{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "We need to make a public list of agencies who treated people well, and horribly, so when these same agencies desperately need people, we can go to the good ones and leave the horrible ones to fall apart.", "post_id": "5eac1c2348755c002f06bf98", "reply_count": 259, "vote_count": 227, "bowl_id": "5565cfca8b2b9a03009acf57", "bowl_name": "Advertising" }

We need to make a public list of agencies who treated people well, and horribly, so when these same agencies desperately need people, we can go to the good ones and leave the horrible ones to fall apart.

likesmartupliftinghelpfulfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

What a horrible, typical “progressive” idea. Do you have enough insight in every agency’s situation to know why the decisions were made, the way they were made? It’s a free country with free enterprise and this makes this country unique and so strong. That’s what brought a lot of us immigrants here, the ability to run your business freely as long as you not breaking any laws. You want to blacklist agencies started and run by people, not the government. They are free to do whatever fits their business model and whatever is necessary to keep their firm alive. I had zero layoffs and so far everyone gets the same salary as before the crusis but I’d defend the right of every agency owner to make their business decisions on their own, without involvement of a mob.

funnylikesmart

Beyond laws, there’s human and business ethic...which is exactly what many agencies unfortunately lacking and, believe me clients are fully aware of that nowadays...as a result agency reputation is on a downward spiral.

like

imre and imre Health have been amazing. We had been growing rapidly and even opened an office in Feb. so timing was rough (duh). But the leadership seemed really prepared, communicated in a human way, and pulled levers so that no one was fired. We already had a flex policy so remote work had been ironed out. I feel very fortunate and am happy that we have been encouraged to work with local schools, donate old computers and the leadership has been very understanding how difficult it is to balance work/life right now. Clients seem to recognize it too and we have replaced some paused work over the last month. I’m sure size has some affect. But the ethics of a company really lead the way.

like
Recent IconRecent

As someone who’s been full time at a handful of agencies for a long time, and then freelanced at another dozen, I’m going to say this: the list of agencies who treat people like billable hours with a name is long, and the list of agencies that treat people like people fits on a post-it note.

likesmartupliftinghelpful

Can I get those post it note names? @CD1

There are agencies where the executive team is taking 20% pay cuts and there have been no layoffs, and there are agencies where the executive team collected a march bonus, took no pay cuts, and fired staff. Both of these groups include major and smaller agencies. You would be surprised. And it should be public.

likeupliftingsmarthelpful

Our leadership took bonus cuts and we retained all staff. People should spread good business practices where people were protected. Threads like this should be where we speak up.

like

Leo Burnett Chicago did pretty well so far. I may be wrong but it seems like Publicis as a whole was on a scale of pretty good to great on their response. Pretty fast on social distancing to begin with, shipped all my hardware to my home, and my client has been reasonable (our leadership set expectations properly back in Feb/ March to allow fluctuations in timing). No layoffs yet, and I haven’t seen a pay cut. We also receive weekly updates from Publicis, and biweekly from our own leadership. Overall I have a better opinion of Publicis and LB after this than I did prior to Covid, which is surprising.

likesmart

Leadership at Leo is doing very well. The town hall last week was inspiring and good to keep track on what people are working on.

like

To build on this, clients (both brands and individual CMOs) deserve to have their reputations open to scrutiny the way agencies do. Why are there no report cards for brands? In this era of radical transparency and social media criticism I say their time has come. And if you are a cheap, stupid amateurish client that doesn’t really know what they are doing then there should be a forum where this can be laid bare for all the world to see.

likesmartuplifting

I get that a lot of agencies behave like shit and very few act decent but I think what is going on in this industry is unacceptable. We never stop working, we give up our lives, our physical health, our sanity, in return for what?! We need to start holding this places accountable.

likesmart

Reminds me of Stan from Mad Men “Reality got her. You work your ass off for months, bite your nails, for what? Heinz...baked...beans.” I would gladly take you that account now though. Or really any other day. Le sigh

likesmart

Anomaly bad

likesmart

GS&P has handled the situation extremely well and continues to be transparent and communicative with everyone. Very happy to be here right now compared to where I’ve been in the past...

likesmart

Liz is WW CCO and chicago CCO

like

Someone should start a spreadsheet similar to the ad industry salary spreadsheet. Agency name, city, what was the agency work from home response, what was the personnel response? For instance, I would love to anonymously report that my agency asked every employee to take a cut, but didn’t offer any details on what exec leadership was doing beyond that they took “a larger cut.” Did they give back bonuses from last year? How much larger of a cut is appropriate for C-level positions vs the plebes on the floor? Idk...I’d like to know what percentage cut they took, and what bonuses or other compensation they gave back though...

like

Google “Real Agency Salaries”. Should be in the top results.

like

Ueno just laid off 35% of staff - one year after sinking a million dollars into a brand new shiny office in IS and holding a costly ‘un-conference’. Short sighted decisions from leadership (read CEO) weren’t cited as a cause, rather new biz pipeline and Covid were scapegoated. We’ll see if another round comes this year...

likehelpful

May be a good opportunity to change the name? Or add another consonant?

likefunny

Agencies that have to let people go to to finances are not to blame. It’s how they do it. If leadership is taking bonuses. If they extend health benefits or if they don’t. If their layoffs target people over 40 or minorities. If their leaders are complete hypocrites with what they are saying in the trades and to clients, versus what’s actually happening. Today, clients want to work with partners and vendors they can standby. There is a culture of doing the right thing at many major companies. When the brand teams learned of how their agency partners have been treated, which is how they are really being treated in terms of the staff left to service them, they will call reviews. So the spreadsheet should be done in a very readable info graphic kind of way suitable for sending to the Fortune 500 CMOs, and posting on a million business community sites.

likesmartuplifting

Where do you work?

Madwell has been nothing short of amazing during this time. Full transparency. Reassurance. Will not be leaving this company for a while.

like

I've heard nothing but good things

like

Yeah that’ll show em. Take that, hobbled industry! We laid off creative folks desperate to feed our families and unskilled at anything else that pays won’t tolerate this treatment more than 10 or 12 years, or however long it takes to get pushed out for being over 45.

likefunnysmart

VpCD: check this out didtheyhelp.com

likeupliftingfunny

We're all grown ups here VP. Give us the info and we can choose for ourselves

likesmarthelpful

Publicis Groupe as a whole is doing a great job so far. Weekly updates from the top and also from leaders. Transparency and a focus on our people first.

like

What Publicis are you working for, certainly not the one that I do. They had layoffs yesterday and apparently there will be more this week? Who, what and where would be helpful. I feel like I am dead man walking until Thursday.

like

Mindshare (and as far as I know, GroupM as well) has been absolutely fabulous. No layoffs that I have heard of, no pay cuts for general staff, great transparency and weekly check ins from local, national and global leadership. Feeling extremely lucky - this is how a great company is run.

like

DoDS, I know exactly what you’re talking about. But that was 4-5 years ago, no? I hold my statement that current Mindshare leadership has been great and things have changed since that era. I will retract my statement on GroupM as the same day I posted that they announced layoffs. I can see why you would still be disgruntled, but currently, we’re doing great.

like

The Community. They think they have slaves instead of creatives

likehelpfulfunny

Yes. I’ve heard this a lot. Had a lot of friends there at some point. They all came out with mental breakdowns.

likesmart

Small market agency, but HLK has been killing it. Releasing fully transparent numbers. Zero reductions in salary or staff as of yet.

likeuplifting

Didn’t HLK pretty much gut its Denver office?

Doing a spreadsheet and chances of being tracked can literally eliminate someone from this industry. The method should insure privacy as well as authenticate its validity.

likesmartuplifting

I'm incredibly grateful for everything our leadership is doing for us at this time.

likesmartuplifting

This ^^^^. The rich get richer and we have this silly notion of “freedom”, while living in constant fear of losing our jobs and healthcare - and do not get taken care of even in situations far beyond our control. How is that different from modern servitude?

like

Additional Posts

How do background checks work with a potential employer? Is it just contacting deloittHR and verifying employment dates and title? I’m guessing HR can’t say anything about performance or layoffs, etc?

like

How long has it been taking y’all to get to JFK recently by Uber/Lyft? I’ve heard traffic has been crazy. I’m coming from Greenpoint for reference and flight is Friday early evening

like

Any MBA folks want to share their MBA resume templates that I can use? Please DM me, TIA

like

Audiobook recommendations? Currently listening to The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck and I’m enjoying it, but I’d also be open to listening to novels aside from self help books.

like

Snap advertising products that are literally more than my annual all in comp

Post Photo
likefunny

Hello Everyone! Had a discussion yesterday regarding “claw backs” being included in a policy for sponsorship if the new employee leaves before 3 years. It was a declining percentage over a three year period. My POV was that it wasn’t something I’ve ever done and didn’t seem like they were sure of the hire they were making. I get wanting to save costs but at the same time doesn’t feel inclusive or welcoming. Thoughts? Have you done this or seen it work? Thanks!

like

Best material to study for the FRM?

like

Has anyone made a successful transfer from the EM/EL position at MBB to a VP at BB ibank, or vice versa? I know the skillsets are different but wouldn’t they even out at the project management level?

Any tips for ACN skills interview?

like

If you were a teacher interviewing principals for your building what is one thing you would ask them?

like

What a time to be on the bench

like

Has anyone exited to a private debt/direct lending shop? If so, what is the comp and WLB like?

like

When your traditional agency’s digital comfort level is YouTube pre-roll 🤣🤣🤣

likefunny

Do our industry awards hold any more value than an insurance salesperson’s?

like

When will Booth issue interview invites?

like

Hi. Does anyone know the policy for reapplying to Deloitte? I failed the preliminary coding interview and I don't know the exact time period to wait before I can reapply for jobs at Deloitte.

like

Since we are now WFH, there’s no need for smokers to step outside to take smoke breaks. And with WFH, there are back-to-back conference calls, so the though is that with video calls it’s okay for them to smoke during the calls. I could get behind that I think. Thoughts?

like

Would you cancel an interview (for tomorrow afternoon) when a partner schedules a meeting at the same time?

like

Hi all! For an experienced hire as a Human Capital Consultant at Deloitte, what should I expect the salary/sign-on bonus to be at a MCOL city? I have approx. 3.5 YOE (non-consulting), MBA and MS degree (non target school) and also SHRM certified (which is probably irrelevant for the role but thought I’d share anyways). Already did my research but the range is kind of all over the place for experienced hires so just want to have a ballpark. Thanks!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal