Tomorrow I'm interviewing a young woman for a Sr. designer position on my team. I'm mid level and have about 3 more YOE than her. Her portfolio is strong, and I'm trying not to be butt-hurt about it.

What are some questions I can ask that actually address my concern that she may not have enough experience without coming off as aggressive/jealous?

(I have no say in who is getting interviewed for this role, and will be reporting my concerns to my boss, but don't want to undermine the candidate)

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

It sounds like you're already unfairly biased against the candidate due to your own ego and insecurities. Like, it's good that you recognize your own jealousy, but this would be a good subject to bring to a therapist because it doesn't sound like a healthy trait you want to carry forward in your own professional career. How can you ever mentor/manage others or lead a team if you're jealous of people who might be more talented than you?

Does she really not have enough experience, or are you afraid she'll be hired and outshine you?

Is there someone who can replace you on the interview loop who might be less biased?

like

Definitely I think you should ask the logical questions around the role. Don't try to stop someone else from getting what they deserve because of your insecurities.

If you're smart enough you will learn from her and also she might learn from you.

Not sure I understand the problem. You want the job instead?

like

I mean, that's not far off. I had a conversation with my boss about how growth is extremely important to me at this point in my career and we originally intended to hire mid-level. Due to some higher up decisions, it was switched to senior level. I was hopeful that we'd hire someone mid-level and that I could grow into someone that could help to lead that designer, and that goal was sort of flipped on its head.

I also generally am still struggling with hiring someone with 2 YOE at 1 company as senior level, when I was hired to a mid-level role that requested 5+ YOE in the job listing.

I think try to be open to the fact that different companies have different definitions of junior/mid/senior and perhaps they corrected that over time (so now they’re hiring someone with less YOE to be a senior). Or possibly they want to be open to not cutting people off who have less YOE on paper but more “valuable” experience. Say someone worked in an in house role where they were hired as a designer but they only worked on print design specifically vs an agency role where they work on a big range of projects. Personally I’d see their experience very differently, even if they had a gap in YOE. For designers I really think portfolio is much more important than YOE. You could sit in a role and basically slack off and still rack up YOE.

I’ve been in situations where I’ve “led” people who are more senior to me and it is stressful. Especially if you feel like they think you’re incapable etc. I think you could ask them what experience they have leading a team. Or what experience do you have working with difficult senior stakeholders? (See how they respond to authority/seniority) Have you mentored other designers before?

In the end, you are the one who will have to be working with them. You always have the option to leave and try to find a senior role if you feel strongly about it.

like

You can also just ask “why are you the best person for this job” and see what comes out of that… a “senior” title and what the responsibilities are varies between companies so it really depends what you’re looking for in this senior role

@OP, If you're mid-level, are you junior to the senior designer? I think that's what you meant, but it was unclear.

Correct! Still would be managed by the CD, but my CD has mentioned multiple times that she wants someone I can learn from.

Related Posts

Hi Deloitte London 🐠. I’m a Manager in the Toronto office. A good friend is doing his MBA in ESADE and really wants to end up in consulting in London. He’s got a good profile (McGill undergrad, last position was Director of Finance at Publicis Canada). Anyone from D London who would be open to connecting with him to chat and help him understand the firm and the local office? My London network is surprisingly small.

like

Hi HSBC sharks, my CCTC is 17.4LPA (Fixed). I have been offered a position at HSBC for Senior Analyst position. They are not offering a single rupee more than 30% i.e., 22.6LPA. What can I do to ask for more? Or it is their maximum at this position? Please help HSBC HSBC India

like

I am currently working in Tcs as a python developer having 2+ yoe. My last working day is 30th of November. Can you please refer me if you have any opening for skills - Python,Django,Sql,Aws,HTML,CSS,Javascript,PostgreSQL,MongoDB. Any help would be much appreciated.

like

Hey hi 17 years experience not even 15 lax, working as a PM role but not on papers, really looking to move on with PM Scrum master opportunities, any references anyone

like

Anyone here knows if their firms’ India Office is hiring for Financial Advisory ? Asking for a friend primarily skilled at Financial Modeling for Infrastructure, Energy and Real Estate clients.

like

Hi everyone - I have experience in Investment banking domain and I am looking for a new role in Canada and would appreciate your support. I have experience in M&A, DCF, Buy side , sell side, Financial modelling, compliance, due diligence, Thank you in advance for any connections, advice, or opportunities you can offer.

like

Anyone ever have Rolex / their AD lose a watch during shipping for servicing? In that unfortunate position and determining what to do.

like

Hey! Attra is looking for candidates with 2-6+ years of experience in the following:
1. Base24 classic development
2. Base24-eps development
3. Postilion development
4. Authentic development

DM me if you are looking for a referral. :)

like

Hi Guys. Today i got shortlisted from a IT resourcing consultancy through naukri.com. They said they are hiring for Deloitte India for IAM analyst role. However I don't know how this resourcing thing works since i Am new to this switch through consultancies. Can someone please explain me a bit how this works.Thanks in Advance

like

What are the various research companies like ISG, Forrester and Everest which are hiring currently in India? Would be of great help if someone can give some direction to this!

With 6 YOE.. what salary can I expect from Amazon at L5 Business Analyst Role?

like

My boss does this thing where he'll give comments like, "make sure you include the proper language regarding X." As if we always include X and I'm an idiot for not including X.

When asked if X is a new development in the law, he'll say something like "no its not new, it's something we always do." But then I if I go look at his past drafts, he didn't include X either and only started in the past couple drafts.

Why can't you just say, "I have some new language that I want to start including"?

like

What is the etiquette for exit row in the middle section (think seats configured to 3-3-3)? Are people meant to climb over your legs to pass or is this reserved for the passengers who are sat there?

like

Which pays better and has better career highlights, FAANG or BIG4 or MBB or big Inv. Banks. I agree it depends on person to person, but it adds value to resume, get LOR from Dr, VP or PI-AP.


Your thoughts.
I know even techies or mba people have worked and moved from these org and they have their reasons to take a big role in big4 or smaller role in tech just because of the pay and wlb. For eg PM profile and onsite opportunities associated with tech co.

like

Interested to hear thoughts on this: 5+ YOE in FS consulting as an SC at tier 3 firm. Interviewing at Deloitte for an SC position. I have a good reputation and setup at my firm and am on a great track to make Manager in 1-2 years. However, no one has heard of my firm and am really interested in a M7 MBA before I'm 30 (so enroll in 2-3 years). What is more valuable for an MBA: making manager at a no name firm or the "prestige" of having Deloitte on my resume?

like

Hey Fishes! What level does an Accenture UK 'Graduate' start at? Also could someone give any kind of salary range? This would be a transfer from another company for 2 YOE. If I were to be placed at the 'bottom of the SFBG (Salesforce Business Group). I will soon be having a conversation over accepting the role and wondering what salary to aim for. This is UK based, Manchester. Thanks!

like

After many years of doing purely corporate law, I recently moved inhouse to do structured finance. Honestly, I am in unknown territories. My boss also not patient about my re-learning process yet they knew from the interview that I know close to nothing about structured finance. I am 2 months into my 6 months probation period and I am worried that I might have bit more than I can chew. FYI - I am doing all I need to do to learn (books) but still struggling. Any pointers on how to get it faster.

like

Any nursing informaticians on here with a bachelor's degree? What helped you the most when applying for that role?

like

Senior manager with 10 years of experience. Looking for a position in private. Located in Los Angeles but open to remote positions too. Anyone have leads?

like

More Posts

why’d I have to break what I love so much

like

Any recommendations for the best location to ride around the Bay Area?

like

After many years of doing purely corporate law, I recently moved inhouse to do structured finance. Honestly, I am in unknown territories. My boss also not patient about my re-learning process yet they knew from the interview that I know close to nothing about structured finance. I am 2 months into my 6 months probation period and I am worried that I might have bit more than I can chew. FYI - I am doing all I need to do to learn (books) but still struggling. Any pointers on how to get it faster.

like

Any nursing informaticians on here with a bachelor's degree? What helped you the most when applying for that role?

like

Senior manager with 10 years of experience. Looking for a position in private. Located in Los Angeles but open to remote positions too. Anyone have leads?

like

Anyone in here have a hospital job for a unit secretary position? How much does it pay in California? Any help is greatly appreciated

like

Need 11 likes to enable DM. Thanks a ton.

like

Is anyone going from Jaipur to Pune on 27 August?

like

I’m a young(ish) male running a private practice. Been with the group a year and a half and haven’t exactly gelled with some of the older employees. We’ve made tremendous financial improvements but in a meeting last night one of the physicians stated, in front of me, maybe we shouldn’t have hired a young guy to run the practice….I can’t think of a more passive aggressive way to ask someone to leave. Thoughts?

like

Hi

I'm looking for job in Insurance domain P&C with 6 year of experience can anyone rafer me ?

like

We are building our extra benefits plan! Care to share some ideas?
How many PTO days do you offer?

like

After 13 years in government, really want to get out. Anyone have experience convincing the rest of the world you’re not a “government employee”? I think hiring managers see government work and assume I’m lazy. Ways to get around this?

like

Best companies to work for in the Triangle area, North Carolina?

like

Some cringe terms we use everyday! Mat karo ye please.

Post Photo
like

Any advice on direct contacting hiring managers for a job you want? I get that in theory it’s the same as selling anything but for people who’ve done it before what did you do, and how did it work out?

like

Hi how much in hand for 15LPA. 1.5lac is variable.

up is starting to took like down for me in this market

like

Additional Posts in Designers

What do when you’ve already accepted a job offer but then received a better offer? Does it look bad on you to decline the first offer?

like

Any companies or agencies hiring a mid-level designer in NYC?

like

This company I interviewed at expects me to create a wireframe and design out visuals, as well as fully animated prototypes. Is that a normal thing these days?

Are you supposed to send a thank you email after the second round interview? What if you don’t have their email, would you contact the recruiter? Or is it unnecessary

like

Just got a design test for a senior role asking me to design social posts, a creative concept for products they’re releasing in a few months (irl), and another conceptual idea for an awareness campaign. Too much for a design test? I’m truly torn. There’s already a few red flags but I can’t tell if this is reasonable or not

likefunny

I need some thoughts on what to ask for a starting salary. My background is ten years in tech support, and currently Lead Graphic Designer for my department with about four years of graphic design behind that. I also just finished my master's degree in Human Computer Interaction design (and was among the top in my class). I thought $80k as an absolute minimum ask but considering my credentials and education I really don't want to undersell myself. I'd appreciate thoughts on the matter.

like

I've been unemployed for close to 2 years now and by the end of this month I will have exhausted all my resources/savings which have been keeping me afloat all this time. I was originally looking for the "perfect job" now I've broadened my search so wide it's kinda depressing. Is it just me? Or are creative jobs in trouble? Seems the more I search the more I see lower and lower wage ranges and longer and longer job descriptions. What gives?

like

Any tips and tricks for managing projects and priorities form multiple product teams? We have a decentralized UX team where every UX designer participates in weekly product meetings and designs for 6 to 8 product teams.

like

Layoffs.fyi

As layoffs start ramping up. I’m getting pretty worried. Should I start trying to find a more recession proof industry to work in-house at (currently at an agency). Or should I double down on my efforts to look great at my agency so I’m less likely to get fired?

Post Photo
like

Is $127k year with no bonus (except stock options) too low in NYC for a senior design manager at a tech startup w over 100 employees and 250+ mil in funding?

I don’t manage designers, I manage the design in the company. I got promoted to SDM to expand my role more horizontally vs my previous role which was fully IC working on product design

like

I’m so tired of the fun getting sucked out design via overzealous feedback on legibility, golden ratios, and whatever new “rule” some design bro talked about in his money grab authoritarian keynote. Surely I’m not the only one who listens to their gut feelings? Sometimes ugly and wrong is interesting. Where did everyone’s imagination go?

like

Any program recommendations for building decks for clients? Indesign is obviously the best IMO, but I’ve found it difficult for clients who don’t have a design background and want to make changes in the future. I feel keynote is a nightmare...wondering if I’m alone in this sentiment lol. It’s so challenging to layer things/ mask photos/ build custom type paths etc. having trouble finding a good alternative and would appreciate any suggestions!!

like

Workflow or Semplice?
I'm redesigning my portfolio site. I'm presenting myself as a visual/web designer (emerging) and I need to level up from Squarespace. THX!

like

UI designers everywhere: Please stop making “peek-a-boo-only” interfaces.

likefunny