Anyone else here an HM in the creative field? I work for an agency who is very stern on finding nothing but the best candidates and I guess it puts a little pressure on me to be very picky, even down to the resume. I can especially be judgmental of a candidate's abilities based on their resume and how creatively it is made. Do you do that, or am I hurting my chances at finding the right people by taking this approach?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I think I would judge their portfolio more than their resume

like

I do pay attention to resumes, especially how they showcase creativity. Still, I remind myself not to judge too quickly, sometimes the most impressive work comes from candidates with simpler resumes. Balancing resume style with actual skills is key for me, even if agency standards are strict.

Yes. You are not a god. You can only review what is history and look for positive patterns. I would also include people on my team who have a noted record of success and expertise in the area you are searching for hire. I have a very good record of hiring, but I have also had my share of poor choices. This is not an exact Science. And, you can’t be an expert in all areas. Team work + practice/experience = a great hire …..most of the time. Soon, and this is unscientific , you will develop what I call the “sniff test”. As soon as you meet the candidate, you’ll note something does not “smell” right. And, then follow your nose because the person will probably say something or infer something to confirm your suspicions. Do not be fooled by looks or friendly conversations. Also, do a second round of interviews with other appropriate staff and see if you get the same results. Here’s one more freebee…..check their FB. Good luck and let me know how you do. Blessings.

You’re lucky to work for a company that’s not trying to outsource creative roles to AI or overseas. A lot of creative agencies are going that way.

Related Posts

Do you review the other side’s escrow instructions and provide comments? 4 years in and I’ve never done this. Working for a new partner and she insists on doing so “in case there are competing instructions” but isn’t that the entire point of funding through an escrow agent/title company?

like

I’m entering an in-house with a bad Glassdoor rating as my first job in a new place. Please wish me luck as I will need every ounce of it 🥺🥺🥺

like

I am in the finance dept at my agency and have been struggling to get into the media department. I'm fine starting off in a junior role but after countless applications no one will give me a chance.

Anyone who transferred to UK or any other country from India from RWE pod ?

likesmart

Guys I can’t stop

like

Wednesday 3/14 FYI Island Visit thread

Comment in the below format if you want visitors or are looking to visit an island.

like

What is the Protiviti senior consultant 1 salary? Also thoughts on Protiviti vs West Monroe?

like

Can you name a firm (preferably NY office) that lets its associates work from a different country with no issues? The mid-size firm I’m currently at has been very flexible during covid but I’m looking to change firm (biglaw). Since my family is abroad I find it extremely valuable to be able to do this (I did this even before covid for a couple of weeks, twice a year). I’ve heard firms like Latham and Paul Weiss don’t allow it for tax reasons.

like

Anybody did the apics certification in logistics ? I have the choose between the cslp and cscp but not sure which one I should be doing

Anyone here recommend a good laser hair removal device safe for your face? I used to go in every few months to get laser treatments but now looking to do it at home

like

Currently being recruited for Alvarez & Marsal (Dubai or Riyadh). I’ve checked with my irl network and no one has worked with them before. Anyone here working with or for them who wouldn’t mind answering a few questions related to my proposed function; Strategy & Implementation?

like

What are good margins for PI associate attorneys; i.e., what should they make for the firm compared to what the firm would/ should pay them?

like

Hello
Anyone working as a Team leader in Operations team of
Standard Chartered Bank? I have taken the assement for the said role, need some suggestions and informations. Thanks in Advance. Standard bank Standard Chartered Bank

like

Does DT reimburse CPA fees if say you write your exams whilst working outside of Audit, eg Consulting , and then return to Audit after passing all courses.

Hi
I've 4+YOE in machine learning and deep learning
Any references in hyderabad in a better org pls

like

Anyone here refinance successfully with SOFI after I-140 was approved by I-485 is pending?

like

What is the minimum experience required for associate salesforce consultant?

like

90 Days notice period has 2 phases.

Initial phase - Candidates struggling to get interview calls.

Ending phase - Companies struggling to match a higher offer.

30 days notice period can really solve everyone's struggle.

like

Hi Sharks
I am into interviewing process with
Paytm for a Data Scientist position.
For sharks who work their what are the projects like? WLB compensations RSU options
Also, if anyone has given or in the process of Interview with Paytm Can you share your experience and the hiring rounds ?

like

Hi Fishes

I need help to decide
I have got 2 offers
1. Tigerhall - 45LPA
2. Zupee - 42LPA
Which one I should choose?
In Tigerhall, I will get a lot of free time as the work is same as what I have done so far in my career therefore, I can focus on more things now.
In Zupee, I will get to learn new skill which might be good for my career.
Also, comparatively in hand salary of Tigerhall is higher than Zupee (it will less tax deduction as it's a Singapore based company)
Please suggest

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal