What are your honest thoughts on cover letters - are they outdated, or even relevant at this point? Do you look at them?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I never read them as a recruiter, however, I think that any of my candidates that had taken the time to do a quality cover letter that laid out why they are interested and why they are a fit, usually performed better in interview because they had already spent time thinking about the fit.

They are nice in theory. When I'm reviewing candidates for a job that I'm hiring for, I only look at cover letters under 2 criteria:
1) it's a supervisor/manager role
2) there are more than 10 applicants
If it's a lower level job, I find most people don't include cover letters.

Recent IconRecent

I hate them, personally!

like

Same. I don’t want to “hear” the brag or read the fluff. I want to see the resume and move on.

like

I don't have time to read them, they're all the same template basically repeating their resume or bragging, sometimes it even shows they're a bad communicator and it actually hurts their chances. Only time I find it relevant if they're changing industries or have a career gap or something they need to explain.

What I do enjoy getting is portfolios and I think its getting more popular since I've been getting them more often (for non design roles/roles that dont traditionally require one). Instead of cover letters I've gotten slides of projects they've worked on that really lets me see in detail what their resume can't show in words.

like

When I was a recruiter I never even opened them. I just need to see if you have relevant experience or not.

like

They are completely outdated. I only do them now if someone specifically asks for one. As a hiring manager, I don't even look at them if someone sends one in.

like

Cover letters have run their course. I'd rather read a straight-to-the-point resume. No need for flowery words.

likehelpful

They don't hold as much weight as they once did, because I may also scan someone's social media profiles, or be looking for a very specific skill set on their resume.

like

By social media I hope you mean only LinkedIn bc outside of that it isn't work related and highly inappropriate unless they actually direct you to it on their resume.

like

I would be impressed if I received one. I do like to see cover letters for positions that requiring good writing skills.

like

Depends on the industry. I’d say create one and have it in your back pocket. You can always adjust it to the role if needed. I see this more as a requirement is academic environments. Bottom line, have one you can work quickly if needed.

like

I agree with this comment. And DEFINITELY ensure you do not send one to a recruiter or hiring manager addressed to someone of a different name. ( You may be surprised how many do this)
Also if you send one, ensure it is customized for the particular role you are applying to.

likesmart

I never look at them

like

I will not read cover letters - I’m trying to skim 50+ resumes a week, I want to see concise statements with lots of details (tech tool experience, data around sales numbers, etc)

like

Waste my time by writing a thoughtful cover letter , to NOT even get an interview. Screw those co we letters!!

like

Basically ignore them completely, to be perfectly honest.

like

As a person who use to recruit, cover letters are meaningless

like

I don't believe they are necessary for most roles. I take cover letters with a grain of salt and typically uncover the information I need during an interview. However, I do think they make sense for some high-level or extremely specialized positions.

likesmart

I like them. Gives the applicant a chance to clarify and red flags or talk themselves up if their qualifications don’t meet the requirements at first glance.

like

True, but the cover letter gets you to the interview.

funny

Personally, just why?
All pertinent information is on the resume.

Some of my hiring managers very much like them so it still serves a purpose with some.

like

My perspective: Outdated, not very many hiring managers I know even open them. Seen more as an optional document to provide. Unless an organization requires it, I don’t recommend anyone to bother with it.

Talent Acquisition/HR Professionals: From my experience, most still think they are effective. Almost all never view them during the screening/interviewing process.

like

I hate them; I don't pass them along to the client. I don't have that kind of time to review them and ensure that they are grammatically correct for either clients or hiring managers. We even review thank you letters from the candidates to hiring managers just in case.

like

Depends on the industry and your experience. If you are applying for a job that you know you qualify for but may have more transferable skills than actually applicable skills then a cover letter helps. To be honest, I get impressed when someone sends me a cover letter.

like

I generally feel like they're not needed and pretty antiquated as your resume should speak for itself. But they're helpful for explaining resume gaps, transferable skills if switching industries/careers, or any other things your resume doesn't provide

like

Related Posts

Started a new role and ended up making more $ last year than what is allowed for roth ira contributions (although i’ve already contributed the full amount to my account)

assuming the best path here (before filing taxes) is 1) call vanguard and ask to recharacterize all my contributions last year into a traditional ira 2) convert that traditional ira into a roth 3) start contributing this year to traditional and repeat back door process. Correct thinking?

like

I’ve applied to AE and AM positions at Amazon and Uber but I can never seem to get past the 1st interview. I have 7yrs sales experience and consistently top3 AM, I sell automotive chemicals and provide business development consolation. I used to have the ability to see a breakdown of past sales, but my company took that away (although I was able to save 2019,2020,&2021 numbers). Any advice on how to get past the 1st interview with hiring manager?

like

JPMC 2nd round(managerial round) what kind of questions to expect? How many more rounds left in jpmc interview process?

Will there be a salary discussion also in same round?

like

I’m available for an internal talent acquisition or recruiter role. Over 15 YoE agency side Fortune 500’s in Construction Management, Engineering, Market Research, Accounting, & Insurance. Multiple ATS/CRM. Remote/Hybrid/Onsite. NE Florida open to relocation. $90k+

like

Can someone tell me how is the Crossover program at Fractal? I have an offer from them for a Data Engineering role and I am supposed to attend a 6 weeks training at the start. Can anyone connect here with me? I have multiple doubts.

#Fractal

like

How is the Accenture workday practice? I feel like I used to have a recruiter email me weekly to join pre-pandemic and it’s been silent since then. Did they have layoffs or just a hiring freeze, and can i expect them to start hiring again anytime soon?

like

I had joined Harman on 3rd Oct at 27lpa(25.11 fixed + 1.88 var). I was tagged to MBRDI(Mercedes) proj & I gave 3 interviews for same. But now I'm told that I'm being dropped from the Mercedes account as there was a skill set mismatch. I was hired as scrum master but the expectations from client are either should've have dev exp or springboot microservices knowledge. Not sure how do I go about this situation. I'd dropped some higher ctc offers for joining Mercedes Benz at Harman. Kindly advise.

like

I am selected for Data analyst Role at Optum Grade 26, current ctc 6 lpa, YOE 3 YEARS...What should i ask HR for fixed component, already HAVING AN OFFER OF 13 FIXED...

Hello everyone,

I love in Europe and was wondering how difficult or easy getting remote front end position in a US company would be and if the salary would be the same as a US citizen who lives in the US?

like

Laid off and tired of interviewing for jobs I’d rather swallow glass than actually be hired for. Going to take the $$$ I saved for my first home and travel instead of using it for rent.

likesmart

So, I've been thinking alot and did quite some research but would really love some insight (Accounting vs Fund Accountant)
As a newbie to accounting (completed my graduation and am currently halfway through ACCA), I've worked 3 years in accounting and account operations (AR, AP, Reconciliations, accruals, prepayments etc) and wanted to check out the other side of the coin in Finance.

I recently came across a role of Fund Accountant and wanted to really know what the day to day work looks like

like

Hello! Do you have any work experience as a designer at Yubico? Currently interviewing and would love to know more about their in-house creative culture. Any info is much appreciated.

like

I am applying at Fidelity investment and the applications keep getting rejected. I have applied for at least 10 jobs that i believe are good fit but they keep getting rejected. Is that to do with ATS template resumes or something else? Did anybody else experience this before? How did you mitigate this issue?

like

@Elevance health Hello, I’m considering applying for the Behavioral Health Director position in Iowa. I noticed a lot of positions suddenly opened in this area. Is this a new coverage area or has there been any other changes in the company? Also, any idea what the salary would be for this position. Thank you.

like

Interviewed at Workday and got an offer: OTE $205 with a 70/30 base/commission split. With $40K RSUs. Thoughts? This is for a senior presales consultant, I come from 8 years of industry experience and 1.5 of presales experience.

like
like

Hey guys , what's the work life balance like in Accenture? I have an offer for senior manage role in procurement technology/consulting team source to pay. And what are the benefits will be like? Is work from home allowed like if I work from Spain or Belgium for a week etc instead of UK.

like

McKinsey & Company McKinsey & Company
I applied to the consulting role after getting a referral. But seems like HR is taking too long ( Over 1.5 months now) to respond or reach out.
Any suggestions how can I expedite the application in the vetting process?

like
like

More Posts

My team is 100% remote. I'm looking for simple low/no expense ideas to engage with them as a group and express appreciation. We do bigger things too, but day to day thank yous and funny/good job memes get old after awhile. Any suggestions to freshen things up?

like

best society/locality to live in/near hinjewadi with family ?

office location phase 1

like

I’m generally pretty organized at work because I have to be. I’m a 4th year lawyer and my firm recently started including me in a new transactional practice area. I know now the lead attorney is unorganized and “meets”all deadlines last minute. They hope that I will bring organization to this area. I’ve lived my whole life trying not to live like this. It’s a good opportunity for me to look good if I fix it, but it’s stressful and more practice management than legal work. Continue in comment...

like

Are there any market corrections happening in PwC too?

like

It happens so rarely, I want to document it here: right now, at this moment, life has hit the balance. My schedule for this week is not unmanageable. My teams are excited and I see growth. My kids are happy and thriving in their communities. My husband and I had a rare “date” last night. It’s Sunday and I have a full day ahead of me to do what I want. The sun is shining. My body doesn’t hurt. Thank you, Lord - and please let this continue for at least one more week. O

likeupliftinghelpful

Hello,

Has anyone worked on Adobe Analytics? Implementation and Reporting?

Want to know the pay range/scale.

TIA.

like

Aite-Novarica Group - Novarica historically didn’t have a sales force and has now merged with Aite. Both research and advisory firms.

Question - does anyone have experience in their newly developed sales role as a new business executive? They say it’s fully remote with maybe 25-30% travel to conferences, client on-sites, etc. Would love perspective! 110k base/80k variable offer 🤷🏻‍♂️

like

Any commissioned corps officers here? I have always wanted to go into the public health service but there were never open calls for scientists until a year or so ago. How did the application process go?
My background: PhD and MPH grad. Currently working as a federal contractor.

like

If the US Census would stop loading surveys this year, I'd be fine with that. Seems like there is a new request every week this year.

like

Blue or black?

Post Photo

Hi fishes,
In between LTI & Coforge which one is better in case of project & learning & job security.
I am ios developer with 9 years experience.

like

Any advice for an Account Exec moving from a boutique agency to a full service agency? I wore a LOT of hats at my small agency and will take any advice as I take on this new challenge!

like

I work at a small Midwest ID firm doing mostly MVAs for an Insurance Carrier. Currently have a case where where plaintiff is claiming extensive lost wages from missing tips from working as a bartender/waitress. Place of employment is a strip club, I got a feeling she’s a dancer not a bartender or waitress. But it got me wondering has anyone ran into someone claiming lost wages or revenue from being an OF creator and not being able to crate content due to injury?

This is what we need to be talking about

Post Photo
like

Has anyone used Emissary for a texting platform? Or any other texting platforms you have used or are using?

like

First Motion Motion for Summary Judgment hearing that I am opposing today. Any tips?

like

Pre-mom here...anyone have to manage IVF while commuting to clients? With all the pre-retrieval ultrasounds + injections, retrieval surgery fun l am feeling less than supported.

like

Alternatives to Power BI for Mac users? Trying to branch out of excel. Reports aren’t too stable with excel

likefunny

Hello Guys,

Need some suggestion. I have knowledge of python pandas and numpy, Advance Excel,SQL and AWS QuickSight . Knows a bit of Data Central ETL, AWS Redshift and some Tableau Dashboarding. Can you folks suggest what job profile I can apply or programs to learn and so I can choose certain career path. Bit of confused right now as I dont know what to do and stuck at a job I dont like whose main purpose is to develop SQL queries. Your inputs will help a lot in shaping my career.

like

Additional Posts in Human Resources

Hi, do you think the current recruitment process is broken ? It is biased by the use of AI ?

like

PHR vs SHRM vs AIRS? Which one should I pursue?

like

I’m looking for alternatives to the big survey companies like Mercer. From time to time I need data (for example on vehicle allowances) but I can’t pay $1,000 for one report or $30k for all the data. My company and budget are just too small. Does anyone have some smaller, less expensive options they turn to? I’m willing to pay but Mercer prices. Thanks!!

like

Does anyone have any advice on passing the PHR the first time around?

Does anyone know if it’s possible to see if an company filed its Affirmative Action Plan?

like

Is it common practice for employee relations teams to have a policy that strongly discourages supervisors from corresponding with terminated employees? Cont’d...

like

So, a recruiter gave me feedback that my lack SPHR or SHRM-SCP is causing my resume to be knock out by AI and human recruiters despite my position and work history in Multinationals and being in Technology. They suggested that we put SPHR ( Lapsed). I let it lapse in 2017. What is your opinion? Plus if I were to take another certification - should I take SPHR or SHRM-SCP?

like

Hi everyone! I received a response on my job application at the company and I've been asked as interview questions over email that as an HR manager in a standalone role for a new country office opening, "what would I like to achieve in the 1st 90 days?"

Any responses you can share either from your experience or thoughts on how best I can answer this?

Note, I'm stuck on this question because the previous question to this asked about my priorities as HRM in the first 30days?"

Please help!!

like

Does your place of employment offer wellness programs and if so what? If not, why? What would you like to see?

like

Anyone actually keep their PHR active? I got my cert in 2013 and have done nothing since.

like

Hi all, as a Talent Acquisition Partner that is looking to start expending my Professional education, would you recommend pursuing SHRM-CP certification?

like

I work in Fintech Startup and we are recently re-evaluating our comp structures.

My Boss and I were going back-and-forth regarding the structure for our engineering and developer team.

Do most Dev teams have a bonus structure in addition to their base? If so, what metrics is this bonus based off of?
Or do the Engineers just get a higher annual raise than other depts?

All insight greatly appreciated!!

like

What would you do if you found out an executive was speaking poorly about you and your work performance to other employees? Is this a case where you would get HR involved? Have a conversation with the individual? Let it go? The comments are confirmed to have happened at an event that the offended party was planning/running, and the exec said negative comments to two other people at the company about the event and their work, and also said the person looked “too stressed.”

helpful

Anyone know an EY recruiter or RM? I just applied to an RM job posting and would like to make a personal connection.

What are the standard fees for outsourcing consultancy work?
I've been working with a newly established consultancy business. Until now I've been paid day rates or project rates.
I've been invited to lead, build and manage the HR consultancy.
What are reasonable fee structures?
1. If they source work and give it to me to complete, what is a fair percentage?
2. If I source work and complete it, what should I 'pay' them given that it's under their 'brand'?

like

Can you share your experience with PEO’s does it make your job in HR easier?

like

Are there any companies in the cyber/security space who offer paid military leave?

like

Can anyone share their employee recognition programs on tenure?

like

Anyone in the food manufacturing industry? My friend is a Regulatory consultant being offered a Regulatory Mgr job $115 salary in East coast. She has 23 yrs experience, MS in Food Science. Has worked for big companies like McCormick, Frito Lays, Hersheys, Pepsico. It is not my industry so I don’t know… but it sounds very low. Thoughts?

like

What is the craziest thing someone has done to get a job at your company and it actually worked?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal