Why jobs don’t give feedback on interviews rather than the generic email you weren’t selected? Normalize transparency to help people better develop their interviewing skills.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Providing feedback is time consuming and is prone to risk of lawsuit by potential candidates that did not get offered

like

It is frustrating, but it’s very time consuming to give individual feedback after interviews. Especially phone screens if the recruiter is responsible for multiple reqs, and talking to multiple people for each req. There just isn’t enough time.

It would definitely be helpful to be given feedback after 2nd/3rd/etc rounds as there likely aren’t as many people that were interviewed, although still time consuming to gather feedback from each interviewer and relay the information to the candidate.

On the candidate side, I get frustrated too, but totally understand their perspective.

like

Definitely think internal applicants should be getting feedback.

like

At least you received the courtesy of a generic email. I’ve never been more ghosted in my life despite following up with thank you/next steps emails and reaching out to ask HR and the interviewers for their decision. Could just be my industry though.

like

While I would like to hear the feedback, I think this falls into the category of "not their job."

The Recruiter works for the company, and their job is to find the right candidate (or, at least a candidate who can get through the interview process). If it is determined you are not the right candidate their responsibility toward you, the candidate, has ended. Unless there is some reason for them to maintain that relationship (e.g. you might be a good fit for another job) giving feedback isn't a priority. And, as others have pointed out, it might also open them up to law suits.

like

There’s really only one answer and it’s because of law suits.

like

Risk

like

Related Posts

Anybody transition from Audit to Advisory within the same firm? 1) Who did you contact and did you have to interview? 2) how was the overall process? 3) was there a salary adjustment?

like

Anyone have insight into EY S&O cases? Would love info on how the interview process works, thanks in advance!

like

I love sales and looking to get into tech sales!
I have 7+ years of inside sales experience.
Currently in real estate but want to get into a remote tech sales position.
So far I have tried applying at company pages “career page” but no luck as of yet.
Resume is pretty strong!
Can anyone refer or recommend a recruiter and/or company I should look into?
I would greatly appreciate any recommendations or referrals.
Thanks for reading and have a great week!!!

like

How many rounds of interview does Persistent take ...cleared with the first round ...any tips/info about the further process?

like

I have client round on friday.. So anyone please help what kind of questions they can ask in client round..? Automation testing using selenium and 6 yoe

like

I have a second interview next week for a senior occupational therapist position at Kaiser Permanente in the Bay Area. I asked the rehab supervisor who interviewed me what the salary was but she said she didn’t know and that was later down the line. Can anyone here give me a range of what I can expect/ negotiate for

like

I just completed two rounds of interviews at Accenture Interactive. I’m excited about the opportunity. Anyone work there willing to share their opinions re: culture, WLB, career growth, pay/comp vs competition?

like

Interviewed for a GS-15 (same agency but different office) and totally aced the interview with excellent answers. They know I’m a top performer with senior references. However I noticed there was an internal candidate who has been there for few years and interviewed that’s a veteran. I feel my chances just sank and want to gauge thoughts.

like

How long should I wait to follow up with a recruiter for an offer letter after receiving verbal confirmation that I am the candidate they want for a role? This is the job I want but I still have interviews coming up with other companies

like

Is it appropriate to ask the interviewer why the previous person left the role?

like

Why for Account Management there so many interviews?? why 4 or 5 rounds??? It is only sales???

like

Making the switch from public to private sector. What questions do you wish you would have asked about your firm in informational interviews?

When it comes to your job search:

1) How often/much do you get feedback from recruiters or whoever you just spoke with? Feels like we're always in the dark. One way feedback street.

2) Who do you like to work with? Headhunters vs internalrecruiters? Is the experience different?

3) Have you had to align your interviews so that the offers would come in close/same day? What's your strategy?

4) What's your process in weighing [multiple] offers? If that ever happens? Where do you keep your notes?

like

I’m interviewing for a position that’s a 6-MONTH HOURLY CONTRACTED copywriter position (5 years experience).

Any advice on negotiating salary on that..? I have no reference point on how much that would break down hourly for 6 months.

What’s a good range to negotiate for?

like

Interview soon for a comms director role. Would be first in-house gig, been in agencies until now. What skills matter more when in house vs agency that I need to prep talking pts for?

like

I'm searching for an EA opportunity either in the LA area or remote. I'm open to working on site, hybrid, or remote and open to most industries. I've been interviewing the past 3 months after a company-wide lay off and haven't landed anything yet within my salary range or that feels like a good fit for me. Message or comment if you have any leads for me - I so appreciate it!

like

Had a recruiter reach out to me on LinkedIn about a Business Development role with GrowthPlug (tech sales). Meeting tomorrow for an informational interview. I’ve never done this before so does anyone have any advice for how to prepare and what sort of questions to ask/expect to be asked? Any tips are welcome. Thanks!

Hi Fishes,
BA profile. YOE 8+

I have cleared Nagarro's aptitude test, soon interview will get schedule. Please help me with the interview details so that I can prepare for it.

like

Passed first phone screen (GCA) and have an upcoming call with hiring manager. Should I expect a formal format (GCA, RRK, etc) or are HM rounds typically unstructured/can be anything? Product strategy role if relevant

like

How many rounds of interview are there in infy... I have taken interview for SAP SD yesterday 12th March it was technical round, the interviewer asked from basic to the issue i handle in my current project and curry CTC and expected CTC... No idea of what is the next step.. can any one help me to know if i have any other rounds of interview... Thanks in advance...

More Posts

Love the intensity of the ending, and the machinations of trying to kill off challenges to the throne.

Someone please tell me if I am crazy. I am at a family law firm with approximately 25 attorneys. I previously worked at small shops where I essentially handled everything myself with no support staff. Now at my current firm I have a paralegal who really only makes my job more difficult… am I crazy to say that I don’t need a paralegal as I am comfortable operating as a solo and pay me slightly. I’m already pretty much operating on my own anyway. Feel like it’s a win win.

like

So many things I am hearing.
Kolkata is going to be the next IT hub? Is it true?
Bangalore IT will drop?
Should I go back to Kolkata? Or is it better to stay in Bangalore permanently?
Any suggestions?

like

Silly question but, how did you make close friends when you first moved to Miami? Feeling like a fish out of water, from Texas.

likehelpful

Best recommendation of a nice restaurant in mid-town to take a client for Lunch?

like

Fam, my I-140 priority date been current for a while (from prior employer). PERM has been filed and lawyers are planning to file new I-140 in premium processing and I-485 concurrently. I-140 response is expected in ~2 weeks. How soon after I-140 is filed, can I safely quit the company?

like

SAG on a rampage these days....

like

Favorite December vacation spots in North America?

like

What’s going on in the District this week??

like

Bvlgari B.zero1 necklace...thoughts? Anyone who has it, feedback (practical? Can you wear it 24/7?) Thank you!!

like

in recent times , in how days we can expect offer letter form oracle india after verbal confirmation? I read that it used to take months earlier . Please share your experience

like

Happy NYE! Does anyone work at Meta (Facebook)? If so, would you be willing to refer me to a job? I'm happy to share a write-up on my qualifications. DM if you can! 😊

like

My Salesforce administrator exam is suspended.
Any one help me on this.

like

My son 529 grows so slow... Any suggestions ? Which bank or state do you all use? Should I just invest for him in a roth at work ?

like

Plz recommend good CFA level 3 prep course?

like

Looking for your career advice! I currently work as a Content Marketing Manager but would love to move into a Head of Marketing/Marketing Director role. What would be your best tips to make that move? I assume it will take time of course, but I'm wondering what/where I should invest in terms of my training and next career steps. Thanks!

like

I would appreciate any advice on how to stay on top of non urgent tasks. As a 2nd year, I’m often tapped to handle tedious tasks that need to get done quickly. Tbh, I like urgent matters. It motivates me and helps me focus. I admittedly struggle to care about checking in on DWQs, record requests, OC’s discovery, scheduling matters, etc. Especially with so many cases. I definitely rely heavily (maybe over rely?) on the paralegals for these sort of things. Any tips?

like

What will be the appraisal cycle for new joiners.

I will be joining in sep

like

I have around 1 year of experience in Java and total 5.5 years in total.

I got a lead role in a company with good package.
The role is of java fullstack, microservices.
I studied hard on spring boot and microservices but my hands on experience is less.
Would I be able to survive,I am a quick learner and deliver projects on time....but first time switching so asking.

Is there such thing as garden leave when moving between the MBBs? As in due to potential conflict of interest, you're not allowed to work for a competitor for x months after you terminate contract with existing employer? Does it only apply to senior levels (partner and above)

like

Additional Posts in Interview Tips

I have a face to face interview tomorrow and was wondering what the thoughts were wearing a nice knitted sweater instead of a blazer for an interview. My blazers don’t quite fit anymore and it’s not in my budget to buy a new blazer. I have one in mind that’s a turtleneck and can be styled with dress pants nicely. Either that or a cardigan….

like

I’m interviewing with the company although I have offer signed with another (going though background checks, so didn’t wanna stop before knowing 100%). Really love the process and the team, but unless something goes sideways with signed offer won’t be joining them. I have a colleague who is probably even better fit for the position, I know that she will enjoy the team too and would be happy for a chance to interview with them. How do I approach this?

helpful

Just wrapped up case style interview at LinkedIn. I was rejected from moving on to the next round. The feedback I received was that I wasn’t concise enough in my answers. I have never really done a ton of case interviews before and I do not have an mba. Any suggestions on how to frame my answers in a concise way?

like

Anyone have experience with Capital One’s mini case? Applying for a product manager role. They will pick to interview me on capital one college checking (which doesn’t exist?) or capital one shopping — (they’re not doing the credit wise case anymore). Has anyone gone through this process and can weigh in? TYIA!

like

Has anyone here joined SAS Institute recently? I received a HireVue interview request for a marketing position at SAS and wonder if anyone could tell me what kind of questions are asked during the HireVue interview?SAS

like

What are some things you all do to prepare for a new job?

like

I just was in a 3 process interview, which included modern hire interview, interview with hiring manager and interview with senior director(Boss’s boss) for another company. The hiring manager liked me and the interview went well to progress, the next interview also went well. In this situation who would make the final decision to hire me? And what would be the reasons I could miss out on the job after having a 30 min final interview (FIT) with the senior director

like

HELP my friends! I’ve been invited to a recruiter screen for the initial interview with HR for Global Safety Associate. This job mainly deals with Adverse event/high prescribing meds product complaints. In my current role I deal with on boarding pt & getting patients work done from A-Z till they get on their meds. The only part which is similar is that I’m the main point of contacts for pt so I can report their complaint to Health Canada. How can I convince them I can handle this new job

like

I have a zoom interview for a flight attendant position with southwest and advise would be greatly appreciated.

like

Is it okay to be upfront with the person interviewing me that I’m just not a good interviewer?! I haven’t had an interview in a very long time. Been with the same company for a while now. I’m nervous and I know I’m not good at interviews but I’m a good and hard worker. How do I go about this?

like

Hi all, can someone help me prepare interviews for HR roles please? Thank you

I haven't interviewed in years and feel absolutely out of place and underconfident. Not able to bring my A game to the table (I can't pitch myself as ideal candidate for position).

I have very strong profile for my experience. All my performance reviews continuously state I'm going above & beyond and theres nothing they can think of suggesting I do different. Just can't interview well

like
like

Any thoughts on an interview coach? I seem to clear first rounds but not make thru second or third rounds...org change management specific roles, my resume is solid but idk what am I doing so wrong... Any ideas, tips?

like

Hello all! My fiancé has been job hunting for the past year for a remote marketing (Specialist/manager/Agent..etc) and with hard luck she could not even land an interview! Any tips, recommendations, or referrals anyone could give us?! She has the experience but not sure why the job market has been so brutal !

like

I applied for another position within my company. I wanted to reach out to the hiring manager just to formally introduce myself and share my interest. Would this be a good idea?

smartlike

I was contacted by an Amazon recruiter for a remote Sr. Program Manager role. I took and passed the assessment and was moved to the hiring manager round which was scheduled for tomorrow. I got an email tonight saying that the Director of the group decided that the person must be in Seattle. I am in Austin, which is not an option. I’m disappointed! The recruiter will let me know if any remote roles come up but in the mean time, does anyone have any remote Amazon roles that they’d refer me to?

like

Has anyone had interviews with Meta/Facebook in a field of market research? Any tips? Also how long is their process? What’s important? Any insight is appreciated. Thanks

like

QQ- who do you fw after interview in regards to next round? Main recruiter or 2nd recruiter who help facilitating? Or just email one and cc’d other one?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal