I just found out a coworker who joined six months after me is making more than I am. I’m debating whether to bring it up with my manager or just focus on my next raise. Has anyone successfully used internal pay comparisons to negotiate without causing tension?

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Don’t mention another employee. Go with data about current market rates and your accomplishments and expanded tasks since you started. Go with a case study presentation of internal work and/or a collection of positive feedback and quotes you’ve gotten from colleagues about your work. I did this and first got a 6% increase with no title change and a few months later another 10% on top of that with a title change. I also let them know I really wanted to grow where I was and could see other people having to leave their roles for growth and I didn’t want to have get what I needed from somewhere else. Have I actually met my very reasonable target salary goal yet? No, but a 16% raise without having to leave is a pretty big deal. And my manager is already talking with me about how to get promoted again. I know new people make more than I do but you’ll get snubbed if you bring that up. I tried putting all my job search efforts into making a promotion case at my current company instead of externally and so far it’s working well. My manager also told me nobody has ever done so much leg work to help them fight for an employee promotion before and that it was a huge help.

like

No, bringing up someone else’s pay is not a good strategy nor is it considered to be good leverage. New employees pretty much always make more. And chances are, this person negotiated better than you. Also, how much more is this person making? 5%? 20%? That matters. If it’s a lot more, I would just look for a new job. You can’t really negotiate salary after you’ve already accepted the offer and started working. You’ll get your regular 2-5% yearly raises but that’s about it.

like

And this is why they give you your paycheck in a sealed envelope, and company adequate asks that you do not share what you make with other people that you work with. How many times do I have to tell you and my grown kids that all your coworkers are not your friends. They are coworkers, they are not your friends you have friends, you don’t need any friends where you work. You have to learn to keep a compassionate distance from people that you work with, judge some favorably, but you have enough friends, FRIENDS are friends, and business is business.

like

So true! Given the chance they will throw you under the bus! I had to tell my current boss that the last boss who she took his place was sexually harassing me. At that moment she basically laughed at me right in my face. I was so angry! As a boss he slap my asset at other times he would pull me closer to him and then if someone walked by his office he push his chair back from me. None of them believed me and then a new contractor came in and I was told they didn't need me. So that was my last job. I was devastated! I will handle iy differently if it ever happens again!

like

You should definitely bring it up. You might get an adjustment out of it, or at least an explanation for what's going on. They might have more education or experience, which could be a factor, or maybe they just negotiated harder. But either way, there's no harm in asking questions.

like

Agree. 100%

like

Experience and SKILLS will get you noticed and ATTITUDE will play a vital role, the other person may have more EXPERIENCE and works well with others, might come in early or does something that the Bosses or Supervisor sees and that how that person is earning more, keep a POSITIVE ATTITUDE and prove your worth, Good Luck

like

With that type of ATTITUDE, I see why you're bitter, what skills do you bring to the table, how many years of EXPERIENCE do you have, you didn't mention anything about it, have you spoken to HR or anyone else, being respectful and mindful of how you approach you're higher-ups might help, if you're not happy where you're at, Don't quit until you find another job

like

People do successfully use internal pay comparisons, but the key is to reframe it as a fairness and value conversation rather than a complaint. Managers are more receptive when you emphasize your contributions and the company’s commitment to equity, rather than focusing on what someone else earns.

like

I don’t know that I would bring it up. There are a ton of factors unknown, and they aren’t going to willingly share all of them. Focus on what you can do to make more there outside of what other people make.

like

There may be a reason, but bring it up and ask what you need to do for parity.

like

No. Start searching for a new position. Exit interview? Explain exactly why you are leaving.

like

I've done that as well and I regretted it. So the next time we had a pay raise my boss told me to ask higher. So when I did he reluctantly gave it to me I deserved it! Especially when I heard what others were making and I found out so I didn't feel bad after that but then she got angry because I was making more than her husband. That kind of threw me but oh well!

like

This exact conundrum gets posted monthly, if not more often than that. On average wages go up over time, and raises do not generally keep up with that growth, so hiring date absolutely matters. More importantly, some people are better at negotiating comp than others.

New people are supposed to get more, not less. Why do you think you deserve the same? Are you equally valuable as this person? How do you know? Let’s say they match your pay with this new person after you bring it up, if two months later another new person comes with even higher pay than you both, then what? Give the whole company a raise?

If you’ve never worked anywhere that paid new employees more, then either you’ve never had a real job at a real company or you are the one living in the fantasyland.

like

Nope you use this as the reason for leaving in your exit interview.

Related Posts

Don’t you just love when an AE one year out of undergrad tells you your estimate sounds high?

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Yosemite JFK to SFO

Post Photo
like

What is the general ranking for A-SC firm benefits across commercial management consulting?

like

How did it go?

like

Hello Guys,

What would be the monthly in-hand salary?
Leave travel allowance, do I need to show bills or it will directly get credited into my account monthly.
SAP SD, 4 YOE, INFOSYS
CCTC - 7.34LPA (inclusive 60k VP)
DELOITTE IN Offered - 13.50 lpa fixed

Post Photo
like

When you submit your resignation after getting appraisal...

Manager:

Post Photo
funnylike

How much time it take for offer letter after digiverification for Tech Mahindra And does the offer is revoked if anyone is not able to update resignation letter within 7days post offer roll out?

I feel like being gay just adds another layer of difficulty while trying to date in consulting.

like

Looking for infrastructure manager role, having 15+ years of experience with knowledge on microsoft and dependable products. Pls help. In notice period

like

What to choose between John Deere and Mercedes benz

like

If a guy invites you to stay the night, does that means something?

like

hiring aggressive... anyone looking for referal at Accenture technology operations strategy consulting drop cv @ mail ayush.splunk@gmail.com

minimum 2.5 years experience mention you skill - Date of Birth nd mobile number. (mandatory fields in referal form ) Accenture #refer

like
like

White watch Wednesday. Loving this look!

Post Photo
like

What’s the right age difference? My friends set me up on a date with a girl who is 12 years younger to me. I was feeling so uncomfortable all through my dinner with her.

Are there any good conservative sources out there that you think people haven't heard enough about? I'm not against liberal viewpoints or anything. I just think they seem more vocal than the conservatives and I would like to find a balance

like

Woman I went on one date with keeps me informed on what she's doing. I.e. Seeing her girlfriend or on her way to a birthday party. Not used to this level of transparency after just one date. We do have a second date planned. Thoughts?

like
like

LinkedIn is a garbage app where I can’t even post my opinion or experience because it will go against the mainstream ideologies. If I even “like” a post then I worry that my peers and managers see what I like and suddenly I need inclusivity training. What a load of shit! You can’t be who you truly are on that app. Which is why I like fishbowl so much, the anonymity is a game changer. If LinkedIn was a anonymous, we’d see a lot more support for Kanye and a lot less LGBQT material. Bet!

likefunny

Additional Posts in Salary Negotiations

Should I Go Back and Reneg? Recently I was offered a role as a Project Implementation Manager (In Retirement Services) .The salary range for Colorado residents was 65-89K. I’m located in NY so the recruiter said he would try to get me more. Ultimately he came back at 90K which is a bit inline with that I was seeing on Glassdoor but approx looks like I may leave 10-12K on the table. I accepted already but may get an offer from another HR company in account management around 90-100K. Need advice

Hi, offer coming through from AWS - is there scope for negotiation with them, or is the offer just the offer?

like

Im currently going through industry change.
Im a pastry cook with 4yrs experience and the average salary start for this position is now at $22/hr here in vegas, especially in the strip. But cooking/baking is not my passion. So im changing into veterinary medicine and im seeing that the starting rate for a vet tech is around $16-18. Why is that?? Why are people in the vet med industry being paid so low?? Something needs to change. Labor of love aint enough for the people in this job.

like
like

Hey guys, how much will be the salary range for a Environmental Engineer with less than 5 years experience.

like

Considering working from India for a couple of years due to personal reasons. Any advice for Salary expectations/negotiations? Haven't worked in India for over a decade.

Senior consultant, came into Deloitte with over 14 YOE (industry), in the FSI -> IM space, expertise & experience in buy side asset management.

If you are open/willing to offer referrals, happy to talk. Any insights are greatly appreciated. Thank you.

like

Hi all. I just received an offer for $130k and will be eligible for about 29,000 shares of stock options. The vesting schedule is 1 year and then quarterly thereafter.

Can someone explain what this means? I “will be eligible”. So, I have to buy the shares? Should I be asking at what price?

Newbie here. Please help!

like

Hello all,

I have an Interview with Atlassian for a pre sales solutions engineer role in Canada that requires 5-8 YOE . What's the salary range I should be aiming for ?

like

is anyone familiar with pay differentials, negotiating for a temporary raise or some other form of compensation for extra work? 3 coworkers on my team have recently resigned, and certain shifts are being expected to work at half staff until new hires can be brought on. if my workload is being doubled, i expect to be compensated, as they are paying one employee to do the work of two. any suggestions or wording on how to address this?

like

Hi , wanted to get some feedback on following position offer in New Jersey area
Senior Manager for pricing startegy
I have 4 and half years of related experience,Masters degree
Base salary offer at 150k, 21% SPI and 10% LTI
How much room I have for negotiation, whats the fair market rate for this level?

like

I received a job offer from company A and am currently negotiating salary. I have an interview with company B next week and know that they offer a higher base pay. There’s no guarantee that I will be offered a job at company B but my gut is telling me that company B would be a better fit for me. Should I accept the offer from company A, continue interview process with company B and then rescind my offer with company A if company B offers me a job? Will I be burning bridges?

like

Started a new job a year ago, high performer. My manager suggested a promotion to Product Manager since that‘s the work I’m doing, but that would be a 50% raise. Higher ups decided instead to make a “new role” (not PM), that has no analog in the company and is hard to price via Glassdoor, etc. I feel like this is to limit my promotion salary to something like 10% from where it currently is. Is there anything I can do? FWIW: I have a PhD from top 5 program and am working in that field. Thanks!

likehelpful

Annual review coming up. Looking for suggestions for asks…

8 YOE, Current 125 base, TC ~140.

Median base for my title/geo ~170 (mean ~166, 0.75 ~226).

Certs: CIPM, M365 Security Admin/Architect, AWS SOA, AN, & Security.

Vet, Inactive TS.

Highlights of the year: flew out on 12hr notice to evac E Europe-based employees & families, plugged 3 exposures before they became breaches, built TVM/privacy program from scratch, onboarded new CNAPP.

(-) Still a student (GIB: BA/MS expected ‘24)

like

I have been in my current job for 1 year now as a booking coordinator for a logistics company. When I started I had no idea of what my workload would be, now I noticed that my coworkers took the opportunity to pass most of their job to me. I’m burned out, can barely take break and end my days totally drained and exhausted, also the same people is harassing me with questions like: “why are you working that slow?” Or the “quality of your job is questionable because…..” continue in comments

Anyone working as a 2 years + lawyer for Fragomen in Canada can share their salaries and working advantages? (holidays, billable hours etc). Got an interview coming up and want to make sure not to under-sale my profile!

like
like

For expert witnesses/lawyers

I’m a former forensic scientist that left the field several years ago. I recently received a subpoena from a case I worked and suggested to DA to have evidence re-worked by the lab or stipulation. If I am required to testify (as an expert witness), I would need to book a flight, hotel, etc. My question is this: can I ask for my requested hourly rate, travel, and hotel to be covered when speaking with DA or is that “not how this works” as the investigator put it?

like

Hey! Any Google folks know if it’s possible to negotiate fully remote if a contract role is hybrid? Personally, I don’t want to relocate and go to the office on a contract role given the current economy. Plus, I’m assuming contractors are the first to go in layoffs. I just think it’s a fair trade off if I’d be allowed to work fully remote. I’m also trying to have flexibility to manage my Airbnb business in a different country. Same time zone as the home office if I’d travel weeks at a time.

like

Hi there. What is considered a good salary for a project manager?

like

Program Manager Healthcare Foundation $85,000. Worth it? Or too low?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal