What are your honest thoughts on cover letters - are they outdated, or even relevant at this point? Do you look at them?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I never read them as a recruiter, however, I think that any of my candidates that had taken the time to do a quality cover letter that laid out why they are interested and why they are a fit, usually performed better in interview because they had already spent time thinking about the fit.

They are nice in theory. When I'm reviewing candidates for a job that I'm hiring for, I only look at cover letters under 2 criteria:
1) it's a supervisor/manager role
2) there are more than 10 applicants
If it's a lower level job, I find most people don't include cover letters.

Recent IconRecent

I hate them, personally!

like

Same. I don’t want to “hear” the brag or read the fluff. I want to see the resume and move on.

like

I don't have time to read them, they're all the same template basically repeating their resume or bragging, sometimes it even shows they're a bad communicator and it actually hurts their chances. Only time I find it relevant if they're changing industries or have a career gap or something they need to explain.

What I do enjoy getting is portfolios and I think its getting more popular since I've been getting them more often (for non design roles/roles that dont traditionally require one). Instead of cover letters I've gotten slides of projects they've worked on that really lets me see in detail what their resume can't show in words.

like

When I was a recruiter I never even opened them. I just need to see if you have relevant experience or not.

like

They are completely outdated. I only do them now if someone specifically asks for one. As a hiring manager, I don't even look at them if someone sends one in.

like

Cover letters have run their course. I'd rather read a straight-to-the-point resume. No need for flowery words.

likehelpful

They don't hold as much weight as they once did, because I may also scan someone's social media profiles, or be looking for a very specific skill set on their resume.

like

By social media I hope you mean only LinkedIn bc outside of that it isn't work related and highly inappropriate unless they actually direct you to it on their resume.

like

I would be impressed if I received one. I do like to see cover letters for positions that requiring good writing skills.

like

Depends on the industry. I’d say create one and have it in your back pocket. You can always adjust it to the role if needed. I see this more as a requirement is academic environments. Bottom line, have one you can work quickly if needed.

like

I agree with this comment. And DEFINITELY ensure you do not send one to a recruiter or hiring manager addressed to someone of a different name. ( You may be surprised how many do this)
Also if you send one, ensure it is customized for the particular role you are applying to.

likesmart

I never look at them

like

I will not read cover letters - I’m trying to skim 50+ resumes a week, I want to see concise statements with lots of details (tech tool experience, data around sales numbers, etc)

like

Waste my time by writing a thoughtful cover letter , to NOT even get an interview. Screw those co we letters!!

like

Basically ignore them completely, to be perfectly honest.

like

As a person who use to recruit, cover letters are meaningless

like

I don't believe they are necessary for most roles. I take cover letters with a grain of salt and typically uncover the information I need during an interview. However, I do think they make sense for some high-level or extremely specialized positions.

likesmart

I like them. Gives the applicant a chance to clarify and red flags or talk themselves up if their qualifications don’t meet the requirements at first glance.

like

True, but the cover letter gets you to the interview.

funny

Personally, just why?
All pertinent information is on the resume.

Some of my hiring managers very much like them so it still serves a purpose with some.

like

My perspective: Outdated, not very many hiring managers I know even open them. Seen more as an optional document to provide. Unless an organization requires it, I don’t recommend anyone to bother with it.

Talent Acquisition/HR Professionals: From my experience, most still think they are effective. Almost all never view them during the screening/interviewing process.

like

I hate them; I don't pass them along to the client. I don't have that kind of time to review them and ensure that they are grammatically correct for either clients or hiring managers. We even review thank you letters from the candidates to hiring managers just in case.

like

Depends on the industry and your experience. If you are applying for a job that you know you qualify for but may have more transferable skills than actually applicable skills then a cover letter helps. To be honest, I get impressed when someone sends me a cover letter.

like

I generally feel like they're not needed and pretty antiquated as your resume should speak for itself. But they're helpful for explaining resume gaps, transferable skills if switching industries/careers, or any other things your resume doesn't provide

like

Related Posts

If you were offered a role at a company where there was little to no diversity within the group you were interviewing for (not even at the level you were interviewing for, or at senior leadership level) would this be a red flag for you in terms of culture, & potential opportunities? I want to keep an open mind but this company has been around for 20 years. The people I interviewed with were great but im concerned that there’s a larger problem at play. Thoughts?

like

Anyone applied/interviewed for a new job while in the third trimester? How did that work out? Would you wait until after leave to make the jump?

like

I am looking for servicenow developer position. If anyone knows any openings then please help.
YOE: 3

like

Feel so trapped in this job because exit opps in Toronto are dismal. 😢

like

I have completed and submitted my PDM and BGV on 5th October. Following then my candidature is on 'interview' stage on IBM career portal.

Now after 60 days HR mailed me that my candidature is on "Business Withhold",They will get back when it's resolved.

Is there still any hope or it is just a false explanation before they will permanently close my candidature.
IBM

like

Hey y’all, any Careerbuilder AEs out there? I’m interviewing for a National AE role but a little hesitant due to a couple mixed reviews. Appreciate any insight!

like

Any 🐟 able to refer for a WD Financials role? Experienced senior with full platform and full lifecycle experience. Thanks!

like

Looking for opportunities outside India
YOE : 5yrs plus
Current Company: Eli lilly
Tech skill : Machine learning ( Deep learning,NLP ,Computer Vision) ,Python
Any referral or help would be appreciated.
Thank you in Advance

Hey I was informed my position was eliminated due to corp restructure. I am a marketing vet with 10 years diverse experience from social to email and both b2b and b2c marketing. I also am about to complete my mba. I love to tell a brands story. Looking for a position at a people first company marketing manager positions or above in Atlanta or remote thanks for your help.

like
like

I’m an Account Sup making 78K. Recently promoted. My friends tell me I’m grossly underpaid for my role. That I should be making 105. But I’m happy at my agency otherwise. Thoughts?

like

Hi Guys, where does anyone do to look for expat job openings?

I know it’s been asked previously, but worth posting again: what’s your take on doing work (in-house) for free as part of an interview process? I’m being asked to do so by a start up and feeling iffy

Hi! I have an interview tomorrow for an Employer Of Record startup. The startup is about 1 year old. What questions should I be asking specifically for startups?

like

EY is hiring for SAP. DM me for a referral if you fit one of these roles.

Post Photo
like

BCG 🐠: I’m looking to make a (hopefully) lateral move. Pre-MBA with about 8 YOE. Can anyone help me out with a referral?

like

Just started a new role and 2 weeks in my manager wants me to take over an 86 slide deck and is acting like it’s no problem! On my own! Am I crazy or how does she expect me to do this :( I am a senior now, but I’m also busy trying to learn the environment and simply getting access to all the things I need. She also tacked on two smaller projects in my plate… and the onboarding material was very bleak. If my old manager hadn’t connected me I’d quit tomorrow, I don’t get paid enough for this.

like

What is the max salary range ,if i am interested in joining BofA with 6 years of exp in Java developer role.

like

Hi fishes, my friend recently had a bitter experience with Dish Network. So her profile was shortlisted and they asked few questions over email. It did take good 2hrs to answer and she replied back. HM said we are good to go for interview and sent an invite. On the day of interview nobody turned up, neither they gave an update later. She did follow up for a couple of days but no response. Is there any reason why this happens ? Me being in HR field felt this to be a little unprofessional.

like
likesmart

More Posts

Tried to join the running bowl, but it doesn't seem active/can't get in. Just needed somewhere to vent: my husband made me take down my marathon medals and put them in storage 3 years ago. Said they looked tacky. They were stored at my mother in laws. Just found out they got thrown out in a big house clean. It feels so trivial but I'm super bummed. I had medals from Boston and Chicago and was working towards all 6 majors. Do I start from scratch and run all 6 starting now? *sigh*

likeuplifting

I feel that every time I give a startup some advice, it provides me with meaningful insight and experience to deal with my own matters.
I'm thinking about making it a side income now. Do you guys have any idea on platforms where I can submit myself for that or any other way to get started?

likeupliftinghelpful

Have any of you consultants actually benefitted from learning SQL or python? How is it being used in your everyday work? I’m in DMV doing federal consulting.

likehelpful

This is what we need to be talking about

Post Photo
like

Does anyone send out updates to specific customers in newsletter format?

One of my large strategic customers mentioned they would like some additional insight into what our teams are working on MoM (we're a managed service).

I thought it might be cool to test out some sort of newsletter-format, to send updates to our stakeholders there. The hope being that it would contain visuals and have a modern feel, and be a little lighter feeling than ANOTHER google sheet or dashboard.

like

For those of you that jumped from Big 4 to smaller audit firms, what are some of the things that you did that helped you have a successful and fulfilling career at your smaller firm?

like

My husband and I worked together at the same company for a year in different departments and they laid off 25 employees last week. My husband was one of them. 💔
It was dealt with poorly and severance benefits were bad compared to other companies we are seeing in the media. I’m really struggling to move forward and heal. The priority is for me to support him finding a new job but I just feel sick giving my time and energy to this company when they did this to us. any advice for strength😔

like

Beginner question- when in the production process do you formally bid out edit, vfx, music, and post? Do you award the job and have general budget line items for post and formally bid them after...

like

Hello Tram, Hope all are doing great!
I already submitted my resume and application to American Express and was curious about whether you are in contact with your company’s hiring team. If so, it would be a tremendous help if you were able to refer me for the Customer Service position. I’m confident that your referral would go a long way toward helping me land the interview I need to get the job. Need assistance.

Anyone work for Alvarez & Marsal? Thoughts on culture and work within PEPI group? Considering leaving D

like

Anyone know what happened at Chiat? Heard they let a few people go!

like

When people ask you for YOE, do you include your time in grad school at all? I feel like writing that you have 2 YOE when you’re 30 years old gives a warped sense of level and compensation.

like

Hi , any vacancy for the 1 year experience in Linux Administration or TechOps ?

like

How to get Id card.I am being boarded virtually!

like

This month I have spent more hours with excel than my gf or even myself. Actually calculation not an exaggeration 🙏 😓

like

My boss is a tyrant...she’ll something unprofessional and condescending to people she works with in person and then sends emails with hearts in them to the team afterwards.

like

Anyone have insight to current M&A tax manager (1st yr & CPA) salary in Atlanta? Thank you

like
like

They are just postponing the Onboarding without any proper reason, this is second time they have postponed . does anyone facing the same ..? HR also not responding on mail or call .. if anyone joined physically recently please let me know ..!

Post Photo
like

Interviewing for Accenture’s MBA Strategy Consulting. Any advice specific for interviewing at Accenture or how to handle Superday interviews?

like

Additional Posts in Human Resources

I'm looking for an an automated callout platform. Does anyone here have a recommendation?

Our company usually does performance evaluations in June of each year. Our pay philosophy is not clear. We usually give a COLA in January each year, somewhere around 2% and if an employee performed well, they get above the 2%. I have suggested we change our process to have a clear pay philosophy with increases tied to performance, with goals tied to overall goals of the organization. What is your process? Are you doing performance evals during COVID?

like

Hi, do you think the current recruitment process is broken ? It is biased by the use of AI ?

like

Does anyone have any advice on passing the PHR the first time around?

I have 2 years of sales experience but am looking to make a career change into HR? Any tips of how to standout on my resume or any general advice? Thanks!

like

How hard is Customer support analyst role in
Workday and how much are they paying Workday

like

What is the craziest thing someone has done to get a job at your company and it actually worked?

like

Hello, currently looking at adding benefits to our existing ones, especially a car plan program. Any idea would be helpful. My industry is retail.

Is it common practice for employee relations teams to have a policy that strongly discourages supervisors from corresponding with terminated employees? Cont’d...

like

What do you include at the end of an online application? Is it necessary to include FCRA rights, an EoE clause, etc., or is it okay to remove this information and include it in the job posting/advertisement?

like

I’m working at a new company and absolutely love it, my boss just hired a new person on our team that has no hr experience, no college background, they worked in IT so she thought it would be great to have her own IT person, now I’m struggling to make it through the day at work because of the language that the new person uses in conversations or the fact that he wears the same outfit all week long to work. Am I just being petty and should I get over it?

like

Hi everyone! I received a response on my job application at the company and I've been asked as interview questions over email that as an HR manager in a standalone role for a new country office opening, "what would I like to achieve in the 1st 90 days?"

Any responses you can share either from your experience or thoughts on how best I can answer this?

Note, I'm stuck on this question because the previous question to this asked about my priorities as HRM in the first 30days?"

Please help!!

like

DearAll,
lam a rookie here with no idea how this is gonna work,but here it goes.

lam currently with Cognizant taking care of End - End HR operations for UK and Ireland and am looking out for new opportunities with better compensation(current CTC: 3lakhs)

Current designation: Senior Coordinator - HR
Total Exp: 2yrs & 5months
Current Role: Payroll,Compensation,Benchmarking, Absence Management, Induction/Assimilation, Mergers & Acquisition (TUPE) andSeperations(+redundancy)

Cheers & Thanks!!

like

Any Benefits specialist looking for a job? North America specific?

like

Can anyone share their employee recognition programs on tenure?

like

I want to get my masters in HR, but I also want to get my phr.. is it better to get one over the other? Or should I do both. Are there any masters hr program someone can recommend?

like

Anyone in the food manufacturing industry? My friend is a Regulatory consultant being offered a Regulatory Mgr job $115 salary in East coast. She has 23 yrs experience, MS in Food Science. Has worked for big companies like McCormick, Frito Lays, Hersheys, Pepsico. It is not my industry so I don’t know… but it sounds very low. Thoughts?

like

Can you share one tradition that you have brought or started at your work that has boosted employee moral and engagement? Something that is like an ongoing monthly tradition.

like

I am interested in getting my SHRM-CP certification this year and I was wondering which study methods and materials worked best for those of you who passed the exam. Also, what are your roles in HR?!

like

Yes, workplace trauma is a thing. Understudied, misunderstood, and detrimental.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal