In our organization, we’re facing voluntary redundancies due to resizing, and I’ve noticed that those of us with fleet cars are seeing a decrease in our severance packages. It feels a bit unfair, as the cars were part of our benefits and not directly linked to our performance. This situation raises questions about how benefits should be valued during downsizing. Do you think it’s justifiable to penalize employees for perks that were meant to enhance our roles?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

That does sound pretty unfair, honestly. Company cars are pitched as a perk; something to make the job more attractive, cover commuting, or whatever role-specific travel and suddenly in redundancy it’s being treated like you’ve been overpaid all along?
It feels like a sneaky way to claw back value without calling it that. From what I’ve seen (and heard from friends who’ve been through layoffs), companies often calculate severance based on “total compensation” rather than just base salary.
So if you’ve had a fleet car, they might be offsetting the estimated value of that benefit (fuel, insurance, the car itself) against what they’re willing to pay out. Their logic is probably “you’ve already received extra value through the perk, so we’ll adjust accordingly.” It’s cost-saving dressed up as fairness on their end.

I completely agree. I think benefits should be separate from redundancy calculations. It’s frustrating when perks end up impacting severance like that!

That’s a tough situation, and it does seem unfair to penalize employees for benefits that were part of their compensation package. Those perks were intended to enhance your roles and should ideally be considered part of your overall value to the company. It raises important questions about how organizations handle benefits during downsizing. Transparency and fairness in these situations are crucial for maintaining trust. Have you or your colleagues discussed this with management? It might be worth advocating for a reevaluation of how severance packages are calculated.

I totally agree; it really is a tough spot. Those perks should enhance the role, not penalise us later. We haven’t discussed it with management yet, but I think it’s a good idea to bring it up. Advocacy for fairer calculations makes sense!

Related Posts

What size Cartier Tank (Solo or Must) for a 6 inch wrist? I’m assuming small as I think large might not look right

like

I joined an agency about 2 months ago and every single day I get more responsibilities, to the point that I don't even know what my actual job title is. I'm frustrated, to say the least.

like
like

Hi Fishes

I urgently need a referral at Barclays for a role. Anyone kindly help me. @barclays

like

I am currently a civil engineer thinking of switching to software engineering. I got my masters in water resource engineering where I was coding a decent amount for assignments and it has really stuck with me. Unfortunately, in my current role and field (civil), I don’t really get to do much coding. Does anyone have a similar experience of jumping ship to do software engineering? What would be the best way to go about it (coding bootcamp, another degree, something else)?

like

Thoughts on the Heuer Monaco? Never been a fan of Tags but the Monaco is a looker! Any ideas where to get one?

like

Joining BNP Paribas for role of Senior BA in bangalore, is the Bangalore office new? How many employees are there? How is company culture? Management etc, I had other offers from societe generale and hsbc similar offer but in hsbc the role was of a manager in compliance risk analytics domain, bnp is in trade and investment banking domain, I choose bnp, was it a good choice?

like

Hi fork
Please help me to choose
Deloitte USI - 22.5 lpa + 5 lpa joining bonus
Impetus technologies inc - 25 lpa fixed + 1 lpa joining bonus
Altimetrik Corp. - 27 lpa fixed + 1 lpa joining bonus

Yoe - 8
Key skill - Python development azure

like

What's up young men?

like

considering betting a ton of money on tomorrow’s elections via “predict it”, as an emotional hedge. is this a stupid idea or a genius idea

like

Thought I’d invest $20K when the market dips due to election but...

like
like

I recently cleared all technical rounds for Global Technical Support Engineer 2 role at PayPal, I have 3.3 YOE. Could anyone please let me know how much does PayPal on average offer for this role.

Hi All,

What will be the In hand salary for this compensation in IBM Bangalore
YOE - 6.7 years
Technology - Salesforce Developer
Current CTC - 10

Thanks

Post Photo
like

FAR, what a pain..that’s all

likefunny

Hi Fishies,
Can you please comment on aspects like wlb, learning in hsbc client at Virtusa? I have been offered QA lead position.

like

How many leaves are there in virtusa in a year

like

What happens at RIMS? Is it worth going to?

like

Additional Posts in Salaries in Healthcare

I’m an inpatient medical coder and make 23.58 currently, I was previously and outpatient coder as well as a billing coordinator. I also have nursing experience. I have seen many inpatient job postings with advertisements of higher pay like27-32$ and hour. Am I being low balled here? I work out of St. Louis

like

Any had any luck with getting off cycle raises? I requested an increase outside of performance review. From a HR standpoint, do you know why this very hard to get?

like

What’s the current salary for an entry level US TECH in GA

like

What is the salary range for a non IT business analyst working for a healthcare company?

like

Hi what are the top end salaries of a homecare occupational therapist in the Bay Area?

like

Anyone work for Ensemble Health? How much do they pay for the Credit Balance Specialist role?

like

I’ve seen a very large range of income for general dentists. What is your income or expected/average income for dentists working 35hrs a week as contractor or associate in the city/ suburbs?

like

I'm a pca in TN with around 8 years of experience. I am making 13 a hour. Is that low?

like

What is an average pay for a clinical lead medical assistant in Philadelphia area?

What is the pay for a Operating room RN with 10 years experience in Austin, Texas?

like

How much does an operations specialist make for Kaiser Permanente?

I am a Fraud Investigator making $61,000 per year at Optum. I feel like I am very underpaid and that my counterparts are making more than I do. What is the normal pay for a Fraud Investigator?

like

What is the current pay rate for clinical pharmacists with 10 years experience?

like

Any advice on renegotiating my salary? I’m a compounding pharmacist and i also float to other stores while also being solely responsible for the compounding pharmacy. I perform MTMs for 6 or so stores and am now a being asked to other projects. I originally signed on to only do compounding and occasionally fill in at other stores when needed. I have another offer from a hospital that is significantly higher than what i am being paid now. Would just like some pointers on this kind of conversation

like

How much job grade 105 is getting paid now? Started working at cvs as pharmacy Tech 2 years ago! I’m thinking of leaving because not much upgrade and No promotions!

like

Starting wage for a Radiology informatics application analyst? I live in Ohio. Thank you!

like

Hi I was just offered a CM Manager position at Evelance aka Anthem with moderate salary 100k with 10% bonus. I was previously making 110k with 10%. Recruiter said probably would not match my previous salary and I would have to justify why I want more that job offer. Has anyone ever experienced this?

likesmart

Looking to go into either management or clinical applications. What’s the starting salary for a radiology supervisor and a clinical application analyst in ohio? I have my MBA and 5 years experience and a rad tech.

Hello , everyone. Im new here . I have been looking around for new opportunities. I would like to now an average for a lead Mammography technologist in New York area ? Thanks

like

What’s the average-higher pay for WCC wound care certified nurse, 6 years experience? In Midwest

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal