What are your honest thoughts on cover letters - are they outdated, or even relevant at this point? Do you look at them?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I never read them as a recruiter, however, I think that any of my candidates that had taken the time to do a quality cover letter that laid out why they are interested and why they are a fit, usually performed better in interview because they had already spent time thinking about the fit.

They are nice in theory. When I'm reviewing candidates for a job that I'm hiring for, I only look at cover letters under 2 criteria:
1) it's a supervisor/manager role
2) there are more than 10 applicants
If it's a lower level job, I find most people don't include cover letters.

Recent IconRecent

I hate them, personally!

like

Same. I don’t want to “hear” the brag or read the fluff. I want to see the resume and move on.

like

I don't have time to read them, they're all the same template basically repeating their resume or bragging, sometimes it even shows they're a bad communicator and it actually hurts their chances. Only time I find it relevant if they're changing industries or have a career gap or something they need to explain.

What I do enjoy getting is portfolios and I think its getting more popular since I've been getting them more often (for non design roles/roles that dont traditionally require one). Instead of cover letters I've gotten slides of projects they've worked on that really lets me see in detail what their resume can't show in words.

like

When I was a recruiter I never even opened them. I just need to see if you have relevant experience or not.

like

They are completely outdated. I only do them now if someone specifically asks for one. As a hiring manager, I don't even look at them if someone sends one in.

like

Cover letters have run their course. I'd rather read a straight-to-the-point resume. No need for flowery words.

likehelpful

They don't hold as much weight as they once did, because I may also scan someone's social media profiles, or be looking for a very specific skill set on their resume.

like

By social media I hope you mean only LinkedIn bc outside of that it isn't work related and highly inappropriate unless they actually direct you to it on their resume.

like

I would be impressed if I received one. I do like to see cover letters for positions that requiring good writing skills.

like

Depends on the industry. I’d say create one and have it in your back pocket. You can always adjust it to the role if needed. I see this more as a requirement is academic environments. Bottom line, have one you can work quickly if needed.

like

I agree with this comment. And DEFINITELY ensure you do not send one to a recruiter or hiring manager addressed to someone of a different name. ( You may be surprised how many do this)
Also if you send one, ensure it is customized for the particular role you are applying to.

likesmart

I never look at them

like

I will not read cover letters - I’m trying to skim 50+ resumes a week, I want to see concise statements with lots of details (tech tool experience, data around sales numbers, etc)

like

Waste my time by writing a thoughtful cover letter , to NOT even get an interview. Screw those co we letters!!

like

Basically ignore them completely, to be perfectly honest.

like

As a person who use to recruit, cover letters are meaningless

like

I don't believe they are necessary for most roles. I take cover letters with a grain of salt and typically uncover the information I need during an interview. However, I do think they make sense for some high-level or extremely specialized positions.

likesmart

I like them. Gives the applicant a chance to clarify and red flags or talk themselves up if their qualifications don’t meet the requirements at first glance.

like

True, but the cover letter gets you to the interview.

funny

Personally, just why?
All pertinent information is on the resume.

Some of my hiring managers very much like them so it still serves a purpose with some.

like

My perspective: Outdated, not very many hiring managers I know even open them. Seen more as an optional document to provide. Unless an organization requires it, I don’t recommend anyone to bother with it.

Talent Acquisition/HR Professionals: From my experience, most still think they are effective. Almost all never view them during the screening/interviewing process.

like

I hate them; I don't pass them along to the client. I don't have that kind of time to review them and ensure that they are grammatically correct for either clients or hiring managers. We even review thank you letters from the candidates to hiring managers just in case.

like

Depends on the industry and your experience. If you are applying for a job that you know you qualify for but may have more transferable skills than actually applicable skills then a cover letter helps. To be honest, I get impressed when someone sends me a cover letter.

like

I generally feel like they're not needed and pretty antiquated as your resume should speak for itself. But they're helpful for explaining resume gaps, transferable skills if switching industries/careers, or any other things your resume doesn't provide

like

Related Posts

Today is my HR round and i have CTC of 8.4 lpa with 12+ YOE. I have earlier told company that expected is 14 lpa. My interview was very good and want to quote now 16 lpa. Can i ask for it.

is anyone in Chicago hiring juniors at all 😰

like

Hi fishes,
Immediate joiner with 12 yoe api, springboks and micro services. Interview process for technical manager is ongoing.. What is ctc I can negotiate ?? Have 33 lpa offer on hand

like

Can anyone share any insights on Accenture’s 2nd round behavior interview .?

like
like

I need referral in Walmart for sde 2 postion
My YOE is 1.3 years

like

Anyone at Atlassian willing to give a referral? Can DM resume and LinkedIn 😊 Thanks in advance!

like

Has anyone interviewed with Atlassian for Senior Salesforce Developer role? How was the experience?

like

Tata Consultancy Hi fishies, I recently interviewed for a Big data dev role for Autodesk but it's via a third party called Applicantz. Initially the contract is for 1 year, which can be extended. There is also scope of Autodesk hiring permanently after 6 months or 1 year. Can anyone provide some reviews about Autodesk and third party Applicantz. Usually I would not have considered anything via a third party, but the company(Autodesk) seems great and work discussed seems good as well.
Publicis Sapient Citi Tata

likesmart

Hi Fishes,

I had recently interviewed for TIAA for the position of BI analyst but failed to crack the SQL round of interview due to my nervousness. I am really pressed and demotivated after my rejection.I made sure to be prepared in SQL and I wish to be interviewed in TIAA again. Will they consider my profile again?

like

Just finished successfully passed my second IAD (investment advice diploma) exam expect to have the third within 2 weeks, have three years relationship management experience at associate level and 2 at analyst level and have multiple degrees (been really fortunate) I want to head into the wealth manager position/junior banker. Can anyone advise the best way to position myself? Would prefer internally from a training point of view but open to external.

like

Hi Fishes, I have around 12 yr of experience in Android working as a Principal Engineer. I have 3 month the notice period. Should I resign now and hope to find a better opportunity? How is the market for Android? I do some openings but 3 months of the notice period is an obstacle.

Reason for change: Super toxic manager.

like

Best ways to root out the red flags in a teaching job interview and a school tour? I'm finally ready to get back to the classroom but don't want to end up at another toxic place where admin doesn't look out for the teachers at all. I know to avoid places where janitorial stuff is being ignored or other health and safety issues, but this is only my second interview (worked for 10 years at my old school, left during covid). TIA!

like

Is it worthing leaving a managerial permanent role in FMCG to get to a contract individual contributor role in META which offers circa 70% more money than the permanent?

Role is for 12 months which can become 24 or permanent

likesmart

I’ve been working on the agency side for over two years now, but would love to jump again to the client side, as I have a sense like you feel more as part of the project.
Any tips from someone who as made this shift, to help me make through the interview process?
Also, what would be a comparable position on the client side for someone who works on paid social media?

like

How is the work life in Barclays payments projects when you are working on a BA role?

like

Hi! Checking whether anyone has any experience working with 'For Good Profits'. It sounds too good to be true! Wondering if it is a good alternative to hiring a standard SEM agency ( I am the only marketing person in a small company for context). Thank you!

like

More Posts

What if "The Metaverse" becomes a thing, but the versions of it that get used are built up piece by piece by many smaller operations and Meta ends up with very little in the way of market share?

Post Photo
like

Has anyone gone from FP&A to internal audit/controls or similar roles (compliance, risk, etc.)? If so, how did you approach it?

like

I found one of my coworker's anonymous Twitter accounts, and it has a ton of red flags involving bigotry, sexism, etc. It's a personal account, so should I mention it to HR or not?

like

Love this bowl. Can you all provide some recommendations as I look to expand my collection?

Some of my favorites are
Scotch: oban, balvenie, macallan
Bourbon: woodford, bookers, four roses

Looking at glenfarclas and yamazaki next if I can find but other recs would be great!

like

Good outdoor date ideas?

Anyone working at, or familiar with, Wood, Smith, Henning, & Berman in NY willing to share any insight/info? TIA.

like
like

Countless rounds of revisions on the sizzle reel from hell, and every time, the client would ask us to ”fix the volume of the music, it’s still too loud.”

There was no V/O. Only audio was the music track. It’s really hard to say “maybe you could turn down the volume on your laptop” without coming across as condescending.

like

I'm currently in the corporate non-profit sector looking to break into financial tech. I'd love to chat with somebody who works in fin tech!

like

WFH still unclear and layoffs last week, but sure, send an email about executive level promotions. An A/S person who lost every acct they had in the 8y I’ve been there.

likeupliftingsmart

Any Korean / Korean-American management consultants in NYC that would be down to meet up?

like

What happens if you have bad recruiter call. Will they remember you for reapplications down the road?

like

As a leader in cyber, one of my aspirations is to increase the diversity of any organization that I am a part of.

For example…When I was in Big4, I referred several diverse candidates who are thriving & now, at McKinsey & Company, I set a personal goal to refer 1 diverse candidate, especially in (but not necessarily exclusive to) cyber/tech/IT, for every month of my tenure.

Continued in comments…

Post Photo
likeupliftinghelpful

Tell me if this is selfish or not. I adore my family, but since they're doing a very lowkey Christmas situation this year, I really would rather take a weeks vacation on my own. Obviously the holidays are about spending time with those you love, but I'm tired! And I see my entire family at least once a month for a group dinner. Am I a bad daughter/sister if I choose vacation this one time?

like

Really struggling with self confidence at work. The subject matter (finance) is difficult to grasp. I’m a midlevel who has move passed ancillaries and onto being responsible for credit agreement and commitment papers + issues lists. These make me feel overwhelmed and frankly dumb, so I tend to procrastinate or speed run them to cure some of the anxiety. What can i do to improve?

like

What are good places to meet people? I'm 10 years older than most people at work and I haven't been out and about for a while.

like

Hi Folks,
Happy Sunday!

Can anyone let me know which companies are good for learning and working on DevOps profile?

Thanks.

like

Exp 9 years
Mulesoft exp 4.8 years
TEKsystems : 33 LPA fixed
Apisero: 35 LPA

Please help me, which one is better for long term commitment.

like

Anyone recently got their H1 stamping in Canada? Do any of the centers have drop box appointments available?

like

What is Chicago 190K base equivalents in Bay Area?

like

Additional Posts in Human Resources

What is the most effective message to send to your employees to get them to write Glassdoor reviews?

helpful

What ATS are you currently utilizing and what are some pros of using it in terms of recruitment metrics?

like

Currently taking HR certification courses with Drexel and was planning to also do the pHR certification, but because I don’t have a degree in HR and I haven’t “formally” been working in HR, I don’t qualify, any suggestions on certifications that can help me develop my current office manager position into full HR?

like

Can you share your experience with PEO’s does it make your job in HR easier?

like

What is the craziest thing someone has done to get a job at your company and it actually worked?

like

Anyone actually keep their PHR active? I got my cert in 2013 and have done nothing since.

like

I’ve been a hospitality manager for 10 years now and I am graduating soon with my degree. I want to get into the HR field. Can someone help point in the right direction? Or companies that hire entry level?

like

First time poster here!

After spending 4 years as a mid-level ops manager, I tried to break into HR through talent acquisition. Now after 6 years in TA, I've had a hard time getting out of it. My goal was always to get into a more broad HRBP position, but I've since worked for smaller orgs without a solid HR career path. When I ask about my career goals, they keep telling me, "Soon!" Or "Maybe in 6 months!"

I'm testing SPHR in June. Any advice for securing the type of role I'm aiming for?

like

I’m taking the SPHR in less than 2 months and haven’t started studying for it. How difficult is it? I’ve been in HR for 20 years and have experienced ALOT in that time, although there are always employee relations scenarios that surprise me! How much do I really need to study for this? I just can’t seem to motivate myself to do it, I’m so mentally burnt out at the end of the day from a high stress HR job, the last thing I feel like doing is studying HR!

like

I'm looking for an an automated callout platform. Does anyone here have a recommendation?

DearAll,
lam a rookie here with no idea how this is gonna work,but here it goes.

lam currently with Cognizant taking care of End - End HR operations for UK and Ireland and am looking out for new opportunities with better compensation(current CTC: 3lakhs)

Current designation: Senior Coordinator - HR
Total Exp: 2yrs & 5months
Current Role: Payroll,Compensation,Benchmarking, Absence Management, Induction/Assimilation, Mergers & Acquisition (TUPE) andSeperations(+redundancy)

Cheers & Thanks!!

like

Any idea what a Hirevue assessment for a talent position at EY would consist of?

like

What types of “time off”do you track? Curious to know what others do if someone has jury duty or has to deal with something out of their control (losing power due to weather). I have some employees who needed time off for the hurricane last week. Thanks in advance!

like

So, a recruiter gave me feedback that my lack SPHR or SHRM-SCP is causing my resume to be knock out by AI and human recruiters despite my position and work history in Multinationals and being in Technology. They suggested that we put SPHR ( Lapsed). I let it lapse in 2017. What is your opinion? Plus if I were to take another certification - should I take SPHR or SHRM-SCP?

like

I want to get my masters in HR, but I also want to get my phr.. is it better to get one over the other? Or should I do both. Are there any masters hr program someone can recommend?

like

Does anyone has any tips or suggestions on recruiting trade professionals? (Plumber, Electricians, and HVAC technicians? They are highly sought after but they aren’t really big Linkedin users in my area.

like

An employee aired his grievances about racist behavior he's experienced at our firm and put in his notice. What is usually done regarding MBA tuition covered by the company? He still has two years left on his contract...

like

What are the standard fees for outsourcing consultancy work?
I've been working with a newly established consultancy business. Until now I've been paid day rates or project rates.
I've been invited to lead, build and manage the HR consultancy.
What are reasonable fee structures?
1. If they source work and give it to me to complete, what is a fair percentage?
2. If I source work and complete it, what should I 'pay' them given that it's under their 'brand'?

like

Transportation and Warehouse OHSA cases of lost days from work, what is a bad number to have? OSHAs last work injury summary says 2.1 per 100 employees.

like

Can you share one tradition that you have brought or started at your work that has boosted employee moral and engagement? Something that is like an ongoing monthly tradition.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal