Which is more stressful? Plaintiff or defense work?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I did both in PI and it depends on what you find stressful. Billing every waking moment, or dealing with a client who thinks this is your only file and demands 1 million dollars. You pick your poison (or find the defense non-billable job which is 1 in a million).

like

Plaintiff's work is more stressful in the sense that you're often working without a net. Unless you're in a very large plaintiff's practice doing pharna ir something, you're not likely to be working on a team or under close supervision. Young plaintiff's lawyers are often just handed cases and expected to figure it out. It's a very sink or swim environment, which can be stressful. On the hand, you'll likely get much more experience much quicker in that type of practice. I was handling defendant's depositions and trials long before my defense counterparts.

like

Yes.

like

I’ve done both and I think they both have pretty unique stressors. I wouldn’t say one is more stressful than the other, but I prefer defense work.

like

I think it depends on the area of law. I do first party property claims (Plaintiff) and almost everyone I talk to that does defense in this area either hates it or they always complain about it. But generally I think plaintiff work is better than defense work.

like

Defense work... work for a solo & we consistently get better results than big firms. Refuse to settle , not paper tigers . Win trials

like

Plaintiff’s work. You're usually wearing a business person and lawyer hat. Defense just has to churn out paperwork and get paid for it.

like

I think this question is odd. Are you only talking about tort work? In the context of a contract dispute, doesn’t matter to me which side of the v I’m on.

I do both plaintiff and defense (not PI or med mail), and I find the most stressful cases to be the ones w assholes on the other side. We are not our clients. We should be civil in our profession. 98% of my cases proceed in this manner.

Second most stressful cases are the ones w non responsive or unreasonable clients (idk, maybe I’d switch this and call this the most stressful).

Doesn’t matter to me who initiated the case.

If you work for a big firm.... it’s easy to collect a paycheck. But the same people who talk a big game have never made payroll or attempted to be on their own.

Plaintiff work by far if you are in state court. You have to do all the work

Related Posts

FUTURE MILLIONAIRES
CHECK IN 📩👇
Send a Dm

like

Looking for a new role outside of my current company. I have 3 years SaaS Product experience, 5 Years customer service (looking to get out of this area), 3 years dealing with accounting software for HOA managment companies and have been working on SQL for database admin. My desire is an account management role or supervisor/manager position. Any leads are greatly appreciated!!!:

Any guidance on magistrate judge-ordered settlement conferences?

like

Have all calls happened? Was expecting a call but haven’t received yet (making me more anxious).

like

Anyone know of open positions as a desktop support manager? Looking to leave my current company.

I understand how VMs work, how load balancing works, understand the basics of networks, understand how Aws security groups work etc, but not very familiar with most AWS services. How long will it take me to prepare for the solution architect certification? I have nothing going on for about a week- is that enough time to prepare for the exam?

like

Anyone working at BCG as software engineer? It seems they have some software roles as well now and I am supposed to talk to recruiter about one. Just curious the interview process, what they look for and any tips and wlb. Thanks

like

I am working for a company that is out of my residential state (A) and my company is withholding taxes based on tht state (B) where my company is. I was checking with my tax consultant and he thought I would have to pay taxes based on my residential state (A) next year (which btw is a massive sum). Any1 else have the same issue or knows anything about this. I imagine with wfh today this maybe a common issue.

like

Does Humana offer a coworking stipend credit?

like

Any thoughts on the Celine Box small bag? I’ve been eyeing it for a while, but just don’t know if this bag is worth it. I heard that the leather gets scratched so easily. Your input is much appreciated.

like

How will ad servers support 3P tags in a cookieless world...?

like

Any knows any opening for UI/UX position?

like

Good Evening!!!

I'm looking to get a referral for
Deloitte as I'm looking to apply to a recent job posting

If anyone can help, please let me know
Thanks ahead of time!!!

like

Looks like somebody has a case of the Mondays...

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Please help and suggest something.

Post Photo
like

So fishes....

My team is dissolved yesterday and they said team members will adjusted in different projects as per requirement and domain...

Now today they asked me to work night shift for 6 month but I said no and asked opportunity for general office time...

Is it wrong to negotiate like this ?
Do I get another offer ?
Im confused coz I don't want to be on bench.

like

I am looking for a job change, Do let me know if there is any opening for accounts payable. I am holding 6 years of experience..

like

What do skinny ppl eat for dinner? Been trying to watch my calories and would HATE to have salad twice a day. 😫

like

Running out of socially distant things to do in the DMV in the winter. Any favorite less popular parks/nature spots? Please share suggestions!

like

Additional Posts in Law

How many times a day do you feel stooopid and what year are you?

likefunny

Goodbye billable hours.

Post Photo
likeupliftingfunnysmart

Lenovo or Mac?

like

Tips for dealing with an older managing partner? I have plenty of older partners who are east to deal with, but the managing partner is stuck in 1995 and doesn’t seem to grasp how technology can be incorporated nor does he understand how to attract talent from younger generations. I like my firm, but I want to know how to approach these issues without offending him.

like

Quick legal question to see if anyone has any ideas off the top of their head: would courts generally honor choice of law provisions if the cause of actions is fraudulent inducement - tort based not contract based?

like

What is considered a good billing realization for a first year at a mid-size firm?

like

I’m a felony prosecutor and have never worked in the private sector (both before and since becoming an attorney). I’m considering switching to a private firm, but don’t know where to start. My private law friends have recruiters reaching out to them based on where they work. How do I get recruiters to notice me? Should I be hiring a recruiter? (Is that even a thing?)

— realizing I have a few blind spots!

like

How much ebb and flow in work is normal? Mid-size firm, civil lit. Some weeks are 40+ hours billed, but others are around 20. When should you start worrying?

like

Client issue - I’m on one of my client’s supervisor’s “bad list.” Our firm requires updates every 60-90 days. Rarely miss sending reports on time, but some of the clients request updates every 20-30 days. I try to respond timely, but don’t always, often will just send a reply saying I will have this for you within 1 week or ASAP. Since October, one of the supervisors for this company will periodically email the head of our department (not cc’ing me) and say they are missing reports. (Cont.)

like

Do things slow down a bit approaching the holiday?
Feel like fewer emails flying around, or it's my illusion?

like

Is a PLLC or PC needed for professional services in NY?

like

Looking for inspirations/examples of time entry descriptions to bill for reading an email. Would appreciate any other examples of billable time entry descriptions that aren’t so obvious too.

like

Have a junior that isn’t improving - not even catching typos. I’ve given him back redline bloodbaths/some short feedback. As a mid level, I’m stuck w him bc of partner staffing. Any tips?

like

First year associate in nyc big law. What do we give our secretaries as holiday gifts? Wine? Cash?

like

Folks who opened their own law firm - what were some challenging issues that you didn’t plan for? Looking back, would you do it again? What are some tips you would like to share ?

like

Anyone work for NYC HEALTH & HOSPITAL that can talk about quality of work? Benefits, WLB, WFH, workload (!!), billable hours (??) etc? TYIA

like

Will remote work negatively impact partnership prospects for associates in a few years? What’s the best way to get your name out there remotely?

like

Employee benefits/exec comp associate here. I lateraled into a firm that sold me on great mentorship from the partners and ability to grow in areas that I need to grow in. Almost a year in and I feel like I am on a “one man island” with little new growth. Do I jump again? Or is this to be expected in BigLaw in this area of law?

likehelpful

When do you consider yourself “at capacity” and start turning down work?

like

Anyone else feel like the more successful you become, the more hate you receive from the pole closest to you? I’m sorry I don’t have energy to be at every event or party. I’m sorry that my career and relationship are top priority for me. I’m sorry that it feels like I get more love from strangers sometimes than from my own “circle”

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal