high school, for example), the sports, the choices of extracurriculars, etc. They also have a pay-for-grades structure that isn’t ultimately doing the kids any favors and doesn’t prepare them for the real world.

Another factor is that we believe strongly in ensuring our kids don’t live in a bubble. They go to a school that is ~25% Black, 30% Asian, 35% Caucasian and 10% Hispanic, and that has added real value to their lives. Our private schools are shocking if they have more than 3% students who are Black or Hispanic.

We can afford to send our kids to private school but have zero regrets about sending them to the public magnet school they attend - it is an outstanding school.

like

Depends entirely on the school district.

like

My public high school sent at least 10 kids to ivies from my graduating class and all the local private school kids were addicted to drugs

likefunny

Well this is flawed..

funny

In the US public schools are generally funded by hyper-local property taxes. Therefore, very wealthy towns have a TON of money for education and very poor town have underfunded systems. The quality of top public schools can rival and surpass private schools. This is why people move to very expensive suburbs, if they can. What I never understood is why folks that live in districts with amazing schools shell out 50k a year for private school.

likehelpful

Agreed. The best public schools are WAY better than ANY private school.

like

Top public schools are the best K-12 educational institutions one can get in the country, but the worst ones are warzones

Highly, highly geography dependent

like

Depends on location. Where I live public schools are appalling. Our neighbors complain about the number of times the police gets called to intervene, have SCARY stories of fights inside the school, and have a lot of racial tension. There are so many issues that academics doesn't even make it to the list (and btw, I really like my street and neighbors, it's just a terrible school district). So private school it is.

like

Agree with others live in the right place and public all the way. I won’t send my kids to private because the cost is too steep and agree with D1 I want my kids to grow up in a diverse reality not a bubble of rich kids. Also a big believer that your upbringing and the level of engagement by the parents plays a bigger role by setting standards / expectations, enforcing those standards and investing the time so support their growth (e.g. homework, projects, going to meet the teacher).

Depends on regions. I grew up in NY and had a great public school

The best public schools are better than ANY private school ever could be, but they’re aren’t that many good schools in the US.

My public schools class sent 6 people to Harvard. I was not one of them

I am a POC and live in an area that is about 95 percent POC. I send my kids to private school for diversity, and that they can see how kids that are in different SES live. I like the community that my private school has. Most of the parents know each other and we do a lot of activities together.

Depends where. I went to public school in NYC and had a good experience. There was def some crime and shady shit but plenty of hardworking students and good extracurriculars

I am pro public schools, however I think those preaching diversity of public schools while saying you need to live near the right one are talking out of both sides of their mouth. You are paying for the good public school in property value and few of the great public school districts have truly diverse student bodies - particularly in the younger grades. Large high schools are sometimes a bit different given that they more often draw from both rich and poor neighborhoods.

I went to fantastic public schools - even through college. But my elementary school was certainly not diverse or representative of my town on any dimension. It had less than 1% of students qualifying for free or reduced lunch and was probably 90% white. It became more diverse with middle and highschool, but it was still segregated with most of the rich neighborhoods in one of three middle schools, and one of two high schools. I grew up in a smaller town.

Anyways. It’s a tough decision in a lot of metro areas these days. I don’t have kids yet but know it will be hard to decide what to do if we still live in the city.

Many send their kids to private schools to meet their community-religious needs (catholic, Jewish, etc)… Others do it for status, others because that’s where “their people are”.

If I had the means I would def send my kid to private school. For education, safety, etc.

If you’re kid is smart then there’s a nice selection of public schools they can apply to in Chicago. Can’t speak for other schools, but I’m sure there’s options in many places

Related Posts

Anyone struggling in their new “long distance” relationship? I go back and forth between missing my bf so much it hurts and being ambivalent/questioning his maturity and why the hell im 4.5 years

like

Hello burnout, my old friend. I’ve come to drink with you again...

likefunny

Perhaps not directly relevant, but I have a difficult family background. Never known my dad, my mom had serious drug/mental health issues. Grew up with grandparents and aunt & uncle. Somehow I miraculously did well in school and ended up in big law. For Christmas I plan on faking quarantine to explain why I’ll be alone, though I want to be more upfront with colleagues, friends and potential partners, but I’m afraid my story will appear off-putting to them. Or will it reflect positively on me?

likehelpful

I'm going from working at a non IT industry to an IT firm. As an introvert I've faced a lot of difficulty in my career... Now since I'm also shifting to another industry completely, I'm feeling very insecure about my life at work. Please give me tips on how to make friends and be in the good books of the managers.

like

Have you ever thought what your past self would think of your current self? Reason I am asking is I am almost 40 and kinda stoked about buying my wife a new minivan. I don’t think 22yr old me ever would have seen that coming.

likefunny

I'm a product engineer and it's hard to turn off work mode at the end of the day, I think of how products *should* be packaged when I'm shopping and can't understand why my wife doesn't care 🤷

likefunny

Trying to get a 45 y/o sibling in to consulting (was an entrepreneur prior in the restaurant industry). No college degree but willing to bust his but to learn. Books/online courses recommended pls

funny

How are your ELs and their parents handling this crisis? I wish I could give them more support.

like

Any other lonely social workers in here? I mean a lot to some of the people on my caseload but that's about it. Don't have any family near me and it's hard to make friends with non-SW's mostly just because I'm too tired after work to want to do much. Do you spend most of your time alone or is your social time self care for you? Just feel like I don't have a support system!

like

Any Dallas/DFW area new moms or locals support groups? New to the area but with covid hard to get out, want to get to know other new moms who are also in the accounting field.

like

Ghosted once more after what I thought was a great first date. Guess I’ll give up on love forever.

likefunny

How do you nicely tell your boyfriend you are not happy in your relationship? Please advise.

like

Any book suggestions for married couples ?

like

Teaching has taken over so much. I’m a wife and mother and still have a home life, but there is nothing outside of work and home. I have no friends, no other activities, no escape. Covid restrictions do not help. I know it’s not healthy to only focus on everyone else, but I’m not sure what to do about it. I have only sporadic time opportunities and I don’t even know what I enjoy doing anymore. When trying to do other stuff I can’t turn off mom or teacher brain.

like

Ok folks...I’m supposed to be working, but instead I’m getting beat up and chased down by my daughter as I prepare to dig into some of these questions you all have. So... you ask...I’ll answer!

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Reached out to an ex after not being in contact for 4 years. Said “Hi, I hope all is well.” No response. Intention was not to get back together (we’re both married now), more to mend fences since we were good friends once upon a time. Was reaching out a mistake?

like

My bf took a guys trip to Caribbean to celebrate a good friend of 20+ year’s milestone bday. The friend’s bday is the day before mine. Normally bf and I trip for my bday over the holiday weekend. Bf will be back for my actual bday, and we’re taking a domestic trip next weekend. That said, I still feel a little miffed that we’re not spending this weekend together like normal. Are my feelings unreasonable?

like

Boyfriend has seemed to be dropping a ton on me lately, even after I got bad news that my company is t doing so hot this week and layoffs are approaching. First it was that we may be moving to another state for his job, then it was that his brother may need to move in with us for a few months after he graduates

It’s just a bit overwhelming at this time and I’m not sure how to communicate through all of this being thrown at me. 3 yrs together and we were friends for many years before that.

like

Sometimes I wish when you were with a partner, there was a very clear sign that the person doesn’t love you so that you know it’s time to walk away. My partner and I keep having the same problems, and when I express he’s making me feel a certain way he says he didn’t mean it like that obviously. But when i say something and explain that it’s not how I meant it he doesn’t care and proceeds to label me as an unkind person who doesn’t support/love him unconditionally. *continued in comments*

like

More Posts

I have a Soc analyst 3rd stage interview with the Head of Information & Cyber Security of a company , Has anyone been on either side of the table? I like to know what to except in such interview to sell myself as the best candidate for the job . Thanks

like
like

Been on a project for 2 weeks and thinking it’s not for me. The manager is kind of rude when I ask for help/direction, but he always says to ask if things are uncertain. He always has this condescending attitude and just keeps telling me that he expects more of someone at my level, C. I just keep feeling anxious that I’m not meeting expectations and feel reluctant to ask for help. Anyone in the same boat?

like

11 like pls

like

Which Big 4 is best by work wise.

like

Can anyone refer me as a PMO specialist or Scrum Master at Citi?

like

I am a Finance Professional having 8+ years of Corporate Experience. I am working in an IT Mid. Size MNC and looking for a change because of no increment. Can anyone please help me with some leads.

like

Hi I am holding an offer from both Bdo rise and wellsfargo and the package is same 14 LPA. I am bit confused as the role eat bdo rise offering is quite good but not sure about the culture and other wlb in bdo rise Can anyone suggest which one will be good wellsfargo or bdo rise..

like

Second round lottery emails coming through from Seyfarth. Did anyone get picked?

like

Has anyone returned to the US using Advance Parole card? I’m traveling outside the country for the first time after getting AP and keen on hearing folks’s experiences, what documents were asked at the POE and anything to be wary of.

like

Looking for input on changing positions from a Buyer to an International Logistics Coordinator. I have international freight experience and have a potential opportunity. Financially, the move makes a lot of sense. Would this be good for career trajectory? For context, I have been a buyer for several years and this is my first 'real' job, so pretty early in my career.

Typically when someone brings a unique experience or skill to the table they’re compensated for it. surgeons/technicians.
Can we bring this structure to the industry in regard to ethnicity/experience

like

Curious as to what other Associate hours are for the folks in the bowl?

like

Hey Fishes,

My variable pay is 1.42 lakhs (21% of fixed) , it is mentioned that I can get anywhere in between 0 to 21% . What is the average that I can expect??

Please reply if you have any relevant information.

Thanks

like

Has anyone here joined SLG recently? How long did it take you to get staffed?

like

Relocating to NYC in a month and just started looking into apartment hunting. Would love some tips and advice from you guys. Primarily looking in midtown area if that makes a difference

like
like

Why are my badges not working? Is it because I'm a lazy bastard and need to put in more effort here? Why am I not enough?!?!?!😂✌🏼/rant

likefunny

Additional Posts in Confession

I just got the contract for a new job in another European country and feel stupid for not being able to fill out the “BLANK(S)”.

“NAME X, born on (BLANK 1) at (BLANK 2), residing in (BLANK 3), at the (BANK 4), hereafter ‘employee’.”

BLANK 1 - date of birth
BLANK 2 - where I was born? City or Country?
BLANK 3 - currently living in
BLABK 4 - ???

Help…..

like

Can we have all the chiefs comment on this or like this. I wanna see how much of you are out there.

like

Gf said Nick Fury from Avengers series is Samuel L Jackson’s most iconic role and I whole heartedly disagreed and said Jules from Pulp Fiction is his most iconic role. Are there others that think this too?

likefunny

My in laws keep saying to stop teaching my 9 month old baby or she’ll learn too fast. Um what?

likefunny

What is a great white elephant gift? My in laws only played once. My brother in law presented Mein Kampf and it was game over..

like

Hate being on my period. Sitting here crying for no damn reason.

likefunny

When people ask me how are you or how was your week, my mind goes blank. All I can say is “good, and you?”

like