{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Thoughts on the new Gillette campaign?\n\nhttps://youtu.be/UYaY2Kb_PKI", "post_id": "5c3e15a681af5500130b68be", "reply_count": 305, "vote_count": 28, "bowl_id": "5565cfca8b2b9a03009acf57", "bowl_name": "Advertising" }
likeupliftingfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I hate it for the same reason I hate the Pizza Hut “lines” ad and the Kendall Jenner Pepsi ad: i think it’s pandering, manipulative, gross and deeply cynical to hitch your brand to an unrelated social cause just to sell stuff, especially a cause your product doesn’t help solve. When Nike did it, the cause directly related to their athletes, exemplified their “just do it” brand spirit and they supported Kap for two years before publicizing it. It was sincere and earned, not an empty gesture. This just says “toxic masculinity is bad”, which is the ad equivalent of a dude telling you he’s a feminist too to sleep with you, which is toxic. Nakedly using a social cause to sell stuff is as gross and manipulative as the incel edgelords this ad pissed off. People are calling it “brave” because it backfired so wildly, but I guarantee Gillette wouldn’t have touched it if they knew this was possible. Nike knew Kap would be radioactive and still did it. There’s a difference.

likesmart

Help me understand what movement Gillette supported that is equivalent to Dove supporting a "fat acceptance movement"

J U S T A N O T H E R A D . Not even a good one. So, please stop hyping it like it is THE ad. Completely agree that they are obviously trying too hard. I can imagine that strategist out there jerking of on his “masterpiece”. Yes strategist. Coz i don’t see any creative part in it. Do you? For those who have “haters gonna hate” attitude. I‘ve only one thing to say. Either you start using your brain and have an opinion or you can keep liking every piece of **** out there that says “Be like this and don’t be like that”.

like

Thanks for sharing this—can’t believe I missed it when it came out. To the critics’ point, this is a better ad. It feels less rushed and its execution is pretty darn perfect. But it’s also amazing at simply and humanely taking on a zeitgeist topic that is nuanced and difficult. It’s hard enough to talk about Me Too and toxic masculinity. They resist shmaltzy, easy statements. And unfortunately for us, easy statements like “men can be better” are too easy for people to willfully misinterpret or get offended at. I love the reflective position this spot takes. Being a man is hard. Being a woman is hard. Try to be the best you can, though.

like
Recent IconRecent

Good concept, weird execution. A little award-baity for me

likesmarthelpful

Agree.

like

New take: Now that I’ve observed how much this ad is pissing off conservative vipers that I loathe, I have decided I love it. May not sell a lot of razors, but it’s fun to watch these guys lose their shit.

likefunnyuplifting

“Toxic masculinity makes men keep quiet about their emotions. Oh, and men, keep quiet about your emotions right now - we don’t care” 😂

like

Current wondering: how many of the above respondents are men, and if anyone has considered that women make most purchasing decisions for the household, and perhaps maybe women love the approach and spot?

likesmartfunny

I am a man. I buy my own razors, despite being married. And I will continue to use my Gillette

like

Seeing a similar arc to Nike. Huge backlash at first now transitioning to positive coverage. It’s getting millions of people talking globally, for a fucking razor ad that’s a win. The most impactful work Gillette has ever done, regardless of how well / not well we feel it was executed

likeuplifting

Love it. It's honestly the only way the brand could go if they want to stay relevant with the cultural shift happening right now.

likefunny

OLD MAN YELLS AT CLOUD

likefunny

Love this message and campaign but they still take part in the Pink Tax..... So it's hard for me to take this as a serious internal movement and actual revolution and more just a flashy topical ad built to drum up good feelings and social conversation.

likesmart

It’s a good point to raise, but it’s not “paying more for perceived value” if the primary difference is gender as expressed through color and packaging; the marketing psychology/angle is then gender norms, not added perceived value. Totally agree with your recommendation to just buy men’s razors (which I personally do). But the fact that the company takes that approach to begin with (and upcharges the historically oppressed sex) is what bothers. And thanks to those of you in this thread who are arguing good points and making me think.

like

A little over produced and felt like they’re trying too hard to be relevant. But good on them for trying, nice twist on their own line too.

like

Yes this

The problem with this ad is that the vast majority of men are decent people and treat women with respect. There are a few bad apples, who I’m happy are finally being dealt with. But to finger wag at an entire sex? It all comes off as fake woke BS. Tell my why your razor is better than Dollar Shave Club, don’t lecture me.

likefunnysmart

‘Vast majority of men are decent people and treat women with respect’ ... are you sure about that?

like

It doesn’t matter if we like or not, the free pr/impressions/awareness is what matters and in that respect they did a good job

like

Gillette have an awareness issue from younger buyers who consider subscription products like Harry’s or Dollar Shave over their Dad’s brand, but I’m not sure going full Pepsi Ad is going to help matters

like

There was a good strategy in here somewhere, but they fumbled the execution and totally blew it with the intended audience. Guessing it’s not gonna sell a lot of razors. Be careful with that brand purpose stuff, guys!

like

@FCB1 @SD1 Only thing as a woman is that Gillette charges more for “women’s” Razors than men’s (it’s literally the same thing), otherwise known as the pink tax and it’s sexist as hell. Dig the new ad but their practices aren’t 100% there yet.

like

Its good

likefunnyhelpful

Awful. I worked on it early. Social justice nonsense written by beta males and dog moms. Boys will be boys. Long live patriarchy. ¡Adios gringos!

likefunnyuplifting

FWIW “dog moms” made me lol

like

@Copywriter 2, I don’t think it’s about which men are “decent” and which men aren’t. It’s about systemic, ingrained notions of masculinity that exist everywhere in our society. Stuff like interrupting women (especially WOCs), expecting women to do most of the housework and not holding men accountable are something even the ‘decent’ men do. I actually liked the ad because it sparks worthwhile conversation, which I think ads are supposed to do.

like

Their biggest challenge in years is direct brands based on price and value. It’s a good strategy to use the muscle they’ve earned for years and in a relevant way

like

Awful. A smarmy lecture with bad casting and terrible performances. The script sucks and the filmmaking looks like stock. You can certainly do something cool with that brief but they whiffed at every turn.

like

💁‍♀️

Post Photo
funnylike

Meh...good concept executed like a pitch video. Too preachy. But good effort.

like

Put this back in the jar please. We don’t need another one.

likefunny

Go outside the comfortable advertising bubble and this doesn’t work. We can’t keep making advertising that works for us and our clients. Maybe try understanding the mood of real people?

like

Maybe the 90% disapproval rating on YouTube?

likefunnysmart

Jeez. What a bunch of negative assholes. Post your latest if it made a statement as this intends to do. I say we congratulate a brand willing to say something beyond “new this or introducing that” because that’s the type of work we all say we strive for but then here we are shutting it down when it’s not perfect in our eyes

like

Simon Cowell isn't allowed to judge singers because he doesn't have a 7 octave range.

like

Additional Posts

Anyone ever used a ride share app that employs women only? Really wish it was an option to choose gender on Uber... especially for late night rides

like

I have a client looking for a lot in Lemont or Downers Grove. Any sellers out there?

Started a new job and these are the investment options available on 401k. I’m 30. Suggestions on how to spread it out?

Post Photo
like

Any details on PWC director salary range, bonus range, signon/ relocation bonus and benefit details? Appreciate it!

like

Anyone work for AppDynamics or have insights into the culture, pros and cons?

like

Currently living in San Diego, but thinking about moving to Dallas so I can buy a house hack, explore somewhere else and try something different. Anyone lived in both places and can share any insight?

like
like

Has anyone tried the Marriott/SPG tribute homes.in London? Looks like Air bnb style, cheaper than rooms and you can earn some points.

like

Which role will be better from career progression perspective (keeping everything else constant)? 1. Marketing science lead (with a couple of direct reports) 2. Sr. Applied Data Scientist ( IC) and why?

like

How typical is it to exit to a software development job? I handed in my notice and I’m doing that.

like

PwC has wonderful benefits for nursing moms but some clients have terrible mother’s rooms

like

EY recruitment process - all interviews done, last hurdle independence check done. What is the typical time to offer decision? How would you assess the HR approval process to get a bc approved?

like

westin, W or another beachside spg/marriott in Fort Lauderdale? Long weekend with husband.

like

COVID WFH: Maama or Maami Thaligai?

like

First time expecting mom here. I have a very noob / stupid question. So I read that you're not supposed to let the baby sleep alone in his/her room when newborn. So then what is the point of the nursery?! Wouldn't it make more sense to have the crib/bassinet in the parents' bedroom, or have a bed for an adult in the nursery as well? Confused here.

Do you think post-covid that companies will ever keep their tech employees in NYC? I’m a software engineer for a financial company and already am probably one of the last people to RTO if/when that happens. But now I’m thinking that this situation has proven that they don’t need to take on the costs of having SWEs in a HCOL city if all of us can WFH/work from a LCOL city with same results. Kinda bummed bc I’m a new hire and I never even got to move there... should I lower my expectations?

like

I need help as someone who is new to Big4 consulting culture. I completely bombed an engagement due to many factors and I’m now rolling off. What is the procedure to move forward?

likehelpful

If you just got staffed on a project and it’s not what you expected or thought it would be, can you roll off without retaliation or a Scarlett letter for other managers? It’s been a month

like

Anybody go from cyber consulting (assessment based/cyber maturity/incident response plan) to a more technical role? I really want to make this move but not sure if it’s possible without cutting my salary down significantly. Currently building up my skills in networking and VM so I have a path built to improve my skills. Just worried about finding a technical role when all my experience is self taught and home lab based.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal