{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "When negotiating salary and being asked if you currently get a bonus, would you \"lie\" if it helps you to get paid more? Is this considered taboo and is there any way a potential employer could find out if you weren't truthful about your current salary/bonuses? Is it illegal if you were to accept an offer for that potential employer to question you about your previous companies pay structure?", "post_id": "619f14b80269e6003d026454", "reply_count": 2, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "553769a790f5eebe1d2a0f92", "bowl_name": "Finance" }

When negotiating salary and being asked if you currently get a bonus, would you "lie" if it helps you to get paid more? Is this considered taboo and is there any way a potential employer could find out if you weren't truthful about your current salary/bonuses? Is it illegal if you were to accept an offer for that potential employer to question you about your previous companies pay structure?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

They can't ask you how much you currently make

like

I’ve always heard it’s illegal for an HR person to directly ask you for proof of your salary. I don’t know if that’s actually true but in my experience, none of the big reputable firms ask for proof. E.g. Wells Fargo, Deloitte. I’d say yes to saying your salary is more than what you’re actually making. If the firm you’re interviewing with asks for evidence, they’re likely not great to work for if they don’t take your word for even that situation. As a note, I’ve negotiated offers from 2 of the Big 4 and 2 GSIBs by stating that my current salary was higher than it actually was (within reasonable limits) and never got questioned on it.

like

Related Posts

Is anyone familiar with the transaction / deal analytics business at Big 4, or PwC specifically? What is the work and salary band(s) like, specifically in APAC market?

like

Bonus number? Anyone?

like

When did you feel like you were successful? People around me think it’s impressive that I work at Deloitte; however, I’m miserable and hate the work I’m doing. Just accepted another job that others would deem a dream company and salary but I’m just afraid of being miserable there too. I just don’t feel like I’m good enough, will be happy, or be in a position where I feel like I’m successful as others.

like

2 years experience at Accenture , expecting offer from deloitte S&O this week. Will they give me consultant title? If so, salary for nyc ?

like

I have just over 3 years of experience (2.5 as an Analyst and .5 as a software engineer) and all doing .Net coding. I live in the Denver area, and work remote. What salary is everyone getting for that kind of position? I make 97,000 with a 10% profit sharing bonus (up to 10%). I've also only been with my company under 6 months and got a raise when I got my current job. Any thoughts?

like

In TCS salary breakup I found there are 2 component of variable pay one is monthly and 2nd is quarterly both having same digit in breakup. I don’t understand whether I will be getting monthly variable as fixed and QVA as per the quarterly performance of myself team and company.

like

I’m looking into an M role at Accenture Strategy in their Supply Chain space. Can anyone speak to that practice and expected salary band? Any and all insights appreciated. Thanks.

like

Hi All, Need feedback on HERE Technologies. anyone working there. Mainly around variable/bonus. Is it not part of ctc and how is the payout?

like

How are the hikes and bonus to Deloitte USI S&O compared to Deloitte Cloud practice (Oracle, SAP)? Are they same for all the capabilities? I heard S&O is one of best capability within Deloitte USI. That's the reason behind this question.

like

PwCers, is all of west coast except for san francisco considered tier 2 salary range?

like

Adops folks out there, what’s your title, years of experience, brand pub or agency side, area of focus, market, salary range? Go.

like

What's the manager salary band for KPMG in a US low cost state (not California and not NY) .. starting salary to be specific? Not necessarily very tenured...

like

what is the starting salary for director in advisory?

like

Strategy& folks, seeing as we are getting close to bonus payouts, have you heard of any more lay offs? Wondering if it's safe to come up for air yet.

like

M and SM salary bands for Deloitte Digital in NYC? Thank you

like

How difficult (relatively) is it to recruit for an MBB London office from a T15 US MBA program compared to a US office? I know it's not done often, but is that mainly due to the salary difference?

like

Salary cut for a new life in a different state coming from New York. Do you feel the 20% difference or it’s all a wash because the cost of living is lower?

like

Overtime: who gets it? (Apart from legally required due to salary thresholds). From what I heard, some departments get it, some don’t. Does anyone have any insight on this?

like

Anyone know bonus as % of salary when getting promoted from S3 to M1 in NY? Also % raise?

like

Long shot, but anyone have any thoughts about McDonald’s legal department in Chicago? Culture, compensation, opportunities for advancement, etc…

like

Additional Posts

Hello, can you please tell if I can travel to India, while there is a pending LCA for change of location? I don’t need to get any stamping done, this is my only concern.

like

When does your account team include you on client communications? When do they not?

like

Need some help (!!) from the women who work in tech in this bowl. The company I work for has a parental leave policy that is only 2 weeks paid leave (pretty sad..) I am proposing we update this to be more competitive. I need other companies that are: 1. US policies 2. Funding under 200 million (not big tech)If anyone is aware of policies that would be helpful in my argument please message me or drop a comment below with: 1. Name of start-up 2. Amount of current funding 3. Parental leave policy.

likehelpful

Is anyone familiar with the transaction / deal analytics business at Big 4, or PwC specifically? What is the work and salary band(s) like, specifically in APAC market?

like

Have you ever been staffed on a project by yourself? Can this really be anything other than just staff aug or if you are a super SME?

like

What are some red flags to look out for when asking about work life balance? ETA: Is the work-life balance really that bad in consulting? I'm seriously considering moving from an internal role to a consulting role because (1) it'll help me break into a cybersecurity role from sysadmin role (2) get away from a toxic coworker who I absolutely dread working with when I have to and just takes a toll on my mental health.

like

If a role requests for 4 years of experience (FAANG BizOps fwiw), is it worth applying 1-1.5 years of experience? I have experience of the things they ask, just for months rather than years... And do internships count for YoE?

like

Bonus number? Anyone?

like

Interviewing with a mid size firm that pays Cravath scale...what's the right way to find out PPP? If I want to make this firm a long term career, I feel like that's a crucial piece of information.

like

Hello I’m in final round interviews with Visa for a role in talent program management. Advice is welcomed, but mostly need some good vibes!

likeuplifting

What’s going on with The Many? They’re hiring non-stop. Is it employee churn? Do they have a million mew accounts?

likefunny

When did you feel like you were successful? People around me think it’s impressive that I work at Deloitte; however, I’m miserable and hate the work I’m doing. Just accepted another job that others would deem a dream company and salary but I’m just afraid of being miserable there too. I just don’t feel like I’m good enough, will be happy, or be in a position where I feel like I’m successful as others.

like

Would it be insane to buy a 1 bd home if there’s a possibility of having a kid in the next ~3 years? Assuming we’d have to look for a 2 bd if we do have a kid and try to rent/sell the 1 bd

like

Hi fishes! Can someone refere me for react developer role.I have 8 months of work experience.Any lead would be appreciated. Thanks in advance!

like

For those who got fired, what were the reasons given?

like

Hi All, I have 2.8 YOE on Linux Administration. My daily activities are patching, incident management, service requests, Change Management, Remediation, Server builds and Decommissions manually and also we handle 1600+ VMs, LVM partitions, User access management. I am also working with configuration tools like Ansible and Installing Mandiant, Nagios, Eracent etc. Involved in MFT project. RHCSA, AZ-900 Certified. Kindly let me know if any vacancies or referrals.

like

2 years experience at Accenture , expecting offer from deloitte S&O this week. Will they give me consultant title? If so, salary for nyc ?

like

How long have you known someone to be on the bench and still stay with the company?

like

Interested in a Product Manager Internship position at Docusign. Any referrals?

like

Diversity in advertising is great, however I think it should also include diversity in opinion/political views. Anyone agree/disagree?

likehelpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal