{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Would you accept a job offer for $12,000 more than you're currently making if the commute was a little over an hour and you had no possibility of ever working from home?", "post_id": "60a7cd54fb4143002a36f366", "reply_count": 69, "vote_count": 5, "bowl_id": "55375ce690f5eebe1d2a0f88", "bowl_name": "Tech" }

Would you accept a job offer for $12,000 more than you're currently making if the commute was a little over an hour and you had no possibility of ever working from home?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Depends on why you're thinking of changing jobs. If it's strictly for more money, then instead of jumping ship right away you should read up on how to manage your personal finances and see if it's possible to get a raise in your current position first. If it's for a strategic career move, then that's another story. But it seems to me since you're asking about money, you're probably feeling like you don't make enough. And maybe you don't. But if you can figure out how to live below your means within your current salary then when you do make more money you'll be able to safeguard it more easily. There's a book called "The Millionaire Next Door" that talks about this extensively. I wish I had read this earlier in my career. If you've never had a long commute you'll quickly learn that commuting becomes a significant part of your life. Only you can decide if spending an extra 43 hours a month commuting is worth the extra $800 a month after taxes. I should also note the type of commute matters, I had an hour and a half commute on a ferry an it was sometimes nice to have extra time to read or watch movies. But very difficult on my family life. I work remotely now.

like

As someone who just moved their family another 35 miles south due to housing prices and I kept telling myself we can do this, this is the best for my family…. (All because of housing and nothing else) I am five month into the commute crap and it’s about 45-50min each way and tbh I am about to have a nervous breakdown. There is zero work life balance, I work 12 hour days (always did but wasn’t an issue before when I was only 15 min away). So from my perspective- I would say no. But then again you mentioned in another comment that it’s prestigious and amazing benefits, which is huge. If you are super young, not married or thinking of starting a family right now - it might be doable if you see a long term future with this company to get bonuses and RSU and other stocks and save up money to be closer or even just get the experience under your belt to get that next and better job in a few years. Something like this needs serious consideration and really isn’t a clear black and white answer.

like
Recent IconRecent

No. I turned down one which was an $80K increase in base salary because the commute would have been 1.5 hours each way and I’d have to buy a car to get there from the city. They wanted four days in office and I didn’t want to live near where they were located.

like

Yeah i feel like OP should've said % vs dollar amounts. 80k could've been a 15% increase for you while 12k might be a 30% increase for OP (i have no idea, maybe OP said percentage somewhere else)

Nope. 12000/52/5/2= $23 an hour for your commute not including gas. Add in the additional stress of driving and what else you could be doing with that time and it’s not really worth it.

like

+1. And not just gas, you'll wreck the value of your car by putting tons of miles on it, you'll need car repairs more frequently, and the lack of WFH flexibility from that distance can become an issue if your car is in the shop.

like

Okay I need to clarify- the new job is significantly better than my current one (better benefits, salary, everything) and its with a more prestigious organization. And I am less than a year into my career. The idea that I've even been offered this job is huge.

like

Is the work more interesting and looking to lead to bigger and better? Unless you will be happier. Don't bother

like

I feel like it depends… starting your career and life out having a 12k boost to your salary could be a huge benefit to leapfrog your career / life early on. However, there is a lot more to choosing if someplace is a good fit for you outside or wfh and commute. As someone who has had commutes ranging from 0-1.5 hour one way the reasons I joined or left companies ultimately was never down to the commute. It was always due to opportunities and culture.

like

I would say go for it as long as you feel excited about it. You are young, now is the time to explore, fail, learn and grow.. I had a 30 min commute.. I prayed for longer just so I can catch some zzzzzz on the train (true story.. don’t judge me 😜) I had a nice quite 55 min commute, but I wanted to work in the big city(NYC) and drink and party every night, but couldn’t afford the city apt and had a 1.5 hour commute.. now I have a 15 min commute and covid wouldn’t let me see ppl.. what I am trying to say is.. be young.. make YOUR UNIQUE MISTAKES and learn and pivot.. Also.. don’t stay so long at your dream company that it becomes a nightmare!

like

No, unless I can move closer to work 😆😆

like

Oh it entirely depends if it's helping my career in general, and primarily if I think I'm going to like the role more...

like

This is it here, OP the question isn't about salary,.it's about dream offer vs commute.

like

Nope, breakdown the value of your time and cost of commute- the salary bump would shrink and the job would drop in interest

like

If the commute is via public transportation, I'd do it.

like

If I had a family, no.

like

No I wouldn’t do that. When you account for the travel and wear and tear on the car and gas, that extra 12k isn’t clearly giving you a better life than your current situation with 12k less.

like

Definitely no. The sheer fact that they’re making you come to the office daily is a deal-breaker on top of the long commute. If they were reasonable about work/life balance and letting you WFH half the week, I would possible say yes. But WFH is a huge commodity that most progressive companies are offering in light of this pandemic.

like

It sounds like a great opportunity especially this early in your career. I did the same for around 6 years but eventually the commute was just not bearable anymore. It takes a toll on the quality of life. Sounds like you are young so it might be the best time to make that kind of sacrifices for future opportunities.

like

That depends. How do the job duties compare? What are your career path goals and the potential options at the company? How much would it cost in gas, and how old is your car (think of car trouble)? And how important is working from home to you? I used to drive 1 hour and 10 minutes each way every day for a low paying job, but in the end, I had higher paying roles and tons of experience which set me up for the next stage of my career. Well worth it at that time for me, but doesn't mean it's right for everyone. But no matter what - you need a reliable car or a good AAA plan :) PS, I enjoyed the drive, gave me lots of time to thinking and decompress before and after work. But you need to know other ways to get there b/c there are a lot of wrecks - and it adds another layer of complication if you have kids that you have to get from daycare/school at a certain time.

like

NOPE!!!

like

Is the position one where you could potentially shift your work hours a bit? Would they allow you start earlier in the morning and earlier in the day so that you can beat rush hour traffic and shorten your commute time?

like

Nope! Did the hour + commute for 18 years, there’s probably a price I’d put on it, but it’s not 12k. The only benefit was the ability to de stress at the end of the day but you can’t really do that while your road raging to get home to the family.

like

I would say yes. Salary is such a snowball, that a little increase now means much more down the road, in aggregate (total wealth) as well as the increases in your total annual comp.

Related Posts

Thoughts on Specialist roles at McKinsey’s Knowledge Center in Boston? How do these roles vary in benefits/comp/progression compared to the traditional consulting peers? Since the roles are not client facing, sounds like a border line “exit” from consulting to me 😂

like

PwCers, is all of west coast except for san francisco considered tier 2 salary range?

like

I have a 2nd round of interview with a big tech company next week. Background: I applied a different position a year ago and got rejected in the 1st round. 1 year later, the same department reached me out and offered me an interview opportunity for a different position. The first round (with one of team member) went well and I got invited to the 2nd round interview with a hiring manager next week. And... I figured the interviewer is the person I interviewed last year who reiected me..! Continue

like

Goldman Sachs - I’m up for early promotion from senior analyst to associate in Controllers this year. What salary range should I expect in Texas?

like

Was offered by D today in consulting, experienced manager. Have a competing offer with ACN Strategy but was more inclined towards D’s role. Sign on bonus at D is very low, what’s maximum offered at M?

like

What range salary would you expect to get for a senior accountant role with good WLB in LCOL area? Second year senior with CPA and some industry experience. Don’t want to undersell myself but also desperate to get out of public.

like

Do these immigration rules (h1b changes to rules rumors) already started to have an effect on hiring practices for consulting such as MBBs? Does H1B sometimes replace Americans on many occasions?

like
like

Need some advice, I’m a third year healthcare/corp/M&A associate in Texas from a small firm. Was let go today because of recent hires and not enough billable work. Feel like I should try everything possible to secure another job and still a bit shocked. So if anyone in this bowl has any leads, please let me k ow! TIA!

like

Has anyone been downgraded on a purchased business class flight (using miles)? Flew Air Can and they switched the plane the day of and thus had less biz class seats. Is this normal? What comp is fair?

like

I’m current an S1 in corporate tax for a Top 10. I had an interview with a Big 4 for a tax technology position, but didn’t get in. I’m heartbroken because it was my dream job. 😅Everyone I spoke to seemed to like my experience and the recruiter said the team liked me as well, but they didn’t offer any feedback. Any advice on software or certifications I should get to help me get into tax technology and tax transformation? I’d really appreciate it - thank you for hearing me out!

like

I'm very much an investing novice and looking for thoughts on how to maximize gains. I've had a small portfolio with schwab for a few years (intelligent portfolio on medium risk tolerance) that has been steady, but should I also be picking stocks on the side outside of their ETFs? And if so, where do you start for selection? 32 y/o with maxed out 401k if that makes a difference (though I do contribute very little for my HSA - should that be more of a thing?)

like

Remote teachers: how many students have you already lost track of or have gone MIA. I have at least 7 (out of 89).

like

I'm so glad to be single lately. Maybe it was weird 2 months ago the way I lived but now I see it as a bonus. I entertain myself in my head and hobbies and don't depend on others for my happiness

likeupliftinghelpfulsmart

Decided to switch bluesy to NATO for the wfh week ahead!

Post Photo
like

How am I doin? 27male not yet married about 30k in savings just got a job away from PA to make $125k a year.. How old are you, how much you make and how good do you think you’re doing in life so far.

likehelpfulfunny

In nyc does it make sense to do a regular 401k or Roth 401k. 25 years old making 140k

like

Anyone know Aarete consulting/their work in the healthcare space?

like

Twitter allowing all employees to work from home indefinitely. Post-COVID, if companies allow more ppl to WFH, is there any reason for client travel anymore? Clients wont be in the office anyways.

like

Additional Posts

like

Anyone have their HBS interview yet? How did it go?

like

Anyone have insight on PwC vs EY benefits package? Looking for major differences, looks very similar to me.

like

Interviews tomorrow for Microsoft but 5 rounds of 1 hour each spread into 2 days. Is this common?

like

When did you feel like you were successful? People around me think it’s impressive that I work at Deloitte; however, I’m miserable and hate the work I’m doing. Just accepted another job that others would deem a dream company and salary but I’m just afraid of being miserable there too. I just don’t feel like I’m good enough, will be happy, or be in a position where I feel like I’m successful as others.

like

Goldman Sachs, IBD, FSIG, Business Operations, Analyst. what are the thoughts on this role?

like

If you were accepted to an Ivy League mba program, would you do it? Why or why not?

like

Going to a week of training in cool city and the firm is paying for the hotel; is it ok to bring my significant other??

like

What’s better, got offers from both Strategy& middle office and EY Parthenon? Looking for advice in terms of culture and overall workload

like

is it a good move to take an industry role (financial analyst) to gain some relevant experience and come back to B4 (transaction advisory) down the road?

like

How long is your one way trip from home to client site? I’m at 5 hours- 3.5 flying, the rest driving to/from airports.

like

Hello, can you please tell if I can travel to India, while there is a pending LCA for change of location? I don’t need to get any stamping done, this is my only concern.

like

I’m looking into an M role at Accenture Strategy in their Supply Chain space. Can anyone speak to that practice and expected salary band? Any and all insights appreciated. Thanks.

like

Has anyone in the national firms moved from an SEC focused audit manager role to your standards and professional practice group? What was your experience like in the transition? How are your hours, and compensation? Thanks in advance!

like

Currently in industry, on the product side with previous consulting background. I don’t like the grind of consulting, but Salesforce CSG (prof services) reached out with a BA role. I’m also in the process of interviewing at FICO as well. I like that the FICO is on the internal product side, but Salesforce has a great reputation. Feeling like I don’t know what I want. For reference, I’m leaving my current place because of terrible leadership & back to office 5x a week/no flexibility. Any advice?

Does anyone have personal finance/investment book recommendations for teens?

like

Hearing about the ridiculous demands from the LA teachers union... Is anyone else frustrated with how political teaching has become? I'm not sure that I would teach at all if it was required to join the union. So sick of the pressure to back certain candidates, walk-outs, and viewpoints. My district has a negotiating body affiliated with the NEA, but it's voluntary to be a member. I'm glad to live in a state with options.

like

Any fishes who have been tricked/lowballed when leaving a big 4 / mbb to a smaller firm, and they bring you in at a more junior role than you had before, what impact does it tend to have on your CV in the long run? Have you essentially lost the Ace you were holding by working for a big 4/mbb or is it recoverable?

like

Hello everyone, I am currently a HR Generalist for a small aerospace company, located in CA. I have been in a generalist role for a little over 4 years now and before that, I did recruiting/safety for about 3 years. I am now looking into getting my HR Certification, but am stuck in between the PHR-CA or the SHRM-CP. Does anyone have any recommendations they can give me?

like

I'm at a F500 company. We've had no success hiring IA senior or staff and have been looking for a month. Is that pretty typical? Not even getting to interview stage

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

{ "isSet": true, "allowed": true }

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal