When responding to a MSJ, do you usually draft the statement of facts or the brief first?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I write the statement of facts last. Aside from general background and the procedural history, the statement of facts should focus on the most important facts used in the argument. So I write the law and analysis section first and tailor the statement around that.

likesmarthelpful

I clerked for a civil judge and I wish more attorneys took this approach. It was so frustrating when they submitted 100+ “material facts” that had nothing to do with the motion

like

I pull the law first and then organize the point headings for the argument section. Then go back and do a statement of fact so it lines up with the language of the law. Then write the argument.

likehelpful

I haven’t done an MSJ response in like 6 months and your question sent a shiver down my spine.

likefunny

I just don't respond. It's the most straightforward approach.

funnylikeuplifting

How can you do the breif without the statement of facts? Don’t understand how that’s possible

like

I know the facts, but the statement goes last. You never know how the law is going to affect your argument and you’ll just end up rewriting it if you do it first.

1. Legal Outline
2. Factual Outline
3. Draft full SOF based on legal outline
4. Full legal analysis

like

I do a rough statement of facts first, to figure out if Im missing any needed affidavits/certifications or documents. You can work late getting a brief done, but you can’t guarantee a client will get you this type of stuff quickly at the last minute

like

It depends on what tactic I am taking in my response. If I want to argue that OC hasn’t met their burden, I do the brief first. If I want to say there are too many fact issues, I draft the facts first.

like

I draft the law first but the end product shows the facts organized before the law if that’s what you mean…

like

I do the argument first then go back and make sure I have the facts to back it up.

Related Posts

Can anyone refer me in Cognizant, Accenture, IBM, Wipro, HCL Technologies, Capgemini.

Tech - .NetCore, Webapi, C#, Microservices, Basic Azure Cloud knowledge

Yoe - 7 year

Preferred location - Pune, Gurgaon

Thanks in Advance.

like

Need career advice, fell on my face during team meeting, 30 min of sheer hell as data locked w laptop/ system & security issues Day 2 and i sounded like a babbling chaotic idiot. Details don't matter, next mtg notice other team member had my LI profile up & i feel leader ask jr person to take over daily call w cust ...Is there anyway to recover from this, i already apologized for wasting 30 min of their time ...team work was flawless last few months & frankly I never crashed & burned like this

like

Any M7 particularly good / differentiated regarding careers in professional sports leagues?

like

My first prenatal visit was billed as “absence of menstruation” instead of “prenatal visit”, therefore my insurance is not covering it (insurance only covers prenatal visits). Is this normal? Did the doctor make a mistake with coding?

like

Hi all,

What is the package offered in Walmart for IN2 (data engineer support) role for 2years experience Candidate?

like

Can I leave a company after 6 months? Will it impact my resume?

like

Any tips for running beginners? I’m out of shape and have been making an effort to move daily (5 miles walking). Been jogging intermittently. I’m 5’8 225lb. I am avoiding the gym since covid. Have free weights at home as well. Since NYE, I lost 15lb but want to be more aggressive. Any advice? Thanks :)

like

Does anyone know of any pharmacies that were lucky enough to get quick shipments of the new COVID-19 booster?

funnylike

I don’t think that most people they find in the lake went in it willingly. Water makes it too easy to cover up murders. Washes away evidence. But it’s dismissed because most people they found had also been drinking. But people just disappearing miles away from the Lake don’t just fall in it. Yes, suicide happens. But many of these cases show zero signs of anything like that. The constant MO is being out with friends having fun. The friend vanishes. Then is found in the lake weeks later.

likehelpful

At what point does it switch from hooking up to dating?

like

What are the chances of lateraling from BCG as a principal to McK/Bain as an ~AP equivalent? I’m a BCG lateral hire in the US that was just promoted but almost never get to work in the industry where I have the most interest/expertise. Would be interested in switching if I could get back to my industry. Is it possible at this level? Would appreciate any advice.

like

Is the portfolio side of a PE/PC firm their ops function? Or is it two different things

like

Is there such a thing as a perfect resume?

(content only, stylistic disagreements will always be, of course)

like
like

Anyone else having problems with ants?

like

Best Denver neighborhood(s) on the north side or best northern Denver suburb for 20 something recently married couple?

Happy Friday :)

Post Photo
funnylikesmart

I’ve realized that I no longer want to work. I’m 25 and it’s time to retire.

likefunnysmart

Additional Posts in Litigation & Arbitration

Any thoughts on what a “standard” origination credit system is for associates at a midsized litigation boutique in Texas? The system is solidified for partners but more hazy for associates. Hoping to get some guidance.

like

I am 2 years out and have a secretary for the first time. How do I use her? I’m use to doing everything myself at my prior firms.

like

International arbitration people: I understand that lawyers practicing in France usually specialize in ICC proceedings, Londoners in LCIA. Where are the lawyers usually arguing before the PCA generally located?

like

I’m a first year associate at a Big Law firm. Most of my assignments have been research memos and summary emails. I enjoy research but the questions asked are never obvious and the answer is usually nuanced, unclear, or the perfect case just doesn’t exist. As a result, it usually takes me a while to craft an answer that I feel confident in. However, more and more often I’ve been given very short deadlines to turn over the research, as short as 3-4 hours for a complicated question. Is this common

like

I live in FL and my AC has an internal leak, landlord refuses to replace it anytime soon. Electric bills are now $300 for an apartment. He isn't doing anything about his aside from coming to the unit to see the issue himself. What type of recourse can I get this is insane.

At what point do you begin to feel numb (if ever) when you’re done trial and prepping for another trial in a span of 3 months, while mains full caseload of other active litigation cases? Should I be worried that I’m going from engaged and stress to numb and slightly indifferent? Or is this what it feels like to power through? I can’t gauge it anymore? And can’t impose judgment one way or another either.

like

My firm is trying to stealth fire me, but my high risk pregnancy is making it difficult to find a new job. I still have ongoing cases and good relationships with certain partners. (Cont’d)

like

Florida: After a car accident can the driver injured in the other vehicle sue the husband (wife was driving the at fault vehicle) for negligent entrustment? Wife & husband both on the car’s title. I understand they have dangerous instrumentality, but how can you say the car was “entrusted” to someone who has rightful legal title to it?

like

What is a reasonable amount to accept to settle a case with undisputed liability? Let’s say for example potential damages are realistically $100k-1M. Let’s say cost of defense is $200k. No chance of them getting out on SJ or a MTD. Is cost of defense a reasonable starting point? It seems like an offer below that would not be serious.

like

Can anyone provide insight on market rate for “of counsel” (practicing 10 years) at a mid-size ID firm in Philadelphia?

like

Is 180 billable hours per month a high “target” (to use the firm’s vernacular) or expectation?Although it may not be unreasonably high, I believe it is a high number and would at least appreciate someone at my firm acknowledging that. Perhaps I’m wrong and I’m sure you’ll tell me if so.

like

Is having too much “attention to detail” a bad thing?

like

Best suit brands?

like

I work at a small firm with not that many workable templates so I usually have to do everything from scratch like drafting motions, pleadings, and researching all potential counts every time. Do bigger firms have better and more templates that allow you to have to do less research?

like

California is the venue. We recently served Trial Subpoenas on a number of medical doctors. Two just responded that they will not show up and will not sign an on-call agreement. Thinking of requesting a bench warrant when they fail to appear. Thoughts?

like

Hi folks. I'm in my sixth year of prosecution and have hit the glass ceiling. My next options are to run for office (ew), stay where I am and get state sanctioned raises for the rest of my career (ew), or jump ship. I'd like to get into plaintiff's litigation. Any tips would be much appreciated on 1.) switching expertise, 2.) fully remote or hybrid work (I love my house & don't want to move), 3.) where to find jobs openings. Thanks!

like

Deadline to Answer was missed, judicial default was entered, then a Default Final Judgment was entered without a hearing. Would this be an additional grounds for a Motion to Set Aside/Vacate? Assistant forgot to the calendar deadline, and when judicial default was issued, assistant was assigned to file the Answer/Counterclaim, but did not. Soon after, she quit. Was first put on notice when DFJ was issued.

like

Best typo you’ve seen in a motion?

like

Headhunters/Recruiters…
I was contacted out of the blue by a headhunter last week promising to do their best to place me in an AMLAW200 firm as a lateral. (4 years practicing, all litigation; looking to move to transactional).
I’ve never dealt with a headhunter before, and I’m taking everything they say with a grain of salt, so insight as to their effectiveness, reliability, and overall successful placements in or equivalent to the type of firms they have connections with is greatly appreciated.

like

First time defending a deposition in a federal case next week. Welcome all tips and tricks. Let’s hear them.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal