What are your honest thoughts on cover letters - are they outdated, or even relevant at this point? Do you look at them?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I never read them as a recruiter, however, I think that any of my candidates that had taken the time to do a quality cover letter that laid out why they are interested and why they are a fit, usually performed better in interview because they had already spent time thinking about the fit.

They are nice in theory. When I'm reviewing candidates for a job that I'm hiring for, I only look at cover letters under 2 criteria:
1) it's a supervisor/manager role
2) there are more than 10 applicants
If it's a lower level job, I find most people don't include cover letters.

Recent IconRecent

I hate them, personally!

like

Same. I don’t want to “hear” the brag or read the fluff. I want to see the resume and move on.

like

I don't have time to read them, they're all the same template basically repeating their resume or bragging, sometimes it even shows they're a bad communicator and it actually hurts their chances. Only time I find it relevant if they're changing industries or have a career gap or something they need to explain.

What I do enjoy getting is portfolios and I think its getting more popular since I've been getting them more often (for non design roles/roles that dont traditionally require one). Instead of cover letters I've gotten slides of projects they've worked on that really lets me see in detail what their resume can't show in words.

like

When I was a recruiter I never even opened them. I just need to see if you have relevant experience or not.

like

They are completely outdated. I only do them now if someone specifically asks for one. As a hiring manager, I don't even look at them if someone sends one in.

like

Cover letters have run their course. I'd rather read a straight-to-the-point resume. No need for flowery words.

likehelpful

They don't hold as much weight as they once did, because I may also scan someone's social media profiles, or be looking for a very specific skill set on their resume.

like

By social media I hope you mean only LinkedIn bc outside of that it isn't work related and highly inappropriate unless they actually direct you to it on their resume.

like

I would be impressed if I received one. I do like to see cover letters for positions that requiring good writing skills.

like

Depends on the industry. I’d say create one and have it in your back pocket. You can always adjust it to the role if needed. I see this more as a requirement is academic environments. Bottom line, have one you can work quickly if needed.

like

I agree with this comment. And DEFINITELY ensure you do not send one to a recruiter or hiring manager addressed to someone of a different name. ( You may be surprised how many do this)
Also if you send one, ensure it is customized for the particular role you are applying to.

likesmart

I never look at them

like

I will not read cover letters - I’m trying to skim 50+ resumes a week, I want to see concise statements with lots of details (tech tool experience, data around sales numbers, etc)

like

Waste my time by writing a thoughtful cover letter , to NOT even get an interview. Screw those co we letters!!

like

Basically ignore them completely, to be perfectly honest.

like

As a person who use to recruit, cover letters are meaningless

like

I don't believe they are necessary for most roles. I take cover letters with a grain of salt and typically uncover the information I need during an interview. However, I do think they make sense for some high-level or extremely specialized positions.

likesmart

I like them. Gives the applicant a chance to clarify and red flags or talk themselves up if their qualifications don’t meet the requirements at first glance.

like

True, but the cover letter gets you to the interview.

funny

Personally, just why?
All pertinent information is on the resume.

Some of my hiring managers very much like them so it still serves a purpose with some.

like

My perspective: Outdated, not very many hiring managers I know even open them. Seen more as an optional document to provide. Unless an organization requires it, I don’t recommend anyone to bother with it.

Talent Acquisition/HR Professionals: From my experience, most still think they are effective. Almost all never view them during the screening/interviewing process.

like

I hate them; I don't pass them along to the client. I don't have that kind of time to review them and ensure that they are grammatically correct for either clients or hiring managers. We even review thank you letters from the candidates to hiring managers just in case.

like

Depends on the industry and your experience. If you are applying for a job that you know you qualify for but may have more transferable skills than actually applicable skills then a cover letter helps. To be honest, I get impressed when someone sends me a cover letter.

like

I generally feel like they're not needed and pretty antiquated as your resume should speak for itself. But they're helpful for explaining resume gaps, transferable skills if switching industries/careers, or any other things your resume doesn't provide

like

Related Posts

Anyone hiring mechanical or materials engineers? I can do both.

like

After weeks of no contact Goldman Sachs have finally come back to me with an offer of £75k for an associate role within Global markets ops (collateral management) in London. I initially gave them salary expectation of £80-85k and have 2 competing offers around £80k range. I’ve tried to negotiate and tried to ask for higher but they won’t budge or match my other offers. They’re saying the pay is in line with the peer group and my experience (7.5 years). Am I being lowballed? Goldman Sachs

like

Hi All

Need some assistance today I have completed 2nd round of interview with IBM where it can be called as managiral and HR where there not much tech talk but having salary and location discussion.

So can I expect offer from IBM or there will be more round of interview.
If offer can be expected how much time IBM took to release the offer.

Thanks and Regards

like

Just had my initial interview for a position at Millipore Sigma. Any advice for the in-person interview and next steps?

like

Hi all, anyone looking for referral ping me Tech Mahindra

Post Photo
like

So I’ve reeaallyyy been trying to get to Google for years now. Recently applied for 2 roles with a referral. Anything I can do besides wait right now? Sorry a bit anxious

like

Hi fishes, can you please help out.i have an offer of these companies. Which one to join for growth and learning?

Bajaj finserv , SBIcard , Cognizant, Evaluserve, or EXL services
for data science position .

likeuplifting

CRO companies as an exit? Yes or no?

like

Hello,
Would anyone be willing to give a referral to
CB Information Services, Inc. ? I’m happy to provide any information. Blessings to all

like

Any know any in-house or bigger agencies hiring for issues/crisis comms roles? Currently working at a big agency with 2 YOE but feeling underpaid and looking into new opportunities.

like

Hey Everyone.
Applied through the GS jobs portal on 10/5 for the early careers program in SLC, one position in trade and transaction management, the other in client services/sales support.
Heard back through the recruiter on 10/8 and just got my HireVue last night (10/13) and completed it today 10/14. Both of the positions are currently saying “Resume Under Review”

Any insight to this at all? How long it’s taken to get a super day invite back? How soon after did you get a rejection or offer?

like

Silly question. Is SAP functional consulting br called as real consulting ??
Am kinda feeling underwhelmed by the role

Hello all, looking for a digital marketing role in account management, content creation, email, SEO, and social media. I have eight years experience and looking in Chicago.

like

Recent college graduate here and really struggling to find a job in the Bay Area. What’s the best way to get my foot in the door at an agency? Applying online and sending emails hasn’t led to much

I interviewed for Data Analyst role at EY, it went well and the job sounds great, but I'm a bit hesitant to leave PwC because I really like the firm and I'm just 8 months in my job as an associate at a subgroup of ITS that has some focus on technology and analytics but it's mostly tax compliance.

I do want to transition to data analytics but I'm not sure if it's a good idea to go to another big 4, or maybe just look for a position in industry.

Any advice or similar experience?

like

Hiya! Wondering if I could connect with anyone at TikTok for a job referral. I’m so ready to make the leap into tech - and I know my best shot is via a referral.

It’s a non tech role (corp comms).

Would love to have a virtual coffee chat and the coffee is on me. Thanks!

Post Photo
likeuplifting

I have a written offer I'm negotiating and finished final rounds with another company last Monday. I'm strongly leaning towards the company I just wrapped up interviewing with, but don't want to send red flags asking for timing. I assume one follow up asking about timing is fine, any thoughts on mentioning the other offer though? It's leverage but I don't want it to come back to bite me. Anyone been in a similar situation before?

like

Hello, anyone willing to give me a referral for KPMG. 20 YOE Supplier Diversity Experience KPMG

like

Hiring for the position of Business Analyst (Public Sector Consulting) at swiss MNC that's is global professional services provider offering research, analytics, and data management services.
Preferred background in Social sector with 1-2 years of work experience.
Qualifications:
M.A. Public policy, Gender, Social work etc.
from TISS, PHFI, Azim premji, O.P. Jindal, ISPP

Please share your name/LinkedIn and Email IDs to know more about the JD.

Work Location: Currently Remote (Gurgaon)

Thanks!

like

More Posts

hi everyone! I just received an offer to join Deloitte Digital‘s client strategy consulting group at the SC-level for 140k with a 10K signing bonus. Is this on par with the rest of the firm or should I counter with a higher number? 3 Years of relevant experience. Thank you!

like

Bain & Company I applied to Bain PEG associate in late Jan and received an invite for online test in late March but have received no response so far. Is it normal that the application takes this long at Bain? Or does it mean I was rejected?Bain & Company

like

Www.helenesnotes call now to sign up for the fall! 516-474-6181 Online lessons! Give them or yourself something fun, positive and good to do! All ages 5 and up including Adults!

Post Photo

Hello Sharks...

Cleared all rounds in
SAP Labs for Linux SRE... Going into Final HR Salary negotiation round tomorrow... This is actually my very first switch...

Current company: TCS..
Current CTC : 15.2 LPA.
YOE: 13 Years.
Tech Stack: linux/UNIX and cloud architect. Having one offer from Kyndryl of 24 LPA. Having another offer from Oracle at 28 LPA fixed.

How much can I ask "SAP labs" without impacting the candidature. I am thinking to ask max. from 36 LPA... Kindly give ur feedback...

like

On average, how many years of experience does it take to make partner?

like

Should I submit a two week or three week notice? Does it matter?

like

Will the housing market be corrected (take a dip even if it’s minor)? Specially referring to SoCal and prices only gone up since the pandemic.

like

AWS vs Azure stack for Cloud Data Platform? Data Lake > Data Warehouse > Modeling (AAS for Azure, not sure what it is in AWS) > easy ingestion for any use case across an enterprise (reporting, ML, etc

like

Any recommended platform to explore remote work( as permanent employee) in IT ?
Skills : Full stack (Java, spring boot, microservices, angular)

like

Currently looking for Tech consulting/ Implementation consultant/ privacy roles in London. I have both CIPP/E and CIPM.
Please let me know if you know any roles that are available? Or any recruitment agencies you can refer me to

Thank you!

Made it past two Skype/Phone interviews for an experienced hire senior associate 2 with KPMG, have the final interview in person at the NYC office. Only scheduled for 30 minutes, is that normal?

like

Who can refer me to Lyft please?

like

What does work-life balance look like in the Corporate Strategy group? Average hours / week, weekend work?

like

120K per year dental on sight technician, lead 3D printer and Mil repair /Maintenance. 3-D Dental scanner trainer and technician. 120K sound about right? Living and working in Texas Dental Office with 8 providers.

like

What are some PDs or education courses that you desperately wish you had before this year or even during? For me it would be how to create simple rubrics that can be applied to students of all different skill levels.

like

I joined the current company 2 months ago and have a female direct report up for Assoc. Director. We get along great unless I make a suggestion to her and then she's unreceptive.

Example, I made a certificate of appreciation for someone on her/my team yesterday. I asked how the person reacted and it was glossed over, indicating the person didn't get the recognition from my direct report.

Ideas?

like

This is why I secretly avoid 1:1s with my manager!

Post Photo
likefunny

How are projects given in EY India LLP technology consulting. Do client call us and give the task or what.!?

like

Is hike dependent on CTC or just 5% uniform for all?

like

Currently I'm working as a BA, have 1.8 years of experience getting 11 Fixed.
I'm married and live with my wife and parents.
Currently I'm the sole earner.
I confused in which area should i improve my skills. When I see my friend who are SDE getting 30-40 LPA, In which field I will getting fast growth also I want to shift to Mumbai or Pune for permanently, currently I'm working in Gurgaon.

like

Additional Posts in Human Resources

Has anyone used All In One Poster Company for their Labor Law posters? If so, would you recommend?

like

Anyone actually keep their PHR active? I got my cert in 2013 and have done nothing since.

like

Does anyone know if it’s possible to see if an company filed its Affirmative Action Plan?

like

Has anyone worked at Apple after having worked at a Big4? What are the major cultural differences/morale at Apple compared to the vibe at a Big4 specifically while working in Talent?

like

Fellow HR Professionals,

Curious to know how you are handling current inflation rates versus 3% merit increases. Are you adjusting merit increases for inflation? If not, how are you handling those conversations?

like

I have 2 years of sales experience but am looking to make a career change into HR? Any tips of how to standout on my resume or any general advice? Thanks!

like

Are there any companies in the cyber/security space who offer paid military leave?

like

Does anyone else check in with their employees within 45 days of their hire? If not, how are you guys going about employee experience and engagement/onboarding?

like

I'm looking for an an automated callout platform. Does anyone here have a recommendation?

Hi! Anyone taken SHRM-CP exam recently and have any tips on studying or taking the exam? TIA.

Any thoughts on the best certifications to get in order to help move forward? I have considered the CCP from World at Work, but it’s fairly pricey to get by the time you wrap up everything. I was looking at both SHRM-CP and SPHR. Everyone that I have spoken to has the SHRM, but that’s also only looking at individuals in a small geographic footprint and within 3-4 different companies. I was hoping to get some thoughts on this from others? Thanks

I want to get my masters in HR, but I also want to get my phr.. is it better to get one over the other? Or should I do both. Are there any masters hr program someone can recommend?

like

Hey everyone! Do any of you use an onboarding software that automated the process? I want to be able to smooth out the process and make it easier for the new hire. I also want to know if any of you use a company that creates company swag for new hires. Any guidance would be greatly appreciated.

like

Can anyone share their employee recognition programs on tenure?

like

Any suggestions for continuing to sharpen my skills as a recruiter when there's no TA manager and no "mentorship" in the company? I'm a 1-man recruiting team and the rest of the HR team is not as knowledgeable in the scope of recruiting.

Thank you!

like

I work in Fintech Startup and we are recently re-evaluating our comp structures.

My Boss and I were going back-and-forth regarding the structure for our engineering and developer team.

Do most Dev teams have a bonus structure in addition to their base? If so, what metrics is this bonus based off of?
Or do the Engineers just get a higher annual raise than other depts?

All insight greatly appreciated!!

like

Anyone have good insight into the company/culture for: Sun Life Financial, Silver Point Capital, and EQT Partners?

like

Where do you find state-specific information for drafting handbook addendums? I’m moreso looking for a summary basically of what is required to be in a handbook per state and not having much luck.

like

How hard is Customer support analyst role in
Workday and how much are they paying Workday

like

What would be some of the 'must-ask' questions for LMS vendors before giving the go-ahead?

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal