{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "What’s the youngest people manager you’ve encountered, in consulting or industry? Met a 23 year old manager that’s running projects and has 2 counselees. So bad ass.", "post_id": "5becfb168a964800186dceb5", "reply_count": 16, "vote_count": 7, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting", "feed_type": "crowd" }

What’s the youngest people manager you’ve encountered, in consulting or industry? Met a 23 year old manager that’s running projects and has 2 counselees. So bad ass.

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Generally leery of wunderkinds, especially in an industry like ours where a solid grasp of PowerPoint and big talk can get you quite far.

Being young and awesome is great, but the important thing is that they're awesome.


Honesty I don't care how good you are, I'm not letting you run a real consulting project 1 year out of undergrad


If they’ve demonstrated a working knowledge of the industry, have the soft skills to complete the job, and are mature for their age, why can’t recent grads be given opportunities to stretch early on? I feel like the individuals that are concerned are behind the curve for their role/age and are worried about losing opportunities to promising up-and-comers...


You guys took this way too far. This “individual” is a first year manager, and is running their 2nd project. Did perfectly fine on their first one and is doing great on the second.
Side note - they also worked in industry all four years of undergrad and took night classes. I’m assuming that’s why they have a leg up


SC1: truth is, they aren’t. And It is not about not giving them the opportunities to do a stretch role, it’s how well they do it and if they can maintain it. Which sadly, a lot of these early promotes cannot maintain it in the long run and they just screw the team morale over


Nope, Big 4.


^fair statement. If they aren’t consistently performing at that level, and haven’t demonstrated a pattern of success, then I’d agree. Ultimately, I’m against prohibiting people from opportunities because of tenure if they’ve demonstrated that they can perform at that advanced level. That being said, it seems like a poor decision was made to promote this individual, as they’re not performing at the level they should be.


There are a few firms that do this - a path straight from analyst to manager.

They always make claims that it's about their excellent performance or something like that, but 9/10 times it's because that person has family connections in companies and/or industries that the firm wants to break into to.

It's a gamble, but it can get your foot in the door somewhere important. If it just means burning out some kid for access, it's usually worth it.



I was a PM at 22 on a project of 13. At 24, I was solely parachuted into troubled projects that were managed by old farts like M1 to bring them back on track. I am now 29 and manage some of our largest global transformations out there with 50+ consultants.

Higher age does generally mean more experienced, and experience is good ... but it doesn’t mean that young folks cant pull it off. PMing is a lot about common sense, being organized and able to manage relationships. If you are confident and awesome, you can do it no matter the age.

You can get away with very young managers doing repeatable work like audits and assessments.

No so much with more complicated work. I’ve see a lot of people plateau after early promo.

Wunderkinds are all over. Our clients see right through them

SC1 - maybe the current project is not a good fit for them?

That could definitely be the case. Although they made have demonstrated the soft skills necessary to manage, perhaps they’re lacking in industry knowledge because of their limited experience?

There are a lot of hidden details which people miss - yeah the manager is doing fine and so is the project but what about the team

I worked for a manager with 2 years of consulting experience and no industry experience - the project was fine but we worked all weekends and lake late nights

Additional Posts

❤️ when the intern looks fly asf on the first day in their new work outfit; looks like complete ass after having to wake up early three days in a row


What's the going salary range for Associate Directors in media these days? Hoping to negotiate with some clarity and realistic expectations. Thanks!


Poloniex will not generate any deposit addresses when I try to transfer ... anyone else have this issue?

Is it ok to ask a friend if you can put their name down so you can order 2x dinner at 11pm so you can have lunch for the next day cause you’re tired of eating ice soup? what a time to be alive


Expert principal and VP roles at Bain: worth going for? Would you consider it a viable /interesting alternative to a partner route?


How do you keep up to date with what's happening in your industry and/or the global economy? Any recommended sources?


Is there a way to simultaneously merge spreadsheets (or workbooks) and decide which columns/rows to update without a third party tool?


WSJ nailed it this morning

Post Photo

Any tips on finding a good mental health therapist?


Hi! Does anyone have information on Business Planning roles with Apple and / or would be open to referring me? T2 strategy consultant with ~2 YOE. Thank you!

India war memorial

Post Photo

I teach beginning elementary ELs. As we prepare for remote teaching, the administration doesn’t plan to distribute any technology. How to I help families and non readers access activities?!?


Futures way in the green. Will be interesting to see what happens in the morning, anyone else notice a trend of futures flipping before market open over the past week? (Red to green, green to red)


Been apartment hunting w my partner who is left brained and still in school (aka no income)... and I’m a designer...I care about aesthetics, my environment impacts my mood, but I feel like he thinks I’m being ridiculous or superficial and could care less about how the place looks as long as the price is cheap.


Let's say I can't get a product or marketing job in tech, but I could get in via sales or customer success. Does working in those roles pigeonhole you, or is it easy to switch later? If you take a job as a customer success mgr for ads, or as a partnership mgr for learning solutions for industry X, are you going to get stuck in those products (ads, learning solutions), roles (CS, sales/partnerships), or target industry (X)?


Just switched from end user environment to consulting. Any other consultants willing to share salary and their role? I’m at $140k as SC which I thought was pretty decent until seeing what consultants in other sectors made. I’ve got plenty of certain and skills to back it up


Asking for general inquiry: Can in the long term the economy and retirement system as is set up survive. Growth and retirement in the US is heavily influenced by an growing population. By all estimates, well peak at a global population around 2050 and then start slowly declining. Without growth in population how will the market and the economy realistically grow?


Every company is a saas company nowadays……


Just signed an offer with mckinsey and recruiter told me the latest I can join in November 19th.

I have a vacation that I've already planned from 12/7 - 12/14. Should I let the recruiter know about this plan? Is this something that I can work out with my manager once I'm assigned?


I had a lot of trouble at work this year. Was depressed and had poor project experiences. So I wanted an exit and i got it. A good one.

I also got an offer from a more prestigious consulting company (won’t name it), which based on this year and also what everyone is telling me, would end poorly. I had always wanted to work at this place and applied many times over the last decade.

I know this is insanely privileged and I’m very fortunate. But I’m also sad to recognize my limitations.


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the Fishbowl app

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or