{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Would you accept a job offer for $12,000 more than you're currently making if the commute was a little over an hour and you had no possibility of ever working from home?", "post_id": "60a7cd54fb4143002a36f366", "reply_count": 69, "vote_count": 5, "bowl_id": "55375ce690f5eebe1d2a0f88", "bowl_name": "Tech" }

Would you accept a job offer for $12,000 more than you're currently making if the commute was a little over an hour and you had no possibility of ever working from home?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Depends on why you're thinking of changing jobs. If it's strictly for more money, then instead of jumping ship right away you should read up on how to manage your personal finances and see if it's possible to get a raise in your current position first. If it's for a strategic career move, then that's another story. But it seems to me since you're asking about money, you're probably feeling like you don't make enough. And maybe you don't. But if you can figure out how to live below your means within your current salary then when you do make more money you'll be able to safeguard it more easily. There's a book called "The Millionaire Next Door" that talks about this extensively. I wish I had read this earlier in my career. If you've never had a long commute you'll quickly learn that commuting becomes a significant part of your life. Only you can decide if spending an extra 43 hours a month commuting is worth the extra $800 a month after taxes. I should also note the type of commute matters, I had an hour and a half commute on a ferry an it was sometimes nice to have extra time to read or watch movies. But very difficult on my family life. I work remotely now.

like

As someone who just moved their family another 35 miles south due to housing prices and I kept telling myself we can do this, this is the best for my family…. (All because of housing and nothing else) I am five month into the commute crap and it’s about 45-50min each way and tbh I am about to have a nervous breakdown. There is zero work life balance, I work 12 hour days (always did but wasn’t an issue before when I was only 15 min away). So from my perspective- I would say no. But then again you mentioned in another comment that it’s prestigious and amazing benefits, which is huge. If you are super young, not married or thinking of starting a family right now - it might be doable if you see a long term future with this company to get bonuses and RSU and other stocks and save up money to be closer or even just get the experience under your belt to get that next and better job in a few years. Something like this needs serious consideration and really isn’t a clear black and white answer.

like
Recent IconRecent

No. I turned down one which was an $80K increase in base salary because the commute would have been 1.5 hours each way and I’d have to buy a car to get there from the city. They wanted four days in office and I didn’t want to live near where they were located.

like

Yeah i feel like OP should've said % vs dollar amounts. 80k could've been a 15% increase for you while 12k might be a 30% increase for OP (i have no idea, maybe OP said percentage somewhere else)

Nope. 12000/52/5/2= $23 an hour for your commute not including gas. Add in the additional stress of driving and what else you could be doing with that time and it’s not really worth it.

like

+1. And not just gas, you'll wreck the value of your car by putting tons of miles on it, you'll need car repairs more frequently, and the lack of WFH flexibility from that distance can become an issue if your car is in the shop.

like

Okay I need to clarify- the new job is significantly better than my current one (better benefits, salary, everything) and its with a more prestigious organization. And I am less than a year into my career. The idea that I've even been offered this job is huge.

like

Is the work more interesting and looking to lead to bigger and better? Unless you will be happier. Don't bother

like

I feel like it depends… starting your career and life out having a 12k boost to your salary could be a huge benefit to leapfrog your career / life early on. However, there is a lot more to choosing if someplace is a good fit for you outside or wfh and commute. As someone who has had commutes ranging from 0-1.5 hour one way the reasons I joined or left companies ultimately was never down to the commute. It was always due to opportunities and culture.

like

I would say go for it as long as you feel excited about it. You are young, now is the time to explore, fail, learn and grow.. I had a 30 min commute.. I prayed for longer just so I can catch some zzzzzz on the train (true story.. don’t judge me 😜) I had a nice quite 55 min commute, but I wanted to work in the big city(NYC) and drink and party every night, but couldn’t afford the city apt and had a 1.5 hour commute.. now I have a 15 min commute and covid wouldn’t let me see ppl.. what I am trying to say is.. be young.. make YOUR UNIQUE MISTAKES and learn and pivot.. Also.. don’t stay so long at your dream company that it becomes a nightmare!

like

No, unless I can move closer to work 😆😆

like

Oh it entirely depends if it's helping my career in general, and primarily if I think I'm going to like the role more...

like

This is it here, OP the question isn't about salary,.it's about dream offer vs commute.

like

Nope, breakdown the value of your time and cost of commute- the salary bump would shrink and the job would drop in interest

like

If the commute is via public transportation, I'd do it.

like

If I had a family, no.

like

No I wouldn’t do that. When you account for the travel and wear and tear on the car and gas, that extra 12k isn’t clearly giving you a better life than your current situation with 12k less.

like

Definitely no. The sheer fact that they’re making you come to the office daily is a deal-breaker on top of the long commute. If they were reasonable about work/life balance and letting you WFH half the week, I would possible say yes. But WFH is a huge commodity that most progressive companies are offering in light of this pandemic.

like

It sounds like a great opportunity especially this early in your career. I did the same for around 6 years but eventually the commute was just not bearable anymore. It takes a toll on the quality of life. Sounds like you are young so it might be the best time to make that kind of sacrifices for future opportunities.

like

That depends. How do the job duties compare? What are your career path goals and the potential options at the company? How much would it cost in gas, and how old is your car (think of car trouble)? And how important is working from home to you? I used to drive 1 hour and 10 minutes each way every day for a low paying job, but in the end, I had higher paying roles and tons of experience which set me up for the next stage of my career. Well worth it at that time for me, but doesn't mean it's right for everyone. But no matter what - you need a reliable car or a good AAA plan :) PS, I enjoyed the drive, gave me lots of time to thinking and decompress before and after work. But you need to know other ways to get there b/c there are a lot of wrecks - and it adds another layer of complication if you have kids that you have to get from daycare/school at a certain time.

like

NOPE!!!

like

Is the position one where you could potentially shift your work hours a bit? Would they allow you start earlier in the morning and earlier in the day so that you can beat rush hour traffic and shorten your commute time?

like

Nope! Did the hour + commute for 18 years, there’s probably a price I’d put on it, but it’s not 12k. The only benefit was the ability to de stress at the end of the day but you can’t really do that while your road raging to get home to the family.

like

I would say yes. Salary is such a snowball, that a little increase now means much more down the road, in aggregate (total wealth) as well as the increases in your total annual comp.

Related Posts

🧐What's your best hard-earned advice for someone interviewing, job seeking, or negotiating a salary? Drop it below! 👇

like

Is an MBA to a lower tiered school or specialized marketing graduate certificate more valuable to a hiring manager these days? My goal is to transition into marketing & become a lifecycle marketing manager. Thank you for your feedback!

like

What is the salary for Senior Consultant (Big 4) in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia?

like

I make $240k in a corporate strategy role, was offered a senior manager role at Strategy&, should I accept? Assuming median year end bonus would be a ~20% total comp increase.

likefunny

Human Capital Consultant up for promotion. Call with an Accenture recruiter tomorrow. On a digital enablement project with no SM and supervising others. How do I position? And at what level?

like

Where do you work, and what educational benefits does your employer provide? Currently working full time and taking some classes toward my master’s. I’ve been at my firm for a little over 2 years as it was my first gig out of undergrad. It provides an annual stipend for education, but I’m bored, unchallenged, unfulfilled, and underpaid. I want to explore what other companies offer to make an educated decision as to whether I should go elsewhere. TIA!

likefunny

What are some techniques for negotiating a higher base salary? Don’t have a competing offer to leverage

like

Help me assess my finances? I make about 57k after taxes. I’m set up to max my 401k, Roth IRA, and have 6 months of expenses by the end of the year. After cost of living stuff, I’m left with $600/mo

funnylike

Are companies that have publictly stated they will be primary remote work going forward seeing an increased quality of candidates for open in house roles?

likehelpful

Can a women serving maternity can continue to work from home for 6 more months after her maternity break in deloitte? Considering deloitte is expecting employees to return back to office.

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

I have recieved offer from EY and in the offer letter they have mentioned about the Telephone/Broadband reimbursement and LTA which is 12,000 per annum and 50,000 per annum. Can I claim this full amount ? Anyone from EY please help me understand the benefits of both the above ! EY EY India

like

So i have sent an email stating the counter offer for Cognizant. For salary revision Havent heard anything from hr? Anyone having experience on this?

like

I’ve made over half my yearly pre tax salary in the past month from MGNI. If I ever get promoted I’m going to find a way to buy their services

likefunny

What do you do when the role description basically has so much crammed in, that it feels like if you take it you will be working 22 hours per day. Do you give the recruiter/hiring manager that feedback?

like

Hi, is permanant wfh option available in Deloitte? I have a small kid and want to know whther they allow work frm hme as I have an offer from deloitte.

like

I am leaving my current employer end of this week and joining another one soon. Is there anything you wish you did during your last week from financial perspective ( 401k , pension , paychecks etc. ) ? Looking for things I need to keep track off Thanks in advance

like

Hi, I have recently got the offer letter from Accenture, but I couldn't find the salary breakup/compensation plan excel with my offer letter. Is it mandatory? All my peers who got offer from Accenture have got a salary breakup excel along with the offer letter. Please help.

like

How sad is your life, if the biggest reason to move into an apartment alone is to avoid wearing pants on wfh and weekends.

like

Hello fishes, I currently work for one of Deloitte's Asian member firms and recently received an offer to move to their London office. Supply Chain offering, Senior Consultant level. 65k base + 5k benefits. I have 3.5 years of experience in the same offering with Deloitte. Can I push for 70k base?

like

Additional Posts

🧐What's your best hard-earned advice for someone interviewing, job seeking, or negotiating a salary? Drop it below! 👇

like

Is an MBA to a lower tiered school or specialized marketing graduate certificate more valuable to a hiring manager these days? My goal is to transition into marketing & become a lifecycle marketing manager. Thank you for your feedback!

like

What is the salary for Senior Consultant (Big 4) in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia?

like

Downtown Philly: Element vs Aloft vs Autograph Notary vs Westin vs other higher end Marriott properties in the downtown area for about 40k Bonvoy points? And…Element vs Autograph collection in general? Not real familiar with these sub brands.

like

Best way to ask for raise without making it seem like an ultimatum, don't have any offers lined up / haven't put in any substantial effort to get offers.

like

Hi all - any tips/what are some Do’s and Don’ts for in-house interviews for big NASDAQ or FAANG companies? TIA!

like

What are the digital tools that all the big 4 utilized? I know pwc we use tableau and alteryx. Is EY and Deloitte using the same tools?

like

I make $240k in a corporate strategy role, was offered a senior manager role at Strategy&, should I accept? Assuming median year end bonus would be a ~20% total comp increase.

likefunny

How far would you go and help you ex-spouse after you divorce, if you have child together? Minimally help with things around their house? Help if there was a medical condition?

like

Hi folks! Does anyone know if you need full original copy of h1b i797 notice or just the bottom section of it for DL renewal? I only got the latter from the HR so wondering 😕

like

Human Capital Consultant up for promotion. Call with an Accenture recruiter tomorrow. On a digital enablement project with no SM and supervising others. How do I position? And at what level?

like

Vegas Baby!! 🍾🍷🍹🥃🥂🥂🍰🍟🍕🍔🥃🥃🍺🍺🍹🍸🥂

like

Where do you work, and what educational benefits does your employer provide? Currently working full time and taking some classes toward my master’s. I’ve been at my firm for a little over 2 years as it was my first gig out of undergrad. It provides an annual stipend for education, but I’m bored, unchallenged, unfulfilled, and underpaid. I want to explore what other companies offer to make an educated decision as to whether I should go elsewhere. TIA!

likefunny

What's your awkward moment with a client?

like

What’s the case to pick Hilton or Marriott? Starting a new travel year, and need to pick one. Thoughts?

Do you all ever have guilt calling in a sick day? I have a pretty bad cold and 5 months pregnant. I’m just so slow today and want to nap. Working from home

like

If you have to travel during COVID, it was helpful to have CLEAR. Less physical contact and don’t have to take off your mask. To confirm your identity stand in front of the screen to scan your eyes (with your mask on) and then scan your ticket with your phone.

likehelpful

Been working on mostly (about 70%) public sector policy and strategy at Big 4 for most of my career. Often go up against MBB on RFPs and have a decent win rate. Would I be too senior to come in as a lateral hire? I guess it’s all about client networks at this level, and being government, it’s locationally dependent - so which markets have need?

like

What are some techniques for negotiating a higher base salary? Don’t have a competing offer to leverage

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal