Bain & Company What is the difference between the people and org practice at MBB and Big 4? I understand the strategy work from MBB is quite different but feels like they are doing pretty much the same in their HR consulting practice 🤔 McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company Deloitte EY PwC

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I've only ever worked at McK so my view is limited by that, but I do think there are a few differences:
1) I've done a number of projects with B4 firms; more often than not, we're advising on the talent strategy and B4 is PMOing it. There have been some hugely talented B4 people on those projects but they are relegated to more admin tasks, at least when McK is also around
2) longer projects. Those same B4 people have been on the same project for 1+years whereas McK folks cycle out and get more variety of experience
3) more senior exposure. Related to 1 above, but I think McK get more access to top mgmt.

likehelpful

Thanks for sharing!

OP, I think our talent strategy and org design practices are fairly strong as in not PMO but actual strat. Can't speak to the other B4 though

like

MBB can be compared to EY P

Rest of EY is more comparable to Accenture or other B4

funny

Lol ok

like

There’s overlap for sure but big 4 will have HR projects around like PMO for an HR workday upgrade, for example. They also are more likely to be BU specific. You wouldn’t see this at MBB’s org practices - much more focused on org wide operating model, talent strategy, etc.

Related Posts

For those in big 4, how much time between accepting an offer and start date have you been able to ask for? Is a month feasible/how should one phrase it? Two weeks just doesn’t feel like enough with this heavy burnout/having to wrap up deals at old firm

like

When do you actually start to feel useful in FDD? I've been in FDD for 6 going to 7 months and sometimes I still feel like I'm doing the grunt work non critical thinking.

like

EY 🐟 , could anyone share their experience with EY’s Big Data practice? What are typical engagements like / scale of engagements? Would love to chat with someone on the team if anyone’s willing!

like

MBB fish: what happens when an Associate/Consultant is found to be enrolled in a PT MBA, after not telling anyone during the interview process? Is that cause for termination?

like

How should i go about rejecting an MBB offer after signing the actual offer(a few weeks ago)? I have some personal reasons, circumstances have changed and i will focus on different thing

Hey, i’ll be joining PA Consulting at the end of this year.

Does anyone know how the business is structured? My contract says i’m part of the Sourcing, IT Strategy & Corporate Services capability. I’ve shown an interest in Finance transformation given my experience and wondered if Finance transformation is within that capability?

like

Bain & Company McKinsey & Company Bain & Company Boston Consulting Group what are the main services you offer within M&A group?

like

How is performance measured at MBB?

like

Are there any RPA UiPath openings in any of the big 4? Is lateral recruitment happening for these roles? Thanks in Advance

like

Thoughts about MBB offices in Doha? How’s the culture, WLB, range of projects, etc.?

like

Hi
Would love to get your opinion on this-
I am planning on applying to business school this year in round 1 and round 2. I am in india working at D. I have received an offer to work with another big 4 in London as manager with their consulting team starting June. The role is definitely a step up in terms of responsibilities from my current role as a senior consultant. Do you think it might hamper my business school application changing jobs so close to round 1? Have been at D for 4 yrs

like

What are the hours like in Deal Advisory KPMG?

like

For those of you who are currently working at or have worked in the past in Deloitte, McKinsey, etc - What is it like working at the big 4 consultancy as a UX designer? Do you think you are able to get strong portfolios out of the work? Do you think it would help you career? Asking as someone considering to move from in-house to a consultancy.

likehelpful

Does anyone know of experience of persons from big 4 us international tax working in UK?

What is the process for paying back your sign on bonus. Thinking about leaving Big 4 within clawback period and would like to hear perspectives/advice

like

What are placement levels like at Top MBA programs from PE Ops? Is it more in line with MBB or would a two year stint in PE ops boost your application significantly

like

What groups are best at tax valuations (e.g. IP and other asset valuations)?

Is it usually done by tax service lines or advisory service lines?

like

Hello to all b4 🐠 - what's your view on the cultural differences between b4 in Australia? Feel free to put down a ranking to your best knowledge, anecdotal or not. Thanks!

like

A quick note about what I’ve experienced, in my decade long career, is the real advantage of MBB or FAANG - it gives you a shot at stretch roles that are outside your expertise. Not all the time or even most of the time compared to better candidates with specific experience for the role but gives you this wildcard shot at a vast array of opportunities.

like

What are some of the best consulting firms for a software engineer? Is MBB still considered elite in this area too?

like

More Posts

Hey Fishes, What is the BGV process at HSBC? I got an offer for analyst, but the date of joining is about a month later. They are saying time is required for BGV. ICan anyone please tell if there are chances of them declining the offer? HSBC Thanks

like

There is an opportunity that I’m currently interviewing for that is very interesting to me. I’m interviewing two other places but I’m not responding to LinkedIn emails for other positions. The other positions don’t interest me as much. On one hand I don’t want to waste time prepping for all positions and rather put that time only for the ones that I have going on, on the other hand I feel like what is that falls through. Wondering if I’m making the right choice

like

Creatives who have done launches - how do you present your work in your book? Doubt anyone wants to see all 25 or so things I worked on but want to show the breadth.

like

Looking at the President and Vice President elect speak!

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Hi,
Can someone refer me at NielsenIQ for Data analytics positions?

hiya! So I was wondering how I can get a remote job in without any tech or call service experience? I have 4-5 years of customer service experience and I’m taking an swe bootcamp at the moment any suggestions?

like

Looking for book recommendations; any favorites? Interested in both fiction and educational/self-improvement (for example, investment / finance books, time management, etc). I feel my vocab is...

like

Any fish have experience with Marsh Risk Consulting? Good, bad, ugly? Thanks.

like

Would like to spend 3 weeks in New Zealand (when COVID permits) and trying to understand what a good budget would be for 2 people? Using points for airfare but otherwise renting rooms (air bnb/hotel) and a car. Both north and south island. Any thoughts?

like

Fishes at T2 firms, is the consulting path worth much? Starting at a T2 soon and everyone talks about accelerated careers or high exit ops but I don’t actually know what that truly translates too. It seems a bit abstract

like
like

I have seen that Some people are seriously demeaning Publicis Sapient looks like they have a personal grudge. I would suggest to connect with your HR and manager in PS or look for right people on LinkedIn.

likefunny

Hi everyone I am asking for referrals for CVShealth and United Healthcare. There a few positions I have my eye on. A referral would be appreciated thank you Stay cool out there

like

Can anyone help me with the tax deduction for the salary of 60 k in Netherlands?

like

I'm currently a Scrum Master that is looking to make an exit! I have a new profound love for data! However when looking at the salary for data analytics, it appears that I would have to take a pay cut. I currently make 123k in the state of NC...any insight? Should I transition to Data Engineering instead?

like

How can I make friends in Chicago?

like

Going in house is the move, right?

like

I love my neighbors.

Post Photo
likefunny

Salary credit timings? Icici bank

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Any recommendations for a work desk?
Not looking for something too big or pricey. Easy assembly / disassembly is a plus.
I see foldable desks going for $100. Any foldable standing desks out there?

like

Question re. Global Entry - expires end of December.. close locations are sold out on appointments until March. Can’t seem to call them, but read somewhere they are offering extensions. Anyone know??

like

What industries are good for stability and lower stress?

No snark, please. I’ve had some health issues come up and was told to find a lower stress environment.

like

So this might be a better place to post this and ask this question: Uncle D has announced explicitly that most people won’t get a pay raise & bonus this year except for those promoted and high performers. Amid this crisis, are companies including other big 3, MBB, FAANG, boutique consulting firms still giving high raises and issue stocks? Can you share the impact from your firm?

like

Any book recommendations for philosophy, psychology, and business? Or any book you read last year changed your values? Going to fly international, gonna read it on flight. 😍

like

My younger brother has the opportunity to do Software Engineering at FAANG and consulting at MBB as a fresh grad. I told him to do SWE, but I’m afraid I’m giving him biased advise cause I’m jaded in this industry. If you were me, what would you advise him?

likehelpful

Need a good recommendation for a home office chair. I work from home a lot and need a new chair. My new one isn’t cutting it for me- it’s not comfy and I have lower back pain.

like

Planning to do a PRM or FRM qual. How useful is it to move from Big 4 Risk and reg consulting to industry? Finding it hard to get anything other than non-PM roles

like

Is a JD or an MBA more useful for consulting? Assuming M7 MBA or T10 JD.

funnylike

Denied for an mba program after I thought I crushed the interview..... sad

like

Thoughts on EW MBA from Booth/Kellogg/Haas. Currently SC at Deloitte and want to transition to tier 1 consulting firms

like

Anyone at L.E.K. Consulting willing to connect?
Trying to see what kind of project y'all do and pay, etc. I really like the fact that all projects are growth strategy and M&A (exactly what I want to do).

like

My current firm didn’t require a case interview. Would like to leave soon, but want to have my ducks in a row. How can I best prepare for Big 4 and MBB interviews? How did you all do it?

like

Definitely not a fan of Westin's "Eat Well" proposition. I'm working in the room at 2:00 AM and the most appetizing menu item is a cold turkey avocado and arugula wrap. I just want a burger and fries!

like

who are the consultants traveling with rimowa suitcases... that’s where I want to work! lol

like

For implementation of a project , Is delivery important or leadership ? If only one had to be chosen rather which will you give more weightage

like

9 pm on Sundays are not same anymore after Succession finale last week. What y’all doing to fill this void?

like

Is Deloitte WLB for a S. Consultant really that bad? Got a great offer from them, but everyone I’ve talked to has nothing good to say about the firm or their work culture

like

Does B4 let people go the same day as their resignation only if they’re going to a direct competitor? How about MBB or a tier 2 consulting firm?

Have people been let go immediately in case they go to FAANG or other industry firms?

like

How did you frame going back to your old firm? Was it awkward?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal