{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Was reading EB-1C conditions. Is it MANDATORY to be with the employer for at least a year before they can file EB1? Switching to new employer & I am now worried that they might not file my EB1 soon", "post_id": "5b51823bff4ba70018cf8244", "reply_count": 15, "vote_count": 0, "bowl_id": "58f8108c753e990016608a0b", "bowl_name": "Desi Consultants", "feed_type": "bowl" }

Was reading EB-1C conditions. Is it MANDATORY to be with the employer for at least a year before they can file EB1? Switching to new employer & I am now worried that they might not file my EB1 soon

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I call BS on EY2. I am on H1b and did it. No problem. You can manage people on H1b it's the job which counts. Infact my H1b never expired when I was abroad. I used the same visa to enter then filed the GC immediately (after spending 1 year abroad with PwC of course).


To each their own. I don't have to validate nothing. However one year outside with same firm is on negotiable.


By soon I mean within 3 months of joining. I am trying to negotiate on that.

Are you on L1A visa? My understanding is that EB1 is restricted for that visa. Also your international and US managerial role must be with the same company.

Nope - it can be on H1B as well. I am joining a new company so my manager experience at this firm is 0

OP you can be on H1 but your chances of approval is low as compared to L1

It is mandatory for you to have at least 1 year of international experience in last 3 years with the employer I.e employed by the same employer or it’s subsidiary outside US

I second EY1. Legally you can file on H1B. But logically it doesn’t make sense. L1A helps in a stronger case as it is for individuals who can support US operations. H1B is specialty occupation. You can’t get hired by a company on H1B and suddenly you’re running operations. Possible, but have fun with USCIS. That being said , I hope you know ‘manager’ is not a title. You need to be executive with org charts etc

BTW also in consulting firms even a senior associate can manage people. I have HEARD a couple of SAs successful as well.

Thanks all! So here what I am sure now: A) one can file EB1, even with H1B. My case itself is that I was Assoc. Consultant at the time of application but is now a senior consultant, in US and managing a team. Agree might be tough to prove the case but at least I will be eligible B) For EB1C, I have to be employed with the firm outside of US for a year - correct? Is that mandatory or if there are any alternatives? I am going to start with a new employer and know for sure that they won’t work me outside of US for a year (cos this is an industry corporate job) What you guys suggest for point B then? Thanks!

@M1 - have you come across any exception to this rule? This could be a deal breaker in my case and I am looking for options / help. Do you think I should take professional help from an immigration lawyer on this?

There is no way pwc 1’s claim can be validated . So have fun applying eb1

The 1 year outside the US is mandatory. As far as I know there is no work around. This is what makes it qualify for multinational executive.

Since I’m on vacation, I’ll entertain this. This is from USCIS memo that clearly defines the law and what kind of profile qualify. This was in response to people submitting EB1 petitions by doing 1 year stint across borders and calling themselves ‘managers’. This is the law. Maybe SAs at pwc are indeed performing these levels. But at least at EY , an ED or Partner will be close to this description. But feel free to negotiate law with USCIS

Post Photo

Sorry to drag this in your vacation, but to the benefit of all our countrymen I wish I can go through each one of the points from the law you quote and tell you how I helped support my application (EB1 was approved without RFE) but let's leave the hard work to the lawyers at EY. This is about multinational manager and not executive. 1. Supervising "professional" employees. Please read definition of professional in case law. 2. You do recommend hiring and firing if you actually interviewd anyone which I am sure you perhaps did and recommend firing or impacting performance if you wrote feedback on them. There's all detail I can go into but I'll stop here. I guess good for me if not many apply.

Additional Posts

Beyond 2 lines the text in each post card is cut off. I wonder how many lines in the comment section?


Post new user


How great would office emojis be in this app?


Make sure your hard work is protected. File or register with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office or U.S. Copyright Office before it's too late. Complete our easy questionnaire and we'll help you quickly submit your application. Use your INNOVATOR code for 10% OFF.*

test post from test


Fhhbbbbjjnnnnnnsn dnnsndjjjd dhjhdjjdjdjdjnd dhjhdjjdjdjdjnd djjfjdjjdndndnnfnd dhjhdjjdjdjdjnd dhjhdjjdjdjdjnd djjfjdjjdndndnnfnd djjfjdjjdndndnnfnd now djjfjdjjdndndnnfnd do. D dndnnfndnnsdhjdjdjdjnd


How does this sound?


My company is now displaying!


test on 1.1.5!


Where is a new build???


Testing for sound!

Linda fjfhfjf djjfjd djjfjd djjfjd djdjdjjd djdjjdjdjdj djdjd. Fend id didn't dish hen djdjdjjd did dishes djdjd djdjdjjd dj djdjd s djdjjdjdjjdjdjdndh do djdjjdjdjjdjdjdndh djdjdjjd djdjjdjdjdj djjjd


3 years at a consulting firm or an MBA - which is the better education?


Desperately waiting for my first bonus check. Hope it's not a disappointment cuz let's be honest, I've spent it already.


When the VP of Technology leaves in the middle of your post merger integration project ✌🏽


Oracle in talks to acquire Accenture


What comp package (base, bonus, RSUs) could I expect from a Director of BD position at a <$1B market cap pharma company?


Help 😳 manager in FS finishing my mba in June. Want to go into mgmt consulting next. How hard will it be to make the move w/o experience in mgmt consulting? Do I have to be a senior again? Salary? 🤔


Does Deloitte drug test as part of the hiring process?

EY SMs, is there anything in our employment agreement that prevents us from going to work for a ch2 acct. we work on?


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or