{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Was offered by D today in consulting, experienced manager. Have a competing offer with ACN Strategy but was more inclined towards D’s role. Sign on bonus at D is very low, what’s maximum offered at M?", "post_id": "5b46b36c4c7f9e001839588c", "reply_count": 32, "vote_count": 1, "bowl_id": "58f0df008ad7250010f8c590", "bowl_name": "Compensation" }

Was offered by D today in consulting, experienced manager. Have a competing offer with ACN Strategy but was more inclined towards D’s role. Sign on bonus at D is very low, what’s maximum offered at M?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

MD1, ACN is absolutely the best consulting firm for Tech Strategy, bar none (Deloitte is good in this area as well). Digital strategy is also another area of strength for us, and in this area Deloitte does indeed match us. To be fair, Deloitte certainly has strengths in other areas of strategy where they outshine us I think you're spot on that we don't compare to MBB, but it's laughable to also say that we don't compare to Deloitte when Vault has us as a top 5 Strategy firm (right behind Deloitte) and number 1 for Tech Strategy. -signed: someone who turned down an offer from MBB to go to Accenture Strategy

likefunny

If you are very experienced I would try to get 25-50k sign on. Salary maybe they could improve by 10k? Would give it one try with a specific recommendation fro you about the other offer you have and what you want from them. Let them know you're more excited about deloitte and want to accept the offer, but be prepared to walk away or accept the offer as is.. I'll keep an eye on this if you have any other questions, let us know how it goes

like
Recent IconRecent

No way - you can’t compare ACN strategy to MBB or even to Deloitte S&O.

likefunny

Damn. If you got Acn Strat you probably would’ve had interviews at MBB...which means you could’ve had a chance there.

likefunny

Lol absorbed by tech^. Someone is unhappy with their SAP implementation.

likefunny

Deloitte S&O is dead. Its going to be absorbed by tech soon.

likefunnysmart

The same comments come up at Accenture. “Strategy is failing and is going to be absorbed by MC.” The reality? Strategy got mid-year raises of $5-10k and year end raises TBA, while MC and Tech analyst programs were combined

like

“Mom’s Best Boy"

like

Damn IBM. It’s Mama’s BAD boy.

like

Don’t get distracted by the bonus. Focus on the role. Opportunity for growth, leadership, learning? With the salary bumps for strong performance, you can eclipse that signing bonus in no time. Focus. On. The role

like

I do agree with your thought process

like

OP: yep, part of Accenture Strategy - specifically Technology Strategy

like

What’s MBB stand for?

like

I joined ACN because it had the best execution portfolio, I have seen incredible variety from CSuite strategy to global BPO, all within a year. Pick your poison and be loyal, find what means the most to you if you had to do it for 20 years

like

What are the salary offers ? Where are you coming from ? Is it a lateral or a promotion ?

MD 1 - when you say you can’t compare, can you please throw some light in comparing them - Accenture Strategy and Deloitte Consulting. Both my roles will eventually be focused on Tech/Digital Strategy. Deloitte’s role is more focused though and ACN’s role is more broad.

What group in Deloitte? I’m an M3 in tech strategy BTW

D 4 - Customer and Marketing Group. I like the role but they don’t have much room for comp negotiation.

What are they offering you? I’m in S&A > strategy

D4 - only 10K as sign on bonus at exp. M level

Related Posts

I’m thinking of leaving audit after my second busy season. My main interest in accounting has always been forensics /fraud . Also thinking of going the CFE route instead of CPA( did it a few times and haven’t passed ) but I pass the CPE reviews more. What position should I apply to or transfer into ? Also do I look for a senior position or just an associate. Please any input will be helpful

like

Hi, To share my experience who are looking to exit. I am a director at KP, YOE consulting 12 years at 200K base 15% bonus: TD / RBC AVP, 160 - 170K Base 50% bonus + stock, etc. CPPIB D, 150 - 170K base 50% bonus CPPIB MD, 180 - 200K base 100% bonus (yes, 100%) Magna, MGR 175K base max SAKS Off 5th (US), D, 190K Base 15% bonus MLSE D, 140 - 160K, Kainos, architect, 190K base max. I ended up with a US based HR tech firm, Architect: 230K CAD 15% bonus stock options. Hope this helps!

likehelpfuluplifting

LEK, Kearney, Accenture, Deloitte, Oliver Wyman. Which would you choose out of university and why? I want to optimize broad exit opps and comp

like

Any positive job changes after becoming a mom? I'm having a bit of trouble deciding which direction I want to pivot my career. Yes I want to do work that is fulfilling but I also want to find a role that allows me to balance my life as a mother, especially during Covid. Being at my current agency does not offer that and I assume is the norm for most agencies.

like

Hi all, Need referral For Barclays /Deutsche Bank/Mastercard/Amdocs for QA automation tester role in pune. YOE-:5.4 years

like

Anyone have an insight on salary for Monitoring & Testing Program Manager role at Facebook? I have an initial call with recruiter.

likehelpful

What is my in-hand salary for level-11..? Please help me.

Post Photo
likehelpful

Friday the CEO sends out an email proudly proclaiming that the company made $22 billion last year. Two hours later I am told on our team meeting that the bonus/raise pool is down from last year. I just have no words.

likeuplifting

I have an offer for Deputy Relationship Manager ll - Wealth from ICICI Bank, I have done MBA in Marketing from Tier ll college in Mumbai with 2 years of experience in Luxury Lifestyle & Real estate in Sales. Is this the relevant position I deserve in ICICI Bank? What pay package should I expect? How is the work culture & work life balance?

like

Does anyone here know the comp range for a data engineer at Accenture?

like

My brother is in his late 30s and wanting to switch his career. What are the job profiles and companies that do not require specific experience or qualification and offer good salary packages ?

like

HF people - what is the average YoY pay increase for juniors? Fund had a good year and looking to get a sense of comp expectations Have 4 years experience and was high 200s last year (3 years total experience)

like

Hi fishes, Want referral in citiustech healthcare technologies

like

What’s salary range of an associate or associate VP at Morgan Stanley?

like

2nd year manager at KPMG strategy current at $205k base (w/ top 10 MBA & 7 yoe). Offered $215k base 10% bonus for a Transformation Director position with a PE backed fintech. WLB is fantastic. Company positioned to go public in 1-2 years or be sold. Should I wait to see if I make director this year at KPMG or jump now? (I have 2 kids under 4 and wife is big law attorney so WLB is key)

like

Hi, I'm having 3.3 years of experience as Backend developer in .Net, C#. If any openings across please let me know, I'll apply or share my resume.

like

Looking to apply for a marketing manager position at Pinterest? Anyone from Pinterest willing to chat about the culture there or provide a referral? Thanks! Any help is appreciated.

like

Hi, A tech company in Abu Dhabi is looking for people with 1-2 years of experience in strategy from MBB/Tier 2 to join the Strategy & Operations team. Very competitive salary, good wlb and exposure. DM me if interested.

like

Hi all, Wanted to ask if EY GDS Leadership retains people by matching the salary if we show them the counter offer letter (from other Big 4)? The fixed offered by other firm is 5.5 lacs more than my current fixed. Any help would be appreciated!

like

Got an email in error a long time ago while I was in a non consulting role. The mailing list included people from multiple large consulting firms. How often do competing firms collaborate ?

like

Additional Posts

What was your AIP Bonus as SS1? Promoted this year and would like to know what people received in the past

like
like

Just accepted an offer at a company that is offering a 4% dollar to dollar 401K match without any minimum time at the company. Is this match as good as it sounds?

likehelpful

Looking for Marriott/SPG hotel recs in Chicago downtown. Thanks!

like

What's the bench policy in Mindtree. I've heard that they just give only 3 chances to clear client interview. Is that true ?

Got good offer from Deloitte better position Manager Specialist from Audit Analytics group (AERS)getting good hike of $32k in salary as well joining bonus of $10K currently on H1B what’s your inputs shall I join no travelling role for this position confirm by hiring leader.Any inputs is appreciated from community members

like

Any recommendations for practicing your answers for Amazon's behavioral interviews? Anyone hire coaches that were effective in evaluating and assessing your responses?Tia

like

About to join a Big 4 in 3 weeks and just found out that I'm pregnant. Will I still be eligible for parental leave?

like

Hi Fishes 🐠, Hope you are doing great! I wanted to reach out because I’m currently exploring new opportunities. I have 4 years of experience in project management and business operations. Please help sharing/referring if there is any PMO/Project Management you have. Just to add, I am currently serving my notice period and will be available to join after 20th Jan'22.

like

My personal PC hard drive crashed - taking with it 8 years of family pics, among other things. Backup lesson learnt. Having said that, data recovery specialists are asking for $900 to recover drive contents. What would you do? No-brainer for me, but other thoughts?

like

Hello Everyone, I've got an interview call. My primary skill is SAP PP but the interview is for QM. I'm not totally blank on QM but I just know basics as I also handle SAP QM related stuff. Shall I proceed with it or ask the recruiter to see if there are suitable openings for my primary skill. Please suggest. Thank you 🙏

like

When you see your seat neighbor texting her entire team about the guy you’ve been laughing at the whole flight 😂 no need to “brag” to the entire plane of consultants about your miles sir

likefunny
like

Alaska Airlines has the best overhead space 👍🏼

like

Hi All, My LWD with the current organization is ending in 20 days and I am in desperate need for a referral for Business Analyst role , Please let me know if you can help me. Thank you!

like

I’ve worked at the same big 3 boutique since I was a clerk. I’m a NEP now. I work in a mid to small market town. One of the partners in one of our larger offices wants me to move to their market. I have a great relationship with this partner and they are telling me they are planning to retire in 5 years. They have a sizable book of business. I have two small kids, my wife is an attorney who practices in state court. I’ll never be more than a well-regarded service partner if I stay. Would you go?

like

Hey all! Currently live in DC and thinking about moving to either: Los Angeles, Austin, Seattle, or stay in DC. Where would you move/live considering: cost of living, housing prices, and job market. I feel like LA has a rough job market in terms of competitiveness of applications compared to DC/Austin but benefits elsewhere. Feel free to share anything else I should know! Thanks!

like

Hi, Any anyone have any idea about current product/sr. Product manager salary in unicorn startups in India? (Maybe city wise say Bangalore, NCR). Actively interviewing and I think glassdoor data is bit outdated. Current Role: Product Manager Salary: 23 lpa Year of experience: 4.5

like

How do you convince yourself you're worth what you're supposed to be? 23/F/48K/CHI/almost 2 years at agency I barely feel like I'm worth this and just lucked into this but everyone says RAISE.

like

What’s the typical process for BCG interviews? I just got the request for a phone screen and wanted to see what questions/ what else I should be expecting in the process

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal